Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Flagstaff
20 restaurant menus in Flagstaff, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"We were exhausted, traveling from California and on our way to Durango we needed to stop in Flagstaff to rest. With two young boys, they wanted..."
Devina Gunn
"The people that work here are amazing. We were visiting from Michigan and my daughter researched and picked this for a place to visit.
We drove up..."
Ron Honey
"I have eaten many pizzas in my life, quite a few of them in authentic New York pizza parlors and I can honestly say this is the best pizza I've ever..."
Bryce Kreger
"Best pizza in Az. Possibly in the world. This is the 2nd review I have ever written so know, I am dead serious. Also I have a pizza tattoo..."
Susie Timm
"Toppings were delishous & fresh. The crust is unbelievably good, almost like a sourdough, so much flavor & thin not all doughy. A fun place, would..."
Marie Copeland-Benoit
"Great place and service. Really good food and wine. Loved the dog friendly outside..."
John Aylward
"La vera pizza napoletana in America fatta con ingredienti rigorosamente importato dall'Italia. Gestito da giovani e intraprendenti ragazzi il locale..."
Alessandra Gallina
"Awesome menu and very knowledgeable and courteous staff. Food was..."
Heidi Gould
"I wish we had a pizzicleta in Phoenix because this place is amazing. Puts any pizza place in the valley to..."
Dan Hiris
"This was my first experience at this wonderful little local pizza parlor! It will not be my last experience! I loved the atmosphere, the service, the..."
Connie Niebruegge
"I loved the staff, and the food is amazing. The ambiance was perfect and I can't wait to go back! It is a must try, and one of the true little gems..."
Arianne Nicole Mahealani Yago
"Seriously Amazing Pizza!! It is worth the wait. Do not miss the Gelato!..."
Tammy Pennell Young
"AMAZING had a wonderful waitress Monique! Great Pizza, Gelato, service! And you can watch them make the..."
Sean McClelland
"What an incredible experience. Great pizza and ingredients, excellent service, and warm friendly ambiance. This was a blast! Keep up the good work!..."
Jeanette Rebeske
"Super thin pizza crust!! I got the pizza special which is Buffalo sauce with cauliflower. The pizza has a kick to it. The bee’s knees was pretty..."
Wan Wan L.
"Really impressed. Some of the best Neapolitan pizza I've had. Don't let reviews from people who don't understand what good wood fire pizza is throw..."
Ryan Sepiol
"It's the most authentic pizza you'll find. It's very fancy, looks and taste great. These guys definitely know how to make pizza, just watching them..."
Daniil Gerasimov
"Food is fantastic, service is fantastic. The pizza is fast and tastes amazing, as does the gelato, and everyone working here seems to be having a..."
Capri Cat
"Super thankful to have amazing vegan options when traveling. This veganara pizza is one of the best I've had, I wish I could teleport pizza to..."
Kristi Krumlauf
"Great pizza, amazing starters, and gelato! Plus lots of vegan options. But the best part was the friendly staff. Highly..."
Rachel Franks
"One of the best dinners I have had in a while. Brought me back to my days of back packing Italy. Everything from the salad to the pizza to the gelato..."
"This place is fantastic!!! Went during the Happy Hour special and just ate off the small plates menus that was half off, plenty of food for the four..."
Jillian Kupper Yi
"Great food,amazing and original pizzas and flavorful pastas. Great service from Kim and we enjoyed live jazz too. Highly recommend this..."
Janice Guckenburg
"We didn’t know where to eat this afternoon and we hit the lottery with this place! The absolute best pizza on the planet - we ordered three..."
Laurie Hoyt Ackels
"Best Pizza I’ve had in 2+ years. If you ever visit Flagstaff and are a true lover of real authentic Italian pizza don’t miss eating here, you..."
Thomas White
"Loved this place! The food, the atmosphere, and the service. They had live music. Thought that was really cool. The tiramisu is to die for. Can’t..."
Julie Wheeler
"The atmosphere is amazing and their food speaks for itself. Everything we ate was amazing, from the roasted cauliflower, to the Parma & arugla and..."
Tessa Shallenbarger
"Delicious food, great staff, perfect experience! The specials were great and wine Wednesday with half price bottles of wine was..."
Amy Settle
"Our server Tyler was excellent with his suggestions. The food was something you will always remember and everyone was so friendly and accommodating...."
Marty Felix
"One of Flagstaff's finest. Love the gluten free flat..."
Patrice M Horstman
"This was the best pizza and service ever!! Brussel sprouts on a pizza -..."
Michele McCain Kendrick
"This place is absolutely fantastic! My husband and I live 3 hours away and I finally convinced him we should eat there (the outside is so unique so I..."
Sharlee Gene Hurtado
"Let me start off by saying I’ve been to many Italian restaurants in several different states and this ones got all of them beat by a country mile...."
Brian J
"How lucky are we to find this AMAZING Italian restaurant! From the start, our server Michael took great care of us. We’re always looking for vegan..."
Dawn Geoffroy
"The atmosphere was great but somewhat loud because the place was packed. I suggest getting reservations as far ahead as you can. Our waiter was far..."
Firelily Sackett
"This place has the best wood oven pizza I have ever tasted. The server was very knowledgeable about the menu and directed us to what to order.
We..."
Jay Mousavi
"Eat here if you can!! Make sure someone has a pizza and there is a tiramisu on the table.
This is the best place I’ve eaten at in Flagstaff so..."
Ed Ward
"Everything we had was out of this world!! From the olives, bruschetta, and to the pizza, it was all SO FRESH and so yummy!! Our server was incredible..."
"The gluten-free crust is the best I have ever had!!! We loved our pizzas - it's so fun to be able to choose as many or as few toppings as you like..."
Shannon Sweeny
"Great food, nice selection of beer (local beer too!), and very friendly staff!
We built our own pizzas. Crust is a thin-type crust and all..."
Nicole Auberry
"This evening was our first time visiting Your Pie of Flagstaff. We had the pleasure of chatting with the owner of the restaurant who was extremely..."
Dustin Hede
"I love this place!!!! The staff is so friendly and the place is amazing. Donations from the soft opening went to the humane society and they have a..."
Mimi Conrad
"My boys liked being able to choose toppings for their own pizza, they loved not having to share. Jayson had a brownie and Sam had gelato. They ate..."
Courtney Anne Ludwig
"Great soft opening! BBQ chicken pizza was really good! I added banana peppers to it. Love being able to build my own pizza. Caesar salad was good...."
Kim Armstrong Johnston
"Absolutely the best pizza I have had in quite a while. Definitely worth trying. The owner and her crew are..."
Edward Gene Mc Keown
"Great gluten free pizza! Best crust I’ve had so far. (Better than Picazzos even). Lots of topping options. Looking forward to my next..."
Kathy Warren
"Great location and very helpful staff. Pizza was excellent! Highly..."
Melvin Music
"The food is delicious and clearly high quality. I’m especially grateful for the clean gluten free crust & daiya cheese..."
Renea Atiemo
"So delicious! You could enjoy a different pizza every day of the week if you were so inclined. The staff and the service are fabulous and hey, don't..."
Dano Gruen
"Highly recommend. Patio is amazing and the pizza is..."
Jacquie Kellogg
"We really enjoyed our pizza! It was delicious. The staff was very friendly. We will be..."
"I ordered delivery to our hotel room tonight - wanted to try a local pizza place and wow were we beyond happy! The food was amazing, delivery quick,..."
Ashley Mekell
"We were visiting a friend, she took us there and we had to go again. It's the best pizza I have ever had. I normally don't eat the crust but I had..."
Jannette Pflughoeft
"My dad has been taking me here since I was just a kid and I will continue to come here for years to come. In my personal opinion Nimarco's has the..."
Ethan Barnes
"First time here. Lunch 2 slice special with a dink $6.50. Slices were huge and had great toppings. Loved the crust... crispy crunchy on the outside..."
Robert Michael Kelsey
"We love eating at NiMarcos best pizza ever we have tried pizza in other places none compares to NiMarcos the pizza taste so..."
Nova Ferguson
"Best pizza in town.. � always stop there with family when we need fast service and pizza baked to our expectation. My boys love the cheese pizza!..."
Faye Begay
"We came to Flagstaff to see the grand canyon and Antelope Canyon, NiMarco's came highly recommended by the hotel staff. Glad we went, they..."
Terry Troutman
"Best pizza I've had! Better then the pizza from where I'm from. Had it delivered to our hotel room. They were very quick and nice people
We're..."
Kimberly Pitcher
"Absolutely the best pizza I have had in forever! Let me describe, because everyone has their idea of what is good so you can decide: The crust is..."
C. M.
"It's a tradition! After our family goes skiing, we ALWAYS go to NiMarco's! Great pizza and excellent service. You might ask what's good? It's ALL..."
Johnny Kap
"Went there for the first time and it was amazing when it came to service, freshness and taste of the veggie pizza and caulifire we ordered...."
Formica Gilbert
"This is one of the best pizzas I've ever had in my life. We got two pizzas and both were split between two different kinds. So we had a chance to try..."
milen rashev
"Got on the recommendation of our hotel manager and very happy we did. The delivery was prompt and the pizza was delicious. I tried the Hawaii with..."
"The Restaurant was amazing, our food was incredible- however Waitress was a little sidetracked, forgot to bring several items including extra plates..."
diana pacheco
"Outstanding food and great service. The portions are very very generous. The pasta is out of this world. . Our son got a great cheese cake for his..."
David Ritblatt
"Amazing food and ambiance to match! I had the lobster ravioli, and it was honestly one of the best, richest seafood dishes I have ever had... Move..."
Paul “Zelus360” Reilly
"Significant addition to the town of Flagstaff. I will go every time I get to flag and I could only tell you that if you miss this Italian food you're..."
Mike Riccitelli
"Upscale atmosphere, great food, super polite staff. The chicken Alfredo was a little plain for my taste but was good nonetheless. I tasted the veggie..."
Peter Vermilyea
"The decor is glam old italian, I liked it, a modern take on an old style. It was bright and colorful. We started with the caprese, it was a good..."
brandon scott
"While looking for a fancier, upscale restaurant to visit for my boyfriend's birthday, I found this restaurant online. We made a reservation (which is..."
Markie Scheidegger
"Great food, and friendly staff. Even though we didn't have a reservation and they had a gigantic tour group taking up most of the restaurant they..."
"Small pizza place well-suited for the college crowd. The crust was to die for - almost like pizza hut back in the 80s when it was a restaurant and..."
Brandon Jagow
"First time eating here and the pizzas are phenomenal. Wings are actually above average than the other pizza chain, one with the black hat. The..."
C Chee
"My first time here. Stopped off the hwy to get something to eat. My cheese pizza was actually not..."
AK Gordari
"Polite and friendly service. Amazing and delicious pizza! Very expensive tho. Cost $80+ for 2 pizzas, 2 orders of wings. One of the order of 5 wings..."
Jason Cook
"Everything was delicious, but the garlic cheese bread did it for us! Great customer service as well. Definitely eat..."
Cara Roth
"This is some of the best pizza I've ever had. Awesome crust and great toppings.
The service was also excellent. The people were cheerful and super..."
Patrick
"I prefer this location to the others. Friendly staff great pizza with a beautiful..."
"Excellent pizza. Clean. The service is friendly. You can tell they really like working with each other. Good crowd of young people working..."
Roamin' Rich
"Service is meh, girl taking order over the phone had no customer service skills whatsoever. Pizza is really good tho! The Route 66 was amazing, the..."
Natalie Sari
"Personally my favorite pizza spot in the area! Great by the slice offers and tasty whole pies too. Incredibly friendly service and a nice homey..."
Austin Gee
"This is definitely the best pizza in Flagstaff. The crust was a perfect balance of fluffy and crispy the sauce was very good the cheese was a perfect..."
Dan Hussell
"This place was great! They let my wife and I create a half and half pizza which is great cause we do not like the same things. Their salads were..."
andres c
"Ordered the Route 66 pizza and it was phenomenal. One of the best pizzas I have had. The BBQ sauce and toppings all paired perfectly together.
I..."
"Looked at the reviews and had to give this place a try. I am glad we did. The server was Carolyn and she was absolutely wonderful. The food was..."
Mark White
"Awesome food!! Staff went above and beyond to make sure everything was to our satisfaction. Best cooked steaks I've had from a restaurant in a very..."
Gina Roberts
"The place is so cute and cozy. My husband and I enjoyed the service and the food was fantastic. I got a salad and the homemade croutons were prefect...."
Justina Morris
"Don’t let the location fool you, this isn’t a typical hotel restaurant. Steaks were delicious and the Moscow mule was on point! I recommend the..."
Alayna Guidry
"We come from Phoenix and every time we visit we have to stop by here for breakfast. Love the French toast! Nice and friendly..."
Jessica Ramirez
"I wasn't expecting too much based on the location, but was pleasantly surprised. My berry crepes were delicious. All of our breakfast meals were..."
Becky Brunet Hebert
"Love this place
Their turkey avocado melt is delicious
Wild rice pilaf is great as..."
Anu Kamat
"Amazing. In the middle of a long drive and move. Stopped in Flagstaff and stayed next door to this restaurant. Perused the menu online, which is..."
Joyce Crook
"Outstanding! Every time I visit my son, who is currently attending NAU, this is our favorite place to have dinner! Not only delicious food(the..."
Amanda Wilson
"The service was great the food was great. The restaurant was very clean. The perfect place for my family and I to grab brunch. I just wish there was..."
Carlos Vargas
"Great food!! Staff was Awesome!!!😉
Best food and hospitality from Minnesota to Flagstaff!!!
Warm cozy atmosphere, definitely be..."
Judd Ziegler
"Awesome food! Great service , very comfortable atmosphere heavy pour drinks from the bar, all for a great price.
I could have went on and on about..."
David cox
"This breakfast was good and huge. The staff was very friendly and attentive. I also never seen all the options for a Mexican breakfast. My husband..."
Angie Davis
"We loved this place! Our waitress was amazing—so attentive and friendly. We got the wings, chicken fried steak, black and blue salad, and mushroom..."
Victoria Tucker
"We stop here a few times a year if we're in the area. It isn't too far off of the freeway and has a dog friendly outdoor patio. It's possible to..."
Kurt Willmon
"This is a good one! Everything about it was great. Our server was awesome, she answered every question and checked on us every few minutes. I had the..."
Ken Warren
"Shockingly delicious!!! We are staying across the street at Hotel Elev8 and needed a quick dinner before we head out… the food is amazing! Look at..."
Leslie Lewis
"Pleasant relaxed setting. Perfect place for comfort food. Staff is friendly and helpful. Had burger and homemade lemonade for dinner last night..."
JP Savage
"Great breakfast place with foodie options (Texas Chili Crepes? Yum! Crab Cake Benedict? Delish!) and standard fare. We had a group of six with a wide..."
"One of my favorites for pizza and wing. The Flagstaff pizza is the best. The few options in wing flavors works.
The price of salads are a bit extreme..."
Kyle D.
"So glad we stopped here! The Santa Fe calzone was excellent! The crust was light and crisp, and the filling (chicken, red onions, lite jalapeños,..."
Donny Gunnels
"5 stars X2! My mom and I stopped in about 7:30pm Monday night and had our anti pasta, wings, and pizza delivered and enjoyed before 8pm. Pleasantly..."
Whitney Alvarado
"In the area and stopped by for a slice. Being from jersey I'm a tough pizza critic. This is hands down the best pizza I've had out here in..."
Matthew Kearns
"It tasted good but for being a meat lovers pizza with jalapenos, it didn't have as much meat as I would hope..."
Michael Daugherty
"The staff at this restaurant are amazing. Don't be fooled by their younger ages. They made us feel like they were hosting us in their own homes and..."
Angela Collins
"Wonderful pizza joint with amazing prices.
We tried the Tuscan special and it was huge hit!
Definitely will be on our list of stops whenever we come..."
Michelle Carrillo
"Great pizza every time! And big! I believe the large pizza is 20". Meat lover's was very meaty, and the veggie pizza was top notch, and included..."
"Met the kids here for dinner.. We've been scattered since evacuation due to the Tunnel Fire so this was a chance to catch up a little and spend some..."
Patrick Fleming
"Visited this location during my Flagstaff trip.
We were done with dinner, just wanted some desserts and ended up having a few drinks and tiramisu..."
Cat HK
"The food was good comfort, they are generous with their salad, soup and bread stick. The eggplant parmesan with spag. The lasagna was delicious as..."
Ma Gen
"Tour of Italy was cooked great. Fettuccine was fire. Our server Natalie was the best. Her attention to detail and prompt service was what a server..."
Yoan Martinez
"It was wonderful. Everyone was nice and helpful . The restaurant was clean . The food arrived hot and delicious. The salad was fresh with just the..."
Mary Schmidt
"Took my family out for a treat and we had the best service I’ve ever received from Jessica! She was thorough and not only wrote down our order but..."
Heather Palmer
"Restaurant was very clean, service was fast, staff was..."
"Tried this place out for the first time. I am not disappointed. So when I arrived with my son, we were welcomed warmly. All the crew were vibin'...."
Orval Elliott
"Reasonably priced (huge value on the lunch special), friendly staff, and excellent pizza. The slices are BIG but the pieces don’t sag at all thanks..."
Thomas Plets
"At an event in town and wanted some good pizza and The Pizza Guy delivered. Awesome pics great service don’t change a thing keep up the good..."
Sir William Adams
"We just gave this place a try tonight, we ordered a 20” party pizza and this is are Most Favorite pizza place now! Great service. Can’t wait to..."
Robert Hughes
"Great pizza. All around great flavor and the crust was fantastic also. Highly recommend this place. Better than nimarcos as far as crust flavor goes..."
David Frey
"This is a small hole in the wall however the pizza is great.mmmmm good.
I recommend this awesome place to..."
"Overall good food and service. $2.69 per topping is too much. If we wanted to simply add basil to our pizza, it would be an additional $2.69 or close..."
Tim Hassler
"This place had the best tasting calamari I’ve ever had. The staff is so friendly and really care about their job. The pizza comes out piping hot..."
Hasan
"Great experience Mask Required 😷 !
Although one of the staff was not too familiar with what is served but 🤔dude you work here, we were able to..."
Eriq
"The Stuffed Pizza is Totally Worth the Wait!! You definitely are going to want to make sure that you are a cheese lover as It is really cheesy and..."
Outdoor Fire and Patio
"Come hungry! This place is truly a taste of Chicago with some southwest flavors integrated in a few dishes. I always end up with a to go box for..."
Butch
"All the staff is nice, we had a to go order. It wasn't ready when we got there so they brought it out to our truck. We didn't have to wait..."
David Hernandez
"The waits to get seated are sometimes long (about 40 minutes for a table for 2), but I love their salads and wings. My partner and I tend to go there..."
"This was the first stop a friend and me stopped by when we arrived to Arizona. I ordered a custom pizza. I really enjoyed the hospitality of the..."
ileana giles
"Had an overall really great experience, the manager, Ray and his team in the kitchen are super hospitable and accommodating. The plant based menu is..."
Rommel Edin
"Delicious (and huge!) vegan menu & excellent service, super sweet spot for a laid back dinner & drinks type of night. I ordered the vegan Curse of..."
"Good pizza with a thick crust. Crunchy with a tangy zest to the sauce. Friendly service. Great vibe. Solid four out of..."
Robert Kanaat
"Just just a pizza place but also plenty of pasta dishes. Italy meets USA. Deep fried hot dogs and fries smothered in “red gravy” (aka marinara)..."
Ryan Kelley
"One of my all time favorite places to eat in Flagstaff. I walked in one day because I noticed it out of the corner of my eye and decided to sit down..."
Ben Davis
"A small local Italian joint recently relocated on the square downtown. The NJ style pizza is the main attraction and is very good for my taste. A bit..."
Ben Ruddell
"Don’t listen to the angry old white people in the comments. We went here on a busy Friday night and had the best experience. We ordered all of our..."
Alex Maschoff
"Nice little place with great food and lots of good service, loved the pizza that is in the wood fired..."
Richard Slocum
"Il Rosso is my favorite restaurant in town. I eat here at least once a week, and will continue to for as long as I live in Flagstaff. The red sauce..."
"Fantastic pizza! Great bar selection and service. Our waiter was amazing and don't even get me started on the desserts! What a gem of a place..."
Carrie Hintze
"I didn't have pizza but my daughter ordered a calzone and she seemed to be quite pleased. I had a grilled chicken salad and asked for olive oil and..."
Julie Wheeler
"My husband and I went there for the first time yesterday. We will definitely be back! The food was great, the atmosphere is very inviting and our..."
Chamarie Hausam
"great salad, great thin crust pizza, plus the pizza is free for your birthday, can't get better than..."
Timothy Forsythe
"My family and I love eating at Grimaldi's! The pizza and salad are great! Last time we went the waitress accidentally sold us the seasonal..."
Sharon Price Hebestreit
"Excellent service, management, and food!! The pizza was amazing..."
Ginny Gulden Mote
"Always a good place to eat good Coal Brick Pizza. Glad I don't have to travel all the way down to the Valley (Scottsdale) for good pizza..."
Stef Phillips
"Beautiful location - great food and service! Highly..."
Tracey Foote
"Amazing pizza, service and the desserts are awesome!!! Highly recommend the Don pizza my..."
Bonnie Bouschet
"My family and I came here looking for some pizza while we were visiting Flagstaff and all of us walked away believing we had tasted the best pizza we..."
Quentin Herrera
"Best experience!!! I love the pizza here. I celebrated my 21st birthday here and they made a customized drink for me which was delicious! Our server..."
Tassie Friday
"second time visiting, waiter doesn’t want to work. it was like pulling teeth to hear the beer menu, no beer list and wasn’t helpful telling me..."
Aaron Sulwer
"Was there this past weekend celebrating our daughter's graduation from NAU. Couldn't be happier with the experience. We were a large party of 30+...."
Rene Lopez
"We shared a small house salad & each got a 12" pizza, & everything was very good! I got a white garlic pizza with chicken, red onions & mushrooms, &..."
Ex Properties
"The pizza was great as it usually is for Grimaldi’s. It was really nice inside, however this particular restaurant had a large outdoor seating..."
"Love this place!! Best pizza ever,great customer service,we stop here every time we are in town,highly..."
Lupe Martinez
"Stopped in for a beer. Guy behind the bar was awesome. Came back for dinner... Also awesome. Had dinner salad, stromboli, tortilla soup, and..."
Christine Cartwright
"Was fast, friendly service and the waitress was so nice. Pizza was fantastic. Will go..."
Hoss Allen
"Cute little pizza place with awesome food and great service it's a must try if you're visiting..."
Zaq Lockhart
"Best wings in AZ... pizza was awesome. Had dinner here before we headed to the Polar Xpress.. great service! Awesome atmosphere. Will definitely be..."
Raquel Lopez
"The best place in Flag town, Always love there..."
Linda Garcia
"My favorite pizza in Arizona !!!! The first place we stop when we get to..."
Shawn Jack
"Very cute atmosphere. Friendly service and awesome pizza! Loved..."
Heather Lee Kelly
"This was the fourth time returning to Alpine pizza since I was told about the new owner and chef that have completely turned around a bad pizza place..."
Tom River
"BEST pizza. Try the pesto..."
Janna Louise Radarian
"Awesome environment and even better food. The service was great and everyone was very friendly. Hands down best pizzeria in..."
Charles
"Best pizza ever!!!!! I've been coming here since 2001. The service has always been amazing. Always clean and the vibe is great. The owner always..."
Edward Acuna
"A great place to eat pizza. They do not serve alcohol, but it's still a great atmosphere. The servers were awesome and we had very good conversations..."
Howard Smlth
"Alpine Pizza is great! Their pizza is not greasy at all and their lunch special can literally feed practically 2 people for lunch! I definitely would..."
Krissy F
"Alpine Pizza never fails. Been coming here over 15 years. I’ve never been disappointed. The sausage was tasty, the mushrooms and sauce were fresh..."
Jeff Sing
"Great Pizza!!!! We just randomly stopped by.....starving. the slices were huge and so delish. The owner was a cutie too!
Go get some Alpine..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes