Lace Kasserman-Marshall
+5
Not only the best food I've found in the keys but also the best company. It's rare when you find somewhere that you KNOW you can't make the food better... even more rare when you genuinely enjoy the company of the chef. Jay really added to the experience, such a kind and fun personality! There's no doubt that if you're at Cuzzy Bubbaz you're among family. Plus, the music is good! If you ever get back to Wheeling, Jay, it'll be my turn to cook for you! Thanks again!
Poutines in the Keys! That green peppercorn gravy was to die for. A must stop for anyone. Great food, great conversation, great gravy. What more could you ask for?
Seriously, this place. I can't. It's so good! I had the crab cake sliders and the classic putines! The sliders are of good portion and served on pretzel bread and the putines were to die for as well! I can say the cheese curds where even a little squeaky! Everyone needs to try it!
Curtis William Erling White
+5
Chef Jay is not only a master at what he creates, he is an affable man who is very worldly and an architect. Chef is a man of many talents and a great conversationalist. I highly recommend his bistro to all of my friends and acquaintances! Six Stars!
Captain Curtis William Erling White
Key West-Mad Beach
Best food on the island by a long shot we were just lucky to stumble across it online when looking at other restaurants menus. Thanks Jay for the best meals we've had in a very long time!
Actually an accurrate rating from yelp. Jay was an amazing chef, bartender, travel guide- all in one. Food was so amazing!! We shared the shrimp taco, poutines, and some improvised jerk taco.
Jay actually let us serve ourselves beers out of the Bar. Highly reccomend this to people that like the unique experience above the rest .
Amazing shrimp and lobster tacos!!! Hubs had the crab cake sliders and they were sooo good too!!! U must go!!!
So many things to say .....all great .....all I can say is eat here ....you won't regret it!
This place is amazing ! I have never had a better tuna tartare anywhere ! It's so tiny you would never expect having such amazing food coming out of this little kitchen!
I LOVE IT !
Had the lobster flat bread today and it was awesome. The other worker at the Pawn Shop had the Crab cake sliders and loved them. Since discovering this place Florida Keys Jewelry & Pawn has been ordering delivery at least 3 times a week with the employees trying different items each time and everything has been better than could be expected.
We just finished and we are planning on what we will order tomorrow.
Just had the lobster flat bread.. Oh My Lord, that was delicious! You will definitely be getting my business repeatedly.
Patricia Rodriguez Heater
+5
Hometown wonderfulness! Try classic poutine...amazing!
If you want to eat like the locals you must go to Cuzzy's. The best tuna tacos I've ever had!!! Ask for the ginger chips the are amazing. The Poutine is fantastic. We will eat here every time we come to Key West!
Great place, awesome food, and even better chef. Had the sliders and tuna tacos. Both were huge portions and outstanding. The ginger chips were like nothing we had before. Come on in, have a great meal and conversation, and make yourself at home.
After eating a lot of great food in the Keys, we went to Cuzzy Bubbaz on our last day, and it was hands down the absolute best food we ate on the whole trip! The lobster and shrimp poutine is heavenly - that dish is reason enough alone for a trip to Key West. My husband loved his original poutine dish as well. Jay was great to chat with and a super interesting guy - obviously enjoys what he does and is extremely talented at it! Loved our visit there and can't wait to go back!
Eating at Cuzzy Bubbaz was one of the highlights during our short stay in Florida. We tried both raw (tuna tartar) and warm (fried prawns) tacos and both were just delicious! Never had a better taco in my life. And talking with the owner about his snowboarding experience (in 85°F/28°C in Key West!) and his relations to Poland really made our day 😆
This is one of those out of the way secret spots that you almost don't want to tell others about. The freshly made food is amazing and the portions are incredibly generous. Seafood lovers will be in heaven with the tuna tartare tacos. Those looking for comfort food need look no further than the country gravy poutine.
Bubbaz was great! I'm from Quebec so when I saw "poutine" on the menu, I was drawn in. Small and cozy, this place offers great food. Bubbaz was friendly and kept us entertained during the short wait for our meal. I recommend this place for anyone looking a quick pit stop with food and beverages.
Incredible food! We tried the tuna tacos, lobster adobo tacos, lobster poutine, and tuna salad sandwich. Would absolutely recommend this.
The only thing to keep in mind is that Cuzzy's is run by one chef who works on island time. Even though it's pickup, expect to wait (but it's worth it!).
We’ve been in key west for days. We have eaten out x3 a day and we finally hit up this gem. It’s absolutely delicious and the owner runs the whole show by himself. I would Wait for hours to taste this food!!!! It’s a must
I had the Shrimp Tacos and Tuna Tacos. Excellent food, just the right amount and reasonably priced. Chatted with the owner for a little bit, great guy.
We had the Tuna Tartar Tacos and Crab Cake Sliders... Saw Mr Jays tuna sandwich and will be back for that bad boy. Food was delicious! Thanks Mr Jay!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes