Best Fish in Fort Atkinson

6 restaurant menus in Fort Atkinson, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Fireside Restaurant
The Fireside Restaurant
91/100 (5892 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Cakes
Fish
Pork
Shrimp
Pancakes
Salad
Cod
Ribs
Bass
Sit down
American
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I took my two granddaughters to see Little Mermaid (5, & 13). Fabulous! The little one sat on my lap as she didn’t want to miss a thing! The..."
Mary Lyons Fritz
"Have never seen a show that I didn't think was well done and never had a meal that didn't taste great! No matter how many times I go (usually at..."
Dawn M Williams
"Went here for the first time for my birthday last year! Saw the church basement ladies and had the best buffet dinner ever! Loved the salad! And the..."
HV Ov
"We saw The Little Mermaid on a Thursday. The buffet was great. Food was fresh and tastes great. Staff was right there keeping it clean and bringing..."
Dana Ann
"We absolutely love The Fireside. Every performance has been nothing short of outstanding. Top notch performers, music, stories, sets for every show...."
Kent Tushaus
"Took my wife here for her first time and my I don't know how many times but first time in fifteen years. And wow it was amazing the food was great..."
Brad Jorgensen
"Never had a bad meal and never was disappointed in the musical they had since they opened in the..."
Patty Keip
"Food was pretty good. But the play was amazing!! To Sebastian who waved and winked at my little red head in the balcony made her day. She said it was..."
Stacey Bleecker
"I had an excellent experience! So much fun! Great food! Also, was very impressed they had a space I could pump so I didn’t have to do it in the..."
Lanae Dolan Haertel
"Great food. Amazing show. I love how this is right here in our backyard. Buying season tickets for..."
Bridget O'Toole Halvey
"Just amazing place! Such a great experience for my 7 yr old! We will be back! Thank..."
Wendy Smet Toyne
"The food was great, went with friends and The Church Basement Ladies 2 was funny. It was a great time and the shops were very cute..."
Chelsea Strokosch Police
"I have loved every show there, but Little Mermaid was definitely one of the..."
Megan Aaroen
"I would give Fireside Dinner Theatre more stars if I could. I love that place. Yes it's pricier than I like to pay but the experience is so worth it...."
Margie Smith
"Fantastic, beautiful theatre in the round. Super nice staff, very friendly. I'd give it ten stars if that were possible Everyone is great from the..."
Erin O
"This place is super cool! The inside of the building was so fun to explore. The dining area is split up into a number of themed areas that are very..."
Johnny Limpet
"Amazing experience! Took my daughter and mother in law to the show today. The meal, show and service was so wonderful. We went to Cinderella and it..."
Sara Bender
"We had a wonderful first time at the Fireside Dinner Theater! This is such a cool place to visit, with great glass art integrated within the walls, a..."
Conor
"The food, as always, was phenomenal! The staff were all wonderful! The show was a lot of fun. I was singing and dancing in my seat through a lot of..."
Ris G
"Polite staff, delicious food and amazing shows! The Elvis shows and the Church Basement Ladies have been the best. I've been coming to the Fireside..."
Mia b
"Wonderful place! Elvis Unplugged with Chance Tinder was amazing! Beautiful establishment! Dinner was enjoyable! Very friendly staff and willing to..."
Janet Wright
Paddy Coughlin's
Paddy Coughlin's
90/100 (1091 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Irish
Bar
Pub
American
Irish
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Tapas
Fish Taco
Tacos
Nachos
Fish
Sandwiches
Burger
Sit down
American
Irish
Bar
Pub
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"The atmosphere is spot on for an irsh pub. Service was great. Very attentive and seemed to really enjoy her job. The Ruben eggrolls and wings..."
Nikki Schmaling Storm
"This place had THE BEST food and SO reasonable for a family of five. With a few beers and full side entrees for everyone it was $70. The Special was..."
Jennifer Rusch
"First time eating here, we'll definitely be back. Excellent food, I had the pastrami ruben and my boyfriend had the whiskey BBQ burger both were..."
April Brazier-Rasa
"This place is such a gem. If I could have their Irish stew daily I would! And their fish tacos are the best! I've never had a bad..."
Michelle Poole
"The Shrimp and chips were delish... batter was light and crispy... not greasy.... salad had all fresh raw veggies and salad greens... atmosphere..."
LA Klug
"We were there for a bachelor party , great place , great bar tenders , did awesome with the party , food very..."
Bob Moldenhauer
"They've got it all going on. Great staff, food, atmosphere, beverages and they're expanding. My wife and I visit every..."
Steve Richter
"I just have to say; I have been here many times but tonight was by far the best meal I have had. The Mahi Fish tacos were the bomb! So good, I..."
Carla Hinrichs
"Best place in town for lunch, dinner, or a drink! Great..."
Mitchell Patterson
"Paddy’s is my favorite Irish pub around! The food is delish and the service is superb!..."
Makinzie Luedke
"The atmosphere is great. The food is delicious. The employees are very friendly. I love the 'Irish' old fashioned!!! We stop by for a good meal..."
Troy Jastal
"Fun place!! Great food, drinks!!! We had a lot of fun and the servers were great as well! Loved seeing the girls that came in with derby..."
Melissa V. Varman
"We really enjoyed the food here! The place was clean & wait staff were super friendly. Appetizers: we had broccoli cheese bites & the Ruben egg..."
Terri Hedgecock
"I had a very solid lunch here. The Reuben was good, but it was a deli-sliced meat rather than a fresh cut in the kitchen. The steak sandwich also..."
Todd
"Very excited to have discovered this place! We recently moved to the area and were looking for a fun place for a good fish fry and we were not..."
Kelsey Storm
"First time eating at Paddy Coughlin's Pub. The food was very good. The pic of the cheeseburger with mozzarella cheese and beer fries. The waiter..."
Brian Rein
"Good draft beer selections. Excellent food. Fried Cod Dinner and Black and Bleu Salad were great. Good..."
Al Stoffa
"First off, their entire staff are awesome. So nice, quick and helpful with a smile. I recommend the big pretzel (with 4+ people, unless you want..."
Amanda White
"Excellent little place that really surprised us! The fish fry was crispy and lightly battered. The walleye was seasoned perfectly! The asparagus was..."
Sarah Weiss
Fat Boyz
Fat Boyz
90/100 (426 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
American
Bar
Pub
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Fish
Sit down
Pub
American
Bar
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Had all your can eat wings 6 dollars taco Tuesday at noon 3 tacos huge 5 bucks. Friday fish beat in town bluegill awesome baked fish awesome. Best..."
Larry Mainz
"My mom and I visit Fat Boyz for lunch more often then we probably should, but the food choices for lunch with a salad bar as well as soup as a choice..."
Suzanne Bina Agnew
"Excellent food, great prices and fine service but don't go there. I don't like crowds. I want to keep this place to..."
Michael Ring
"Great biker bar, friendly staff and good looking women at the..."
Angelo Vasta
"I love this bar! The bartenders are all such sweeties! It's a great place to go out with friends and have a great time. Iv never had a bad experience..."
Abbey Jaeckel
"Any chance we get we head there for their Saturday night steak specials and to see Deb, oh and to have a few of my favorite, Moscow Mules!! The food..."
Leslie Ann
"Gee can ya tell from the name this place is very biker..."
Ed Mueller
"Very good service and cold beers!! Porterhouse is excellent the special had lobster with it..."
Rita Stanberg Winch
"Prime rib was delicious and the old fashioned was too. I feel at ease..."
Shirley Stoller
"Great food! Great service!! The waitresses are always super friendly and helpful,making sure your experience is top..."
Barb Rieger Kersten
"We eat here frequently for lunch at work, we're known as the office with the cats. Super excellent..."
Tami Hajcak
"Super friendly owner and staff! One of our best Cannon stops yet. Thanks for the great service and hospitality. Becko & Junior..."
Rebecca Krueger
"Nice place to grab a bite to eat. Check their website for upcoming events. Mardi Gras is next week and the celebration will be at Fat Boys in Ft..."
Maggi Jochem
"I stoped by yesterday and got the ribeye it was the best steak I had in a long time so good and so juicy and every one who works here we’re very..."
Andrew Vlha
"Fat Boyz always has great food at great prices. We had the chicken strips last night and they were some of the best I've ever had. The service was as..."
Kevin (Kevin)
"Went for a motorcycle ride and stopped here for lunch, I was also here about three weeks ago and the food is good, very good actually. Cool..."
H G
"Always enjoy visiting John, Kevin and the rest of the staff. Good drink selection and a great menu of bar food..."
Kevin F Pellatt
"Great pizza nice bartenders alright spot to go out and have some..."
Shannon Yager
Soup's On
Soup's On
87/100 (427 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
Diner
American
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Fish
Sit down
Pub
Café
American
Bar
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Still one of the best fish fries in the area. The clam chowder is awesome. The potato pancakes are homemade and absolutely delicious! Prices are..."
Traci de Groot
"A local hot spot for breakfast and lunch [used to be dinner as well, but no one should work around the clock 7 days a week] Awesome food, great..."
Rick Kucken
"Best breakfast in town and best prices. Staff is..."
Claire Sterwald
"Love love love it and our out of town guests were extremely happy 😊 dining..."
Roxy Granzow
"Great food and good..."
Gene Quies
"Always prompt service, personable wait staff and that cozy feeling of knowing you're gonna have a good meal at a reasonable..."
Will Kirchmayer
"Love soup love Lisa even more awesome owner even better person.... love..."
Anthony Esquerra
"Good food, good prices, good..."
Ron Wells
Stagecoach Inn
Stagecoach Inn
87/100 (737 ratings)
Restaurants
Soups
Steakhouse
American
Soups
American
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Ice Cream
Fish
Pork
Shrimp
Lobster
Salad
Scallops
Sit down
American
Soups
Steakhouse
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Mid-range
"This wonderful old pub is located just up 26 from Janesville a few miles. Friends of ours mentioned the Inn to us and we were happy to try it out. We..."
Scott Ross
"Had a delicious meal - beginning to end. Disappointed when we learned they had run out of prime rib just before we ordered, but we all (11 of us)..."
Sarah Peterson Kelley
"First visit - Ron Faiola's Wisconsin Supper Clubs book brought us to the Stagecoach Inn. Super fun visit started at the bar with a couple of..."
Ted Pittman
"We’ve been to the Stagecoach several times and have never been disappointed. Expect a wait but it won’t bother you because old fashioned are..."
Marc Rocklin
"Went tonight for the Prime Rib. By far the best we've ever had. It's also our favorite place for Friday Fish. Cod or Perch....can't be beat. Sean is..."
Steve Swick
"We had the best first experience! Friendly staff, delicious food, great old fashioneds and the perfect atmosphere for us. As I write this completely..."
Kelly Byford
"New Year's Eve is a busy night to dine out. Restaurants are always packed! Stagecoach Inn is a very popular supper club on a normal evening. On New..."
Storm Krueger
"Best Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet around! The food is always spot on and the relish tray is the BEST! Sean and the wait staff are are always friendly..."
Christina Grindle
"Friday night fish fry with family. Awesome food. Reservations, table was waiting when we walked in the door, and waitress was awesome. She quickly..."
Sue Heritage Griffin
"Great food, great service, and decent prices. We had the filets and shrimp and it was amazing. The French onion soup is also the best I've had...."
Roxanne Hansen
"Always have a great meal here and the owner is great. Good Friday fish fry! Sizzler is also outstanding. Good times and memories..."
Bradley Karen Puerner
"Thoroughly enjoyed the customary Wisconsin brandy old fashion along with the Saturday prime rib dinner. Everything was wonderful and was served in a..."
Steve Anderson
"Two of my sisters, my cousin from Norway and myself just got home from a fabulous dinner. The filet and deep fried lobster bites were delicious and..."
Jenny Bondehagen Bianes
"Love it there, we go often, great food,out standing service,friendly place.Highly recommended..."
Linda Stobber Pausch
"Amazing service and AMAZING food. Fast and friendly. Making this place our go to spot from now..."
Char-ity Jean
"We love the prime rib and shaun has the best..."
Kelly Hilliard-Douglas
"The atmosphere is fantastic! The food is wonderful, luv the relish tray as always. The staff is quite fantastic as well ! The prices are within good..."
Dawn Mcmenamy Davis
"We have been going there for years, such a friendly environment and having a cold drink at the bar prior to dinner, you will find the guests there..."
Bob Engstrom
"Stagecoach Inn is a Wisconsin supper club. Dinners and drinks are delicious. Owner and staff are..."
Janet Wilson Schoefernacker
"Great service and food. Everyone was very friendly, was worth the long..."
Chandra Rinehart
"Always delicious no matter what you order. Been here alot of times and have never been disappointed. Great bang for you buck. The only improvement..."
Dawn Griffith
"Excellant food and outstanding service. Never disappointed when we dine..."
Joy and'Rodney Larson
"Thank You Sean and everyone at Stagecoach for making my Wife and Mother's birthdays that much more special on their day this evening! All food was..."
Scott T. Kjornes
"Awesome dinner and service as always. Filet Mignon was perfectly cooked...."
Dave Martin
"I have tried several prime ribs at the various restaurants in this area, but there is no need to try any more. I have found the best at the..."
Peter Nielsen
"Amazing food and service. And everyone is so friendly. Been going here since i was a kid and love that nothing has really..."
Jessica Schultz
"Wait staff is great, food is awesome and the owner is a pretty swell..."
Joe Kopplin
"I have been here a few times while visiting friends nearby. The vibe is great! Friendly staff with a supper club vibe. Everybody is social and..."
Don Dearinger
"Phenomenal food. Little expensive, but well worth the cost. Service was quick.. almost too quick. Felt a little rushed. Husband and I got his & hers..."
JessNess Monster
"We had a fantastic time on our 1st stop for our 22 Supper Clubs in 2022 tour. Atmosphere is warm and welcoming, service was fast and friendly and the..."
Becky Saliby
"First stop on our 22 Supper Clubs in '22. Did not disappoint. Filet Mignon was delicious. Staff was very friendly. Overall great..."
Steve Saliby
"First time visit tonight. Our server. Jamie, was excellent! The drinks, food and dessert were all fabulous. Great atmosphere, easy to get to and hard..."
M Wachter
"Had their special sirloin steak and shrimp. The steak could have been more tender. Service was..."
S K
"This place will seriously rock your taste bud's! My fav is the steak and lobster. I have ate at this world class supper club well over 100 times in..."
Rick Kucken
Sunset Bar & Grill
Sunset Bar & Grill
80/100 (662 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
American
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Fish
Sit down
Pub
American
Bar
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range