16 Half Meat Lovers Half Veggies Minus Olives Mushrooms And
Half Stegall Mill Add Jalapenos Half Caprese
Jalapeno
Meat Lovers Pizza
Extra Cheese
Cauliflower Crust
River Rat Pizza
Knotty Garlic
Pizza
Parking Available
Digital Payments
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Now with indoor seating and slices when you’re too hungry to wait, or while you wait for a whole tasty, affordable, brick oven cooked pizza! Only 2..."
Rita Thrasher
"Ordered both a cheese pizza and The Cartecay. Been hearing great things about the pizza and we were not disappointed. Some of the best pizza I have..."
Chris Holt
"Best pizza hands down in this area. Great crust and top shelf ingredients at a great price. Went there for the first time today - will now be..."
Mark Belongie
"The absolute best pizza!!! Fresh ingredients - basil and oregano grown right there!! Dough is handtossed, cooked to perfection! Not greasy at all...."
Laura Nichols
"Best kept secret in Northern Georgia for pizza. Don't let the food truck stop you from trying it. Absolutely delicious! Great customer service..."
Michelle Degner
"The pizza here is absolutely delicious! And, the prices are great. We tried the Cartecay and the River Rat. Fresh ingredients and excellent crust. I..."
Stephanie Sims Cardd
"Brick oven pizza - what more do you need to know?! The pizza is fresh made fresh ingredients, full of flavor, and always cooked to perfection. ..."
Laura Wilson
"I absolutely LOVE this place. The pizza is great, and so is the staff. Seriously, if you haven't had one of their pizza's go check it out. It's the..."
Alexis Strickland Greer
"What a great place for pizza! Lots of toppings, brick oven, good crust. Highly..."
Rebecca Harrell
"My husband & I had a pizza from here tonight, it was the Cartecay we asked them to hold a couple of the toppins and it was the best pizza we've had..."
Debbie Bass Bush
"Drove past and decided to take a chance and turn around- soooo glad we did! Incredibly fresh ingredients, super friendly service and we got exactly..."
Carole Palmer
"Best pizza in Ellijay. Tim McArthur and his wife know what they are doing! Highly recommend to anyone wanting..."
Adam Pulliam
"I can’t believe this was our first time at Cartecay River Pizza!!!! The pizza is AMAZING! I can’t wait to try The Vinny next week! Seriously, the..."
Tracy Segraves Van Namen
"Every week, we look forward to getting our pizza fix and this pizza hits all the right spots. Definitely, the best in the..."
Terri Millstone Siegel
"This is the best pizza in town by far! It took no time for us to get our pizza and it is a great..."
James Young
"A great and unique experience. Ingredients are fresh and the oven tops off everything. You've not had pizza like..."
Jason Williamson
"This is that hole in the wall you WANT to go to. The outside is shabby to say the least, but the pizza and subs are fantastic. Homemade meatballs and..."
Julie DiPalo
"We did a Google search for some pizza and this place come up. We were hesitant at first because of the river rafting rental signs. The reviews told..."
Mike R
"Easily top 3 pizza places in Ellijay, far superior to any chain. A little pricey, but worth it. Friendly staff, great ingredients, and wood fired..."
Max Gunn
"It's hot in GA and they only have an itty bitty AC unit. However, the pizza is delicious and the staff was incredibly nice. They had our pizza out..."
Alyssa Moody
"This pizza is GOOD! Really good! We had the “clear creek” pizza and it really hit the spot after a long day of hiking at Amicalola Falls. It is..."
Stephanie Diaz
"2nd time here this week and the pizza is delicious! New owners = new crust, cheese, and sauce to perfection. My go to for pizza in N. Ga..........."
Charlie
"Delicious wood fired pizza. It was cooked to perfection. Crust wasn’t limp or soggy like at some pizza places. Met the owner who is very friendly...."
Southernlady
"Absolutely amazing service, and the pizza was top-notch. The owner was very polite and down to earth. Will definitely be back anytime I'm in the..."
Victor Snail
"**Cartecay River Pizza - A Must-Try**
This was easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Visiting Cartecay River Pizza was a treat. The..."
Chris Johncke
"I love it!!!! Super nice place with a nice atmosphere, and the pizzas amazing!!!!!! O…M…G!!! What a tasty pizza. I recommend 100% to everyone, so..."
Luis Enrique GQM
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes