The Italian sausage pizza I had was amazing. I past at least 3 other pizza shops on the drive there and it was so freaking worth it.
Stopped in after son played at Cooperstown dream park. Not being from New York, but hearing how great the pizza is, they did not disappoint.
Stopped by while in town to see the Hall of Fame. This place did not disappoint. Pizza was by far one of the best I've ever had! Friendly staff too. Thank you!
Delicious! I finally understand why NY pizza is the very best pizza.
Great pizza (loved the gluten free option) and friendly staff
Stopped in to eat after visiting Baseball Hall of Fame. Had the Veal parmigiana. Service was friendly and helpful. Food was hot, fresh and excellent. Veal was tender and the sauce was just the way I like it. Price also very reasonable. If I am back here in Cooperstown I will definitely stop back in.
Stopped by close to 8PM yesterday after visiting the Baseball HOF. There were plenty of seats. We ordered a large pizza and it was fantastic. Price was very reasonable. My wife grew up with NY style pizza, but I'm Chicago pan. I was impressed! She was, too. Free refills on drinks. If we every come through Cooperstown again, we will stop!
This place is a "must visit" place.. one of our favorite places to eat!
Great place, good food, nice people! I've been living on their food for a month and I'm picky. :)
Planning my recent trip to Cooperstown, I found out about New York Pizzeria and planned to come here for dinner after a fun day. And the verdict was, the pizza was delicious, the best pizza I ever ate. Great job.
Excellent Pizza and service. Being from the big easy in new Orleans. Pizza definitely did not disappoint.
Great pizza...cheesy and greasy, just the way I like it! A little warm upstairs though.
The pizza was fantastic! The A/C could have been turned on though.
Chicken riggie and the most ginormous delicious pizza. We ate well in Cooperstown!
Fantastic! Friendly. Great pizza!!
Will come back next time we are in Cooperstown.
Food was good. Pizza was a little greasy but not bad. Dough and sauce were good. Garlic knots were also good
Clearly a busy day! They are quick at taking the orders! Affordable pricing! Fast service!! I ordered a Small Buffalo Wing Pizza !! Most importantly it was delicious 😋!!🍕
We’re in town, visiting. Fridays are pizza days. We decided on New York Pizzeria. It was AMAZING! My son is picky about his pizza and he LOVED this! The pizza was some of the best I’ve ever had. The staff was super friendly and so helpful. If we ever come back, we’ll definitely eat here again!!
Last year we discovered this place and we made sure to stop again this year. During our visit to Cooperstown, we must have eaten here 3 times!! The pizza and wings are soo good! A must stop!
We dined inside, outside (weather was perfect) and we did take out.
I was blown away by how delicious the chicken parmigiana hero was! Chicken was so soft and tender, the bread was delicious, and the pizza was pretty good as well! The atmosphere and staff are very friendly. If you're in Cooperstown, this place is a must-dine.
This place hit the spot after a long morning on the baseball field. I would highly recommend it! The food was excellent.
My partner and I often get lunch here as he works at Bassett and has 30 minutes for lunch. Those who work the register are super polite with us. We love cold cheese slices! They also have a wonderful dessert fridge on the counter with tasty treats to enjoy.
I got a Calzone with Ham and GF got a Pasta Dinner. The food was hot, fresh and delicious. The staff were extremely pleasant and very friendly.
I stopped in for a bite while visiting my father at Bassett. I ordered a plain cheese slice. It was the best pizza I have had since moving to Western NY in 2003. The pizza was true NY( Brooklyn style.) Cheese was good but not too greasy, not too much sauce. The crust was the perfect thickness with just a hint of salt. The restaurant has plenty of seating and a loft area with TV’s. Overall it was a comforting atmosphere. Thanks!
Diligent and friendly staff with fantastic pizza.
I grabbed a couple of slices for lunch. They had my favorite crust; a nice crunch into a warm, soft center. Also, they didn't skimp on the cheese or toppings. Great pizza, you won't be disappointed.
Cooperstown-Being local, we often order a couple large pizza’s to go.
Always ready on time, delicious, and everyone likes them. Service is also always good.
Consistently a great place for pizza, and probably other foods as well
Delicious pizza and mozzarella sticks. Sticky tables and high chairs,, but yummo I haven't had pizza this good in I can't remember when. 5 stars if things were a bit cleaner. I don't want to have to wipe the high chairs before we sit.
Great Pizza. Very nice staff
We devoured a pizza and garlic knots. Our only complaint is that we didn't order more knots! This pizza was great.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes