"Absolutely love this place! Not to mention that they are the only restaurant in town that has good beer on tap..."
Clint Gabbert
"A nice place to eat in downtown Craig.The spaghetti and meatball dinner was very tasty. Italian restaurant with many selections of..."
William Charles Schulte
"Excellent food. Wasn't expecting the price of the steak to be $36 But it was worth it in food and service. I'll be in for 22in widow maker next..."
Eric Heflin
"Some of the best food I had was from here! Waiters are awesome, always have fresh food, drinks are never empty! Great..."
Blake A. Wertz
"We had a party of 10 people and they were busy and they took us in and seated us quickly! Service was perfect and the food phenomenal! We're not from..."
Collett Thacker
"Best pizzeria in northwest Colorado, damn good chicken alfredo..."
Justin Patrick
"Food is always hot & consistent. Wait staff always..."
Chris Lyons McKinley
"Love the people best food. Love the atmosphere. Staff makes you feel like..."
Steven Baptist
"Excellent Pizza! Brett has some great golf story's to tell. Great to see some Dead Heads in Craig! Highly recommend this place and will be..."
Craig Erlandsen
"Great service & a great meal. The new "look" in the back dining area is..."
Wayne Wright
"Fabulous place to eat. Great food. Friendly employees, clean..."
Ryan O'Harra
"Best Beer on tap in town along with the best food..."
Kyle Hammer
"All it was advertised to..."
Heathyr Knowles
"We miss coming in for a great meal and the atmosphere. Even more we miss seeing Brett and Stephanie!
Congratulations on Mulligan's! Dave and..."
David Dremel
"I love to get a calzone and choose the toppings I want in it. Also, the Colowyo stromboli is delicious. We have to order the bigger one because we..."
Julia Whitten Fineran
"Carelli’s Pizzeria a quiet little fancy restaurant in the small town of Craig. This place is absolutely divine. The atmosphere was comfy, warm,..."
Charae Flores
"A great stop as you head out or into the mountains or anywhere! Crispy crust with just the right amount of doughy edges. Slices ready to go or whole..."
Drew Griffith
"Just outstanding. Nice selection of beer. Micro brews. Good ipa. Lots of options for Italian food. A very good..."
Aloys Metty
"We had one of the BEST meals, today!
Eggplant parmesan, mushroom steak, and walleye dinners!
Exceptional food! Excellent service!
I am from out of..."
Sheila Madison
"It was my first time in Craig, CO. Carelli's pizzeria was one of the recommendations from FOH at the Hampton Inns hotel. After a bit of a Google at..."
Fearghal Bergal
"This place is so good. In town visiting and decided to give it a try. The shrimp scampi and the steak were great. Fresh high quality food. Thank..."
Sarah M
"I've never had anything bad there. Their pizza is great, love the colowyo stromboli, & homemade ranch salad dressing. Excellent service too, so..."
Nancy Croy Hirano
"Occasionally come to Craig for work, this is my favorite place to eat. Had the prime rib special with garlic mashed potatoes and veggies, it was very..."
David Hymel
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes