Best Fish Taco in Edgartown

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Port Hunter
The Port Hunter
88/100 (1044 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Late Night
Oyster
Halibut
Chicken Sandwich
Calamari
French Fries
Key lime pie
Hanger steak
Mussels
Cheeseburger
Kale Salad
Tuna
Kale Salad
Cakes
Calamares
Sandwiches
Curry Mussels
Pesto
Burger
Tuna Special
Fish
Famous Chicken Sandwich
Burrata
Chowder
Buffalo Brussel Sprouts
Portside Spritz
Red wine
Tapas
Shrimp
Fish Delish
Caprese Salad
tostada
Fish Taco
Elote
Tacos
Fresh Oysters
Halibut
Lobster
Asparagus
Curry
Pasta
Salad
Brussels Sprouts
Vegan Risotto
Clams
Jalapeño Cilantro
Toasts
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Outdoor Seating
Television
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"This place is clearly very popular because there was a queue outside the restaurant before it opened for 5:30 p.m. dinner service on a very rainy..."
Jane Ma Nolan
"Nice ambience. Food was generally good. I got fish tacos which were underwhelming but other fish dishes, especially the specials, were fantastic...."
Fel Madi
"We stopped here for apps and it was great. We sat at the bar and the corn appetizer was incredible as was the Brussels sprouts. They have some..."
Andy McNeill
"Awesome food. The brussel sprouts appetizer ('buffalo brussels') was about the best thing I've ever had - flavor explosion. I also adored the salad..."
Lisa Murakami
"came on a wednesday evening. reservations were totally booked for a month but luckily the bar is first come first serve. we ordered an IPA and an..."
Rachel Con
"This is fine dining with superb food! However, you will never put a fork down without one of the empty plate hunters picking it up to move you..."
jeff hebert
"Fantastic dinning experience in Edgartown. We had the ceviche whoch was very wel excecuted. The kale amd fennel salad was very balanced with the..."
Juan Uribe
"I always love their cocktails and food. Creative menu that doesn’t break the bank. Great oysters too. Sit at the bar, it’s a perfect way to enjoy..."
Scott Matus
"I am not a foodie, but what I can tell you is my experience overall here was absolutely fantastic! From the moment we spoke to the hostess we were..."
Mark Alexander
"The food was amazing and drinks were just as good. Prices are a little higher than other places in the area, but worth it for the..."
Bryan Greene
"My favorite place in Edgartown! I’ve been coming here for years and always go several times when I am here. The food, drinks, service and..."
Dan Colucci
"The fish tacos are an ABSOLUTE must!! So fresh and not too heavy. Buffalo Brussel sprouts were also a must have. Inside is nice for a drink as well...."
Christan Nicklas
"We enjoyed our dinner here. It was a little busy so they said we could sit at the raw bar. We did, the guy running the raw bar was great. He was..."
Daniel Haughey
Backyard Taco
Backyard Taco
88/100 (239 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Mexican
Vegan Options
Southwestern
Mexican
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Eggplant
Tapas
Fish Taco
Tacos
Tortillas
Falafel
Fish
Mexican
Southwestern
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"One of the best places on the island! Great service, top notch tacos and the best nachos on the..."
Jimmy Barber
"I love these guys and their food!! It's exceptional! Everything is made from scratch, even the tortillas and totally gluten free. For those who love..."
Posy Bass
"From scratch everything. This place is flat out fantastic. Like a bad ass SoCal Taco truck moved indoor. Get your cocktail, eat your tacos, and enjoy..."
Derek Bremner Ryan
"The tacos at Back Yard are exceptional and cooked with love! The owners, Evan and [Zarid??] are always behind the counter, working and creating a..."
Beasley Patrick Brian
"this place is some serious SPECIAL. nothing like it on the island and much needed - delicious and fresh food, all made to order. the homemade corn..."
Sheryl Dagostino
"BEST tacos on island! And the only place that hand makes their tortillas DAILY. They so so fresh and delicious. The tacos are fantastic and..."
Marnely Murray
"Great tacos! Homemade tasty chips and corn tortillas plus that margarita is tasty too!. The chicken had great flavor I felt it had a hint of curry..."
Ginny Love (nanciGWP)
"This is by far the best place on the island to buy a taco. Amazing service, food freshly cooked after order, and you get a lot of value for your..."
Patched
"Had a great time getting some late night tacos here with the girls!! Ordering was fun, my spicy marg was tasty and so were the tacos..."
Morgan Fykes
"Got in late needed a quick bite and drink. Here for a weekend wedding. Got a eggplant taco and falafel taco with a swamp margarita(super spicy). Off..."
Jason Ferguson
"I had a falafel taco, and it was delicious. The guacamole was also delicious. If you like tacos this is your..."
Cindy Beck
"Pretty simple review: best tacos I’ve ever had. The tortilla is usually just a boring vehicle for what is inside but their handmade tortillas were..."
Konstantinos Velentzas
"Pleasantly surprised with this taco spot. Nyc prices, like anything around here. The cauliflower tacos were my favorite, tasted like they used some..."
Shelly I
"My girls and I had a wonderful time this evening at Backyard Taco. The tacos were the best taco’s by far, we ever had. The owner was very..."
Michelle McArdle
"Delicious tacos and friendly staff in an informal setting. There's something here for everyone, carnivores and vegetarians alike. The fish tacos were..."
Chris Gerry
"This is the place to relax after work, good tacos, margaritas and mezcal is my go two here! The short rib and steak tacos are the best. There's some..."
Laurie LaVigne
"The beef tacos were ridiculously good! We were in MV Fri-Mon and I managed to eat them twice! A magical place for people like me who eat gluten-free!..."
Kerri Katz
The Seafood Shanty
The Seafood Shanty
77/100 (4347 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Bar
Sushi
Seafood
American
Vegan Options
Sushi
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Flourless Chocolate Torte
Tapas
Crab
Fish Taco
Tacos
Scallops
Fried Clams
Clams
Fried Whole Belly Clams
Fish & chips
Swordfish
Oyster
Hot Buttered Lobster Roll with French Fries
Sandwiches
Fish Sandwich
Calamari
Mussels Shanty Style
Burger
French Fries
Mussels
Fish Tacos with Pineapple Mango Salsa
Mudslide
Cakes
Tuna
Chocolate Cake for Two
Shrimp Scampi
Dark and Stormy
Pesto
Calamares
Vegan Avocado Roll
Shrimp Cocktail
Chicken Sandwich
Fish
Salmon
Chocolate Layer Cake for Two
Shrimp
New England Clam Chowder
caesar salad
Fish & Chips
Oysters
Salmon Salad
Crab Cake
Lobster
Pasta
Fried Shrimp
Chowder
Salad
Surf & Turf
Fish & Chips
Clam Chowder
Fish Sandwich
Lobster Roll
Sit down
American
Bar
Sushi
Seafood
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Our first time at Seafood Shanty and we were quite pleased. The restaurant was a bit empty on Thursday in October, which I feel may have made the..."
Patrick
"Great service! Amazing food. Our server Kosal S was so attentive. I just had the best pan seared tuna sandwich ever! We also had the Shanty's..."
Yamilet Gonzalez
"I love this place. If it’s nice outside this is the go to place in Edgartown to dine and drink and enjoy views of the water. The food was so good...."
Adam Kotzman
"On a glorious sunny day in late September we sat out on the deck and enjoyed the views of the harbor. The portions were more than adequate, and the..."
Robert Golenbock
"Having read multiple reviews and having looked at a number of menus while walking around Edgartown, we decided on the Seafood Shanty for..."
Steve in NEPA
"Really loved this place! The service was top notch. I got the cold lobster roll and a few pieces were pretty fishy. It was a really good size though...."
Samantha Mackowitz
"Fantastic view! Get there when they open at 11 AM - people were already lining up. We tried the oysters, 1/2 lb lobster, fish tacos, and tuna steak..."
Emma Johns
"This place was incredible!! The warm lobster roll with butter is the best I've ever had. A MUST on the..."
Lovesexxee Love
"Fast service. Kind staff. Good food. Ninety minutes for a table, but you didn’t even need that long with how quickly the food came out. The Bloody..."
Natalie Caldwell
"Fried calamari and lobster roll were large and delicious. The fish taco was overcooked. Service was friendly and super fast. Make sure you dine..."
Ruibing Wang
"First up, Louis the manager is good man and made everyone that walked in feel welcomed and at home. He takes tremendous pride in his restaurant and..."
Gene Waxman
"What a great place, fantastic views, great service and really good pub grub. The calamari starter with a tangy side sauce was fantastic. Our waiter..."
B MORENO
"Fresh, delicious, and fun place!! Loved getting to watch the boats in the marina while eating outside. The food was..."
Michelle Carmeli
"Amazing experience. Excellent view of the boats moving in and out. Wife and I ordered way too much, but lived it all. Drinks were delicious and..."
Wilson Good
"Absolutely a must visit! We came in October, and noticed the hours the restaurant was open weren't dinner friendly (11am-5pm) so we stopped in for a..."
Katie Boudreau
"Always a go to during the summer. The only sand beach bar on island. Great menu for all including the kids. From fine lobster rolls to the food to..."
Brian “Bmanpitt” Pitcher
"Favorite lunch spot on the vineyard! Amazing views, great cocktails and fabulous food! I ordered the hot lobster roll and my husband ordered the fish..."
Taylor Coombs
Sharky's Cantina
Sharky's Cantina
75/100 (1092 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Mexican
Southwestern
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Mexican
Gluten Free Options
Southwestern
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Tapas
Fish Taco
Tacos
Burger
Burrito
Shrimp
Fajitas
Beef
Nachos
Queso
Burrito Bowl
Lobster
Salad
Fish
Wings
Pork
Sit down
Mexican
Southwestern
Bar
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Parking Available
Outdoor Seating
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Television
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"So much food for such a great price! This is a wonderful little place to eat with a great atmosphere. The serving sizes are huge and it was hard for..."
Daniel
"Huge huge huge servings. Took us totally by surprise. The quality was also really not bad. It's just that the service seemed a bit aloof and rude...."
Jay Beau
"On a sunny afternoon, this looked like a dead place from the outside. Couldn’t have been more wrong about it once we entered. The service staff was..."
Kartik Bharadwaj
"Just stopped in to have a beer and nachos. Ladies behind the bar were very cool. The nachos were fantastic and between my wife and I, we got only..."
Sean Allen
"We just stopped in for drinks and some coconut shrimp. Staff was nice and attentive. Ritas were excellent, as was the shrink. Also super clean and..."
Ryan Boehm
"Excellent Tex Mex menu options. Good drinks. Good service...."
Marsha Newman
"It's there one thing I crave at all times from Sharky's, it's their nachos. No kidding, these are some of the best nachos around, as you can see from..."
Marnely Murray
"Good food, friendly waitress. Taco salad was large, fresh, and delicious. Back again in August 2019. Our waitress was excellent! Super friendly and..."
Mary McDaniel
"Food was good, bartender was friendly, place was just missing something. Oh, both meals came out at two completely different..."
Joe H
"Shark's has become an annual traditional stop when we vacation on the Vineyard. My kids love this place. Food and service is consistently good! ..."
Hector Guerreiro
"A go-to for us whenever we're visiting MV. Nachos are the best we've every had (and we've tried a lot of..."
Stephanie Sullivan
"Very good place to eat , tons of food , bar tender , very nice , no pressure , phantom gormet should be here ,two thumbs..."
mark hussey