Best Lobster Roll in Edgartown

12 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
19 Raw Oyster Bar
19 Raw Oyster Bar
88/100 (675 ratings)
Restaurants
Bars & Pubs
Gluten Free Options
American
Bar
Bar
Gastropub
Seafood
American
Gastropub
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Lobster Roll
Shrimp and Grits
Charred Octopus
Chowder
Sriracha Fries
Lobster Roll
Clam Chowder Soup
Tapas
Duck Pot Pie
Tacos
Cod
Shrimp
Scallops with Crab Fried Rice
Octopus
Lobster
House-Made Chowder
Salad
Lobster Tacos gggggg
Clam Chowder
Spicy Lobster Tacos
Brussels Sprouts
Sea Bass
Steakhouse Burger
The cod
Crab
Oyster Platter
Slider
Scallops
Oysters on the Half Shell
Clams
Tuna Carpaccio
Oyster
Sea Scallops
Steak Tartare
Tuna
American
Seafood
Bar
Gastropub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"19 Raw is the PERFECT spot to bring your friends have cocktails and oysters on the patio and it is dog friendly! What more could you need! We had..."
Sarah Heaney
"What an awesome spot! The service was great, they treat you like you’re a regular even if it’s your first time. And the food was delicious -..."
Andrea Comer
"We have tried several restaurants all over the island, but I gotta give 5 ++ * to this restaurant. We first started with fish ceviche. The fish..."
QD Nguyen
"This was a great stop for lunch. Had the lobster roll, which was served warm on a toasted brioche roll. The roll was substantial enough to handle..."
Dotty Clapp Hodgkins
"This place is awesome! The oysters are the best on the Vineyard. The Kim Chee sauce is to die for. Drinks are great. The staff are fantastic and the..."
Andrew Harrison
"Absolutely Wonderful!!! Great patio, great food, great wine. Our server Joselyn was..."
Betsy Green O'Brien
"This place has only been open for about 2 weeks, but it has some of the best food on the island. If you love oysters and seafood, make it a must..."
Hannah Loewentheil
"Stupendous! The owner, bartender and service are the BEST to note, thus far. Very knowledgeable about the craft beers, which we loved. In addition,..."
Tara Toolan
"Saw the place buzzing with people the night before so had to pop in for lunch. Love the vibe. Unique atmosphere and one of a kind menu choices. Our..."
Deb Thibeault
"Amazing dinner! Excellent waitress Jocelyn!! Fabulous experience. Thank you for the best meal I’ve had on the..."
Patti DeLuca Quinlan
"Random stop on a day trip to Edgarton. If we lived closer, we would be regulars. Lobster taco was spot on as was the charred octopus. We also had a..."
Regina Mayhew
"Amazing culinary! A hidden gem. Thanks to my MV colleagues who introduced me to this..."
Jimmy Barber
"Delicious! I highly recommend the honey suckle oysters. My husband ordered salmon and the chef felt it was over cooked so made him a new one! My..."
Tina Hardt Vital
"Amazing food, service and atmosphere. One of my favorite places to eat, but more importantly, one of my favorite places to recommend to friends and..."
Greg Politz
"The lobster roll and the chowder were the best I've ever had!! The service was great. Everyone was really friendly and could not have been..."
Allie Yanka
"The staff was very friendly. Great service. And the lobster roll to die..."
Paul Anthony Demato
"Best seafood ever, nice staff, cozy athmosphere. It is a bit far otherwise would go there weekly. Frank -..."
Frank Geerts
"A true gem in the heart of Edgartown village! Gorgeous atmosphere, outstanding food and amazing service. Joe offers an incredible array of oysters,..."
Dina Salvatore BenDavid
"Clearly the best new spot on the island. Great atmosphere, great food, beer,great people, lots of fun, right in town, expect great success the rest..."
Michael Vacante
"19 Raw was absolutely awesome!! My partner and I came to Martha’s Vineyard to vacation. Someone gave us recommendations to come here and we..."
Mark C. Baker
"19 Raw Oyster Bar is one of a kind. My husband and I have traveled all over and this place is definitely one of a kind. I wish they were in our home..."
Kelly Shain
"Went three times during our 4 week stay in our sailboat! Oysters perfect along with lobster roll and tacos! A must do for any visitor to..."
Peggy Williams Schorle
"Awesome! Spicy Lobster Taco was real spicy but couldn't stop eating it!!! So good! Sat at the bar. Cool cool spot with great food. Buddha by Wash..."
Christopher Ward
"What a fun place and what delicious food - Joe and his team have created a new must go to eatery in..."
Guinevere Cramer
"Amazing! Perfect in every way! Great atmosphere and the food was top..."
Kelly Randazzo
"Great atmosphere...great food...great..."
Lori Shaffer
"Fresh flavors. Great oysters! Great drinks! Staff was awesome. We will be back...."
Ned Casey
"Everything was amazing and so fresh. Cod, Lobster Rolls, Lobster Tacos and those French Fries!! You can tell he cares about what he..."
Janine Fazzina Boudo
"Amazing place for super fresh seafood; great beef selections. Tried several items and everything was incredible fresh with great uses of subtle..."
W Dixon
"We had a lovely meal here today. After calling the Atlantic (our former favorite), they had said on the phone we could eat outside but we arrived..."
C Mayone
"Every one of our party of 7 had nothing but a stellar lunch here. Frank and staff were superb hosts. “One of top three lunches of my entire..."
Todd LaRoche
"What a blast. 19 Raw is such a fun, delicious, and fantastic venue. We decided to go the seafood route versus steak route for our dinner. Erin was..."
Natalie Caldwell
"We loved eating here! The oysters were fresh and delicious. We enjoyed the cocktail, kimchi, and vinegar based sauce. The cider we ordered was..."
Todays Present
"On A chilly but sunny evening. The front lady kindly turned on the outdoor heaters for us. Not just one but two heaters! For the price, we really..."
Samuel Choi
"When we arrived there was a private event happening. We asked if we could sit at the inside bar in the back dining area and the hostess figured it..."
Donnelle Jageman
"This place has it all figured out! We couldn’t believe how good everything was - the usual menu options but everything just a bit better than..."
Amanda Dragani
"Great service, a variety of drink options and fresh oysters! I recommend to try their local oysters, clams and their watermelon froze. It is locates..."
Carla Acosta
"Excellent experience having our entire meal at the bar outside. Everything was great from the drinks to the food to the service. This place..."
Scott Matus
"The innkeeper where we stayed recommended this place and it is truly a gem. Tuesday night it was closed but we checked on Wednesday and were very..."
Hilary Levitt
"This restaurant was delicious! Had mostly appetizers and small plates. Our waitress was great and helped recommend oysters and dishes. The octopus..."
Max Bulian
"We were a table of 7 people, and everyone felt this was the best lunch we have had. The ceviches and other seafood appetizers were beyond outstanding..."
Raimonds Dzelme
"I went in for lunch with my friends. My friend and I had their Spicy Lobster Taco and it was deliciously fresh. Then shared a side of Roasted..."
Amai
"We had a lovely dinner at this adorable restaurant. Location is perfect, just a skip off of Main. Service is attentive, not intrusive. We sat at a..."
Loretta Lambright Redrick
"Best oyster we had so far. Price is on higher side but worth every penny. Surprise that there are no bread but serve portion is..."
Joe Wang
"Went here on a Friday night, no reservations. We waited for about 25 mins no big deal at all as we had a drink at the bar. The place is beautiful!..."
JENNIFER FRONZAGLIA
"Took our first trip to Marthas Vineyard and this was one of our favorite places we ate. ordered octopus, gnocci, scallops with shrimp fried rice and..."
Amanda Key
"Other than restaurant seating, this place has two bars. We sat at the less busy one inside to the back right. Great service from the bartender and..."
Paraiso Realty
Wharf Pub & Restaurant
Wharf Pub & Restaurant
87/100 (1012 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Seafood
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Crab Cake
Lobster
Fish & Chips
Pasta
Lobster Roll
Salad
Broccoli
Cod
Wings
Potato Skins
Swordfish
Clam Chowder
NY Strip Steak
Fishermans Platter
Sandwiches
Fish
Fish Sandwich
Chili
Mango Margarita
Burger
Paninis
French Fries
Fried Dill Pickle Chips
Scallops
Mozzarella Panini
Hamburgers
Espresso
Nachos
Seared Wordfish with Asparagus and Potatoes
Clams
Fish & Chips
Cocktail
Cobb Salad
Washington Apple Martini
Oyster
Steak Frites
Fried calamari
Pesto
Friday Special Prime Rib and a Burger
Calamari
Lobster Roll
Mussels
Linguine & Clams
Calamares
Chowder Fries
Shrimp
Salmon
10oz NY Strip & Fries with Horseradish Cream
Beef
Jambalaja
Fish & chips
Sit down
American
Bar
Seafood
Pub
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Late Night
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"I've been coming here for years and have never once been disappointed. The food is always on point, the portions are quite generous and the staff is..."
Ken McGahee
"Just had dinner there this week. The Mussels are the best I’ve had on the Island. The meatloaf was also excellent. My wife Had the vegetable..."
Samuel A Kistler
"This is a def go to place for great food and service, one of the..."
Mikey Waters
"The service was great. The prices were affordable for a large family. I had the clam chowder over French fries and it was the best thing I've eaten..."
Cristina Negrón Mitusina
"The food at The Wharf Pub is excellent! My companions and I stopped in for lunch (as well as the opportunity to meet Jeff Voorhees, manager, who..."
David Bigelow
"Best people, excellent food, friendly and just a great all around place to visit, have a snack, have a drink or a meal, it's all..."
Laurel Clontz Beaulieu
"Alex Kintner signed my Jaws book, told stories from filming, and took photos with us. That alone was worth the price of admission. The wonderful..."
Stephen Demmer
"I remember getting my honor roll gift certificate in the late 1980s and taking my parents to the Wharf. Finally got to bring my own. Thank you for..."
Erikas Aleksander
"Since we stayed right down the street, it was our "go to place". We traveled to different places on the Island but would return nightly and head for..."
Vinny Cruz
"Nice location in the center of Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard cozy pub dining with a good variety and good..."
Jeanne Spillane Allard
"Excellent service!!! Great place to eat with family and friends👏One of our favorite places to eat!! The owners are wonderful!!! 5 stars all the..."
Tracy Ann Malowski
"Awesome awesome fish and chips calamari outstanding people the service is great excellent music you can never go wrong if you are at the vineyard..."
Joe Rehm
"We went to the Wharf after a dear friends mother's funeral. It was her mother's wishes after her service for all involved to go & get drunk. Well, we..."
Marc & Robin O'Donnell
"Excellent location and the food quality matches it. The chowder fries definitely stand out and are a must-try here. We ordered the pastrami with side..."
Swagat Mishra
"Ended up here 3 times on a work trip. Ordered steak frites all 3 times…the 2 orders I had at night were amazing, cooked perfectly, had the perfect..."
kevin Sivanthong
"A little confusing at first but once someone greeted us we were seated immediately. Food was pretty good. Drinks were okay. Service was marginal but..."
Blake Thomas
"We left Oak Bluffs due to a power outage and went to Edgartown by bus. We looked for a well-rated place that wasn’t on the main drag and found the..."
Dana Smith
"We had a great family meal out at the Wharf. Eddie our waiter was incredible. He was very kind to our son and even let him pet a lobster. Food was..."
Nicole Kopaczewski
"This place is a gem!! Jack, our waiter was absolutely amazing, food could not have been better, 5 stars all the way! If I could give 10 stars I..."
sharon Meyer
"Good food, small simple menu that is seafood based. There is a handful of vegetarian options that worked well for my wife. Portions were large and..."
Cyril Moore
"The food was good. It's a bit pricey. The waitress seemed..."
T S
"This is a great place to go if you’re looking for picky foods with a casual & chill experience. The customer service was great and all of the food..."
Shauna Lynch
"Casual atmosphere, good food and friendly staff. Interesting house drinks and an impressive selection of..."
Martin Schwartz
Edgartown Seafood
Edgartown Seafood
85/100 (175 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Seafood
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Lobster
Clam Chowder
Scallops
Chowder
Lobster Roll
Swordfish
Fish
Sit down
Seafood
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The new owners are great! Got some fresh sword and the cut it to order. Stuffed clams and stuffed scallops were delicious with plenty of..."
Bob Fiorito
"Not at all what I expected but it turned into a blessing in disguise. Edgartown Seafood turned out to be a fish market but still offered some of the..."
Evan Hamilton
"Always delicious with laid back, friendly service. Lobsters cooked to order..."
Todd Anderman
"Great island family owns this buisness. They also support and are good the the island commercial..."
Angela Fisher
"We recently vacationed on Martha’s Vineyard and wanted to bring some lobster home with us. I ordered 7 - 1 1/2 lb lobsters. They told me the best..."
Donna Kessler
"Friendly service, was able to answer all of my..."
Lakisha Bah
"Wonderful staff and even wonderfuller..."
Tobey Moller
"Love these guys. They are always open. Fresh fish. And a take out menu!!! Anything that comes out of that little window is well worth the effort and..."
Annie Bryan
"There are a couple of places to choose from if you want fresh fish to cook at home. I prefer this Market over the others. The fish is always fresh..."
Michael Teiger
"The hot buttered lobster roll is all you need to know! Oh, yeah and they have the freshest seafood and locally made pesto for pulling together dinner..."
kathleen b
"I highly recommend the fish..."
Jeremy Froehner
"Nice selection of fresh fish and seafood. Plus they make up nice dinners as well. Always fast and friendly..."
Steven Ogden
"The BEST salmon and shrimp. We went there 2 times the week we were in Martha's..."
Betsy Winchester
"Well organized, quite good seafood we did raw oysters, steamers and cooked cracked lobster. The..."
Irving Schoppe
Square-rigger Restaurant
Square-rigger Restaurant
84/100 (413 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Seafood
American
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Clam Chowdah
Lobster Roll
Grilled Stuffed Lobster
Cod
Katama Club Sandwich
Swordfish
Double Stuffed Lobster
Fish Sandwich
Sandwiches
Mocha and Chocolate Mousse Cake
Cakes
Burger
Garlic Asparagus
Clams Casino
Pesto
Fish
Fried Scallops
Grilled Salmon
Fish & Chips
lobster tail
Shrimp
Hamburger
Lobster
Chicken Wings
Lobster Bisque
Pasta
Seafood Paella
Salad
Surf & Turf
Breakfast Taco
Scallops
Fish Taco
Salmon
Fried Clams
Hot Lobster Roll
Chowder
Sit down
American
Seafood
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great place for lobster and prime rib! Added bonus is the bar, drink menu is fresh and the bartender Camilla is a..."
Lisa Woodford
"Very good food, be prepared to wait... clam chowder was delicious, but needed a little more clams, the fish in the fish tacos was cooked to..."
Len Bradner
"New owners! The lobster and steak were delicious, so tender, and cooked to perfection..."
Elisabeth Brosens
"Absolutely loved everything from the appetizers to dessert! Excellent staff and..."
Joseph Fulmore Jr
"My husband and I went there for the first time and it was Amazing. All of the staff was friendly and worked together which you rarely see. The..."
John La Magna
"Good size portions. Excellent fish Tacos. One order had two good sized tacos. Very fresh. The clam chowder was very starchy/thick and potato heavy...."
Jeff A.
"Our service and food was awesome! My leftover lobster bisque with the added pork bellies was even better the next day for lunch! I have already..."
T Lynn
"Loved the place, the food was good, and the price is not outrageous. Service is awesome..."
Carlos Henrique Trindade
"Kamila is the best, always ask for her!!!! Great experience and amazing drinks. She was really the..."
Alex Giesey
"Amazing food, great calamari and cocktails. Nice atmosphere, you can eat inside or out. Our server, Kamila, was..."
Jennifer Silverstone
"Quaint little place, quality food, knowledgeable and friendly staff, our bartender Kamila and our server Carlo were superb. I’ll be back and would..."
Mike G
"Looved! Will definitely be back for dinner. Came for lunch we were a large party and were seated immediately. The lobster bisque was amazing huge..."
Shay Lawson
"The food here was excellent! We all loved our meals. The dill sauce that comes with the swordfish was a pleasant surprise and the risotto with the..."
Sarah Stoppe
"Good lunch food 2 days in a row, I'd recommend. Chicken salad on spinach wrap was yummy, good burger, good fries, fresh..."
Madmatt D
"We had an excellent dinner at the Square Rigger, the food was great, and the portion sizes were large, I highly..."
J C Stiglitz
The Right Fork Diner
The Right Fork Diner
84/100 (749 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Diner
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Lobster Roll
Ribs
Burger
Burrito
French Toast
Breakfast Burrito
Toasts
Lobster
Omelette
Pancakes
Corned Beef
Ice Cream
Salad
Cobb Salad
Crab
"This place is not only great for lunch, but if you have the chance to stop in for breakfast, do it! Get the fried chicken eggs Benedict over polenta..."
Marnely Murray
"We love this place, especially for breakfast! Great place to take children and fun to watch the planes take off and..."
Carol Martin
"Always awesome! The first place we head to when we get off of the..."
Joanne Trotta
"The food is awesome, the staff kind and knowledgeable- this place is amazing.... My fav on the..."
Mj Sansouci
"Had the corned beef hash, which was amazing, and sat out on the deck. Great spot to fly in, grab some really good food and enjoy the airport. I'll..."
Chris Adams
"Amazing food. Had the eggs bennidict and hash browns, which were nicely seasoned and fresh from the kitchen. The coffee was even good, and if you..."
Megan Milo
"For a diner they have an amazing menu. The food is and has been delicious. Keep up the great..."
Jane Erris Kuttner
"Charming, delightful and most of all, delicious. Had the Lobster hash one day and came back the next for Lobster Benedict on polenta with th a side..."
Nancy Natow Cassidy
"Great food and great amusement when the planes are flying. Our grandson enjoyed both the blueberry pancakes and the little planes. As usual, we..."
Terry O Martinson
"Fantastic!! Service , generous portions !! Yikes you could split..."
Paula DeStefano
"Absolutely amazing food, top 2 or 3 breakfast spot I’ve been anywhere in the world, hands down...and you get the cool little grass airfield with..."
Pete Carrillo
"Great food and fast service! We tried the Lobster Benedict, French toast brioche and corned beef hash. All were fantastic. Cool place to eat..."
IVY POHL
"Great food with even better location! Situated on Katama Airfield, this diner offers more than most restaurants could, with front row seats to..."
Gregory Goodrich
"Great spot. Amazing food, beautiful location and incredible staff. Well worth the wait, enjoy a cocktail while waiting on your..."
Justin Cecil
"The Right Fork Diner is a great spot for either breakfast, lunch, or dinner. You just might have to wait in a..."
Christopher Guerin
"Very delicious lobster roll plus you are entertained by the vintage..."
Jennie Wobeter
"Great breakfast with cool planes to look at. Highly..."
Craig Rowlings
"Their fried chicken Benedict is to die for! Highly recommend stopping by this place if you’re in Martha’s..."
Maya Menefee
"Good eats, great & interesting location, efficient staff/service...oooh, but do the Bi-plane ride BEFORE your flight...!!!..."
David S Nolan
"Breakfast is fabulous. You will probably have to wait, but they text your phone when your table is ready. Worth it, and you can watch the airport..."
Richard Hamilton
"I had the Spiced Chickpea Stew. It was delicious! The quality and variety of ingredients used were great, and the portion size was bigger than I..."
Ben Henry
"This past season of 2019 was just fine. It's fun to sit and watch small airplanes come in and out of the grass strip Airport. The only problem is..."
Michael Teiger
"Great little place. Awesome to be able to watch the planes take off from the airfield. Definitely a decent wait on weekend/holiday mornings. Our..."
Ariella Fishkin
"Food was solid but many choices were not available. Was never asked what type of sauce I wanted on my BBQ. It was the first night of summer menu so I..."
Eric Ragot
"Fantastic location, great food. Lots of innovative new items on the menu for the 2016 season with some great vegetarian options. I had the grilled..."
E Hazen
"RFD is a great place for family food gatherings. There is parking for both cars and bikes. It is right beside Katama Airfield which means there is..."
Stella graceU
"Cute setting at the air field. Food was really good. Staff was nice. Fun watching the planes take off and land. Smoothies are fresh and delicious. I..."
Cheryl Kozlosky
"Great food! Wonderful pancakes - just like Mom (or Dad) used to make. Sit on the back deck, eat your delicious breakfast and watch the take-offs and..."
Richard C. Laskey
"Locally grown fresh ingredients. Airfield adjacent to diner which added to the ambiance. Attentive..."
Warren Mitchell
Rockfish
Rockfish
83/100 (519 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Pesto
Scallops
Fish
Oyster
Pork
Risotto
Tuna
Burger
Salmon
Lobster Roll
Tapas
Shrimp
Tacos
Beef
Cod
Swordfish
Halibut
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Burrito
Sit down
Bar
American
Accepts Discover
Reservations
Serves Alcohol
Seating
Gift Cards Available
Table Service
Highchairs Available
Wheelchair Accessible
Full Bar
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Great pizza oven.....very creative menu, with an active bar scene. Great casual spot, with sophisticated..."
Randy Weis
"We had a party of 8 including 2 children. We all agree, the food is fabulous, atmosphere very welcoming and comfortable and incredibly friendly..."
Sheryl Duest James
"I just love this menu and the really great staff! Thank you. The chef is wonderful. Always good and menu changes often. Keep it..."
Kelly Baumbach Hess
"Consistently excellent in all aspects. Awesome staff, thoughtful management, great food. Definite go to spot. Love it. Never..."
George Anthony Donahue
"First, our waitor Devin was phenomenal. The fried chicken with honey jalapeno sauce, smoked cole slaw (unique and delicious), grilled corn, and..."
Karry Brown
"Went here for one of our honeymoon dinners, buffalo cauliflower amazing,fantastic, must get starter!! My husband was eating so healthy � chard oven..."
Stacy Anderson
"Rockfish really "rocked it" last night!!! Flatbread pizza was perfect and the kids had almost one each. The chopped salad with ginger vinaigrette..."
Ryan J Flanigan
"Was at Rockfish for dinner last week. The scallops and short ribs were off the chart! Add in the homemade pasta and in-house desserts and you can't..."
Bill Fiore
"Great food and friendly staff..."
Athena Bistolas-Daouros
"Great Staff!!! Unbelievable food. An absolute must..."
Tommy Brandis
"Love Rockfish! Always great food, great cocktails and a wonderful..."
Mary Shanahan Meyers
"Had a great meal on Opening Night at Rockfish. The pizza was great and sitting in front of the wood fired oven=warm and cozy. I'll be back..."
Josh Goldstein
"Food was great, prices very..."
Glenn Cannon
"Great place for seafood, especially lobster rolls! Atmosphere was nice, although the TVs are a little distracting and annoying. Beer on tap was..."
Arthur Bouffard
"TLDR: service: remarkable. Prompt. Offered a wine taste. Graceful with finicky babies. Food: well-balanced flavors. All options amazing taste and..."
Kristen Hole
"The chef brilliantly paired a perfectly broiled nice-sized halibut filet with wild and white rice topped with the most amazing Avocado and cilantro..."
Tim Wacker
"I visited Rockfish today since it was a 15 minute walk from my hotel and was pleasantly surprised about how good it was. I had the calamari as the..."
Brittany
"While visiting "The Vineyard," after perusing many streets, we decided on Rockfish. The menu just outside the entrance displayed a pretty good..."
Frank Fazio
"Had a nice dinner. Only downside is we had to seek server for 2nd drink and my expensive filet was supposed to be medium but was well cooked with one..."
Linda Andrews
"There was no wait, we were seated upstairs right away. Great town view from the window where we were seated. Our server showed up very shortly..."
Del G
"Came here during a work trip. It was cold and foggy when we came in and was pleasantly surprised to see how warm and homey it was on the inside...."
Tim Stolarz
"Not a big restaurant… mostly a large bar area with tables around it. Our server was wonderful and the food was good. The Caesar Salad was..."
Blake Thomas
"We really enjoyed ourselves here for lunch. We came early and the place was nearly empty. Filled up as we ate. We tried a burger, pizza, salad and..."
Avi Smith-Rapaport
"Great service and food! The pan roasted cod was delicate and flavorful with a refreshing salad. The short ribs were tender. I accidentally spilled..."
JaLia S.
"Short ribs grilled cheese is excellent. Fried fish superb. Excellent beer selection. Top notch espresso martini. Service..."
Kenneth Mancinelli
"This was the best dinner we had on Martha's Vineyard! It wasn't even very expensive. I had the pan roasted cod with haricots verts, pine nut & black..."
donna lohrmann
"An amazing meal with a cute date. We ran away from a different restauraunt so we could stumble upon a different venue and ended up at..."
Alan Karp
"Nice selection of local beers. Lobster tacos were very good. Nice atmosphere. Good..."
gregory hemelt
"Went a couple times during our week here, because the menu has such great variety! You’re missing out if you don’t get the scallops over risotto...."
Amanda Dragani
"Love the welcome, the food, the drinks selection, friendly service and whacky shirts for tiki nights! ..."
Kelley Bermingham
"I ate here on June 27th. The shrimp appetizer was outstanding, the large shrimp were really flavorful. I really enjoyed the Greek salad and the..."
Happily Retired
"Best food so tasty! Great service . We are a tough crowd.... no complaints. Amazing pizza, short ribs melt in your mouth. I don't even like risotto..."
Melissa Monteiro
Atlantic Fish & Chop House
Atlantic Fish & Chop House
78/100 (1663 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
American
Seafood
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lobster Roll
Salad
Cod
Clam Chowder
Swordfish
Mac and cheese
Halibut
Skirt Steak
French Fries
Crab
Octopus
Filet Mignon
Sandwiches
Ceviche
Clams
Oyster
Kale Salad
Burger
Kobe Beef
Snow Crab Guacamole
Calamari
Truffle French Fries
Grilled cheese
Cakes
Octopus
Broiled King Crab Legs
Mussels
Ahí Tuna Sashimi
Lamb
BLT
Pistachios Baklava
Tuna
Char-Broiled Oysters
Pesto
Carrot Cake
Sautéed Pei Mussels
Calamares
Black Truffle Lobster Mac & Cheese
Shrimp
Fish
Peach Liquor
Salmon
Grilled Bacon
Beef
Pork
Lobster Arugula Salad
Chocolate cake
Atlantic Clam Chowder
Crab cakes
Crab Cake
Lobster Croissant
Lobster
osso bucco
Chowder
Pasta
Sit down
American
Seafood
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Television
Live Music
Waterfront
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Fine Dining
"A great spot! We came for a snack between lunch and dinner. The drinks were AMAZING especially La Rose De Paris - absolutely the best cocktail I’ve..."
Samantha Knight
"Food was good not memorable. Shisito peppers had too much cheese. The fries and bacon was good. Lobster salad was decent, too many craisins and..."
NY chinchilla
"Perfect lunch spot for the whole family! This was our first time in Martha’s Vineyard and The Atlantic Restaurant was a great star. We sat outside..."
Joseph Adelantar
"My wife and I had a very nice dinner here, with a partial view of the marina. Don’t worry if you see a long line outside, because what appears to..."
Jeff F
"We had a party of 10 including an 18 month old. They accommodated us no problem. The server recommended several dishes so we ordered a few and our..."
John Lake
"Food and scenery is picture perfect! We sat outside, right near the docks, which made for a great backdrop as the sun began to set. If you're looking..."
Antonio Caban
"Amazing! Great food and service! Delicious!!! I had lamb shawarma which was perfect! We also ordered large $200 appetizer set (get it! Worth every..."
Slava B
"Fresh and excellent foods and drink. The server was really nice. I dont know what ppl talked about in these reviews, but sometimes you could miss..."
P S.
"A tale of two experiences. First, the good: the food. The chef is absolutely not afraid of flavor, and I found myself being taken on an absolute TRIP..."
Richard Levins
"Great setting by the water. Went for lunch with wife and two kids (10 & 7). No kids menu but the kids got a burger and lobster Mac & cheese. No..."
Sean Middleton
"The Atlantic has such a great view and if it's your first time on island, I always recommend this for lunch. For the seafood lovers - order the..."
Marnely Murray
"Part of what makes a trip to Martha's Vineyard soo great. Wonderful dining experience. Forrest was an extremely attentive waiter and very well versed..."
Derek Bart
"This may be our favorite restaurant on the island, especially when you can get a seat outside overlooking Edgartown Harbor. Food is always excellent..."
Bill Yelenak
The Seafood Shanty
The Seafood Shanty
77/100 (4347 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Sushi
American
Seafood
American
Vegan Options
Sushi
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Tapas
Fish Taco
Crab
Fish & chips
Tacos
Scallops
Fried Clams
Clams
Sandwiches
Swordfish
Oyster
Mudslide
Shrimp Scampi
Burger
Cakes
Fish Sandwich
Calamari
Mussels
Dark and Stormy
Pesto
French Fries
Fried Whole Belly Clams
Tuna
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish
Hot Buttered Lobster Roll with French Fries
Calamares
New England Clam Chowder
caesar salad
Mussels Shanty Style
Salmon
Fish & Chips
Shrimp
Oysters
Chicken Sandwich
Fish Tacos with Pineapple Mango Salsa
Salmon Salad
Chocolate Cake for Two
Vegan Avocado Roll
Fried Shrimp
Chocolate Layer Cake for Two
Crab Cake
Surf & Turf
Lobster
Chowder
Fish Sandwich
Pasta
Fish & Chips
Flourless Chocolate Torte
Salad
Lobster Roll
Clam Chowder
Sit down
American
Bar
Sushi
Seafood
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Waterfront
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Our first time at Seafood Shanty and we were quite pleased. The restaurant was a bit empty on Thursday in October, which I feel may have made the..."
Patrick
"Great service! Amazing food. Our server Kosal S was so attentive. I just had the best pan seared tuna sandwich ever! We also had the Shanty's..."
Yamilet Gonzalez
"I love this place. If it’s nice outside this is the go to place in Edgartown to dine and drink and enjoy views of the water. The food was so good...."
Adam Kotzman
"On a glorious sunny day in late September we sat out on the deck and enjoyed the views of the harbor. The portions were more than adequate, and the..."
Robert Golenbock
"Having read multiple reviews and having looked at a number of menus while walking around Edgartown, we decided on the Seafood Shanty for..."
Steve in NEPA
"Really loved this place! The service was top notch. I got the cold lobster roll and a few pieces were pretty fishy. It was a really good size though...."
Samantha Mackowitz
"Fantastic view! Get there when they open at 11 AM - people were already lining up. We tried the oysters, 1/2 lb lobster, fish tacos, and tuna steak..."
Emma Johns
"This place was incredible!! The warm lobster roll with butter is the best I've ever had. A MUST on the..."
Lovesexxee Love
"Fast service. Kind staff. Good food. Ninety minutes for a table, but you didn’t even need that long with how quickly the food came out. The Bloody..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Fried calamari and lobster roll were large and delicious. The fish taco was overcooked. Service was friendly and super fast. Make sure you dine..."
Ruibing Wang
"First up, Louis the manager is good man and made everyone that walked in feel welcomed and at home. He takes tremendous pride in his restaurant and..."
Gene Waxman
"What a great place, fantastic views, great service and really good pub grub. The calamari starter with a tangy side sauce was fantastic. Our waiter..."
B MORENO
"Fresh, delicious, and fun place!! Loved getting to watch the boats in the marina while eating outside. The food was..."
Michelle Carmeli
"Amazing experience. Excellent view of the boats moving in and out. Wife and I ordered way too much, but lived it all. Drinks were delicious and..."
Wilson Good
"Absolutely a must visit! We came in October, and noticed the hours the restaurant was open weren't dinner friendly (11am-5pm) so we stopped in for a..."
Katie Boudreau
"Always a go to during the summer. The only sand beach bar on island. Great menu for all including the kids. From fine lobster rolls to the food to..."
Brian “Bmanpitt” Pitcher
"Favorite lunch spot on the vineyard! Amazing views, great cocktails and fabulous food! I ordered the hot lobster roll and my husband ordered the fish..."
Taylor Coombs
Macphail's Corner Cafe
Macphail's Corner Cafe
77/100 (176 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
American
American
Cafe
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Lobster
Lobster Roll
Breakfast Sandwich
Sit down
American
Café
Seating
Takeout
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Amazing breakfast sandwiches and the coffee can't be beat. Oh, did I mention they are ALL happy to be here? A+ on service with a smile. Thank you..."
Douglas Karma
"Amazing lobster..."
Alicia Fitzpatrick
"A theme I found in Martha’s Vineyard was the feeling of being rushed. I ordered their lobster roll. The cashier rung me up. I wanted to add a soda...."
NY chinchilla
"Best and LARGEST lobster roll on the island. Hefty warm roll filled with chilled, large chunks of lobster salad. So amazing I wanted to go back for..."
Natalie Caldwell
"We had a really good lunch here last week. Lovely friendly staff and food made to order quickly. The veggie burger and egg sandwich were delish!..."
Angie Honey
"Nice place . Delicious lobster roll and cheeseburger..."
W.S. JEE
"Was looking for a quick bite to eat to tide me over before a late dinner and very happy I walked in here. Food was made fresh and very quickly..."
Alexander Kantor
"Egg and cheese on an everything bagel was incredible. We got it twice for breakfast on our trip. The bagel was soft and sweet and toasted well...."
Josh Biggs
"The Lobster Rolls are..."
Felicia Royster
"Lovely location. lovely Indoor sitting area and outdoor patio with many tables. Good macchiato. Friendly..."
Henry Katz
"Great staff, positive, friendly. Food is always fresh . I've made several trips there Always..."
Jimmy Keough
"Breakfast sandwiches are good. Great quick breakfast stop with great frozen Arnold Palmers and breakfast burritos and sandwiches. The sausage and..."
Todd Stewart
"Very good food but it is pricey. I would reccomend the French fries and popcorn..."
Teddy
"Quick bite. Amazing breakfast sandwich, buttery and..."
Jacqueline Borges
"Love this place. Great service, delicious..."
Camden Johnsen
"nice spot.. open a bit later..place for when u want something..."
korey “brainsklz” whitfield
Lucky Hank's Restaurant & Cafe
Lucky Hank's Restaurant & Cafe
76/100 (650 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Brunch
Toasts
Salad
LH Famous Crunchy French Toast
Brownie Sundae
Omelette
Clam Chowder
Vineyard Benedict
Blueberry Pancakes
Cakes
Mac and cheese
Blueberry Cheesecake French Toast
Oatmeal
Fish
Scallops
Blueberry-Banana Pancakes
Sandwiches
Steak Benedict
Coffee
Risotto
Grilled cheese
Buttermilk Pancakes
Salmon
Classic Eggs Benedict
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Chowder
Beef
White Sangria
Lobster Roll
Salmon Cakes
Ribs
Cod
Lobster
Breakfast Sandwich
Pancakes
Lobster Roll
The Best Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup
Eggs Benedict
Pasta
Fruit and Berries
French Toast
Meatloaf
Scrambled Eggs with Home Fries
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Reservations
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Brunch
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"poached eggs. such simple fare. yet so exquisite when done correctly. how i have missed my poached eggs for breakfast. yet, as anyone who is a..."
MaryAnn Cahill
"It's the best breakfast and dinner place. They use a lot of local ingredients. The atmosphere in the restaurant is very casual and makes you feel..."
Mila Lowe
"One of my favorite restaurants on island. Aside from the gluten free bread, cozy setting, easy parking, friendly staff, the food is outrageously..."
Helen K Neumann
"The food was delicious and worth the price i enjoyed every bite and ending on a pie is the best way to end a..."
Victor Lion Leon
"Delicious Food! A must to eat at! We all ordered different breakfast dishes and everyone was very satisfied! Thank you Lucky..."
Lynn Ann Averill
"Wonderful little spot in Edgartown. Great for breakfast & lunch. Dinner has a casual feel with an innovative, delicious menu. The farm share -..."
Ruth McDermott Levy
"The lobster mac n cheese was excellent! 5 star customer service! I will definitely visit this restaurant..."
Michael McGee
"Cod Cakes were fabulous - Very friendly and attentive staff. I will definitely go back and highly..."
Jeanie R Carter
"Excellent food! Best lobster Mac n cheese and the lobster deviled eggs were amazing. The bread and honey butter were so good but they were skimpy..."
Janis Gochoco Mulrooney
"Lobster eggs Benedict and whole wheat toast on the side with fresh mimosa...perfection. Nice quirky atmosphere as well. Would highly recommend their..."
Elizabeth Clausen
"Great menu and wonderful atmosphere! Staff is delightful and knowledgeable about their craft! Try the homemade sausage patties. I have had just about..."
Rob Topp
"I so miss you guys--especially the lobster deviled eggs, to die..."
Stephanie Ann Smith
"Staff was great. Food and drink were delicious. Our first visit, but will definitely..."
Nidia Johnson
"Absolutely delicious and staff is amazingly..."
Kendall Robinson
"Thanks for a fresh and delicious breakfast. Our daughter has a gluten and dairy allergy and we really appreciated that you had almond milk & gluten..."
Debra Dorsey Shuman
"The flavors and presentation were awesome. Such a fantastic meal. The crab cakes and scallops were off the..."
Ned Casey
"With brunch themed cocktails and Eggs Benedict on the menu, this was my kind of breakfast. With only two tables in front of the restaurant, I chose..."
Greecian Koukla
"We went to Lucky Hank's for our anniversary and it was the coziest breakfast spot we've ever been to. The food was delicious, the staff was kind, and..."
Evan Shaw-Mumford
"This is very overdue - we've been going to the Vineyard for 12 years, and Hank's always serves the best meal(s) of our trip. I usually get the Farm..."
Angela
"Lucky Hank's is unassuming. Don't pass it by! The food was top notch and the atmosphere was lovely. I had the lobster salad...amazing! Even the table..."
Erika DeShay Lowenkron
"Nice sized restaurant. They didn’t have the cod cakes but substituted with salmon cakes. Tasty, but was looking forward to trying the cod. The..."
Michael Peterson
"Excellent local and farm fresh American fare located conveniently across from the stop and shop in Edgartown. Except typical “vineyard” prices..."
Kate Avruch
"I had the 3 egg omelet + the beef brisket eggs Benedict too! Tasty, hot and timely service. Kudos to thus..."
Jan Nixon
"As usual Lucky Hanks does not disappoint for breakfast! The French toasts are out of this world! And the omelets, although not the massive American..."
Lauren E. Galinsky
"We went for breakfast on a rainy weekday morning. The food was delicious, and the menu had some enticing options! I opted for the French toast and..."
Libby Chernouski
"We were recommended Lucky Hank’s by our B&B Jade House host. LH’s didn’t disappoint. The food was scrumptious and very fresh. The servers were..."
Angela Marquis
"The cutest place I have ever seen. They have really nice outdoor and indoor screened porch seating (only issue - quite a lot of bees). Great food and..."
Sumaya Khan
"Amazing food. The servers were a bit rushed but the food more than made up for that. Cute little spot for breakfast or..."
Vinay Kapoor
"Everything here is fresh, delicious and healthy. I ate the lobster mac and cheese. It's topped with crunchy baked kale for the perfect topping. The..."
Maria Eileen Duncan
"We had a great experience. So accommodating. The Farm Fresh special was on point. We sat at the table out front with our..."
Seth Andrea McCoy
"Great tasting French toast. We ate on the back porch and it was a nice quiet..."
Dan Kellett
"Loved that we could get a brunch cocktail and loved the vegetable options- the veggie breakfast sandwich was very good! We had a little mishap with..."
Lisa Neefe
"The breakfast sandwiches are to die for! But seriously, it's so..."
A.J. H
"We went last minute because the other place we wanted couldn't actually accommodate dogs. Very pleasantly surprised. Meatloaf was out of this world...."
Matthew DeLaney
The Newes From America
The Newes From America
74/100 (1204 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
American
Soups
Bar
Pub
Soups
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Chicken Sandwich
Veggie Burger
Pasta
Cakes
Salad
Fish
Wings
Clam Chowder
Burger
Fish & chips
Mac and cheese
Crab
Hamburgers
Calamari
Calamares
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Haddock
Shrimp
Ribs
Beef
French Fries
Bangers And Mash
Lobster
Sit down
Soups
Bar
Pub
American
Television
Live Music
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Seating
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Brunch
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"The food was excellent and worth the wait. Even in the off season it was busy for lunch (always a good sign) and food took a bit longer than..."
Patti Wakefield
"Best lobstah roll on the island, no comparison. A regular stop when I'm in..."
Jim Jingozian
"We had the Bangers and a Reubrn. Great meal. We've been fans since day one, never a..."
Larry Nuesch
"My experience at the Kelley House was the absolute perfect end to our stay on island. Very rarely would I say that I would plan a trip around a..."
Renee Hirschberg
"Worth the 360 mile drive! Great food and great..."
Nick Persons
"Loved the food and atmosphere! Had the fish and chips and husband had the pasta bolognaaise. It was a chilly rainy day so this was a great..."
Leslie Frye
"We love being greeted by Ester! Service was great food..."
Heidi Matthews Cantin
"I loved our waitress and the hostess Esther has such a great personality, she makes you want to go back just to say hello. She makes all customers..."
Sandy Mcnamee Bruscino
"Have loved The Newes for years and years. Love seeing Esther too....took a selfie with this amazing woman too. Keep being Great! Be back..."
Greg H. Goodman
"Great place for a spot of luncheon during our day on the Island during our trip from London to Boston and Cape..."
David Hastings
"Always a favorite spot. Doug is a great bar tender! ..."
Meghan Gravander Lavetsky
"Consistantly delicious food and service! Love the French Dip and Beer..."
Lauren Giglio
"Love the News! The food, atmosphere and the wait staff. So glad they are back open for..."
Janet Scott
"Great cozy decor and vibe. Very attentive service and adorable waiters. Fish and chips were yum but pass on the overpriced tomato bisque and wedge..."
Dominique Callimanopulos
"Great service. The food was good, but the salad tasted like water, no salad dressing on it. The atmosphere was good. It just needs better lighting...."
Amanda Bettencourt
"Amazing food! I had the best fish and chips on the island! The staff was..."
Emma Bainbridge
"Great spot to have dinner. The Maple ale was great too. I had the fish and chips and it was great. We had about 10 people with us and they..."
J. Jackson
"Open year round, the Newes is just such a cozy spot, with a fireplace for those cold, snowy days. And the perfect meal? A bowl of their French Onion..."
Marnely Murray
"Sat outside on a warm summer day. Beer selection was excellent and typical but delicious pub food. Highly..."
Alison Moon
"A classic for Martha's vineyard not to be missed. It is one of the few reasonably priced restaurants on the..."
Michael Teiger
"We stopped here for lunch and my wife and I both had excellent salads. the garden salad was good but very basic while to the Caesar salad with..."
Rich Hardie
"We are so passionate about every costumer service. We always love to see smiles on their faces when every they come in to eat for lunch or..."
cassandra edwards
"I love the atmosphere. You feel like you are in an English pub. The food is Fab. Truffle fries outstanding. Lobster Mac and cheese decadent and..."
Mary McDaniel
Quarterdeck Restaurant
Quarterdeck Restaurant
70/100 (140 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
American
Fast Food
Seafood
Fast food
Seafood
American
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Fish Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Lobster Roll
Fish
Clam Chowder
Fried Clams
Clam Strip Platter
Sandwiches
Burger
Clam Chowder
Clams
Fish & chips
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Sit down
Fast food
American
Seafood
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I recently had lunch at The Quarterdeck in Edgartown, and it was an absolute delight. The picturesque setting on Memorial Wharf, with views..."
Marnely Murray
"the best fried clam strip we've had, the clam chowder was comfy and tasty, the fish and ships was nice but not crispy as it should, like the place,..."
A H
"Super friendly person behind the counter. Yes, it's cash only, but there's an ATM there if needed (though the fee for cash at a bank ATM is likely..."
Steve in NEPA
"Judy was our waitress and made excellent menu suggestions. Midwesterners need help! Glad we..."
p browne
"Best cheeseburgers in Edgartown. Totally hit the spot and I could have eaten three of them for the price of a burger anywhere else in town. If you..."
Henry Gwazda
"Recently, on my first trip to Martha’s Vineyard, I wandered through the streets of Edgartown one soft summer night hoping to find a walk-up cafe..."
Barbara Perry
"Stopped here for lunch with my family and we all enjoyed the food so much we came back the next day for more. The food is fantastic and the wait time..."
Shellcode
"This is the BEST lobster roll I have ever had. Not to mention the prices were fantastic! I’ve lived in New England all my life and my favorite food..."
Ivy O'Brien
"We had cheeseburgers and they really hit the spot. At $6 a pop, they’re an excellent deal. Toppings tasted fresh (LTP: lettuce tomato pickle) and..."
Thomas Lynn
"Lobster rolls were packed with meat and not a lot of mayonnaise. We grabbed three to go and ate them on South..."
Light Breeze Cruisin'
"Delicious! Lobster roll, beyond burger and chicken finger platter. All exceeded expectations. Good..."
Liz Libson (Liz Etherington)
"Wow!!! Super good fresh seafood! I could not skip the lobster burger, and wow So good. Don't miss out on this little place plus there open to 1..."
Elvin Chacón