Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Elizabethtown
13 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"NO RESERVATIONS so don't think you have one if you call and are led to believe you made one. When I initially called to make a "reservation" my..."
Teresa Williams
"I was visiting the area for the weekend with my son and friends in a group of 5. We actually stopped by here twice. The first day was on Saturday..."
Zay McCullough
"Our first time eating there today. Food was great; the waitress (Sylvia) was PHENOMENAL. The nicest and most caring waitress we have ever encountered..."
Nate Mackey
"How any times have you planned a trip route so you pass a favorite restaurant!? This is mine! A very special creamy delicious cheese stands out to..."
"A local treasure! Great food, made fresh! Salads, pizza, pasta, steaks, and more!!! We eat here almost weekly, usually carry out, but it’s always..."
Justin Williamson
"The steaks we ordered were delicious. The waitress was pleasant and knowledgeable. The only issue during the visit was the lighting. We used our cell..."
Jean Holt
"What a delicious surprise! Don't think twice about stopping in for a meal. Service was great, patio seating fantastic, good was AMAZING. Had the..."
K Paller
"Love this place. Georgio's Pizza is an absolute delight! Their pizzas are loaded with fresh, high-quality toppings, and the calzones are perfectly..."
Honeycutt H
"Our waitress was absolutely fantastic. She kept coming by our table checking on us to be sure we were ok, always smiling. You just don't get that..."
Nancy Stuart
"Wonderful experience. The waitress was very helpful. She made recommendations for ordering. Those were spot on. I loved my pesto penne with chicken...."
Holly Boyce
"Giorgio's is one of my favorite restaurants in Elizabethtown! Their service is phenomenal and I really enjoy the atmosphere in the restaurant. They..."
Merritt Martin
"My first trip here. This is a great restaurant, food is great, prices are reasonable, and staff does a great job. I will be back for..."
"I visited Impellizzeri’s in Elizabethtown for the first time today at lunch.
The staff I interacted with were friendly, competent & attentive.
My..."
Lucy Wells
"This place is awesome, great place to hang out, snack, or just get so full on dinner you need a wheelbarrow to get out....they have the best pizza..."
Marie Gustin Greenwell
"A great atmosphere along with awesome pizza, other food items, and a full bar.........
What more could you ask for???
How about Tv's everywhere and..."
Robin Monroe
"Delicious! Wanted to try the pretzels and beer cheese-got a salad on the side.
Filled me up , and had enough to take home for lunch again tomorrow...."
Monica Sanders Cundiff
"Yet to have had a bad experience. Great food, great atmosphere. Staff is friendly and on top of service. Would recommend to..."
Dustin Elliot
"Great food, great service & a great bar. I just love to sit at the bar and people watch while I am eating dinner. Well worth the price! And Robin..."
Arnold Myers
"It is definitely my favorite place to eat in eat Elizabethtown. Well executed food with a fun and relaxed..."
Seth Curry
"I love the Impellizeri’s in Louisville so I had high hopes for their Etown location - I was NOT disappointed! My son had then meatball sub (he..."
Laurie Perkins Henson
"Awesome place! My dad and I ate there for lunch and our waiter Jimmy explained the menu and helped us out with our order! Will go there again..."
Denise Goodman
"This was my first time visiting Impellizzeri's ever, and I was very impressed with everything! I've never tasted anything like the cheesesticks, and..."
Courtney McDowell
"Yesterday was our first visit. We got there around 300 and seated immediately. Our waiter was TK. I was raised in Etown and TK was very knowledgeable..."
"Food was really good - service was lackluster. The girl at the counter wasn’t outright rude but clearly wasn’t in the mood to help customers. One..."
Tamara Dellinger
"The subs are flat out amazing !!! Highly recommend the cheesteak and cheeseburger subs, you won't be disappointed. Very good staff, service and..."
Joshua Long
"My favorite place in Elizabethtown for quick Italian fare. Their bread and pizza dough is made fresh daily which - besides making it smell heavenly..."
Matthew Brown
"The chicken bacon ranch sandwiches keep me coming back! The seasoning on their chicken is so good. It's actual real pieces of chicken and not the..."
Allison O
"Wife and I went to the little oddities museum and decided to come here for lunch the cheesesteak were really good and the bread was very fresh and..."
james dunnigan
"Had two slices of cheese pizza and two fountain sodas my brother and I enjoyed it very much, it was delicious, will definitely..."
SenSaSion Rodriguez
"Love their cheesesteaks when I get nearby! Bread is unbeatable and service has been great every time for..."
Alicia M
"Ordered a Buffalo chicken cheesesteak & bacon burger cheesesteak with garlic knots and WOW. Phenomenal..."
Kinda Dark
"Always a great experience for me at this local Italian place. Good service + pizza, specialties, and their homemade bread is amazing dining in or..."
zoltan2k6
"The food is always really good, but the girl at the counter is absolutely rude on the phone and in person. Not the person you want answering phones..."
Jacinda Ludwig
"I would like to start off by saying there food is amazing!! There fresh bread, rolls and pizza is outstanding! The only thing I complain about is the..."
Gordon
"These reviewers complaining over the staff need to get over themselves. They make really good subs and pies. I wouldn't care if they go tell me to go..."
Ryan Martin
"We have been to P&J's many times since moving to Elizabethtown 10 years ago. We instantly fell in love with their Stromboli. Over the years we have..."
Renee
"This place actually makes banging pizza. The best part is that he didn't have any slices. But what the guy behind the counter said was I'll make..."
Rhett anderson
"This is one of the best pizza restaurants in town. They also have delicious subs/cheesesteaks. They make their own rolls. It's a smaller store with a..."
Nancy B
"I placed my order for a slice of pizza and a tossed salad with ranch dressing. I took a set and relaxed, in minutes I was enjoying the slice of pizza..."
"I went in to try the philly cheesesteak and it was pretty tasty. I wish the large sub was a bit bigger though. I also ordered fried mushrooms and..."
Marc Cummings
"Love the new owner ship and the food is delicious but I always order chicken broccoli Alfredo. With - garlic cheesy bread. Honestly the last 4/5..."
Jennalee Seitz
"First time stopping in at My Place. It was great food at a reasonable price! I had fettuccine Alfredo, which was very cheesy and delicious. We also..."
Greg Mazzeo
"The pizza and subs were fantastic, this is now in my top 3 for Pizza in the Harrisburg area, hands down. The NY style 18" pizza was exactly as it..."
Joseph Haney
"Ordered a pizza for the first time here. They got the order wrong but corrected the issue immediately and we're super nice about it. The food was..."
Nicolas Caputo
"YUM! Great family owned restaurant! Nice people ....great amazing HOME COOKED food...tamales were awesome...Alfredo perfect! Pizza is banging too!!!..."
Stacey Sierra
"Best pizza in E-town. Great staff. Amazing food. Highly..."
Justin Whitener
"Excellent food with an old school pizza place feel and look. Definitely worth it as the prices are..."
Joey Shoe
"Very clean. Kid friendly. We ordered alot and the food was just..."
Shanna Precise
"Great family business, food is excellent and the staff is very..."
"I visited Impellizzeri’s in Elizabethtown for the first time today at lunch.
The staff I interacted with were friendly, competent & attentive.
My..."
Lucy Wells
"This place is awesome, great place to hang out, snack, or just get so full on dinner you need a wheelbarrow to get out....they have the best pizza..."
Marie Gustin Greenwell
"A great atmosphere along with awesome pizza, other food items, and a full bar.........
What more could you ask for???
How about Tv's everywhere and..."
Robin Monroe
"Delicious! Wanted to try the pretzels and beer cheese-got a salad on the side.
Filled me up , and had enough to take home for lunch again tomorrow...."
Monica Sanders Cundiff
"Yet to have had a bad experience. Great food, great atmosphere. Staff is friendly and on top of service. Would recommend to..."
Dustin Elliot
"Great food, great service & a great bar. I just love to sit at the bar and people watch while I am eating dinner. Well worth the price! And Robin..."
Arnold Myers
"It is definitely my favorite place to eat in eat Elizabethtown. Well executed food with a fun and relaxed..."
Seth Curry
"I love the Impellizeri’s in Louisville so I had high hopes for their Etown location - I was NOT disappointed! My son had then meatball sub (he..."
Laurie Perkins Henson
"Awesome place! My dad and I ate there for lunch and our waiter Jimmy explained the menu and helped us out with our order! Will go there again..."
Denise Goodman
"This was my first time visiting Impellizzeri's ever, and I was very impressed with everything! I've never tasted anything like the cheesesticks, and..."
Courtney McDowell
"Yesterday was our first visit. We got there around 300 and seated immediately. Our waiter was TK. I was raised in Etown and TK was very knowledgeable..."
HelenmuddnBobby Bennett
"Awesome Server. We got lunch special, a slice and two breadsticks, it was a lot of food. Thin crust pizza cooked to..."
Brandon Hoeppner
"Love the pizza so much, but I'd love it more if you didn't drop the sauce cup on top of my food. It can't be sterile, and there's room in the box for..."
MaryLou Emerine
"Awesome food! One of the rare places (outside of Buffalo, NY) that we found cup & char pepperoni. Impeccable service as well. Great to find an..."
Julie N
"After having a bad experience at Louisville location. We decided to try this location. It was amazing. The food , the wait staff, and the decor. Very..."
burn after reading
"I’m visiting from Iowa and heard good things about Impellizzeri’s. The location is great, and we walked in to find out they had live music as..."
J H
"OMG💕
Always wanted to visit the Louisville location when I was younger and never got the opportunity. My children were too young to have even..."
"Bubs. Great food and portion size, never had a bad meal. Everything made to your order. Mike & Marsha are wonderful people who add a great deal to..."
Gbear
"Great Cooks, Good Food. Bubs Pizza and Deli never fails to deliver great tasting food no matter your taste. Great sandwiches, subs, pizza's and..."
Pepperoni Paparazzi
"Stopped in off the highway during a very long travel day. Ordered a pizza and it was done very quickly and the way we asked. Delivered right outside..."
Greg Schramm
"THE BEST..."
Sally Wachowski
"A great place to celebrate my dad's birthday! We got our order quickly, and were able to eat at one of their little outdoor tables. They even came..."
Tiffany Skerrett
"Best pizza of upstate New York! The owners and the workers are great and very..."
Izzy Turner
"Although there isn't many options in the area for takeout; with bubs you don't need any more. Solid offerings, good price, reasonable amount of time..."
james porter
"Best subs, wraps, sandwiches ever. Small..."
Charlene Nickerson
"Great food, Great price, friendly..."
Dan Wachowski
"Excellent staff and excellent pizza. If you need a quick bite to eat they have pizza by the slice. You can order one uncooked and bring it home to..."
"I recently had the pleasure of dining at Babbo’s Pizza on a Monday looking for a place to take my parents out and being new to the area. I must say..."
Youri Litvine
"We came to eat here tonight after the light show across the street. The food was great and my husband was happy they had draft beer and a good..."
Maddy G
"I only had to drive 100+ miles from Williamsport to have the BEST Garlic Pharmeson wings I've ever had...."
Jim Hine
"Food is always great, service is fast, owner and staff are always friendly. Don’t listen to any negative reviews about this place, I highly..."
Phillip Gruber
"Really good food and nice people. I love the convenient drive thru so I can pick up my food quick before..."
Mason Neidigh
"Best meat balls and onion rings. Marinara sauce was light and wonderful. Great place for lunch if in the..."
Sandy Parker
"Been here a few times. Plain pizza is good, but the margherita pizza is excellent. Highly recommend. Chicken parm sandwich is also solid. Babbo's..."
james godfrey
"Passing through on the way to Phil. This was a nice little find. The pizza sizes are very big. We ordered a small pepperoni and a medium special for..."
kendra wilson
"Delicious deluxe cheeseburger & fries & Harvest salad. There was a mixup in our order which was delivered by DoorDash. After calling -they quickly..."
Steph Engle
"Great pizza! Cool little place. I’ll definitely be stopping back in next time I’m here working in..."
Jack4nd1
"Excellent find! Fantastic service, very helpful staff, delicious food, and a wide variety of drinks available. Very spacious dining room and the..."
Mary Beth Libby
"I’m from out of town watching my 2 little granddaughters while their mommy and daddy are in the hospital having their baby sister.So First time..."
Faith swanson
"Always great food. This was first time dining in and it was also a great..."
At home with Tina
"This is honestly one of the cleanest restaurants I have been at I’ve only been once but the food was delicious and was actually pretty..."
Keegan Dick
"Great place with good food. There is an area inside to sit and eat. No waitress but you enter, order, and are given a hockey puck looking device that..."
"I recently had the pleasure of dining at Babbo’s Pizza on a Monday looking for a place to take my parents out and being new to the area. I must say..."
Youri Litvine
"We came to eat here tonight after the light show across the street. The food was great and my husband was happy they had draft beer and a good..."
Maddy G
"I only had to drive 100+ miles from Williamsport to have the BEST Garlic Pharmeson wings I've ever had...."
Jim Hine
"Food is always great, service is fast, owner and staff are always friendly. Don’t listen to any negative reviews about this place, I highly..."
Phillip Gruber
"Really good food and nice people. I love the convenient drive thru so I can pick up my food quick before..."
Mason Neidigh
"Best meat balls and onion rings. Marinara sauce was light and wonderful. Great place for lunch if in the..."
Sandy Parker
"Been here a few times. Plain pizza is good, but the margherita pizza is excellent. Highly recommend. Chicken parm sandwich is also solid. Babbo's..."
james godfrey
"Passing through on the way to Phil. This was a nice little find. The pizza sizes are very big. We ordered a small pepperoni and a medium special for..."
kendra wilson
"Delicious deluxe cheeseburger & fries & Harvest salad. There was a mixup in our order which was delivered by DoorDash. After calling -they quickly..."
Steph Engle
"Great pizza! Cool little place. I’ll definitely be stopping back in next time I’m here working in..."
Jack4nd1
"Excellent find! Fantastic service, very helpful staff, delicious food, and a wide variety of drinks available. Very spacious dining room and the..."
Mary Beth Libby
"I’m from out of town watching my 2 little granddaughters while their mommy and daddy are in the hospital having their baby sister.So First time..."
Faith swanson
"Always great food. This was first time dining in and it was also a great..."
At home with Tina
"This is honestly one of the cleanest restaurants I have been at I’ve only been once but the food was delicious and was actually pretty..."
Keegan Dick
"Great place with good food. There is an area inside to sit and eat. No waitress but you enter, order, and are given a hockey puck looking device that..."
"Service is was lovely. All the staff are friendly and helpful and the restaurant is clean. We never need to wait too long for our food or for drink..."
L
"Love their salad and Lasagna. The salad here is always great. They never overpower the salad with too much Italian dressing, it’s always the..."
Tony Golladay
"Some days I just NEED Olive Garden - and the one in Elizabethtown is a nice choice. Friendly people with good food. I ordered Asiago Tortelloni..."
Cathy Schultz
"This was our first time dining here. We got the Chicken Alfredo and Tour of Italy. Both were very good. Justin our server was..."
Laura Tate
"Overall our experience was great here. The servers were very attentive and took very good care of us. The food was amazing! My only complaint was the..."
"Olive Garden is my favorite restaurant and we go usually at least once a month. This last visit one of the waiters went above and beyond by talking..."
"My review is pretty biased. This restaurant has been my favorite since I first tried it as a small child. Not just the chain but specifically the..."
Austin Mackenzie Milby
"I always notice they have a culture of "friendly" here. That is usually testimony to great leadership. We again enjoyed our quick, impromptu decision..."
David Gary
"The food is always warm & tasty. The salads are never really the best, probably due to them being made early in the day & sitting in the refrigerator..."
Tom Lewis
"Baked spaghetti so good and fresh hot buttery garlic..."
Toni Graham Meeler
"I've watched this place go from trash to a pass.
The inside has been fixed up and cleaned up, and the food is far more acceptable to serve to the..."
Raiya Safaia
"Fantastic food staff and experience. Delicious! Cleanest restaurant I've been in in a long time. Very personable staff can't say enough about them...."
Kathy Patterson
"The store was pretty busy when we were there and some of the customers were less than friendly. Andrew was the cashier at the front counter and he..."
Stephanie McClain
"Kevin P was awesome. Not only as a server but helped me and my granddaughter get parked safely when my truck stalled out. Food was great and very..."
Timothy Jones
"The absolute best place in town to doordash/ubereats for. In the 10 or so orders I've picked up from here I've waited maybe a total of 5 minutes...."
Cur Dee
"Great pastas any one of these you would be happy. The breadsticks are awesome. And everything is at a great price. Also great customer..."
"This area (Lancaster County) abounds with pizza shops that specialize in making their own bread. They're all really good. However, Sal's Pizza may..."
Aaron Spoonhour
"Superb, local pizza joint as we passed through PA on a long journey. Enjoyed the jalapeño poppers and BBQ boneless wings as well. Staff were also..."
Jesse Hallam
"My experience at this restaurant was excellent. That’s why I’m giving it a 5 out of 5 stars. I live in Salt Lake City Utah but I have some..."
Scott Ober
"This family owned restaurant has THE BEST pizza. Thin crust, just the right amount of red sauce, and real cheese. It's not greasy, everything is..."
Ilyse Ben Zagmi
"I'm very picky about my pizza, but Sal's was great. Good crust, good sauce, smokey pepperoni, nice cook. I recommend this place for..."
Adam Leavelle
"When I went there, it was clean. (This was in the summer time) Anyways, when I went there there was flys but it wasn’t that bad. Whenever I ordered..."
Amaya Heisey
"We've ordered takeout here many times and it's always good food, good service and plenty of seating if you ever want to eat-in. Love the convenience..."
Nicole Gramlich
"I was in town for two days. This pizza is awesome. They are nice folks, too. This is real normal/regular pizza for hungry men, not that “art..."
Glen Ward
"We had to stop and try Sal's. The outside of the building is gorgeous. I ordered a cheese steak Stromboli and wife ordered a chicken wrap. Both were..."
Greg Mazzeo
"Although the wait was a little while (they were busy) when we got the pizza home (a large pepperoni and small White Pizza) they were both..."
David Livingston
"Visiting in the area and stopped by for lunch before heading to a bowling tournament and was super pleased! The location is very inviting with a..."
Jessica Rivera
"The pizza is great! I have been here a couple times and they are very consistent. They serve pizza, Stromboli, hot & cold subs and Italian dishes...."
Jamie Crump
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes