26 with Mushrooms Half Banana Peppers Half Black Olives
Single Slice Build Your 'Za w Basil Mushrooms and Sausage
Salad
Sit down
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Service wasn't the best, as waitress never came back to check on us and we had to ask another waitperson for water, and I believe one shouldn't have..."
Jennifer Lonnes
"🍕 Great place for NY style pizza in Denver, no complaints here!
Idk why the reviews for this place are such a mixed bag, but I *almost* let that..."
Michaela Starling
"Love Fat Sully's! A single slice is a meal. They are huge slices, true New York style. Fold it in half and..."
Andrea DePoyster
"Thems some big pizzas - and I like big pizzas. Really though...some good thin pizza to highlight your favorite toppings. Folding is..."
Matt Meow
"This place is great for a lot of different “dates” friend date, 1st date, date night. They have NY style pizza slices that you can add toppings..."
JC
"We always make it a plan to go here when we come into town. My New York husband is is very picky about his pizza and he absolutely LOVES this place!..."
Sky Malone-Quigley
"A really fantastic pie. First time ordering and I got 1/2 cheese and 1/2 supreme style. You can fold the slices in half like NY style and the tomato..."
B. Marcin
"I recently tried the 20-inch pepperoni pie at Fat Silly's Pizza, and it was nothing short of amazing! 🍕 For just around $20, you get an enormous..."
Sedrick Perry
"If you are from New York like me, you have found your new favorite local pizza slice. For a real taste sensation, go inside and order a whole pie! It..."
Alan Sherin
"Pizza was great but I made a huge mistake of ordering the 26” pie in house with only two of us to eat it. My girl and I are very medium sized..."
Mike Camarco
"I thought the pizza was excellent. NY style, very thin crust and large slices. We ate at the outdoor window and the service was definitely below..."
Andrew Schneider
"Good pizza, just a little hard to eat because the slices are HUGE and the only option for a regular size pizza is gluten free. But pretty good. I..."
Rebekah Moncada
"This has literally the best pizza I have ever had in my life and I am a complete pizza foodie. If you love thin crust, don't even think about it,..."
Madison Castillo
"This place is kid friendly and has great comfort food, and their pizza is really tasty (that's coming from someone on the east coast). In the morning..."
m russo
"Amazing thin crust/NY style pizzas, and they're HUGE!! Wings are great too and so are the salads and beer..."
Sammy Knoxville
"Rockin local joint for huge slices, great salads and a quality smash burger! The waffle fries take any place to school! Great late night..."
Mark Shin
"Stopped for something to eat yesterday after walking dogs for an hour, really quick and very good. I accidentally ordered gluten free.. didn’t read..."
Taylor Strother
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes