5 restaurant menus in Key West, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"The hidden jewel of Key West. Fresh Fresh Fresh with ingredients that have been passed down for generations. All of the seafood dishes are..."
Rich Easton
"Excellent! Great service by Andrew! A very good Chilean blended wine. Guacamole and shrimp/squid appetizers were fabulous. Snapper and Mom's special..."
Rusty
"Excellent! Well prepared delicious food. Friendly attentive service. A..."
Txbluz
"Very limited menu, high prices and small sizes make this hard to reccomend to the commoner that isn't impressed with normal food with a special..."
Jason
"Excellent restaurant with outdoor seating. We had lovely evening there with fantastic service to match the lovely..."
Pavel Ollitervo-Murphy
"Wow! Our first time in Key West and we were lucky enough to come across this lesser-known gem. The food was amazing! I had the Petronia Chicken and..."
Christa Miller
"My bf and I had dinner here and it was our best meal during our stay in Key West. Service was excellent and the food was delicious. The overall..."
A. Gill
"We visited with friends after reading the good reviews and were relieved that they were able to seat us without a reservation. We stayed anyway and..."
Helen Jenson
"Nice quiet place, limited menu-only 6 or 7 main entrees and most is in a cream sauce. Only vegetarian meal was pasta. The red Sangria was really..."
Amanda Conley
"The best meal we have had in Key West. Attentive staff, delicious food. We started with the Red sangria; it was so delicious we had to try the white..."
Anne Scuderi
"Colombian-inspired cuisine, and it's all delicious. Wonderful guacamole always for starters (though the empanadas are also to die for). The entrees..."
John Teets
"My husband and I stopped in here for dinner on our first trip to Key West and it was the best choice we could have made. Everything we had was..."
Jessica Noble
"Everything on the menu is delicious! Fresh. Authentic. Mouthful of flavors...Their homemade guacamole is truly the best! The housemade Sangria is..."
"Our server was Missy and she was excellent! Started out with appetizer lobster and gnocchi. Holy smokes the flavors were out of this world. Should..."
SC Bache
"This restaurant was an excellent stop for lunch. The BBQ Pork Sandwich was great and the coleslaw was unique and delicious. The seasoning on the..."
Harrison Netz
"Great food and great service!! We started off splitting the empanadas. I had the catch of the day which was snapper and my friend had pasta with..."
Susan Funk
"Best beer and wine list in Key West. Cruise ships should all stop here!!! Quick and friendly service, beautiful..."
Adam
"Excellent service and fabulous food. What a wonderful place to..."
Beth Hardeman Saint
"Great food and service. I loved the Cuban..."
Amanda Morris
"Excellent food and service. Top..."
Dan Duncan
"Nice ambient at outdoor sitting area, you can watch the street while eating. Relatively good prices compared to couple others around. Food was..."
Tuncay Demirtepe
"Perfect drinks, food and service. I highly recommend the Frozen Key Lime Colada and the Shrimp..."
Mark Martinsson
"Great service! Great food and..."
S.Y. LEE
"Food and service was amazing! The ambiance was..."
Ashley Batts
"We had our wedding cocktail reception last year and had to come back. Love the setting, the food and especially the service..."
Wendy Simon
"Very pleasant, comfortable place. The house Chardonnay was much better than expected. We ordered the Catch of the Day. The fish and vegetables..."
Dave Senske
"My husband and I really enjoyed everything about this restaurant! The food was really good specially the Gnocchi & lobster in cream sauce, it was so..."
Nora Beutel
"Blackened fish of the day was good, but the shrimp quesadillas were phenomenal. Awesome..."
Joe Alfenito
"This was an excellent choice for our last evening in Key West. We went to see the sunset from Mallory Square and then we wanted to find a place that..."
Janis Smyers
"My family made a reservation for an outdoor/rooftop table on Christmas day.
We were seated immediately at the best table in our opinion.
The..."
J.P. T-L
"I was recently had my wedding reception/dinner here and had the best experience! Maria was super helpful the entire planning process and answered all..."
"Excellent food and service. I love to sit at the bar which is first come, first seated. Their French Onion Soup is delicious. Service at the bar is..."
Michael Alexa
"I have to say, the filet al forno rates in the top three (possibly top two) of steaks I've ever eaten anywhere. It was absolutely fantastic!
The..."
Beverly Gustafsson
"Michael’s came recommended by many, so we decided to come for dinner on a Saturday night. We had to wait a couple minutes for our reservation so we..."
Lindsey Shanck
"Amazing service, unique mixology. I would totally recommend the crab stuffed wontons, and the shrimp papparadelle is truly light mouthwatering..."
Biking Momma
"I love this restaurant. We eat here every time we visit the Keys. The steaks are always my..."
G E H
"To be off the path this was a great place to eat...the staff was great ...the food was to die for..the price was just..."
envetha stetson
"Great dining experience. Great service. Food was great. Best preparation of artichokes I've had in a restaurant (served with the red snapper). ..."
Karen M
"The atmosphere here is beautiful, we sat outside and it was perfect. All the workers are friendly and helpful. Nick was our waiter and he was..."
Shaun Spanos
"Very cute place in a residential area. I sat outside in the courtyard and it was pleasant. Owner was very pleasant and involved checking on guest. ..."
Sarah Moss-Solomon
"DO NOT BELIEVE ONLINE BOOKING IF IT SAYS THEY ARE FULL - a quick call to the restaurant and we got a seat. It was not even half full. They..."
"The person who makes the ice cream serves the ice cream and it is delicious! Plus he makes excellent sorbet and gelato. Be sure to stop by if you're..."
Aaron.kiko
"Great experience! The ice cream is homemade and the waffle cones are made to order and served warm. Delicious and fresh ice cream, gelato and..."
Carmen Koch
"Loved this place! Very freshly made homemade ice cream and gelato and sorbets. My husband loved the cantaloupe sorbet; I loved the creamy coconut ice..."
Julie
"Well I have never written a review before. I know I should but I just don't. However this may be the BEST ice cream I be ever eaten. My husband and I..."
Jennie
"Stopped here on a whim and glad we did. We had two hotdogs and two cones. Everything was absolutely delicious. Nathan's hotdogs with homemade chilli..."
El Chupacabra
"Theres one in islamorada too just great homade icecream... You should stop by on you trip to the..."
Haley
"Awesome ice cream and delicious smoothies. And the guy who works there is really friendly and will let you taste whatever you..."
Summer E
"Mmm... Kookie dough ice..."
Markiepoo
"We enjoyed our dessert after dinner. Fresh made waffle cones and ice cream, yummy ! They have sorbet & gelato also..."
Lo Ja
"We love this place! The ice cream is great, you can tell it is homemade and you can feel how proud the owners are of it. The *one* downside, is..."
GR well
"All homemade ice cream in so many flavors and so creamy! Yum! Homemade waffle cone was great! Loved having it warm but it did melt the ice cream..."
Biagio Cerbelli
"I’m from Wisconsin and this was god honestly the best ice cream I’ve ever had. My gf and I went on a vacation to the keys and stopped one hot..."
Lauren Norberg
"Me and my wife went here multiple times on our honeymoon! We got to meet Mr C and his cat and they were both so friendly. This place is the..."
Hunter Bailey
"Get the cone! One of the only places I have seen fresh waffle cones made in front of you, awesome ice cream with a very personal experience, wife,..."
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
"Mr. C’s ice cream is a must! The ice cream was fresh and creamy. The Oreo was to die for hands down some of the best ice cream I’ve had in a long..."
Kristen Bivins
"This place was dead on a Tuesday night, which was surprising! But either way, they had SO many choices of ice ream to include sorbet, gelato and..."
Megan Thayer
"It was a very personable experience with a great employee helping us. Gladly gave suggestions and helped and gave service with a smile. The person at..."
Matthew Bailey
"Mr. C and his wife are lovely! Everything is HOMEMADE by Mr. C. I HIGHLY recommend the cannoli ice cream. (NO high fructose corn syrup in any of..."
Barbara Wygal
"Best ice cream I have had in a very long time. Came to the keys with one of my sons and when we travel one of the things we love to do is go to hunt..."
MARGEND PALACIOS
"I would give Mr. C’s a 10×5 stars if I could. Absolutely delicious! A creamy cold treat that should not be missed if you’re in Islamorada..."
Jamie Engel, Florida Keys Real Estate
"Mr and Mrs C are great! We stop and get homemade ice cream every time we pass by almost every Sunday! Well worth it, dulce de leche and vanilla chip..."
Marky Mark
"Best ice-cream I’ve ever had! The sorbets are amazing!! Mr C is the best, so friendly and knowledgeable. Everything is all natural and home-made...."
Teresa Kirk Cormier
"Delicious ice cream and yummy hot dogs..."
Lmart
"Very good ice cream. Friday night has a good line of customers but they get you your ice cream really quickly. Lovely staff and excellent selection..."
Steve Soto
"Big selection of ice cream and gelato! Waffle cones are made fresh right when you order! Everything is homemade without high fructose corn syrup...."
Chris Runde
"So so so good!!! A lot of care and love is put into making the ice cream! You must try yours with a fresh waffle cone (they make them fresh, to..."
"FAST service!! It was our second night at Mallory square so we bugged out about 15min before sunset. Walked right in the empty restaurant and got..."
Schmoo Smith
"This relaxing, family friendly spot provides great seafood and other eclectic choices. I recommend the peel and eat shrimp. Start with great..."
David Hunter
"The food is so good! And you get really large portions for a really good price. Fish and chips was amazing. Mahi taco was incredible! I was only..."
Nicole Fretwell
"Ambiance is good and it's right by Mallory Square. The food was fantastic, one of the best Conch Fritters and Key Lime Pie in Key West. Price is..."
Raymond Porciuncula
"GREAT FOOD!! Had the Mahi Tacos, Blackened Shrimp & Scallops w/grilled Veggies!! Super filling!! Definitely recommend it if you are looking for a..."
Heart of a Mermaid
"Had best mexican food here... Staff was very friendly and helped us with the choosing options. I would like to visit..."
Sudha R
"Very good location for them just beside Mallory Square, friendly staff, pretty quick service and happy hour deals are good...but really, that could..."
Dan B
"It was a pleasant surprise...we were looking for a restaurant that was close by ..i Google restaurants and picked Red Fish Blue Fish...
The..."
jays porch
"Really great place! Picks up at night. The owner is awesome, and the bar tenders are amazing :) I will be..."
M R
"I had the catch of the day - blackened yellowtail snapper. It was fantastic and the appetizers were very good too. The kids loved their meals. My..."
William Rentfrow
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes