Best Peanut Butter Cookie in Denver

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Hinman's Bakery
Hinman's Bakery
97/100 (114 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Croissant
Peanut Butter Cookie
Blackberry Pie
Apple Pie
Cherry Danish
Blueberry Hand Pie
Spinach and Artichoke Hand Pie
Café
American
Mid-range
"Wow , what a gem of a business. Their baked stuff is the best I have had since I left my native country the Netherlands. The Ham and Cheese..."
Fred Kops
"After purchasing two pies, cookies and a Yule log from Hinman's bakery, I can only say John and his staff are doing excellent work! These folks..."
David Muramoto
"The cheesecake is to die for....along with some many other yummy..."
Kristi Cooke
"Gave an artichoke/cheese hand pie and a cherry one too a try at the Montview Preschool carnival on Saturday, went to the storefront today for lunch,..."
Dawn Mendel
"We haven't been to the storefront but we picked up a Cowboy Pie today at Heine's Market and holy moly so delicious. I see a lot more Hinman Pies in..."
Jessica Woodbury
"Before I even got to try the pie I would have reccomended this biusness to anyone. The owner was so nice and went out of his way to help me for a..."
Kandace Lucas
"My fiancé and I ordered an assortment of Hinman’s mini, handheld PieEttes for our engagement party and they were a success! John was easy to work..."
Juliana Todeschi
"This place is great! I walked inside was hugged by sweet aroma of pastries. I purchased the key lime pie and it was delicious-- it was the perfect..."
Ana Temu Otting
"WOW... if you have not tried one of these pies you are truly missing out. I went to the local Heinie's market, Full intentions to purchase a..."
BA Sumner
"I had the great pleasure of receiving two Hinman pies, cherry and apple, for my birthday. Absolutely 100% delicious! These are some of the best pies..."
troy zabel
"I came across this place when I was looking to give a friend a pie for his birthday. Well...these guys know pie...sweet pies and savory pies. I have..."
Sarah Parmley
"I experienced Hinman hand pies today for the very first time! I picked them up at our local Farmer’s Market. They were awesome! Not too..."
Cindy Furman
"Holy moses, these hand pies are awesome! I ordered a dozen of Hinman's frozen hand pies to bake at home, so happy I did. The Huckleberry is legit..."
Theresa Wynn
"My husband and I found this bakery at the Pearl Street farmers’ market and are glad we did! The chicken mole and the blueberry pies were delicious!..."
Katarina Wisniewski
"While attending the Denver Flea Holiday Craft Fair, we had the opportunity to try, and then purchase several baked items from Hinman's Bakery...."
Kimberly Schmit
"Baked a pork green chili personal pie at home. Amazing! Great crust and the filing was amazing. Good stick to your bones warm comfort food on a cold..."
A D
"Delicious pies! We had blueberry and salted maple, both fantastic! The owner also went above and beyond to ensure his customers were all satisfied..."
William Bunge
"What an amazing addition to the neighborhood! The place is totally unassuming but the food is fantastic. We have been there 2 days in a row at this..."
Julie Hinson
"We ordered the Neapolitan Hand Pies for all our staff for Pi Day and they were soooo tasty! And thank you for delivering in spite of a raging..."
Matt Sherman
"I'd purchased pies from another bakery for the holiday but we were gifted an assortment of Hinman Pies hand pies by a friend. Long story short the..."
Jocelyn Haufe
"My now wife and I wanted pie instead of wedding cake. John's hand pies were perfect! Our guests loved them. Thank you for helping make our wedding..."
J. Scott Kiger (Crow)
"THE HANDHELD APPLE PIES!!! OMG! I need everyone to stop what they are doing and grab one expeditiously. My friend and I accidentally walked into a..."
Chiemerie Ogbonnaya
"My husband is SUPER picky about pies and actually bakes them well, but sometimes we just need a pie now and we would never buy one anywhere else...."
Stephanie Effken