12 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"We were all wicked hungry after kayaking on Lake Otsego, and we decided to get dinner here after driving by here so many times before. The food was..."
Regina Riem
"I was passing through Cooperstown, I Googled something up and saw this pop up as a suggestion so I drove five minutes to get there. Really glad I..."
Kitty Couture
"Came here for dinner with a group and found the food to be amazing and the service excellent. We ordered multiple items like chicken riggies, lobster..."
Ajay Bansal
"Wow! We've been here a couple times for lunch and this is our first time here for dinner. I can honestly say, every single thing was AMAZING!!! You..."
Joe Sweet
"Hand made pasta .. warm bread beautiful ambience. Loved the food. Outdoor sitting was good and warm. Their service could be improved. And btw they do..."
Mary Britto
"What a nice little restaurant. Everything is cooked to order. The greens (Verdura) were great as well as the meatballs and Caprese salad. My..."
david gutowski
"Unbelievable!! The spaghetti carbonara was so good I could cry. I asked for the espresso martini recipe because it was so tasty. And the..."
Catherine Bryden
"Probably the best experience dining experience we've ever had! Fresh, delicious, and a smiling staff. We went a couple of weeks ago while driving..."
Kathy
"Delicious Italian food with a great staff, especially our waitress Rachel. She was very nice, extremely personable, informative and..."
Paul Vetrano
"Every single dish was amazing!!! Loved that the greens were crunchy and not soggy as well as flavorful. The mussels in wine, butter, and garlic sauce..."
"Very good food, decent prices and great sized portion for the pasta and veal parmigiana. Feel like this is a must when visiting Cooperstown. The..."
Pawan
"Great service, amazing food and fantastic atmosphere! Took a quick trip to Cooperstown and picked here out of a bunch of options. We got the octopus..."
Brooke Clayton
"We wanted to find a nice restaurant near our hotel and we hit the jackpot at Toscana. Lobster Ravioli and Chicken Parmesan….delicious. Nice..."
Lucy Dee
"If I could give this place more than five stars, I would. My wife and I walked in and asked for a table. Though they were clearly busy and backed up..."
Whiskey Plays
"Amazing dining experience for my husband & I who were celebrating our wedding anniversary by visiting the beautiful cozy town of Cooperstown, NY. We..."
MaryBeth Jewell
"I live roughly five hours away and still make sure I can find away to come past here once a year for my birthday dinner in July. This is by far the..."
D “Shellsabub” H
"3 of us went to the hall of fame and saw this place across the street. We are so glad we did!!!! Liz was the best!! All and I mean all our needs were..."
Steve Cherry
"I’ve been a few times now. Sea bass special is delicious. Calamari done right. Very busy for good reason. Great staff, especially considering how..."
Stacey Mae
"Fantastic food. The Haddock was a large filet that tasted excellent. The cheese ravioli in vodka sauce was wonderful. Service was spot on. And..."
John Daum
"Came here for our anniversary dinner and really enjoyed our meal. The cozy, warm Italian vibes were romantic and charming. The service was..."
"This place was recommended by Patty at Rose and Thistle Bed and Breakfast. It was without a doubt one of the best meals I have ever had. We started..."
Stephanie Mary Bentley
"M husband and I Just ordered two blackened chicken sandwiches.. let me tell you..... Sooooooooo amazing. We have eaten at Mel's alot.. This sandwich..."
Jessica Humenanski Van Dyk
"Our food was excellent - chicken parmesan for me and sirloin for my husband. There homemade marinara was amazing! Service was great from the hostess..."
Cary Hatton Sylvester
"We have been to Mel’s for lunch and loved it but this was our first dinner there. We come up from NJ often as we have a home in nearby Sharon..."
Carol Mitschele Klotz
"My boyfriend and I ate at Mel’s this past weekend and we enjoyed every single thing! We made reservations for Saturday night and got right to our..."
Laura Bornt
"Really nice place to go when visiting Cooperstown! The chef/owner came out to ask everyone how everyone’s food was... great service... will..."
Tommy Kafkalas
"OMG!!! If you go here you must get the scallops -appetizer and the lobster risotto!!! Major..."
Cooper Turner
"We really enjoyed the food here!! Our server was really great...attentive to our needs and a step ahead. We will be eating here whenever we are in..."
Kristen Parker Dandreano
"Great food. Excellent wait staff (Rebecca). Coffee was extremely good. My wifes drink was very well..."
Kevin Catheron
"Food was excellent. Staff was very friendly and attentive. I had dinner here on a Saturday evening at 7:00 and goodness was it prime time. Good thing..."
Bre C
"We had reservations at another establishment but decided to dine here at last minute and so glad we did. Service was top notch, our server Sean was..."
Kathy Eaton
"This is a great spot for food and drinks on the tiny strip that is downtown Cooperstown. Having just spent a week in a rough and tumble camp barracks..."
Paul Waldschmidt
"It's definitely a place that is above a country town caffe! Cute corner with fast service and nice food. The food was both tasteful and appealing...."
Walkiria Perez
"Mel's was absolutely amazing. Our dinner and cocktails were great. There is a casual vibe but a more upscale menu, which seems to fit Cooperstown..."
Emily Robinson
"Do not overlook this little gem! You have to try it! We visited the Baseball Hall of Fame and while walking to Sam’s Pizzeria across the street, we..."
Regina Comer
"First visit to Cooperstown NY in 40 years. Chose Mel's since it was very close to our rental. Food and service was outstanding! Had the curry..."
Fred Duncan
"Highly recommend this restaurant! The food is fantastic. The service was great. If you do plan to visit from out of town as we did, I do suggest..."
Matt Augustine
"We were visiting the Hall of Fame and stopped here for lunch. We had a party of 10 and they figured out how to accommodate us even though it was busy..."
J B
"Service was excellent and the food was very good. The pesto garlic fries were the best! I wish we had Crabbies ginger beer in GA!..."
Amanda Davis
"What a great little restaurant! We day at the bar and had dinner; the bartender was wonderful. My husband's filet was cooked perfectly, and I had a..."
Carolyn Hoffman
"Great service and delicious food! Ordered the rosemary shrimp, which was amazing. My daughter got the clique six salmon, which was also very..."
Amanda DeMarree
"Busy place in Cooperstown. One of the" fine dining" options in town. Lunch and dinner. Good quality food. Attentive service but can be slow when..."
Rich Herman
"Wonderful and service. Pesto fries were..."
Leslie Todd
"A valiant attempt at fine dining. Service was great, food was pretty good. Most of our dishes came out on the bland side and were overcooked. Given..."
Oh Doyle
"American fare at reasonable prices. The food, especially the burgers and salads were excellent. There is outdoor seating, but on a warm, uncrowded..."
Brad Moffett
"A HUGE thank you to Mel’s and MacKenzie for catering our wedding. The food was absolutely incredible! We received so many compliments from our..."
anneliese carrascoso
"Came in late, no reservation, but they were able to seat us, a group of five, in about five minutes. Place was crowded for a Thursday night, so u may..."
New York Strip Steak with Moody Bleu Cheese Crumbles
Pasta
Chicken Pesto
Cakes
Batter Dipped Haddock
Salad
Eggs Benedict with Bacon
Pesto
Crab
Salmon Filet
Fish
Scallops
Pancakes
Sandwiches
Paninis
Clams
Fish and Chips
Burger
Wine
Mussels
Scallops
Haddock fish
Salmon
Lobster
Omelette and Toast
Italian Lemon Cake
Shrimp
Crab Cake
Crab Cake Sandwich
Beef
Haddock
Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
Seafood Platters
Broiled Seafood Platter
Sit down
American
Bar
Seafood
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Reservations
Waterfront
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Great restaurant with amazing view of lake. The food was very good and the service was fast and friendly. We came here with a big group of baseball..."
Yessica Martinez
"Came to the lake front for dinner by myself. Sat outside over looking lake. Nice outside seating. Ordered the clam chowder and panini sandwich. Both..."
Delow Red
"Extraordinary amounts of patience required here. The atmosphere is awesome, the food was great although a tad pricey. Visited many restaurants while..."
MamiBear1
"Best seafood in town. I was there last night with friends and we enjoyed an array of meals. Started with the special appetizer clams. Done and..."
Barbara Riggs
"This was a wonderful place to eat. Staff was fast and friendly. Food was excellent. Views were..."
Kim Williams
"Have been for both breakfast and dinner. Amazing views and atmosphere! Dinners were appropriate portion size and had great flavor! Our entire party..."
JD Greenman
"A quiet, clean hotel (many would say motel) with a nice view of the lake and walking distance to hall of fame and..."
Martin Rodriguez
"Solid food! Not quite a Hall of Fame meal but it was rock solid. I had the crab cake sandwich.
The view and location is fabulous. It's so peaceful..."
Aaron Maass
"Very good food and great service. Nice..."
Mark Allen
"This rating is mostly based on the quality of the food and the uniqueness of the location. The chefs absolutely know what they are doing...2..."
James Whalen
"Nice. The room was small but new and clean. Not enough toilet paper for 2 people. :-( My wife walked to the office at 7:30am for more and they were..."
Colin Seitz
"Adorable restaurant on the water. We had the grilled cheese sandwich with candied bacon. A fantastic combination.
We accidentally came upon this..."
Reg Thatch
"Nice little stop on Otsego lake, tasty food and drink and great..."
"Friendly staff, good beer and delicious food. I had the "All American IPA". Not overly hoppy but tasty and very drinkable. The garlic pesto fries..."
Christian Hanrahan
"I don't have words... We had every beer on tap and every single one was amazing. We went back for food and I had the best burger of my life. The..."
Sheila Herbert
"A local recommended this place saying that they had the best burgers ever.... it did not disappoint! The burgers and chips were delicious as were..."
Season Consiglio
"Good place to eat ..very near Comfort inn and Holiday Inn hotel. A place to grab a bite to eat before or after Railroad Explorers..."
Arja Reels
"Really awesome place to go for good comfort food. Had the fried haddock which was beer battered. Just amazing food. They have small bar when you..."
Scott Harrigan
"Great stop for quality casual fare and friendly ambiance. A fresh take on the standard pub fare (steak or bratwurst, anyone?) and a good selection of..."
Ginny Kurz
"Good beer! Bratwurst and sauerkraut was..."
Louise Bolte
"Had an opportunity to both try a couple of their brews and eat dinner. Not sure what was better...
Loved the beer and the Brie Burger was..."
Robert Snow
"Stopped in to eat and have a beverage after visiting the National Baseball Museum. The food was phenomenal and my husband and I agreed it was the..."
Lynnette Paton
"Very excellent food and Beer 🍻 the service was fabulous 🤩 the 2 burgers at our table were both ordered med. and they were both perfectly..."
Bob Rehner-Brown
"We sat in the smallish tasting room / bar and tried a few beers. They were mostly pretty good. If you're wanting something off the tourist routes,..."
Nathan Chandler
"Great Microbrew in Cooperstown. They have a balanced selection of their own beer choices. They also have a guest tap and an assortment of ciders in..."
david gutowski
"Here’s a great out of the way stop. We had steak tacos that were some of the best that I’ve ever had and local beer and cider. That was the..."
"Staff is super awesome, food incredible and atmopshere is amazing. We had burgers for lunch, customizable to your preference. Bartender also..."
Mechalia Gratton
"Great place Gerry our Bartender was a great lady. She kept the beers n chow coming. The clam chowder was 2017 award winner for the winter carnival...."
Lonnie Cee
"Fun place, great tunes, friendly staff, and the food. I had French onion soup and a Warm beet salad both were..."
Mandy Hartman
"Excellent and friendly service! The food here is amazing. I had the Carolina Pulled Pork sandwich here last night and it was by far the best pulled..."
Sean Siffel
"After playing Leatherstocking Golf Course this past weekend, our ladies group ate both breakfast and dinner at this great restaurant. I had the..."
Barbara Akers
"We visited Cooperstown with some friends.. Found this Cafe and LOVED it!! The waitress was wonderful, helpful, friendly! ( Karen) The salads were the..."
Tracey Kirch
"Best spot on main st for your Cooperstown trip ! Good beer and good prices..."
Emily
"Tturkey sandwich was freshly roasted on premise...."
Rock Garramone
"Good food, good service, great selection of beer, try..."
Anthony T
"A Cooperstown stalwart..... The staff are well-trained, friendly, and fast. The regular menu is a bit stale, but the board of specials changes often,..."
Amanda Hill
"Fantastic. Great breakfast's-great price,Great lunch and dinner, alway a smile waiting to greet you, They appreciate your..."
Localcoop
"Great "pick your own" omelettes. Pieces of toast were HUGE. Even though it was a busy brunch time Sat, and we were a party of 6, we got seated..."
JJM III
"Delicious. Practically no wait, tables turn fast and the food is damngood. Try the..."
Andrew Bondarev
"Breakfast. Always stop in for breakfast, Never a wait and food and service is..."
Ron Zaprzal
"It's such a nice place!! I had a margarita and a BBQ Korean chicken, I'm not sure if they gave me that because there wasn't BBQ at all :( but it was..."
J. Yesenia Delgado
"Great service. Great food. Nice cafe on Main Street. So glad we gave the Doubleday Cafe a try. New England Clam Chowder and the Vegetable..."
Lucy Dee
"Cute hometown Bar/Cafe eatery. We had a very friendly waitress and the desserts, which are in-house, hit the spot with a cup of coffee. They also..."
Clarence Fernandes
"We are from out of town so we were hoping to find a nice local place with great food. This place was everything the good reviews said on here. And..."
Stephanie Porth
"This is a great spot for lunch! Amazing food and service. Great location in main street. Our waitress was very friendly and kind. Love the..."
Yessica Martinez
"This is 100% a tourist town so finding amazing food at good prices just isn’t going to happen. Overall in most towns I would give them a 4, but..."
Michael “Wolfy” Howes
"It was our first time visiting Cooperstown for Doctors & after looking for breakfast came across this cafe we had No idea it was a baseball hall of..."
JUDY MORALES
"Nice baseball themed cafe with excellent food and service. My wife (who is not a baseball fan) liked it. She said, "A quaint place that takes you..."
Ralph Rio
"Had a delicious reuben for lunch. Lunch was so good we were still full at dinner time so we popped back in for dessert. The mudslide pie was..."
Lynn Cichocki
"I had a great meal, French Onion soup and the Grilled Chicken BLT. I highly recommend stopping here for a bite to eat. Great staff and always..."
Mr. S (Honest Reviewer)
"October 2023. Stopped for some lunch. First timers. Service was very good. We had a chicken BLT. It was ok. The taste was good but it came on a roll..."
LEMA FAMILY
"Brunch was very good here. Everyone in my party was happy. This is apparently the place to go during the off season in Cooperstown and i can see why...."
K Lee
"Service was awesome, no wait to be seated. Food was priced well and tasted..."
Jennifer Lauck
"The food was surprisingly good. The cafe used shell pasta for the macaroni salad, which is a novel. The place was busy, but wer were seated..."
Bob Baxter
"We been coming to Double Day cafe for induction weekend for over 20 years. This is the only place we eat breakfast at while in town, Highly..."
Patrick & Allison OBrien
"The food was awesome and the service was fantastic! It was packed but the food came out fast, I will be going back soon. Also, the bartender/manager..."
Left Field Lou
"One of the best places to have a beer and something to eat in Cooperstown village. The magician bartender is phenomenal. My wife and I were in town..."
"Had a fantastic meal with an equally fantastic view of the lake! I got the truffle burger with fries, and it was delicious (pictured). (My companion..."
Kelly Phillips
"The place is so beautiful!!!
The food was great and Jim, our bartender was very friendly and welcoming!
Were definitely coming..."
Zonika Rizz
"Very great vegan options. Good service. Carrot hummus is AMAZING! A little expensive but that’s what you get on the lake with amazing food. Could..."
Autumn Coogan
"I love the Hawkeye, there was three of us for lunch during a work day. Service was quick, lunches were served quickly, wait staff was awesome and..."
Robin Walrath
"Great atmosphere! Food and drinks are delicious and service was great. There was live music playing while we were..."
Julie Lanty
"If you are looking for a dining experience with incredible views, gracious staff and relaxed atmosphere then the Hawkeye is your perfect spot.
Our..."
Anne DeSimone
"Great little gem. Burgers were out of this world! The view is AMAZING!! Our waitress was super friendly and attentive. Yummy bloody Mary. Reasonable..."
Genna P
"Not a bad place, lacks coziness, too big and feels like something is missing but overall a great place with good food but you have to know what to..."
Nata
"Fantastic place to eat with an amazing view of the lake. Their burgers are delicious and the staff is..."
Marcia Moraski
"My friend and i were there today (12/2) between 1:30 and 4:00PM. The bartender on duty was Nikolai. We were so impressed with his efficiency,..."
"Food was fresh and well made. We all enjoyed our meals. Not much on atmosphere, but you don't eat atmosphere. We'll go again next time we're..."
Janice Lambertson
"amazing food, hibachi and sushi is worth going back! good customer service as..."
Grace H
"Very quiet and the food was well prepared. My only complaint was that the Scallops in my Hibachi dinner we’re a bit over..."
William Emmons
"An Oasis in Cooperstown.
The food came out very quickly, 5-10 minutes from my order. Their tempura bento box was excellent! Each piece was..."
Ainsley McCall
"So delicious! I loved it. The highlight of my trip to this town. Little spendy, but we got quite a bit of food and filled us 3 all up for..."
airi
"This was an excellent location to get sushi for the night. We came into town and we were not very familiar with the area and the external appeal was..."
Dan Fial
"Sushi sashimi combo was great! Excellent presentation and good portions. The staff is very welcoming and courteous. The price are typical neither too..."
Richard Miller
"Service was fast and very nice. Food was great, but portions (for kids and adults) were a bit much. But anyways great variety and great..."
Ryan Michalowicz
"Nice service. We had a sushi boat for two. Good quality and..."
Neil Halin
"I live by the ocean and have access to terrific sushi. I didn’t expect this to be on par with what I have had at home, on the other coast, or in..."
Justin Fox
"Food is excellent, beyond anything I've had in new york or California. Staff is great, ambiance is low key, Jason was the..."
Joseph Dee
"Good food and..."
Rachelle Janiga
"The sweet potato roll is incredible and the service was so fast!!! We will definitely be going back again very..."
Katie D
"Take out is great...never ate inside..better than expected..nice staff...great food..great..."
Kathleen Colwell
"Probably the best sushi I have ever had freshly made and cooked just perfect and they made it really..."
"A real find tucked away along the shore of Lake Otsego. The waitress (as all that we saw) was super friendly and efficient. The food was reasonably..."
Stephanie Davis
"Luckily we came early enough we were able to get a spot directly on the water. Next time I would do one on the upper deck as I feel he would get a..."
Christine Kazlauskas
"My husband and I dined here. The service was attentive and friendly. We started with crab cakes. No fake crab meat here. Yummy! Then we had a lobster..."
Nicole Karker
"Went here for dinner to celebrate getting engaged 💍 while on vacation! This place was a very quiet & intimate spot .We sat outside with a perfect..."
Meagan Higgins
"Lovely views of the lake from the covered porch or lakeside. Fast and friendly service.
Check out the fantastic gift shop on your way in or..."
Anne DeSimone
"It was our first day here in Cooperstown we arrived pretty late and it was only 15 minutes before they closed
We were pretty hungry because of..."
John Tseng
"Service was great, food is always amazing, chef was able to do a bit of a requested modification to replicate a prior menu item and it turned out..."
Nicole Corrigan
"Arrived early on a summer Saturday eve and we were seated right away for a table of six without reservations. Yay! Service was attentive. Food..."
Julie Stepp
"Must go if you are in coopstown
Amazing view and a lovely place to shop
A little pricey so go out for a celebration if you are tight on the budget..."
Mary Britto
"You never know when they are open or not. The web site hours are not always correct. We drive an hour to get there only to find it closed sometimes..."
"We bring our entire baseball team here annually and they always welcome us with great service and delicious food. The menu is large and the prices..."
Michael P. Cracco
"Such a wonderful experience! The bartender was great! The waitresses were amazing! Everything was..."
Megan Hughes
"Was upstate in Cooperstown for a baseball event with the family also went to the wax museum stopped in for a late lunch early dinner at the hardball..."
Cosmo Nestola
"We enjoyed our lunch at Hardball. They had big picnic tables in the back for large groups- like our baseball team. Average food, but better than some..."
Natasha Pittman
"Can't speak for the whole menu but the French Dip sandwich was probably the best I've ever had. I wasn't even that hungry and I devoured the whole..."
"Me and a coworker were looking for a handicap accessible place to eat and had a hard time finding one....The owner came out and offered to lift our..."
Jennifer Weber
"Glad we found this place, great burger. Brats. Ruebens. Ribs. You’ll like..."
Jeff Davis III
"Good food just around the corner from the Hall of Fame! Nice menu with food for kids and adults (and several flavors of ice cream). Owner was..."
John Lott
"Really good food...wife enjoyed the Monte Cristo..I had a German Burger...Cooperstown Blonde draft..we were served by the owners..nice..."
James Czerwinski
"We visited The Pioneer Patio 2x's during our week of tournament play at the Cooperstown Dreams Park. This place is DELICIOUS!!! The staff was so..."
Leah Zimmerman Rollins
"Great place to..."
Andrew P. Thompson
"Love the food love the wonderful friendly staff but it's a shame that I have to go to the Sherman tavern to get my twisted..."
Pris Jacobson
"Phenomenal service and food. My husband and I will make the hour drive to come out again and..."
Heather Allyn Isphording
"This is worth finding in Cooperstown, it is on a side street and not on the Main Street but only a five minute walk from the museum. Cute covered..."
Flash Moll
"Good food, friendly staff, out of the way respite. Nothing artisinal, just plain old good food...and drinks! I ordered a burger, the waitress did not..."
Krissy T
"Prices are a little high, but that makes sense given the location. The food was great and the service was friendly and efficient. Highly..."
Amy Mulzer
"Nice German restaurant with outdoor patio, deck or indoor dining, in Alley in back of Main Street. Ice Cream shop next..."
Scot Egg
"We were so glad to come upon this place, just off Main Street. Great food, a cool atmosphere and our server Ro was an absolute delight. We will be..."
Robert Fitz-James
"Fantastic food and great service! The heated patio was very nice and the price was very reasonable! The environment of the town is also very nice,..."
Quantum_ Leaps
"I love coming here. Food is good, atmosphere is great. Cute..."
Charlotte Bernhardt
"We go there every 2 years when we visit the HOF. Food is always..."
Stephen Mykoliw
"One of my favorite places to eat in Cooperstown! It family friendly, and you can eat outside on the porch even when it gets cooler (the porch has a..."
Kim Cossey
"Wonderful place to eat awesome food in a relaxed atmosphere. Great service by a bubbly and attentive waitress named..."
Silvia Bragulla
"I absolutely love it there! The food comes out quickly and tastes good. The service is amazing! Would definitely..."
Nadia Therese
"When we came in they had a very large group on the bottom deck. Two waitresses came over separately told us they had a group and if we didn't mind..."
Saver Momma
"We had the opportunity to have dinner at the Pioneer Patio Restaurant and it was Fabulous! The food was delicious and the patio comfortable, but..."
Barb Bunch
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes