"Love the large pieces of pizza. I really dig the sauce and ample cheese. I could have used a little more pepperoni though. The vibe is chill but..."
Chris Dellis
"Got a very large, great order doing gig work and was told they were backed up on their deliveries. I said, "No problem. I'll have a slice of cheese..."
Michael Gee
"I haven’t been here for a while with Covid and their closure, but I was very happy to see they back up and running!
I live in CO and travel here a..."
Gary Cooper
"Nice pizza place, great variety, huge slices, and fun..."
Cyril Oberlander
"My adult daughter accidentally ordered an item different than the one that she wanted. We were not aware of this until our food was brought to our..."
Brian Botts
"I am a regular at Paul’s! Hands-down the best pizza in town! Service is always great. Restaurant is always clean and pizzas always cooked just..."
Jennifer Maguire
"AMAZING pizza. I would absolutely drive back out to Eureka for..."
Rebecca Siegel
"The staff was so lovely and the pizza was delicious!!! We got just a Hawaiian pizza, and the dough was perfect texture...a little crunchy but soft...."
Aayumi
"We’re not from the area and we asked one of our friends that is, where the best pizza was in Eureka and he told us to check out Paul’s Live from..."
Brice D.
"I like their pizza here for lunch time. I had the "Rumble in da Bronx" and "New Amsterdam" slices. Both are awesome. The people who work there are..."
K_McBass
"We were in Eureka for only 2 nights and ate here 3 times. It's that good! It's the best New York style pizza I've had outside of..."
Sarah Giles
"Huge delicious slices! You gotta fold it big. Great topping options, and cozy wide open dining..."
Darcie Rose
"Walked in here after attempting to go to 3 other restaurants that were all closed on a Saturday night. There was a line out the door and the smell..."
Jeff Downing
"Paul's is the only pizza place I've been to in CA that could survive in New York. They'd do much better than survive though, this pizza is good as..."
Frank Hadley
"Exceptional pizza, the sauce was especially good. Nice wide open seating and friendly staff. It's street parking, but when we went for dinner there..."
Kristopher Roy (TanKCR)
"The ordering was confusing. No one to help and girl counting out other register made no attempt to make eye contact and explain the situation. After..."
Steve Bowman
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes