Best Ice Cream in Eastham

3 restaurant menus in Eastham, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Ben & Jerry's
Ben & Jerry's
88/100 (432 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Birthday cake
Sorbet
Waffle Cone Sundae
Sprinkles
Ice Cream
Vanila and Chocolate Ice Cream
Chocolate-Dipped Waffle Cone
Milkshakes
Banana split
Caramel Macchiato
Café
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Takeout
Mid-range
"Its become a tradition for our family to stop at Ben and Jerry's to have a yummy treat on our way to go to the Wellfleet drive-in right down the..."
Kelley Curtis Godin
"Great little ice cream shop. Staff so friendly! If you're in Cape Cod you have to go..."
Rich Thompson
"Though we only visit the Cape twice a year we never miss Ben &Jerry's. I can taste a large waffle come Cherry Garcia now!!..."
Skip Carpentier
"Free cone day is a sucess!!! All staff is extremely friendly and cheerful!!! The ice cream is amazing as usual!!! It was a pleasure to meet Judy the..."
Ivana Rabay
"We had a great experience in this location. Staff was nice and friendly. They had everything on the menu even the new wiskey biz 😋 We was so..."
Stacey McKenzie
"Almost great ice cream and great service but looks closed from the road. It needs to be brightened up from the outside. I’m sure it would be busier..."
Jessica
"This place is amazing!!! The ice cream is FANTASTIC and the store is clean (I mean of course it is, it's Ben & Jerry's) Not only that, but they..."
Emily H
"Seriously - does Ben and Jerry's even need reviews?? You know you are getting some of the best ice cream made whether a cup, cone, sundae or shake!..."
Jim Perrone
"Chocolate therapy was delicious just the right amount of..."
Vahid Furblur
"Hand-scooped Pints of my favorite flavors was so worth the trip. It was busy, but the staff handled it well. Exactly what you'd want to experience..."
Duck-Duck Is My Dog! (Anna S.)
"Great place. Always come here when my family come on vacation to the..."
Erianna Gilbert
"Our go-to place for ice cream! It's been a huge part of our family vacations every year. The lines are long, but move quickly and are well worth it...."
Katia Hancock
"Ice cream at Arnold's is..."
Garth Cadiz
"LOVE THE NONDAIRY..."
Michelle Dewey-Dawson
"Fun different ice..."
Gina Santillo
"Great spot! Helpful..."
Sam
"Stopped in on July 24th at about 5 PM. Great service, and the girl at the counter was courteous and friendly. Got Cherry Garcia and a raspberry..."
Cuse Bill
"The guy who made us 4 shakes during a rush deserves some serious recognition. I imagine that was a pain but we were pretty sold on the idea before..."
Troy Dumas
Nauset Ice Cream
Nauset Ice Cream
86/100 (540 ratings)
Dessert
Late Night
Ice Cream
Frozen Yogurt
Sit down
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"Hands down the best place to get ice cream! The coffee health crunch is by..."
Jessica Ogonowski Picard
"Great flavors, generous portions, made in house. We also had them serve ice cream at our wedding last year, which was a big hit. Our family highly..."
Seth G. Slade
"Great generous servings and the Coconut Carmel Delight is my favorite..."
Judy Connolly Mitchell
"They have a variety of flavors and daily specials too! Kiddie size was huge enough for me. Tried the pistachio which was great and cookie dough which..."
Mary Ng
"Great local ice cream shop with homemade hard ice cream. Delicious coffee and chocolate peanut butter. We grabbed some on our way to the Wellfleet..."
Madeline C
"Best ice cream I've had on the Cape and one of the better ice cream places I've been to period. All homemade that are really well done with..."
Samuel Wenninger
"Average ice cream shop experience. Good selection of flavors. The ice cream was creamy and tasty. The coffee Oreo was great with large chunks of Oreo..."
Heather M.
"Excellent ice cream! Large portions. I had the mango sorbet and it was wonderful, a little tart and very flavorful. Rest of the family had ice cream..."
Andrew Schmitt
"I was busy eating ice cream so no photos but ice cream here was amazing! Love peppermint and coffee specially. Very fresh and not too sweet so I can..."
se SG
"Can't complain, decent ice cream. Not the best I've ever had, not the creamiest. But it's satisfying nonetheless on a hot summer day. Cookie dough..."
Lester Mendoza
"The portions are huge and they have amazing flavors! A must go place during any time of the day for a dessert! ❤️highly recommend from our..."
Prajakta Patkar
"Pretty good ice cream shop. Didn’t necessarily blow us away but it was still good. I would come..."
Adrianna DiNobile
"Don't be alarmed by the long line. Service is fast and great portion of ice..."
Kris Freymuth
"The fact there is a Ben and Jerry’s that’s in business 100 feet away is a shame. I feel awful for anyone who chooses to get ice cream from there..."
Chris Barish
"The ice cream is great and the young staff is always upbeat and..."
Peter Newman
"Excellent ice cream with tons of flavors. Good..."
Luc Nadon
"Best on cape. Try the Reese's peanut butter cup..."
David maciver
"Very good ice cream and not overpriced like most ice cream shops on Cape..."
craigcatolane
"Very good icecream. Good size scoops. Good friendly..."
John Taber
"Delicious ice cream, approved my the whole family including our lulu..."
Lorena Conley
Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar
Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar
86/100 (4221 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Clams
Fried shrimp
Oyster
Ice Cream
Calamari
Cakes
Mussels
Sandwiches
Fish
Calamares
Burger
Salmon
Crab Cake
Fish & chips
Chowder
Shrimp
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Steamers
Lobster
Fried Clams
Salad
Wings
Seafood Platters
Clam Chowder
Cod
Crab
Fish Sandwich
Scallops
French Fries
Sit down
American
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Cash Only
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We ordered the fish and chips and the clam strips. The batter they use comes out light and crispy and the seafood tasted so fresh. I felt that it was..."
Shawna R
"**CASH only establishment with ATMs on premises** THE BEST FISH I have ever eaten in my life - light, flaky, fried deliciousness - came with the..."
C
"Our favorite seafood spot on the Cape for years. Great food, casual atmosphere. Our favorites are the hot lobster roll, scallops, fisherman’s..."
Heather M.
"Yes the have the best fried clams !!! I went there and total cape cod kinda place. Order at the register and wait and bring your food to your table..."
Boston Irish2009
"I would definitely recommend this place while on the Cape. Good atmosphere and food variety for families. Line moved quickly, cash only, find a..."
Mike Hastings
"What a delicious and fun seafood joint! So many amazing choices and a great way to start our Cape Cod adventure! The lobster roll was incredible. ..."
RTM
"By far the best fried seafood! Best Onion Rings you can find! Always fresh and flavorful, never soggy. As a fried food junkie, I promise you these..."
Matt
"We got lobster, raw oysters, clam chowdah. Always lines, but worth it. Alcohol available. Full service and mini..."
Marc Dombrowski
"That is a $5 "small" 2-scoop ice cream. It is quite large and very filling! You can get 2 different flavors if you like. My kids have nut..."
Chester Liu
"This was a great family vibe, summer vibe, with great sea food at a decent price kind of place. This is not fine dining, in a stuffy atmosphere kind..."
Morgan Hill
"Overall great service, great quality seafood joint. Loved the fresh warm lobster roll! It was just what I was looking for visiting the Cape. My..."
Cassandra Domingos
"This place was fantastic! I've been here twice, once for a lobster roll and once for fish and chips, both were delicious. The service was nice, and..."
Kyle McFatter
"We have been enjoying Arnold’s for many years! We were there just the other day for one last lunch before flying back home. The fried lobster was..."
Jennifer W
"Not accepting cards is inconvenient. There is an ATM, but it does not add to the convenience. The food is good and the wait times are not long at..."
Amanda McAdams
"Always have to come here when vacationing! Amazing food and..."
Jo Sapphire
"This is a favorite stop on the Cape for us. Very fresh, high quality, simple, and tasty seafood. Menu is mostly fried, but I got the lobster roll and..."
Tibor Toth
"We got the seafood platter. We thought it was pricey however, the amount of food we got filled the two of us up with enough leftover for the next..."
bassinRN -Fishing-Flying-RVing