Great whoopee pie, black and white cookies. My wife's cake looked incredible!!! They are worth the trip. Please support a good local business. They are so cordial with the customers that I would not mind driving the 20 minutes to this location.
Black and White cookie!!!!
Jelly Donut and Boston Creme Donuts are my favorite!!!!
I can’t give Mike and his team enough praise. It’s a great, delicious bakery. It may not look like much from the outside but every single time I’ve gone, Mike has been able to accommodate every request I’ve made. He’s transparent whenever there’s something he can’t or won’t do but able to work with you to achieve what you’re looking for. He made our wedding cake, countless birthday cakes and other celebration cakes. He makes non-dairy buttercream which tastes great. There is no wrong option when going to Merritt Bakery!
I met with Mike the baker, about a simple wedding cake I needed for our daughter's church wedding celebration. Told him exactly what we wanted, and boy he did not disappoint! It was beautiful to see and tasted AMAZING! Truthfully I liked it more than the cake at her reception! Thanks for all the Love you put in your art
Sincerely,
Mary B
I needed a spur of the moment gift for a friend. I ordered a dozen whoopie pies and they were delivered within the hour. My friend's office is 3 miles away. Mike was so nice and helped me surprise my friend and they were fabulous. I may have to order some to ship to me in MA. Thanks again Mike you guys are awesome!
I ordered a special cake for a 90th & 60th surprise Birthday party from Merritt Bakery
Mike was very helpful and delivered a fantastic cake. it was Beautiful and delicious. many compliments from my guests.
Excellent mud pie. Cakes & pastries are tasty & very affordable unlike many exorbitantly pricey other bakeries.
Couldn't locate it easily because the main signboard says "Bakery." A smaller window sign says "Merritt Bakery". Excellent customer service.
OMG!!! I bought a carrot cake for a small celebration and the cake is mind blowing.
So rich, creamy and nutty it just can’t get better. The lady was super sweet as well!!
Definitely recommend don’t miss out heaven on your tongue.
The best bakery on Long Island. Everything I’ve tried is delicious and fresh. My favorites are the rainbow cookies, the pumpernickel loaf, black and white cookies and the Irish loaf cake.
Awesome bakery . They have all the basics and then they have these mini apple turnovers that are really great and specialty items like pizza dough or custom cakes. Highly recommend if you want a no fuss but solid place.
We have ordered cake which is in tree log shape by showing a picture. Mike, the baker has done a wonderful job on that. Immediately when I show the picture of the cake, he was saying me that I was showing him an award winning cake which is so tough to make. But I requested him to make it for me and it came out prettier than the one in the picture. Thanks Mike!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes