Best Fish in Elmira

8 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Railside Bar & Grill
Railside Bar & Grill
93/100 (744 ratings)
Restaurants
Polish
Bar
Pub
European
American
American
Polish
Bar
Pub
European
Dinner
Lunch
Potato Burger Grilled
Perogies
Beef Wet Burrito
Fish
Railside Cheese Fries
Steak salad
Stacked Club Sandwich with Green Beans
Pattie Melt
Smoked Pork Chop Bunless Beef and Cheese
Potato Burger with Blue Cheese
Cheese & Bacon Fríes
Caramel Chocolate Brownie a La Mode
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Burger
Potato Burger Fried and Spinach
Whitefish Sandwich
Polish Plate
The Sicilian Pizza
Smelt Basket
Deep Fried Potato Burger and Onion Rings
Polish Nachos
World Famous Potato Burger
Potato Burger Deep Fried
Salad
Sit down
Polish
Bar
Pub
European
American
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Really good food we had a pizza that was fantastic. The butter crust on it was delicious. We also tried the pirogies which were great. Our server was..."
Ben Myslenski
"First time stopping in after driving past this place for almost 30 yrs. Great Polish food was enjoyed by all of us. Will be a regular stop on our..."
Mike Gerhardt
"BEST SERVICE I HAVE HAD ALL YEAR! (possibly in a few years to be honest) food was delicious, quick, and service was outstanding! I wish I would have..."
Laura Gregware
"We were hangry so had to stop somewhere. I saw the Google reviews on this place and gave it a go. Glad we did. It was real good. We went from hangry..."
Sandra RietKerk
"This place is such an unexpected surprise! We stopped here for an early dinner, and we expected run of the mill pub food. When you walk in, you feel..."
Amanda Flynn
"Lura was amazing and ran the whole establishment on the Tuesday afternoon that we stopped in. We had a delicious lunch of Polish food and perch!..."
Elizabeth Williams
"We have been here numerous times over the past two years as it is very convenient if you are hiking around the Jordan River Valley (e.g. Deadman’s..."
David Malin Jr
"Food was delicious. We ordered the polish platter to try more dishes. Everything was good! Kielbasa and sauerkraut were great. Golumpki was nice..."
Alice Keyt
"Loved the food, the atmosphere, drinks and service! Great Polish food! The lady behind the bar is very pleasant and..."
Lori Holliday
"Such a delicious and fun dinner, so happy we dined there. We loved the service, the delicious food and friendly atmosphere. We will definitely return..."
Patricia Davio
Hill Top Inn
Hill Top Inn
88/100 (720 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Irish
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Italian
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Drinks
Brushetta
Carmel White Russian
Pasta
alfredo pasta
Scallop's Au Gratin
Salad
Salmon Cakes GF
Bloody Mary
Calf's Liver with Bacon and Onions Mashed Potatoes and Vegetables
Crab
Side Salad
Scallops
Tuna
Tuna Appetizer
Salmon
Eggs Benedict
Filet Mignon
Mousse Au Chocolat
Calamari
Filet Mignon
Pork Tenderloin
Bread Pudding
Blue Point Oysters
Shrimp
Pesto
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Beef
Fish
Grilled Buffalo Wings
Pork
Brownie Fudge Sundae
Prime rib
Mike's Fettuccine
Sit down
Bar
American
Irish
Seafood
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Takeout
Television
Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Table Service
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Private Dining
Serves Alcohol
Accepts American Express
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Discover
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"A colleague and I actually dined at the restaurant and it was AMAZING!! The Food and Ambiance was Wonderful, but it was the SERVICE that tied it ALL..."
Derryck Holston
"I absolutely love going to the Hill Top for all of my special occasion dinners. I celebrate every wedding anniversary here. The service is always the..."
Samantha Skinner
"The food was delicious! We went on a day where there was some smoke the views outside were still breathtaking. Some of the food items were forgotten..."
Aubrey Wiles
"My family has been going to Hill Top since the 1950s. We have never been disappointed. One of our daughters had her wedding reception there. The..."
Harry Hillman
"We attended for a work event recently, everything was FABULOUS! I appreciate their attention to food allergies. Gluten Free options are abundant..."
The Wilson's
"Amazing place! Great service and food! Husband and I both ordered steak, mine was cooked how I asked. Had to send husband's back because wasn't..."
Shawna Loggins
"Always a great atmosphere. Staff are always attentive. Eating out on the back deck is always..."
heather austin
"Beautiful night to dine outside with a gorgeous view and sit by a fire. From apps to dessert such a memorable evening...."
Denise Long
"Food was excellent staff were wonderful. Will go again for their..."
Rose Latshaw
"Every time we've been to the Hill Top, it's always been a great time. The food was excellent and the staff were so friendly and conscious of their..."
Richard Moyer
"From reserving a table to checkout everything was top notch. I was very pleased with the hospitality. The food was absolutely wonderful. A must try..."
Holly Wilson
"We are frequent guests at Hilltop. We love the environment, the food, the staff, and the views. Today we got the pleasure of having Easter dinner..."
Jessica
"Food and Drink was excellent. Friendly staff and great..."
Robert Morrissey Jr
Maple Lawn Dairy Restaurant
Maple Lawn Dairy Restaurant
86/100 (1035 ratings)
Dessert
Restaurants
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
French Toast
Beef Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Toasts
Prime Rib Breakfast Burrito
Corned Beef
Banana Cream Sundae
Ice Cream
Its a Chocolate Chip Cookie
Fish
Homemade Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Frosting
Spaghetti
Bacon Cheeseburger Omelette
Banana split
Grilled Rueben
Pizookie
Icecream
Burger
Prime Rib 29 00 Size with 2 Sides
Combo Plate
Batatas Fritas Caseiras
Smaller Prime Rib Dinner
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Salad
Pancakes
French Toast
Salad
Sit down
American
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Mid-range
"They were a bit busy when we arrived, but the staff was very friendly. We ordered the corned beef omelet and the cheeseburger omelet, both were great..."
The Sudzy Buddha
"I love the homey atmosphere here. They serve breakfast, lunch, dinner and a huge menu for desserts and ice cream specialties. We went for breakfast..."
Holly Wilson
"I eat there often. Never disappointed, tried different items off the menu and always good. I like that I can start with a beer and finish with a..."
Eric & Aneta Anderson
"Great atmosphere, locally owned & operated! Good food and even better service. Happy to support & promote. -Flores Family. Los Panchos Mexican..."
Cisco Flores
"Visited on a snowy evening, so we were the only ones there. Received very attentive service. Ordered the combo plate and their Pizookie. Pizookie was..."
Siddhesh
"Delicious dinners. Wonderful atmosphere. Light Christmas music in the background. Decorated nicely. Sweet service, masked of course, but her eyes..."
Brenda Lutz
"Went for brunch with a group of 5. Everyone was very happy with their food. The service and atmosphere were equally good. We plan to go back and try..."
travis randall
"Food was fantastic. Would definitely recommend the banana French toast and the (homemade!) corned beef hash. Didn't try their desserts but they..."
Jared Marvin
"Stumbled upon this place this past Sunday, Stopped in for a quick lunch and came back in again today (Weds) Both times our Server was extremely..."
Cassie Steiner
"The best breakfast around will definitely be back to try the other food they have to offer they also have ice cream and homemade..."
Joe Phenes
"Very good food. Good service with a nice..."
Eric Bergquist
"Waitress was friendly and accommodating. The food was delicious and well cook. We always save room for ice cream..."
Iron Mae Colby
"This place is a great place to eat and very family friendly ( affordable) very friendly staff! The food is..."
Andrew Schultz
"We enjoyed a meal with our daughter. The food was good. The service was good. Try the strawberry..."
Carol L
"We all ordered the same dinner. Fried haddock with two sides to choose from. The fish was delicious and it was more than enough. We each brought half..."
Donna Workman
"Very good food. A bit pricier then I remember, but seems that is a trend post covid. Very attentive, friendly and helpful staff. Great variety on the..."
Oneironaut -1
"Best home-cooked food and homemade ice cream in the area. The environment is very clean and the atmosphere is welcoming. The staff are so friendly..."
Brie Fortier
Legends Bar And Grille
Legends Bar And Grille
84/100 (703 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
American
Pub
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Wings
Fish
Pub
American
Bar
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Best ranch ever. If your anything like me you base your decision where to eat based off how their ranch is. There’s is homemade, thick and creamy...."
Holly Wilson
"I thought I was hungry when I went in there, and judging from what I ordered you would have thought I was hungry as well, but when that half pound..."
Morris Hall
"I will definitely be stopping in here again the next time I’m up to visit my uncle at St. Joseph’s Hospital. My steak “Pub Steak” was great..."
Shaun Marosy
"Great food. Great service. Burgers delicious with unique flavor. Pulled pork sandwich was good as was the spaghetti and..."
matthew Pierce
"Fantastic food, personable staff, and amazing..."
Justin Ramos
"This is my son and I's favorite restaurant!! Only thing we have tried that we didn't like was periogies the onion flavor was..."
Samantha Becken
"Fish fry, homemade chips, bacon cheeseburger & salad w/ grilled chicken were all excellent! Will definitely visit..."
Momma Bear Buckley
"Review of Fish Fry: Fish: large piece, somewhat dry. 4/5 Sides: Very good sized portions. 5/5 Mac and Cheese: 4/5 Baked Potato: 4/5 Coleslaw: 5/5 ..."
Donnie
"A real nice small town bar and grill with good food and real nice local people. Go now I..."
Chris Hricik
"Great food, great service, nice..."
Mark Hartman
"Nice environment, fun trivia night, very friendly staff and regulars. Food is really good and..."
K Mims
"Best bar food around, period! Try their wraps. I am not a regular there, but it was awesome to see all of the regulars genuinely being happy to see..."
Justen Samson
"Quick and good food. Priced well. Service was..."
Yvonne Wolfanger
"You must try the homemade chips! Also, best burger..."
Denise Long
"Good food! Good service! Good atmosphere! Went back for another meal just a couple weeks..."
Richard Kopacko
Bernie Murray's
Bernie Murray's
78/100 (640 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
American
American
Bar
Pub
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Wings
Ribs
Chicken Wings
Fish
Nutty Irishman
Reuben
Famous Chicken Wings
Burger
Salad
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Late Night
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Everything was good except our table in the dining room. The base appeared to be stabilized with a shim placed under one of the feet. The top,..."
Richard Kopacko
"I miss this place! It was a great hangout for me and my friends. I liked everything I ate there. The wings hold up to just about any other place in..."
Ed Blandford
"Medium wings for the win! Never had bad food from Bernie’s and I’ve been going for 30+..."
Jordan Allington
"The food was delightful and worth the money. We were saddened by pasta not being available tonight. And it was a quaint small atmosphere. Deff meant..."
Chloe Wells-Burlingame
"Food was incredible! Look at the meat on that Reuben! Best Reuben sammie in the area. Only glitch, we had a long wait and received very little..."
C.P. Stringham
"Calm Tues night great customer service...huge reuben sandwich and nicely cooked wings.. burgers were big and..."
Richard Kennedy
"Known to be local Elbow Room’s rival, both have great wings and I love reviewing the two so let’s get to it! The King of Wings Review THE..."
Keith Seymour
"Our waitress was outstanding and very attentive to our little boy who wanted chicken nuggets that they did not offer but she made it work. He gave..."
Chris Callas
"Obviously the price of food has gone up.. chicken wings were $18 here but you get 14 and they were delicious. Absolutely perfect house made blue..."
Joanne Fairbanks
"Our burgers were delicious! Cooked perfectly the way we asked for and fries equally yummy! Our server was outstanding and fun! Great..."
Teri Corsaro
"We were at an after-funeral luncheon (buffet type) and the food was..."
Carol Gizzi
"We called ahead & our food was ready right on time. My husband's wings we hot and delicious. My chicken ceasar salad was perfect. Great Food. ..."
Spiritual Minister Services Ordained Minister
Lib's Supper Club
Lib's Supper Club
76/100 (1178 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Drinks
Salad
Calamari
Calamares
Filet Mignon
Meatballs
Chicken Parmesan
Pesto
Fish
Pork
Shrimp
Eggplant
Pasta
Sit down
Italian
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Private Dining
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"Ordered calamari and shrimp for appetizers. Honestly wasn’t too impressed, not much flavor to the calamari and shrimp seemed like it was dethawed..."
Matt Rohde
"Looking for great food that comes with a great experience? Make a reservation for Lib's Supper Club. We celebrate our anniversary there every year..."
Scott Hamula
"Haven't been here in a while- no reason not to come other than we are 30 minutes away. Enjoyed our meals and we'll worth the drive! Advise..."
Jennifer Riley
"Only been here once but will be going again. Best chicken Parmesan I've ever had. Both entrees were very generous in size with a price that wasn't as..."
Scott Bauer
"Incredibly delicious food! Everything from the cocktails to dessert were over the top. We considered the prices to be good, considering the amount of..."
Trish DeSocio
"Whenever I come home, my friends and I always go to Libs. The shrimp scampi is my favorite, but this time, it was a little heavy on the garlic and..."
Deborah Woodard
"Consistently amazing food!! I've tried several dinners, & ALWAYS above average, great service & selection. Extra large portions!! We go back every..."
Katie Reed
"I absolutely loved everything my plate and I saw how hard and fast Mr. Conner Hall works, and my appetizer and my side of pasta that Conner cooked is..."
Andrew Dorff
Champions Sports Grille
Champions Sports Grille
74/100 (508 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Bar
Pub
Pub
American
Dinner
Lunch
Fish
American
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Standard sports bar and grill experience. The waitresses are very nice and work very hard for clearly being run short staffed by mgmt. Food is good..."
Sharkeisha Splatter
"Super neat place! The chicken sandwich with coleslaw on it is KILLER and the pretzel bites with beer cheese are super good. The beer cheese is nicer..."
Lonny
"Friendly atmosphere with attentive staff. The food is always excellent. Made fresh to order. There are many things on the menu I would recommend..."
Mark Edge
"Really good time. Good food and attentive service. My wrap was particularly..."
Marcus Coppola
"Good food, great atmosphere. Servers are fast and..."
Hank J
"My husband and I both agree that these are the greatest wings we’ve ever tried. Service was great..."
Cheyenne Wallen
"Broiled fish, Mac and cheese, fries and Cole slaw. Yummy and reasonably priced. Very good server. She checked back with us multiple times even..."
Barb L
"Nice atmosphere. People were great. Food was great also. We all had burgers an wraps, wings to go. Sorry no..."
Donald Stansfield
"Ate there about 2:00pm. Good came out fast. Mine was great but wife's burger came out well done. She had ordered mediim well. Overall good food and..."
Mark Delgrosso
"Love this place...nice atmosphere...friendly service...great..."
Donna Montgomery
"Amazing place to go enjoy a cold beer with friends or a delicious dinner with family! Kid friendly to boot! The Buffalo chicken quesadilla and fish..."
Tim Strong
"If you're in the mood for an uncomplicated meal - burgers, wraps, meal salads- in a relaxed atmosphere where you can talk and laugh without feeling..."
Kristin Card
"Wait times to be noticed can sometimes takes a few minutes especially if you are alone but I absolutely love this place!! It's my favorite..."
Samantha Becken
"This review is for the food at this establishment. I had takeout that was picked up for me. It was Chicken Strips & Fries. I believe there is a..."
Victor Mann
Curly's Chicken House
Curly's Chicken House
73/100 (1388 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Rainbow Cake Slice
Chicken Fingers
Lumpy Chicken Dinner
Cole Slaw
Coconut cake
Breakfast Melt
Philly Cheesesteak
Pork Tenderloin
Confetti Cake
Shrimp Dinner
Warm Cinnamon Roll
Friday Night Fish Fry
Chicken and Biscuits and Gravy
Chicken and Rib Dinner
Chicken Soup Cup
Beef
Chicken BBQ and Texas Hot Dog
Salad
Fresh Haddock Dinner
Chicken Plate with Side Baked Beans and Coleslaw
Ribs
Potato Salad
Fish
Sit down
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Very good place for breakfast with a good amount of options. Really good waffles and breakfast melts, and I highly recommend the cinnamon roll you..."
Kimberly Howland
"Down to earth restaurant. Great food. Cole slaw is the best ever. If your in town plan on stopping at Curly's -- it's worth the trip. Recommend the..."
Maria Schifano
"This was my 1st visit eating here, other than one time i had ordered some takeout. The food was good, portion was too big for me to finish. Our..."
J B
"Was my first time here , I was very impressed.. service was great.. food was really good I'll definitely be stopping again whenever I get in the..."
Chris
"My husband and I love to eat here, staff is always very pleasant, and food is Sooo good (if you like chicken), their lumpy French fries, FF, with..."
Kimberly Woodard
"YUMMY FOOD AND HARD WORKING STAFF CHICKEN BBQ, CHICKEN DINNERS. AND COLESLAW CANNOT BE BEAT!! MANY GOOD OPTIONS BESIDE CHICKEN. CATERING IS OFFERED..."
Lori Lee
"Really great food. We decided to dine out at more small businesses and Curly's didn't disappoint. Fast service, and great food. Tasted..."
Tammy Nichols
"Chicken wings are not the same. Loved the wings they used to sell. Cole slaw was just as great as it always has been, and I enjoyed every..."
Susan Mick
"A place where you feel at home. I have always loved this place, and my recent trip was another memorable experience. The atmosphere is just so..."
James Rymell
"Thank you Ron for the attentive service for our Cousins Luncheon Sept 19th. Ron, you did an amazing job of keeping 19 cousins fed and happy, ..."
Joyce Rogers
"Waitress was very friendly and the service was great. The food and portions were excellent and we will definitely come back for their ribs and..."
Sharon Hall
"Very very good fish fry. Excellent Cole slaw, Mac and cheese and big fish breaded nicely. Ice tea great on a summer evening!! Will be going back...."
Patricia Briggs
"Food was fresh and delicious! Service was polite and extremely efficient! In addition large portions and very..."
Cinnamon 175