Best Steak Sandwich in Evansville

2 restaurant menus in Evansville, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Hornville Tavern
Hornville Tavern
87/100 (617 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Bar
Pub
American
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Prime Rib Special
Cold Beer on Tap
Ribeye Steak and Loaded Baked Potato
Large Chef Salad
Salad
Double Cheese Burger with Seasoned Fries
Crawfish
Corrots N Green Beans Fried Chicken Roast Beef and Lasagna on Breakfast Bar
Catfish
Catfish Filet on Hoagie
Fish
Breaded Tenderloin Sandwiches and Fries
BISCUITS
1 4 Fried Chicken
BBQ Pork Crunch Wrap
Sweet and Spicy Chicken Wrap
Bison Burger with Onion Rings
Fried Chicken Dinner
12 Oz Ribeye Steak Dinner Baked Potato Salad and Beer Bread
Pepper Pig
Burger
Chicken Salad Wrap
BBQ Chicken Salad
Steak Sandwich
Pretzel
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Really good food and great service never been before hoping to go..."
Brenda Arthur
"One of our very places to go! Food is delicious and fun atmosphere in the bar! Love their fried chicken and their beer is very cold! We bought a..."
Jennifer Jones Feigel
"Great place to eat and to have parties!! The food is..."
Sharon Arvin Frasier
"Thank you for catering our wedding! Quite a few guests were telling us it was amazing food! A special thanks to the bartender for being extra nice...."
Brittany Baum Alnatsheh
"Stopped in for lunch and had the ribeye special with fries! The staff was warm and friendly and my food came out quick and hot! Definitely will be..."
Jeffrey Wilkerson
"I had the best lunch in a while there!!!!!! I knew they had good food from a class reunion years ago , but, this is exactly what I wanted when I felt..."
Kristi Wargel
"A hidden gem! Really enjoyed our trip to Hornville Tavern. Went in for lunch and got the fried appetizer platter and it was huge with lots of..."
Brad Elliott
"My husband and I celebrated our 3 year wedding anniversary and decided we had to try their pork chops. Such a good decision! Their pork chops are..."
Ashley Gorman
"The old saying that the hole in the walls serve the best food applies to Hornville Tavern. I had the Ribeye and did not regret it. It was tender,..."
Queena Frye
"In my worldly travels, I ran across this little place, a bit off the beaten path from the interstate, however, these are usually the best finds...."
Tac
"Been here 2-3 times with my sister-in-law & her husband, Jim & Laura Richie-Runion, and every time I am blown away by how good their back ribs are!!..."
Richie Tribe
"Great food and service. Shared a breaded tenderloin and a ribeye steak sandwich with my gal and both were outstanding. Friendly..."
Mike Merrick
"Excellent, energetic service and equally fine diner/tavern style food. The pulled pork sandwich and smoked chicken entres were delicious. The mashed..."
Don Annis
Hilltop Inn
Hilltop Inn
75/100 (1080 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
American
American
Bar
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Open Face Roast Beef
Cinnamon Rolls with Cream Cheese
Fried Cheese Cubes
Roast Beef Lunch Special
Salad
Fish Baked Potato Loaded and Slaw
Fish
Cod Fish Sandwich Combo
Pork
Pork Ball
Onion rings
Odd Drink I Got Instead of Malibu and Pineapple
Chicken Livers
Chicken Gizzards and German Potato Salad
fishbowl
Club Sándwich
Chicken Sandwich
Pork Tenderloin
Steak Sandwich
Burger
Chicken Fried Chicken
Rootbeer
Tenderloin Sandwich
Fried Gizzards
Sit down
American
Bar
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We used Hilltop for the liquor for our wedding. We had a consultation, and Tyler was very knowledgeable and friendly. We had a couple check-ins..."
Allison Goodman
"Came here with a friend because somewhere online it said bottomless mimosas and bloody Mary's but ended up finding out it was an old promotion from..."
Eva Taylor
"We had the Chicken Livers! They were good, just the right amount of crispness. Brought half of mine home for another..."
Benson Brewer (Brew meister)
"The experience this restaurant just keeps getting better and better. After a short closure and a very slight remodel the atmosphere here is the same..."
LatteDave
"Hilltop is a wonderful place to go for home style food. The service is great, and the staff are very friendly. You can tell just by how busy it gets..."
Koda “Kodabear” Collins