Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Commack
14 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Personally I think this place has one of the best tasting pizza in Commack. We used Milano's for my daughter's birthday party and all the kids loved..."
Robert Yinny
"If you haven’t tried this restaurant yet, you should. Commack has a lot of Italian/pizza places, this one has definitely come to rank number one..."
Ginny Reib
"Excellent pizza and other Italian dishes. If you order online, allow 30 minutes for order to be..."
Kevin Feit
"Deep dish pizza is outstanding: homemade sauce, fresh mozzarella, thick but light crispy..."
Thomas Wilson
"I visited this establishment after my friend raved about it! I understand why she did!!! FANTASTIC pizza’s!!!! Their eggplant rolatine is my go..."
Guy Turchiano
"Great pizza and awesome workers!! If you love thin crust pizza, this is the place to..."
Jim Perry
"God, I love this place they feed me like the Italian grandmother I never had. Every dish is two meals, and totally worth..."
Hole, Major A
"Found this place on Uber Eats. It is far and away the best place in the area (I come from 2 towns over for it). Pizza is good but entrees are GREAT!..."
Greg Galgano
"Deep dish pizza was very..."
Sally Wong
"They made fresh manicotti and it was so good. Even better the next day. The pizza was delicious and had just the right crispness. Very nice people..."
"I had past this place numerous times, and decided to give it a try. I finally went one Thursday to get a Sicilian pie. My family loved it, but the..."
Geneane Makowenskyj
"Awesome! I'm writing a review because honestly when I walked in I was skeptical, but the pizza was unreal and the customer service was great too...."
Adrienne Brand
"Best pizza of all time !!!! If your in the mood for NY style pizza, Pizza D'Lusso's your stop for sure !!!! Times running out, retirements coming..."
Jeffrey Mascolo
"The best regular slice and meatballs in the Tri-State area hands down! DiFara's has nothing on Pizza..."
Joseph DeMartino
"I AM SAD TO LEARN THAT D'LUSSO PIZZAREIA IS CLOSING FOR GOOD FRIDAY MY FAMILY AND I HAVE BEEN GOING TO ONLY HIM SINCE THE 60'S JOE WILL BE MISSED..."
Edith Friedrichs
"That guy who claims the pizza is subpar needs to get a life,this pizza is the best I've had my whole life and has now become the only pizza I will..."
"Pretty good pizza! But when I asked for half of my pizza to be spinach, I just got soggy spinach on half of a cheese pizza instead of traditional..."
Daniel C.
"Ordered via 2G2G. Amazing experience. The employees are so friendly and it usually includes a full bag of delicious garlic knots and assorted pizza..."
Fayjai Mike
"If I could give 10 STARS, I would!!! Jonny, the manager, was so incredible to my group who came in for a Heart Shaped pizza for Valentine's Day. We..."
Gianna Borrelli
"Best New York-style pizza in Commack! Great salads and pasta too! Friendly service and always have order ready and hot on..."
Jeremy Lambert
"Very tasty Eggplant Roll!
Much tastier than other places.
Garlic balls are..."
Ved Overclocked
"Mario’s caters the company meetings we have and never fails to Supply us with great food and remarkable custoner service!!
Thank You
Frank
Alure..."
Frank Stehlik
"Our margarita pizza was..."
Tiffany Macartney
"I am more than pleased with the service and quality of food. The upgrades to this location are stellar. The holiday decorations are very nice as..."
Manuel Rosa
"The staff were more than accommodating with the use of the beautiful and spacious private room.
Great food, great..."
Anthony p
"Delicious pizza with great variety. So clean and organized with lots of room to sit and enjoy a slice or a meal without being on top of people. The..."
"The buffalo and margarita pizza was phenomenal. Anthony was very attentive to my 3 year old by helping me with napkins and serving us our food. I..."
Iman
"My family hosted a luncheon here for my Italian -American family after my father's funeral. I have to say that the quality of the food far surpassed..."
Mary F
"First time here. Came with friends. The food was great, the staff were very busy as it was a Friday night, but still found time to keep filling the..."
Andrew Brofman
"My girlfriend and I often stop by for a bite to eat since we really enjoy the food. It was such a beautiful day that we got to eat outside. We just..."
Ryan
"A fine place for lunch! Don’t let the strip mall entry mislead you...inside a lovely dining experience in a relaxed and attentive environment. The..."
Glenn
"This is a rare breed. Both dinners and pizza are good here. It’s usually one or the other but Taormina is atypical. The best garlic bread you’ll..."
Sunny Peace
"We drove 45 minutes from Brooklyn NY. 14 of us to enjoy a Fathers day celebration. We loved it. Server and manager was amazing. Food was delicious...."
Z G
"Great food. Warm and engaging hosts. It's like coming to dinner at my Aunt's..."
Mike Reynolds
"Couldn't wait to start eating! Excellent food, portions and service. Highly..."
george smith
"I ordered online and it was ready for pickup at the exact time they said . Food is excellent, pizza was delicious and the staff is very friendly...."
Rb1330
"I came with my wifecand 3 kids. We order so.e slices and garlic knots. Slices and knots were grear and place is very nice and..."
Fred Caputo
"One of my favorite restaurants in Comac. Food is always superb and service...."
Ron morasse
"Family atmosphere. Big menu with big portions. Food was really..."
Howard Spencer
"Love this place !!! Good Food and service.
Best Italian restaurant in Commack.
The food is always fresh and tasty.
And the service is..."
"Great place to stop in for a quick bite! Great ambience! You can sit at the huge bar, or at a large array of tables. By far, one of the best..."
Pat B
"Our go to place. Local favorite. Food is always good. Atmosphere is fun. We love watching sports here. A great casual dining establishment. Great..."
Audrey
"Anthonys is by far my favorite pizza around. This place is consistent, you always know that you’re getting a perfect and delicious pizza. Not to..."
Bre-Ann O'Connell
"Really good pizza and an incredible rewards program!
We had the roasted cauliflower (pictured) and the traditional (basically their regular cheese)...."
Tim Walsh
"Enjoyed the best wings tonight at Anthony’s. The caramelized onions are the perfect touch. Service was above and beyond. The manager Andy was the..."
Dean Sam
"Love this place… we get the house salad which is my favorite salad around town!!! Wings are the best! But most importantly our bartender Alex is..."
Jamie Flynn
"I take out from here a lot. Food is always good and ready for me on arrival. On the times when I have dined in the food was always served within a..."
Christina La Tempa
"We asked Anthony's if they would make a donation of food to help us celebrate Certified Nurses Day at the hospital where I work. They graciously..."
anna haugen
"Wonderful pizza and meatballs. Wait staff is great. Reasonable..."
Owen F McEntee Jr
"Amazing, don’t know if if just is or if it’s because its the only coal fried pizza in town, this place is wonderful and turns pizza into..."
Candice DickFitInYoMouth
"I'm normally not a fan of thin crust pizza. I'm a New Yorker and enjoy a good NY style pie. To me the traditional California thin crust has always..."
"I travel regularly to try pizza as its one of my favorite foods to get. This place was a solid 4.0 out of 5 for me. A 5 being Johns of Bleeker, and..."
Joe Lucchesi
"Fantastic people, food, and setice--and great ambient music playing at all times!! You have something for everybody here, from pasta and chicken or..."
lawrence kauffman
"Thank you for participating in “Pizza Strong”, by donating to help
Those affected by the Farmingdale bus tragedy. Your food and pizza are..."
Marianne Oliva-Pavlat
"Been there once the Sicilian slice with cheese on bottom was great, I usually go to deerpark ave pizziola I think your location has better..."
Rich Rettino
"Food is good, but beware of no menu prices listed other than for pizza, which is a bit dodgy. Might as well just put "Market Price" (Sarcasm). You..."
Rob A
"One of the best round pizzas on Long Island. Loved the crust.
When I went inside to pick up my pizza it was like I'm invisible. All the help was..."
Bruce C
"Had reservations about this place because I've never heard anyone speak of it before. Turns out, I finally found a good pizza in commack. Perfectly..."
john c
"I ordered a white slice, I got a white slice. It was really, really good. The ricotta was light and seasoned, the mozzarella was perfectly..."
Joseph “JStars” Staropoli
"We have been going to Pizzaiolo for years. Always tasty food and great service. This is my go to pizza place in Commack. Best garlic knots and..."
Frank Antonelli
"Many different types of pizzas to choose from...."
Carla Carvalhao
"I am happy to write this 5 star review.
This establishment takes pride in their customer service, quality of food and most of all meeting my..."
Adam Holtzer
"John and the staff are great. They always have what I want and serve it with courtesy and a big smile. A pleasure to eat there or take..."
Robert Tanner
"Best pizza around Commack that will cover..."
Alberto Hernandez
"We brought our soccer team here last night for a birthday party for one of the players. The owner and staff could not have been more accommodating...."
"We had bottomless brunch on an afternoon weekend which was fun! We drank mimosas with a orange juice base, but opted for pineapple juice since it..."
Kimiko
"My wife and I came here to celebrate her birthday, and it was definitely a very memorable dinner! Our waitress Colleen was continuously present at..."
Michael Zucker
"The drinks were amazing (forgot the name of mine, hot girl summer i think). The waiter was so friendly. Didn’t feel rushed and enjoyed my time..."
Jaclyn Altebrando
"There are not enough positive things to say about my experience here! We had a party this weekend and everything was just amazing! Not only are the..."
Lauren LoMonaco
"Food was so fresh and delicious, I went back multiple times since I first ate there and tried new things everytime, everything is amazing. Virginia..."
Mike Carney
"First time here tonight and not one complaint! Our server Michelle was fabulous and such a sweetheart! The pretzel was AMAZING with the three dipping..."
Isabel Felice
"Friendly & helpful staff with amazing food and drink suggestions. We loved Ally ❤️! The Purple Haze was my fave drink, delicious and strong...."
Tionna P
"We were looking for a restaurant during restaurant week but came across this gem. IT WAS AMAZING !!! The ambiance was really beautiful and everything..."
Merced Giuria
"I have visited this restaurant a few times at this point, which is normally when I feel comfortable giving a review. The food is always very good,..."
Angela Scunziano
"I couldn’t even wait to leave the parking lot to start this review because I was so pleasantly surprised by how amazing this restaurant and the..."
Alexandra D'Atena
"This was my second time visiting and it was a wonderful experience. I was there on 10/22 for brunch and got the ultimate bacon egg and cheese which..."
Connor Donnelly
"This is such a great spot to grab dinner. We had a reservation which was good because it's gets pretty busy. The Fondue short rib burger was..."
nasha nicole
"Went for birthday brunch. Lots of different choices. Our group enjoyed it. It was all of our first time. Good music. Good vibes. Will definitely be..."
Nathalie Coutrier
"Everything and everyone was fantastic. Food was great and..."
Jay Lopez
"Our server was the very lovely Colleen who recommended the Peach 🍑 Salad for my wife and she loved it.
I had the Stallion, a very unique sandwich..."
"A Taste of Italy. We've been regulars here for almost 10 years. The food is delicious, the wait staff friendly, and the atmosphere authentic. It..."
Lenape61
"The cheese garlic knots are delish!. We order them every time we..."
E. Kavanagh
"Excellent food, reasonably priced. Never had a bad meal there in 20 years. Pasta and shrimp dishes..."
BRAPPRA
"Walking into La Scala and you figure this is just another pizza place, but by the time you leave you realize you had entered someplace..."
PizzaReports.com
"Food was okay, but the service was excellent.
Ordered the following:
1. Spaghetti (Sauce 6/10) and meatballs (8/10) = Okay
2. Lasagna 👎🏼..."
Sajan Kumar
"Wasn’t crazy about the cheese slice but it was decently good. Had an order of garlic knots (I believe cheesy) and they were really good but super..."
Victoria
"I was here twice in one week. Love the food, the workers are very friendly. Always smiling. You have to try it you will not complain..."
Linda Nicosia
"First time ordering food from here and it went pretty good. My cousin who lives nearby orders pizza from here. The wings were alright but the pizza..."
Crystal
"I called just a few days in advance to organize a soccer team dinner for 40 adults and kids. I spoke with Chris and he was so accommodating. The..."
Jennifer McKissock
"Delicious pasta and sauces. Excellent service when you dine in house. Nice wine selection. When you get food to go, it taste just as good as if you..."
Sarah Lalueza
"Always happy to come here. The food is AMAZING… actually tried something different, the veal Gorgonzola dish and it was fabulous and the garlic..."
Kathy Berman
"I had the stuffed filet and WOW! I was hesitant at first due to La Scala being known for their pizza and pasta—and very happy with my choice!!! The..."
Brittany Lynn
"Came here to celebrate a Birthday, but was worried because I haven't been here since before Covid. And I was concerned the food and service changed...."
steven mattocks
"Carlos is a fantastic waiter, he is cordial, polite and extremely professional. Especially tonight that it’s Christmas Eve he is delivering overall..."
fra (frareviews)
"I got a take out lunch at La Scala..we had chicken and veal parm hero's. It was delicious and cheesy!! It's a beautiful restaurant that is wheelchair..."
nasha nicole
"Been there as long as I have been. Great place
Run well clean aways staying modern , updating all thr time not just with food but the place..."
Brett Bar
"Their pizza is so delicious, it taste like no other and their pasta!!!…. SO DELICIOUS!!!, worth the money & worth the wait! They’re very quick..."
Monica Palencia
"Please get the chicken bacon ranch pizza. It was AMAZING!!!! We also got the chicken masala slice which was good but not as good as the chicken one...."
Isabel Castro
"One of the best Italian establishments on Long Island. Both La Scala and Cafe Amici are top tier for me. Yes its my opinion but I am always trying..."
Jonathan Barcenas
"I will start this off with the fact that I’m bias and I grew up around the corner from La Scala, but this is the best pizza I’ve ever had. The..."
"Good food. Always consistent... They get a little frazzled when they are busy but food still comes out..."
Jim Perry
"Always consistent and delicious. I've catered and ate in the store as well. My favorite is the Pasta..."
Val Connors
"We order from Memas once a week and the food is always amazing! We ordered 7 pies (mostly specialty pies) for our sons party last weekend and they..."
Dana L
"Little Mema's is my go to pizza place when home. Their pizza is delicious! A nice chewy crust followed by flavorful sauce and the right amount of..."
Dion Rupa
"First time coming here, got a vegan pizza with vegan pepperoni and sausage. So delicious, even the meat-eaters were..."
C R
"Had a party catered by Mema’s yesterday. Food was incredible, delivered on time and ready to eat. The Chicken Mona Lisa and Pasta Purses were..."
Robert Roggenkamp
"This pizza changed my life, it was magical!!! And that staff was amazing would 10/10..."
Lauren Mueller
"I love the family take out special during the week! Mema's never disappoint..."
fallen robin chase
"Always amazing this place!! Owner is very friendly along with the rest of the staff with and we cater from here often with no issues. In terms of..."
Andrew Marshall
"We just ordered Mema’s for a Christmas party and were so impressed with the taste and quality of the food. Many attendees were gluten free (myself..."
Amy C
"Professional, friendly & yummy!
Mema’s Pizza is the best pizza in town…. everything is made fresh & delicious!
The owner is a fine community..."
Kathy Sanacore
"One of the best pizza places in the area. Their staff is friendly, the food is delicious, and their menu is expansive and accommodating. My..."
Molly Brand
"My friend and I came Into Memas with 4 toddlers. The staff couldn’t have been more kind and accommodating! We were so impressed. There was a large..."
Lori E
"We moved to East Northport in 2017 and were on the search for great pizza and were very unsuccessful. We then moved to Kings Park in 2020 and have..."
Stefanie P
"As a surprising twist on a early Sunday evening dinner I discovered this hidden treasure in Commack: Mema’s Little Kitchen. The service was great..."
"Omg! the wild mushroom pizza was amazing ..everything was delighful. Service was wonderful .it was a very clean establishment .highly..."
Dana D'Amico
"Consistency and texture of the crust was top notch. I'm not a fan of their sauce though at all. (my personal opinion) Place is clean and people were..."
Ryan Perullo
"This is a nice and clean pizzeria in a Shopping Center right off Jericho Turnpike servicing Commack, New York with plenty of parking. Gourmet pizza..."
Eric San José
"Everything has been great here. Their wings have a lot of meat on it, which is great since most places like to gyp you. It was all delicious..."
Jenna Alexander
"What can I say? We ordered catering from Henry's last year for a work Holiday party and it was awesome. The staff loved it so much that they asked if..."
DAVID PREISLER
"I got White, Regular, and Vodka slices. They were all good I liked the Regular the most. The crust is nice and crispy reminds me of a bread stick..."
Scorpzilla25
"Henry’s just catered my son’s communion party. They did a fabulous job and the entire process was seamless. Everything we ordered was great and..."
Debbie Raguzin
"I made the move to Gluten free...Richies was there with a GL personal pizza....delicious!! Clean, bright and friendly service...definitely will be..."
Glenn
"Albert runs a beautiful pizzeria! Friendly, outdoor seating and amazing..."
Arlene Louro
"Loving this place, I always get the cauliflower crust pizza, delicious. I had them cater my sons birthday and everyone was raving about the..."
Renee Suriel
"Had Henry's Pizza cater a party and all the food was delicious. It arrived hot, there was more than enough for everyone, and everyone raved about..."
Michele Albert
"Went for a buffalo chicken slice at lunch (12ish) and it was perfect!! Crust was nice and crispy and I think it might be my favorite buff chicken..."
Mackenzie Rothschild
"We had our daughters 6th birthday catered by Henry's Pizza in Commack. The food was amazing!! We wanted food that both the adults and kids attending..."
Claudia Del Basso
"This is some of the best pizza I have had in ages. It's hard to stand out on Long Island with pizza, but this place nailed it.
The garlic knots are..."
Theresa Jusino
"Was in there with my wife yesterday. We had the chicken chipotle bbq slice , sausage margarita slice , regular slices, garlics knots and pepperoni..."
Michael Jusino
"Regular pizza was crispy and tasty, buffalo pizza was little bit thick but it was tasty. Owner has great personality, the staff was very friendly...."
Sahin Bakkalbasioglu
"Extremely nice for a local pizza place, service was phenomenal with the cashier knowing lots about the ingredients as well as the food was..."
Jake Deptola
"Pizza is always awesome here. A step above most. Many specialty slices to choose..."
"I have been to Emilio's quite a few times and this would be the first time I am writing a review. In most cases that I have been to Emilio's, I order..."
Acava
"Stopped in for a few quick slices...very friendly and tasty. Grandma's and marinara both very good! I'll come back and do the sit down restaurant..."
Marco
"GREAT food and GREAT service! We highly recommend Emilio's! Excellent Sicilian-style..."
Julie
"Noisy as it gets, if you can get past that then enjoy the full menu of tasty..."
Mark
"Risotto-mushroom is amazing. Creamy with lots of..."
Tanya Kaganovsky Leht
"Pizza. This establishment is on thier game in all aspects of customer servive, quality & old fashioned goodness:A must try, you won't be sorry;..."
RPalumbo
"Part of the family. My husband and I have been going here for yrs. It is nice to go where people know your name, and know your typical order. The..."
Kyrie Mantell
"A Commack legend...huge menu, a couple of amazing dishes. Grab a Sicilian slice you'll never forget or keep it simple with a traditional Italian..."
Laurlou
"Really good grandpa slices def their best slice pizza is the what they do best here but their pasta dishes arent to shabby either not a bad italian..."
Enjoyin Life
"Emilio's helps us to support our Veterans. Every 2 weeks we buy Pizza for our Veterans at the VA. The men at this facility pass up dinner waiting for..."
Fly
"One of our favorite Italian eateries... Excellent..."
Maria G. Baiardi
"Fresh, Zesty, and Huge. This place has won awards from Zagat for almost a decade for their excellence. A real treat. I was looking for the perfect..."
Bigcitytastes
"Some of the best pizza I have ever had, and the pasta dishes and wraps are delicious too. I highly..."
Ima
"Great fresh pasta. Emilio's has always been a great quality Italian place. I went there recently, after a very long break, and re-fell in love with..."
ARB
"Great pizza. Two pieces and a soda about 9 bucks depending on why you get you can beat that. The choices are plentiful and they all look and sound..."
Marc Gregory
"Always a good meal, fresh ingredients, and tasty bread basket!!! Don't stuff yourself on the delish bread because the food is plentiful and great..."
Rob
"Best of Class. Great restaurant, wonderful food. Best pizzas on Long Island. Marinara, Grandma's, Sicilian, salad pizzas. All slices always..."
BRAPPRA
"Stopped in for lunch and we were quickly seated. After browsing the menu it was nice to see many options but for me the prices are a bit high and..."
Victoria Duran
"Family friendly. Food was ok. Service was a mix of awkward and slow, but it was..."
Bill M
"Dined here on a whim with my mom for lunch and thoroughly enjoyed my experience. We were waited on by Sandy. She was friendly, and attentive and..."
Danak D
"Love this place! They have a big menu with options for everyone. Highly recommend sharing a pizza for the table as an appetizer! Came here with a big..."
Clarissa C
"Had the regular cheese slice , a Buffalo chicken slice , and a favorite of the three Bacon Chicken Ranch … first of all as I walked in I was..."
J Diplomatic (Fake Review Debunker)
"We had a delicious meal and outstanding service. The pasta fagioli is one of the best I've ever had. Calamari arrabiata was tender and plentiful. As..."
MARIA DISPENZA
"Hands down one of the best restaurants out there. Amazing food, memorable service, beautiful decor and fair prices.
Get the..."
Asaf Bochman
"Place was yummy. A bit over priced but decent food! Calamari was..."
Carolina Campero
"Absolutely amazing. The food here was so incredibly good, well, we took the 12 inch NY pizza, and it was delicious. The service was great as well,..."
Michelle Okonowicz
"Nice Italian restaurant. Bread served when we were seated
Meals were delicious, Big portions, nice atmosphere
Plenty of..."
AClayton
"Easily one of the best italian restaurants on long island. homemade pasta, great entrees and great..."
Fronimakis Anastasia
"This is one of my top 5 favorite pizzerias on LI, right next to Ralph's in Bayville and Umbertos of New Hyde Park. Emilios however, is more than just..."
Chris (Scipio Africanus)
"Wonderful, casual, reasonably priced and nice surprise from what you would expect at a pizzeria. This is a restaurant and quite enjoyable for family..."
Glenn
"Great red sauce Italian in a friendly and casual environment! A great option for a quick bite before the movies or other evening..."
"Great Brooklyn style pizza. Paul and Sal are great and I love their house special pie. After Dinapolis in Kings Park closed I tried 8 other places..."
Scott Peabody
"Great pizza and service. Had a problem with a delivery and they are replacing it immediately. Great way to treat..."
Anton Posner
"Good to see Sal still there and the family is still there.
Came in for a pie and house rice balls.
-Man you can't beat any other place DAMNN.
-I even..."
David Lew
"This place has the BEST chicken roll I ever had. Literally melts into your mouth everything about it is perfect I think it’s the best thing I’ve..."
kaseyyx21
"Incredible food! We catered my son’s baptism party from Original Brooklyn Pizza and had chicken Francese, eggplant parmigiana, and penne a la..."
Angela Hernandez
"Service is Top Notch and even though prices went up it is still worth it coming to this place for excellent Food. Paul and Sal should know what a..."
Car Wash Slayer
"Original Brooklyn never disappoints! It is an absolute staple in my household (especially their chicken marsala pizza). We've ordered personally and..."
Kay Ganzz
"Always fantastic food whether eating in or having it delivered. Their pies are great, almost like I really am in Brooklyn. The heroes are large and..."
Epsilon ChiPhi
"Hands down my favorite pizza on Long Island. It's as close to Brooklyn as you can get... with a paper thin, crispy crust and the perfect mix of..."
Michael Thomas
"The fresh mozzarella pizza is excellent. They also have the best--best grandma pizza. The rice balls taste like those in Italy. Nice, friendly..."
KAEFB
"There are good places, and there are places that are good - and make you feel like family. The guys at Brooklyn are just that - they’ll fix up..."
Devin Brandes
"Been coming here since I was a little kid and it'll be the pizza my kids grow up on. It's a family run joint and they always ask how my mom is doing..."
Vins Labels
"When I think of pizza this place is the standard. I grew up going to this place, and can’t recommend it strongly enough. I moved away and can’t..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes