Best Dinner in Fire Island

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Schooner Inn
Schooner Inn
77/100 (280 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
Seafood
Pub
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Fish
Sit down
Bar
Pub
American
Seafood
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"5 out of 5. We split our drink & the gentleman running the front bar took care of us immediately. Dude is the TOP DAWG. Highly recommend. Great..."
Connor McGuire
"The Schooner Inn is a hidden gem, it's a beautiful restaurant with a private beautiful small beach overlooking the Great South Bay. They have..."
Erin Daly
"Fire Island is, in and of itself, a spiritual experience. However, there is something extra special about Schooner Inn… …Someone once said,..."
Rob M
"Nice local bar with friendly staff. This was our 2nd visit and this time we had dinner. We started out with the sweet potato fries, they were so..."
Elianny Salcedo
"I ate here three nights in a row as the sea food was excellent!! Swordfish, fish of the day and lobster! There was live music and a spectacular view...."
Kevin Sowden
"Schooners is a great place. The bar and restaurant are great and the service is amazing. Food is awesome. Bonus is the cute little beach behind it...."
Michael DeNicola
"Such a great beach vibe. Food had great portions and delicious. Will be returning..."
joe balestra