We wanted to give this place a try for a pre-Mother's day dinner. We ordered our pie with a half sausage and onion but got half with sausage and half with onion. :(
It was a pickup order and didn't see it until I got home. I should have checked before leaving. Our kiddos didn't touch the half with onions.
The desserts were excellent. We tried a couple and REALLY loved them!
True New York style pizza and the best in the Seattle area we have found. We ask for and love the thin crust extra crispy pizza. Very nice selection of pizza by the slice as well as custom cooked full pizza pies. Excellent salads, fine fast service, good prices - ample parking on street as well as adjacent parking lots.
Great pizza. By the slice or pies. Spacious and clean dining area. Customers are encouraged to graffiti the walls. We ate here and then walked to Funko Pop store. There is a metered parking lot next door.
During my short stay over in Marrysville I struggled to find impressive food spot. Then I stumbled across this hidden gem. This is the Frank Sinatra of the pizza game in the PNW. Walk in to Brookyln as soon as you open the door. The food is amaizng with even better pricing. The interior design add that new York meets Seattle vibe. I loved it here and it's shame it so far away cause cause now I'll have to make a 2 hour trip just to come back bur it's so good I definitely will. The menu has a wide variety of items so get anything and you'll be impressed. This is the best pizza joint in town and that's a fact.
Love that they have slices! Food is always very good. Room has an echo quality to it so if you're looking someplace quiet, this place may not work. But for pizza, you can't go wrong here.
The Bay Ridge pizza is hands down my favorite one here. The I ingredients are always fresh and tasty, and the dough is especially delicious. I love that I can come here for a slice or two during my lunch break, and the staff is always very friendly. A little pricey but honestly so worth it!!
The Pizza here rules! Easily the best NY style pie in the area, their signature pies are sure winners and the calzones are excellent too. It does get a little crowded if you're dining in, the building has a lot of charm to it and the folks in the kitchen are fun to watch. Some stuff isn't on the menu displayed above the register so make sure to grab a paper copy that's nearby.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes