Best Ice Cream in Fishers

9 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Graeter's Ice Cream
Graeter's Ice Cream
93/100 (657 ratings)
Dessert
American
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great service! Love the outdoor seating! Always tastes really good and has lots of options. It’s hard not to buy hundreds of pints to take home...."
Ally Bright
"Great ice cream 🍨 store. When we want the best treat, we travel to..."
Sheila Martin
"Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip is to die for my family made ice cream in the 1930s and 40s Graeters makes it the old fashioned..."
Rudy Riggin
"Graeter's makes my family's favorite ice cream. My favorite flavor is unfortunately seasonal (strawberry chocolate chip), but I suppose that makes it..."
Kayla Eickert
"Best ice cream in the planet. Chocolate chips the size if your head and the creamiest since liquid silk. Save your money for some real ice cream...."
Joe Large
"Always liked their ice cream but the kids working there need to put different flavors in a cup side by side not on top of each other, common sense..."
Elaine Baumann
"Fantastic ice cream and even better staff. Friendly and incredibly patient. Great job..."
Benjamin Devenney
"Greater's is always so good! I love the ice cream and I've never once had a problem with the staff. It's a little expensive but still amazing! 10/10..."
Mariah Gradl
"The peach ice cream is fantastic. I like all of their choices, but I'm always glad when July/August rolls around. The service was great, as well,..."
Diane Wilson
"Ever been on one of those random quests for something like ice cream out of the blue? You know, it's almost 10:00 at night, and someone says, hey!..."
J.T. Crawford
"Love that they have a dairy free option now. And it's really good. They have been well staffed the past few visits we have made. Their ice cream is..."
Shawn Miller
"Fantastic ice cream! Great staff. Nice place for a quick dessert after..."
Bryan McCorkle
"Despite being packed and busy, the line went smoothly and people who waited on us were kind and model employees. I recommend this location. The ice..."
Robert Stevens
"One of the best ice cream shops in the area. Pricey but a single scoop is huge. The chip flavors are a specialty but all the flavors are good. ..."
Krista Gremos
"Four of us came after dinner, already knowing the ice cream was great. We couldn't have anticipated the awesome customer service. The crew appeared..."
Darren Chittick
"Yummy ice cream and good service. Too many favorite flavors to list, but black raspberry chip, mint chocolate chip, and coconut chocolate chip are..."
Bob Carnahan
"Excellent customer service Good taste $5 - 1 scoop 8%..."
Asnave Cumbre
"Favorite ice cream shop in the area. On the pricey side (especially when compared to Handels) and has a smaller selection, but their ice cream is..."
Reina Jo
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream
91/100 (1919 ratings)
Dessert
Vegetarian Friendly
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Ice Cream
Café
American
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Cheap Eats
"Some of the best hard scoop ice cream I've ever had! They had plenty of flavors to choose from too. We tried the birthday cake and coconut cream pie...."
Megan
"One of the GEM in city, I love this home made ice creams. The 4 sampler is the best concept here, I wish other stores adapt this concept as well. My..."
Teju Reddy
"One word, delicious! Handel’s is certainly, in my opinion, one of the best ice cream spots in Indy! If you do get a chance to enjoy a delicious..."
Jennifer Ahlers
"Busy weekend night at Handel's for good reason - best selection, service, & ice cream! First time taking our preschooler, and we'll definitely make..."
Lisa Elaine
"This was a great experience and good service with friendly staff. They have delicious ice cream. I love their Extra thick chocolate milkshake!..."
Chris Barton
"Came here on Father's Day. It was busy, but the line moved quickly, and we were at the front before we knew it. The selection is a bit overwhelming,..."
Bridget Campbell
"Fast and accurate service handled the many customers before us. I enjoyed the black cherry and my taste of the black walnut was wonderful too. I..."
Asit Patel
"I confirmed my suspicion that I was lactose intolerant here. Great ice cream, huge portions. Will risk my stomach issues again..."
Mickey
"It was a hot day, and my husband suggested ice cream. The lady working there was super nice and got our order quickly. The ice cream was just what..."
Sherie Bishop
"Oh, yum!! I’m not from the area so my group shared two 4 scoop samplers- That turned into a perfect way to experience Handel’s. I recommend the..."
Pamela Decker-Wright
"If you're anywhere within an hour of this place and you've never been, it is a must visit. Some of the best I've cream you'll find anywhere and..."
Tyler Devan
"The lines are long for a reason. Pictured here is the pineapple upside down cake with gobs of maraschino..."
Lisa Gonzalez
"Handles ice cream always has the best flavors which makes it hard to decide. No matter what you choose it is almost always a great choice. I always..."
Matthew Dodge
"Love Handel’s Ice Cream! Their staff is so friendly and the ice cream is always delicious. I recommend the hurricanes especially cookie dough and..."
Jessica Barton
"Edit: Messing up is something that happens unfortunately, but when owners care enough to make things right, that will always stand out more to me..."
J C
"Love, love, love! Never disappointed. They hire the best HS students and train them really well...the ice cream is to die..."
Jose Leon
Ohanalulu
Ohanalulu
87/100 (374 ratings)
Dessert
Restaurants
Cafe
Cafe
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Donuts
Café
Café
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Drinks
Late Night
Brunch
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
Pure Eatery
Pure Eatery
86/100 (758 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Shrimp
Salad
Tuna
Tapas
Tacos
Hummus
Ice Cream
"Fresh food that very healthy and unique. A little bit on the pricy side as most dishes range from $8-$11 but it's definitely worth the price. Seating..."
Caleb Nichols
"This place is great! Great menu selections, something for everyone. The food was soooooo good. I had the Chicken Caesar wrap. Really good. And my..."
Mark and Andrea Wager
"Service, food, and atmosphere were wonderful. Our server Evan was extremely helpful and kind and took great care of us. The menu had a great..."
Matt T
"Really good food and plenty of drink options. Excellent vegetarian chooses - not just fake meats or cheese sandwiches either. The mushroom and..."
G Mack
"Brunch is now only on Sundays which is sad, but we still make it a priority to go because it's so..."
Charity Young
"Good atmosphere, a good amount of vegetarian options. I really enjoyed my food and..."
Lauren Lantz
"Pure yummy goodness. I live in the area but I only recently tried this place and I am so disappointed in myself for not trying it sooner. Don’t..."
Jessica Haley
"I had heard of this place in downtown and was surprised to see a location in Fishers as well. Went in for a lunch with a vegetarian friend and was..."
Arunima Ram
"11am brunch on Sunday was wonderful! We started with bloody marys and avocado toast. They have healthy options and southwest-inspired dishes. Our..."
Colleen Haynes
"Came in for lunch. Staff were great. Good vibe. Loved the healthy options - but best of all, the food was delicious - fresh ingredients, great..."
Brenda Thompson
"This place is great. The food is amazing. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about the food also. My girlfriend had bad gluten sensitivity and..."
Matthew Bartlett
"This is our kid's favorite place to eat out! We love the fresh, healthier menu options & have never waited to be seated. The staff are so kind, the..."
Abby Gale Reinhardt
"Ate here on a whim. It was late, we were hungry, and this was someplace new to us. Wow what a great call. Food was delicious, service was great,..."
Mike Syrek
"This place is amazing. Incredibly fresh and very well prepared food. I wasn't sure what to expect but they far exceeded my expectations. I will be..."
Jason Speckert
"Super cute place with good cheap eats! I had the portobello spinach melt with a side of cucumbers and carrots as my side. It was the perfect portion..."
Angie Gonzalez
"Love the food. Staff is always nice. Have never had a bad experience in my 3 years going here. Was great and easy to get pick up orders during..."
Nicholas Bennett
"Loved this place! Our waitress was great and offered delicious recommendations when asked. I'm a picky eater but there were so many options that I..."
Natalie Hogan
Culver's
Culver's
84/100 (2865 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
Fast Food
Fast food
American
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Burger
Fast food
Fast food
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Drive Thru
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"One of the rare fast food places that still serves a grilled chicken sandwich. And it’s really good, too. Also, their cheese curds are amazing. The..."
Joe Tamborello
"This branch of Culver’s is a staple in our weekly menu. We buy from there every single week! However, lately they added a pork tenderloin sandwich..."
Abdelhamid Azzaz
"Honestly you can’t ever go wrong with grabbing a bite at Culver’s. I’ve been here multiple times and the food is reliably awesome. Burgers..."
Sukhjit Singh
"They have the drive thru to a science! Ya gotta try the turtle sundae, it’s so good...."
Kori Jean
"Great experience! I odered The Culver's Deluxe double as a meal with onion rings. It was well put together and tasted great. The inside and the drive..."
Mason Ellis
"Great burger and milkshakes. Ordered cheese curds and got fries. They were fresh and hot, at least. Slightly disappointed, but the food is really..."
Gayle Hausmann
"We go to this location often and it is always good... Tonight, we had a small hiccup with our drive thru order. The manager Simon was right on top of..."
Kem Mitchell
"Stopped at Culver's on the way out of town. This place was BUSY. I mean drive thru cars blocking the entrance hoppin! But the food was good as always..."
Gordon Londini
"Our food was great, it was obvious people took time to make food look presentable and it tasted delicious. The staff was very attentive to the..."
Kara McCarthy
"Staff were all wonderful. Service was prompt. Order was perfect. No issues in drive through despite it being really..."
Amber Lowe
"Best Culver's burger and cheese curds I've had. Fast and friendly even though they were super busy. Great..."
David Viertel
Dairy Queen (treat)
Dairy Queen (treat)
76/100 (1212 ratings)
Dessert
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Sit down
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Lunch
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Great food and a great price for Ice Cream. The lunch menu is small but the food was..."
Clifton Morlan
"Love the new changes and new staff!! They even served us at the table. Place looked..."
Melissa Richman Whitesel
"Excellent service. Hot dog delish. Water bowl for my puppy too.... clean facility and friendly..."
Marjorie Ann Korshak
"Very clean, fast and super friendly! Absolutely LOVE this DQ and will definitely be..."
Linda Short Smith
"We had a great experience at Dairy Queen! Bryce was super nice and asked about our day! It was nice! The staff was efficient and a good team. The..."
Ally Bright
"We go to this location often and it is always good... Tonight, we had a small hiccup with our drive thru order. The manager Kenny was right on top of..."
Bob Patel
"Fastest Reese's blizzard I have ever gotten at a DQ. Wasn't even inside for a full..."
Clarissa V
"I went in for a DoorDash order and I placed an order for a small soft serve cone for myself because I’ve had a horrible day. The young woman..."
Zoe Bestmann
"Folks were nice, friendly and fast about getting the orders..."
Joe Burgess
"Liz was out cake decorator and we had a lot of special requests. She called to make sure she had it right after we placed the order online. She went..."
Amanda Jennings
"I have no complaints here. It is Dairy Queen and you get what you expect. A consistently good ice cream product. The food is also decent but I would..."
Shea Wynn
"This location has undergone a lot of manager changes over the past few years. In the past, it was a pretty inconsistent location. It was usually..."
Jessica Cockrum
"My kids love riding bikes here. Great safe neighborhood gathering place. The cakes are always decorated perfectly and are ready on time. The staff..."
Allison Steinke
"Great little spot for some quick ice cream. Never really saw this shopping strip busy and service was excellent. Service was quick and treats we're..."
Eric
"We went to this location for a treat in the middle of the afternoon on 4-24-16. Despite being seriously understaffed and a line to the door, the..."
Angie Hartman
"Ordered a strawberry milkshake from this location and was absolutely blown away by Custer service here...the counter person(belive her name page) and..."
David Driver
"I commend a couple of the employees who work at this location for their service skills. It. For one its a lot of patients to deal with the uppity,..."
Lori “Lola” Westcott
Peterson's
Peterson's
76/100 (1809 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
American
Steakhouse
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Late Night
Ice Cream
Bread Pudding
Cakes
Lobster
Salad
Lamb
Crab
Fish
Scallops
Oyster
Risotto
Tuna
Salmon
Crab Cake
Filet Mignon
Halibut
Shrimp
Sit down
Steakhouse
American
Private Dining
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Late Night
Dinner
Fine Dining
"I recently dined at Peterson’s restaurant and had an exceptional experience! The prime rib was cooked to perfection, bursting with flavor that left..."
Rebecca Collins
"Our experience was absolutely amazing. We came here for our 5th anniversary. Everyone in the restaurant said happy anniversary. They gave us a..."
Shannon Richardson
"I had the pleasure of celebrating my birthday at Peterson restaurant in Fishers, and it was an unforgettable experience. Not only was the food..."
Leonida Makori
"I would like to first start off by saying our waiter, Coy, was amazing 👏🏾 he displayed great customer service and also had a great sense of..."
Jasmine Jackson
"Made a reservation for 5pm on a weekday because didn't know how busy they would be. It wasn't very busy but it was still early. Server was very..."
Matthew Barts
"Definitely will return... one of my new favorites. The food is absolutely amazing!Thank you so much for your impeccable service..."
Eric Batchelor
"Celebrated a birthday here. Great atmosphere, business casual dress. Highly recommend lobster fingers tempura. You get 3 but they were hugh. Great..."
Marquita cohen
"For me, Peterson's is the best restaurant in the Indianapolis area. My go to for a special occasion. Took my daughters for a graduation..."
Bryan Alexander
"We were there celebrating our Anniversary and Coy was the absolute best. From the moment we were seated until we paid our bill. He was..."
James Byrd
"The most welcoming atmosphere I've experienced in a long time! From coat check, to a warm greeting from other servers, this first visit was..."
Nashiba Cosby
"Peterson's was one of the best options in Fishers and... It still is today. There are many new restaurants in Fishers now, but Peterson's has..."
Kevin Cahill (RUNKMC)
"Seen this place a few times on my route at night… so I celebrated my girlfriend’s birthday here… we our server was great!!!… started off with..."
Steve Wade
"My fiancé and I had a wonderful experience here celebrating my birthday. Our server Chris was attentive, checked in just the right amount of times,..."
Lydia Daigle
"Dined in for our anniversary. Everything tasted so good. The lobster lady fingeres werent that great but oh well. Will dine again, no special event..."
Kym M
"First time here and we loved it. The food was to die for and the atmosphere was great. Our waiter, Coy, made the dining experience top notch. We will..."
Christine Dillon
"Peterson has low noise and ambient lighting, creating a welcoming intimate atmosphere. Outstanding service providing a personable waiter who was..."
April Mitchell
"This was by far the best restaurant experience we’ve ever had! Our table was ready and prepared for us when we arrived. Coy was great! He’s very..."
Bill Smith
"Went here with my wife, and the experience we had with Coy was top-notch. This place instantly moved into our top 5 spots in Indy for fine dining. ..."
Durrell Cullens
The Old Custard Stand
The Old Custard Stand
74/100 (495 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Fast food
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Fast food
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Drive Thru
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"I love this place and can't get enough! Be sure to bring your pups and order a pup cup! It's under a buck and they get a small scoop with a Milk Bone..."
Heather Nicole Rolinski
"It's always the best sign of spring when The Old Custard stand opens! Yay! We've loved it for many..."
Natalia Wallace
"Loved the memories made here as a teen and have enjoyed coming back for years! This family owned business is wonderful..."
Emily D. Barcomb
"We moved here 4 years ago and love this place. Ice cream, sandwiches, fried pickles the BEST.. independent owners make it a family..."
Karen L Glick
"Great treats! Our family has loved going there for many..."
Tony Johnson
"I love their lemon custard!!!!!! AND I love that the inside always looks absolutely spotless!!! Another superb..."
Angela Fowlkes
"Custard is delish. Owner is a Hotty ! Love you guys..."
Kelly Mooney
"We love our Butter Pecan custard! You guys..."
Dawn Jarrell Arthur
"I've been coming here since I was a little girl! I'm always..."
Rachel Hoffman
"Chris King doesn't know what peach cobbler is supposed to taste like, I spent 3 years the peach state, and my grandmother was born and raised in..."
SheShe Abdul
"We love this..."
Kerri Merrill Melson
"I have been coming here for many years. This is our go to custard/ice cream joint. I have always supported local owned and operated but this is not..."
Chris Conway
"Delicious ice cream! Super cool spot. Stopped by while visiting family. Will plan to visit..."
Michael Casey
"Our first visit here tonight after a long day moving into our new house and we couldn't have been happier with our food and service. The employees..."
Amber Lowe
"This is hands down our best place ever for a cold treat. The food options are yummy too. But what really makes this place is the customer service...."
Coffee and Koko
"A local favorite for great ice cream, shakes, and much more. They even have a small selection of regular food. A great place to take the whole..."
Michael Milivojevic
"I really enjoy sitting out here and taking my time with family to eat the frozen custards. It has nice trees and benches. It tastes like a cross..."
Joseph Moore
"Great custard! My girlfriend and I were so excited for the seasonal reopening. You really can't go wrong with any of their flavors, and they have..."
Eddie Jensen
"This is truly some of the best ice cream in the country. It favors gelato in some ways compared to traditional ice cream. Recipe seems to be..."
Michael Burk
"Always a treat! The service is always great and fast. I was unsure on a flavor and they let me have a sample. Great price, great flavors, and great..."
Ryan84TA
"Best red cream soda I've had in years.... the walking tacos were flame!!!! And the custard is delicious! Staff was friendly and nailed our order!!!!..."
Amanda Wood
"This is the perfect local eatery whether you live down the street or are looking for something to eat on your way through town. The Old Custard..."
Erika Smyser
"I took my son here for the first time. He absolutely loved this place. He order a sloppy Joe and a strawberry milk shake. I ordered the turtle..."
Sam Loyd
"I have never eaten here before until today. I ordered a chicken salad sandwich and onions rings. The onion rings were homemade and so was the..."
Jenny McNamara
"Amazing frozen custard. I had the lemon which was excellent. My wife got a fudge sundae and my daughter got a mint shake. We'll definitely make the..."
Tony Tuite
"Nice outdoor seating. Chicken salad was good. My aunt enjoyed her taco in a bag, her first ever. Glad we could enjoy a meal together..."
Marcia Vannet
"Great custard. Friendly employees. Usually go with the small hot fudge and strawberry Sundae (2 scoops of custard). Yesterday went with the Smores..."
Dorothy Clark
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill
70/100 (679 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Fast food
Fast Food
Lunch
Ice Cream
Sit down
Fast food
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Fun tasty treats! Don’t know a kid who doesn’t enjoy a DQ treat. Burgers, dogs, soft ice cream, sundaes. Sheet Cakes and Dilly Bars too. Great..."
dave
"Thanks to the woman working at the counter (Michelle) today for being such a kind person and going out of her way to make sure my pickup order was..."
Scott Bardash
"it’s the BEST Dairy Queen in the area. they butter their toast so well, the chicken was cooked PERFECTLY, and the fries are always solid. Also..."
Shelbie Patton
"Best dairy queen I've been to in a while! Fast food isn't what it used to be but this DQ was on point. Packed Sunday and probably 10+ cars in the..."
Fallan Maunz
"Nice Custer service since new management. Much much much better than 6 months ago!! Bravo New Management 👍🏻 Their treats are awesome..."
Beverly Westerfield-Epperson
"Clean inside, quick service, and nice surrounding areas. Would come here again. We were in and out including eating there in about 15..."
Ben Harrison
"I love the dilly bars especially when they have the butterscotch ones! My family and I love the blizzards and have never had a bad one..."
Bekah Deuerling
"Looked at the menu prior to ordering at the drive-thru. The prices looked very reasonable and our order should have been less than $10.00.They..."
Thomas grant
"I'm making it a point to a knowledge excellence is customer service because it is rarely good anymore. I would like to highly compliment Khi's..."
Melissa Jones
"This Dairy Queen does really well in service and speed. They follow all modifications as requested. The food is usually fresh and they make great ice..."
Emily F
"I had a great experience there. The young woman who waited on me was very good at her job and the food tasted great. This next comment will sound..."
Terry Brooks
"I had the #1 combo (Bacon burger ) It was served hot and that's rare anymore for a drive through. The worker's are clearly new but very polite and..."
Raynard Corr
"I always get the best service at this Dairy Queen! Each of their employees has been trained on making the Blizzard perfect. I've had Blizzards barely..."
Supa Soda90