6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"I went to my first fish boil and it was awesome. You have to make a reservation because they fill up fast. They will tell you the check in time and..."
Joyce Laswell
"The White Gull Inn is the first place we head to when we return to Door County. We always share the corned beef hash and stuffed cherry French toast...."
Jo Ann Traveler
"The food, the staff, the place... everything was perfect! Our waitress was absolutely the best there is. Unfortunately I forgot her name but she was..."
Konstantin Semyonov
"It was awesome! Fun, especially in fall to sit around the fire, with a glass or wine or beer, and listen to the history of the fish boil! Highly..."
Jeremy Niewolny
"Even if you never stay at the White Gull Inn ( you’ll be missing a great experience) you must stop for breakfast. If the line is too long, get a..."
Jeffery Gleason
"Went for my first fish boil... it was delicious and the gentleman who did the boil was
So interesting with the history of the boil. The staff was..."
Deb Powell-Smith
"Always been a fabulous dining experience, highlighted by the traditional boil over ... a real crowd pleaser. Neil Teskie, a Gill’s Rock native,..."
Bill Lecher
"Absolutely love this place! The cherry stuffed French toast is my favorite. Totally worth the 2 hour drive it takes for us to get there...."
Ashley Wright
"Our favorite place for breakfast every year! Cherry stuffed french toast is fabulous! Well, everything is really fabulous! Wonderful waitress too!..."
Carole Lefever Stoffel
"Charming place for either a meal or a weekend getaway. The food is incredible as is the service. We never come to Door County without stopping..."
Chérie von Känel
"This is one of the main reasons i come to door county every summer. The best breakfast the best..."
Anthony Oquendo
"We have yet to have a bad meal here! The coffee is delicious. The food quality is fantastic. Just go early for breakfast (7:30am) or you'll have..."
Vaughn Heyer
"Came for much needed relaxation time with my husband. The second we walked in we were lovingly greeted by the most wonderful lady! From that moment..."
"This place had the best treat around! We tried a few places in this area. And this was by far our favorite! Suzy Q's slice of heaven pie A LA Mode..."
Nick Mack
"Service was fast. Overall it was good but felt we've had better for the price. We had a banana strawberry split and rootbeer float. However the..."
Pakou Lo
"We have been coming here for years. It’s a great place to get food and especially custard desserts. They always have vanilla, chocolate and butter..."
Christine S
"I cannot think of a more fun place to bring your kids in Fish Creek. This is situated right on the creek (bring bug spray). It has an AWESOME..."
Sarah L
"Awesome Custard ice cream plus u can sit by water and enjoy the..."
karen sauber
"Amazing atmosphere! Very kid friendly. The food is very..."
mikeinkaptenemo
"Great place to bring kids in Door County! They have a playground with sand and outdoor service for ice cream and burgers. They also have duck feed so..."
Momma J On the Move
"If you happen to be in the area, this is an absolut must. The burgers and dogs are on point. get some popcorn and sit by the creek to feed the ducks,..."
nicholai reed
"We both ordered the cookie dough sundae with hot caramel added. The cookie dough was so good and comes as big scoops on your sundae. The custard is..."
Cayla Rosche
"The food and custard are great. Both offer a great selection. The playground and creek keeps littles occupied while grill orders are completed. There..."
Timothy Nott
"Our favorite stop for the best Homemade custard on a hot day!
Everything you get from NLY is locally sourced making it that much more special.
You..."
Deb Koch
"Delicious! Line moves fast even when it looks way to long. Custard was great. The pond next to it is a fantastic place to sit and enjoy the frozen..."
"Always our first and last stop when we come to Door County! Great bar tending staff and our server Mary was wonderful!!! Can’t wait to keep coming..."
Annie Pearce Malinowski
"My husband & I were on a little 2 day vacay. After attempting to catch Al Johnson's, but caught off guard by their 3pm close, we decided to pick..."
Carey Martin
"A trip to Door County is not complete without visiting Bayside Tavern. We have been coming here for years. The food is always great, drinks good..."
Mary Hanzel
"WOW! Clean and neat atmosphere!
Clean bathroom too!
Food was great, I had a burger, the Wife had Lobster roll and daughter had Mac n Cheese. The..."
Brian Q Johnson
"We were on a girls weekend and stopped here for lunch. From the time we walked in, we felt welcome. We had attentive, friendly, hilarious bartenders...."
Michelle Husman
"The staff was very attentive greeting you as you entered. The waitresses were right there to hand out menus and take drink orders. Although pricey..."
MB Symons
"The Bloody Mary was on point! The service was perfect. Kind and friendly! Highly recommended spending an afternoon enjoying the authentic bar and..."
Summer Guerra Wilson
"Great Old Fashion! Pike Sandwich was cooked perfectly and the homemade tartar was perfect too. We are out of towners, as are most guests, and we feel..."
Patrick Johnson
"Friendly service and tasty pub grub while you watch the World..."
Mark Michicich
"It’s like finding $20 in your favorite pair of jeans. Comfortable with a little something extra - and it always makes my ass look..."
Derek Crawford
"Good food, good service, very nice atmosphere! Would highly..."
Debbie Doherty
"Love this place every time I come. Brandon the bartender..."
Murphy Maes
"This place is so good that even though we are only here for 4 days we've already gone for dinner twice. Both times were great. Their soup of the day..."
Paul Kandel
"Decent food for a fair price! We had the fish and chips. The fish was crispy and better than I expected for the price point. I wish the fries..."
Emily Gazagnaire
"Bacon cheesebuger was delicious. Large hand pattied juicy 1/3 pound burger. Almost too huge for one person to eat alone. Onion rings were golden..."
Cynthia Koshalek
"This is what I think of as a true tavern. Excellent food - we actually went back the next..."
Dawn DeAngelis
"4 stars only because my debit card was charged twice. Other than that it is a fun place to stop. The staff was all very friendly and fun to chat..."
Andrea Maurer
"Cool bartender...liked good music. Great history at this place. Exterior remodel took me by surprise but remains virtually the same on the inside...."
Colin Piaskowski (HTA Colin)
"One of the last original establishments in Fish Creek. A nice bar and grill with great food and loud friendly atmosphere. The grilled cheese was..."
Jim Di SILVIO
"Carly makes the best Bloody Mary's EVERRRRRRR! Perfectly paired with a brunch of fried cauliflower and a mushroom burger. Carly is the best, but no..."
Colm Miller
"Such a cool bar. Huge wrap around bar with a lot of antique touches. Didn't have any of the food, but the drinks were amazing. They had a really good..."
Tara Miller
"Large interior bar, outdoor seating in back overlooking the water, great location and food served nice and hot make this a great place to stop for..."
Mel Brousseau
"Bill is an awesome bartender! Eaten here 4 times and food was prompt and service always courteous. Perfect if you are craving pizza, burgers, brats..."
Jeannette Plana
"The burgers were amazing, as were the sweet potato fries (worth the extra 50 cents over the regular fries). However, maybe don’t come if you’re a..."
Cassi O.
"Popped in for a bloody n bite. The bloody was pretty tastey, nice beer selection. We felt like one of the bar tenders didn't pay much attention to..."
BLFL
"Busy, busy Friday night at Bayside Tavern. There were lines. Since there were only two of us, we found a seat almost right away. Our waitress was..."
"Excellent pizza. Gluten free pizza AND beer options. (The gluten free beer was a little pricey though) Sami was an EXCELLENT server. Very attentive..."
Joe Pivonka
"I don’t write restaurant reviews, but this place is incredible. Amazing food and even better staff. I can’t say I’ve ever had better pizza. ..."
Joe Opperman
"I have eaten at both Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grilles in Door County. Not only would I highly recommend their pizza, I think the pizza is the..."
Philip Duket
"We love everything about Wild Tomato in Fish Creek. The staff is so friendly & the service is great even though the place is always busy. The..."
Ruth Black
"The gluten free pizza is amazing!! Our waitress was wonderful as was the Wild Tomato! So worth..."
Paula Olson Taylor
"This just might be the best pizza I’ve ever had. Great place, great food, great service. We’ll be back. Thank..."
Angela Truskowski
"One of the best pizzas in my life! Great staff and I loved watching them toss pizza dough in the air! Cheese curds appetizer were like HEAVEN. Highly..."
Stephanie Striegel Poree
"I have been coming to fish creek for years. I am sad it took me so long to try your restaurant. We had a great experience. Great service and food. ..."
Katherine Webster
"Loved the food , my wife and I got the green and gold pizza and it was amazing , the burgers looked fantastic as well but what is the best is the..."
Andrew Scott
"We are there Sunday night. Had a pizza and salad. It was the best Pizza we have ever had. The wait staff was very good, very friendly and helpful..."
Sue Fugate
"Best pizza I’ve had! Service was very friendly and all round great atmosphere! Highly recommend this..."
Joanne Suker
"Personable and wonderful staff! Chloe, Ally and Carlton are the best, plus actually watching the chef make our pizza in the fire kiln... awesome! The..."
Helen Gesell
"I am a pizza fanatic and this is quite possibly my favorite pizza place. I can’t wait to visit..."
Nathan Knuth
"Our first stop in Door County! We ordered the Door County Cherry Salad and the Margarita Pizza. It was so good! It's a very small space. We were..."
Rachel
"stopped in while visiting Door County! What a hidden gem! The pizza was amazing! We sat outside, the weather was great! They do have inside seating,..."
Jennifer Hinrichs
"Consistently one of my favorite spots in Door County. Have visited this location at least 30 times and everytime is amazing. The service is awesome..."
Caileigh
"Really good wood fired pizza, great choices and combinations! I made my own and had real bacon and caramelized onions, and my man had sausage..."
Toni Holder Flanagan
"Best pizza I've had in ages, and it was wood fired on top of it!!! We ordered the D- lux small one and it was the perfect size for the 2 of us! The..."
Carrie Smeby
"Long wait on a Saturday but worth the wait. Great pizza! Would definitely come by again, cherry cheesecake was..."
Vishal Varma
"Awesome specialty pizzas. Great crust, crispy and chewy. Fresh, flavorful toppings. The small is about 12” and enough for two or a very hungry one...."
Eric Aune
"Took a day trip to door county and researched pizza places as my wife and I travel the U.S and hit every small town pizza place we can. First walking..."
Maxzeus
"Phenomenal pizza. I would highly recommend their Green and gold pizza. Wild tomato is always worth a stop if you're in the area or passing through...."
Mason Aulik
"Second time there this summer. Absolutely amazing!!! Best vegan pizza (with vegan cheese, otherwise I order pizza with no cheese) I’ve had. It’s..."
Nicole Mariani
"Loved watching everyone enjoy the irises out front as they walked by & the pizza dough being thrown in the air. It's best ate at time of order, the..."
Tina Johnson
"We ate here in early October, arriving at 6:15 p.m., and we still had a solid 35-minute wait. It was worth it. We ordered the Deluxe pizza which was..."
Ted Wachholz
"By far our favorite place for pizza when visiting Door County. While there is another location in Sister Bay, we prefer the Fish Creek location...."
Kāwika Kolomona Kamake'e'āina
"Good food with potions bigger than you'd expect. Shared a couple of small pizzas, a salad, and some cheese curds between 4 people and took some home...."
Lightningdesign
"Delicious Wood Fire Pizza served in a fun and friendly atmosphere. Highly Recommended.
On a scale of (1-5)
Cleanliness: 5 (Nice Clean..."
Eric Wild
"Great cheese curds and when you order extra cheese and extra pepperoni pizza, you get both! :) Cherry cider also..."
Monica S
"By far our favorite pizza place we’ve ever stopped at! We stop every time we’re in the area and it’s consistently amazing! Last time we tried..."
"Amazing. Sandwiches. Full stop! Ok, not quite done here.... Not only does this place boast a great selection of locally produced goods, but the..."
Jon Gulbrandson
"This place is beyond amazing! I work close so when I forget to pack a lunch I just walk up the street. I introduced myself to the owners when I was..."
Taylor Ely
"Small footprint, so a limited selection. Still, everything you need with a quick stop. Parking can require some patience during crowded..."
George Gogola
"Fish Creek Market is such a nice store and best for a quick sandwich from the back counter. Incredibly friendly..."
Jack Nolan
"Deli sandwiches are fresh and delicious! Great selection of groceries and unique food..."
Bryon Shea
"Lots of fun stuff to look at and buy! Found some nice sweatshirts to take home. Will definitely visit again. Love the little town..."
MNtwinsfan4ever
"They have Country Ovens Cherry De-Lite, including the 1.75 pound..."
Tim Bailen
"This is a great place! Has what you need but also some fun high-end specialty items to try. I found some great Door County items from here that..."
Madeline Johnson
"A must do! They have it all! Incredible selection of wines, fresh produce, and delicious prepared sandwiches to..."
Becky Rosazza
"Extremely fast service. Food was good and priced reasonably. Wait staff a real..."
"Dining in the upper patio is a great experience. Drinks are yummy. Food is decent. I had the fish sandwich. While the breading was nice and flaky,..."
Amanda Wolfe
"This is a beautiful outdoor restaurant. The open bar area is upstairs and has many heaters when the weather warrants them. It has a nice view of ..."
ann fenley
"Great food and service. The perch fry and cherry cheesecake are highly..."
Omar Reda
"This restaurant was surprisingly very dog-friendly! They brought out water for our dog and even have a dog menu. I liked that they offer a lot of..."
Amanda P.
"Scoop time. Pictured are the mussels of the day tossed in an herb cream sauce and served with a loaf of bread. There are 20 mussels in this bad boy..."
Amy King
"Good food, decent prices. Good cocktails and local..."
Justin Kutchenriter
"Shrimp and rice was excellent, hamburgers could have been medium done. But we're..."
Craig Mellon
"My wife and I ate here on 10/16/15 during a trip to Door County. Overall, we were very happy with our experience. We were seated immediately, our..."
Christian Zummer
"Great tasting food. Nice atmosphere and great staff. That sun coming in the dining room upstairs, you guys need a shade!
We came back twice the next..."
Angela Daugherty
"I will have to give this place 5 stars. We it was our first time here and it was great place to stop and have Sunday lunch. The staff was so..."
Masauko Lipato
"Very nice mix of food options with a cool causal atmosphere. “Outdoor” seating upstairs is less socially distanced. Downstairs seating is...."
Flip Flop Guy
"We enjoyed an exceptional cocktail while snaking on tasty Blue cheese chips and..."
Deb Fredricks
"Nealy was the best bartender! Made great cocktail suggestion when I really didn't know what I wanted and hit the mark with the White Old Fashion and..."
Terry Kaphingst
"Great food, awesome service. Bartender and most customers are only loosely following masking orders and physical distancing. Being open air seating..."
Karrie Been
"Stopped in for a few beers. The outdoor upstairs patio is great. It's covered, but you still get the sense of being outside. All pints of Door County..."
Chris Troge
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes