Best Stuffed Mushrooms in Fort Myers Beach

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Matanzas On The Bay
Matanzas On The Bay
92/100 (3038 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Bar
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Ceviche
Shrimp Burger
Grouper Sandwich
Banana Daiquiri
Crab
Cakes
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Scallops
Fish
Fish and Chips
Oyster
Sandwiches
Pizza
Baby Back Ribs
Calamari
Burger
Margarita
Key Lime Pie
Tuna
Salted caramel cheesecake
Seafood Chimichanga
Calamares
Smoked Fish Dip
Key Lime Colada
Crispy Grouper
Crab Cake
Shrimp
Bay Bread
Chowder
Beef
Stuffed Gulf Shrimp
Seafood Platters
Salmon with Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Ribs
Coconut Shrimp
Stuffed Mushrooms
Lobster
Peppers
Salad
Key lime pie
Spinach Salad
Clam Chowder
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Live Music
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Waterfront
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Just a great spot for lunch or dinner. Have been going there for years. Great view, service and food. Up top for happy hour and music..."
MaryJane Hayhurst
"The view awesome, the pizza excellent and the waitress was attentive without being intrusive. The whole experience was topped off by the live music..."
Brian Lloyd
"Excellent food & service. Can’t say enough. We’ve been here before and I highly recommend..."
Norman Giovannini
"capt Kelly is the best bartender server going the pizza is good..."
David Ciarcia
"Loved this place. Hubby loved the clam chowder, I loved the coconut shrimp. The house salad was outstanding. Service excellent. Thank you for..."
Kathy Landis Phifer
"Who would have thought there was anything good about the bridge leading into Ft. Myers, well I finally found it, this place sits right underneath it..."
Kurt Kramer
"We were there just for drinks but stayed because the music was so good, Mary was sin ging,..."
Judy McLaughlin
"Great location and food. Live music, on the water and excellent wait..."
Karen Burchett Phillips
"Had a wonderful dinner on the bay! Delicious salted caramel chocolate martini! The $20 add on lobster tail is huge! Great..."
Rhonda Neuner
"Beautiful views, great service, crab cakes and onion rings were delicious. It's fast becoming my go to place for lunch on the..."
Pam Bangs Pearson
"Amanda the Bartender was so nice. The food was excellent . The view is amazing. We will be back and will be bringing..."
Marion
"Beautiful spot for a good meal. Love being on the water- the ambiance and live music was great. Gorgeous views. Food was good. The fish dishes..."
Nicole P
"This review is being written in June 2023. Hurricane Ian struck our area late September 2022 has changed the landscape. Fort Myers was particularly..."
Deborah Eckdahl
"Ordered a couple of beers....nice and cold! Got chips with homemade Pico and some guacamole, hubby got the chicken Cesar wrap, both were delicious..."
Donna Dolan
"Matanzas on the Bay is a true gem in Fort Myers Beach. This restaurant offers an amazing combination of mouthwatering food, a great place to dock..."
Rene Schildt
"One of the best restaurants in town. The quinoa salad is the best salad I’ve had at a restaurant. It’s very filling and comes with lots of..."
Monica Keith
"Never been here before but we loved it! We celebrated my mother in laws birthday here today and had a fantastic dinner. I had the broiled platter and..."
Mike Price
"Location was gorgeous! Food was unbelievably delicious! Server was awesome! We sat outside under heaters and the water view was spectacular. We will..."
Vanguard Cigar Club
"Very nice ambience on the lower deck formal dinner feel on upper deck bar crowd feel with live music which can be heard downstairs makes a nice touch..."
Francesca's Runway
"Food and drinks were really good. Enjoyed the views too! Would..."
Amy Lenz
"Great restaurant, we loved everything! Please always pick the stuffed options for few more dollars and more flavor. All of the adults had fun drawing..."
Jaynee Joe
"Good food! Only wish server would have come back around and refilled water after we paid and tipped very nicely! We were in town visiting with old..."
Kimberly Edmondson
"Beautiful restaurant on the bay - what a view! We stopped for lunch, the food was very fresh and very nice. We sat outside (it was very hot but worth..."
Lacey Mason
"Amazing as always!! We ordered and stayed for lunch and also bought several frozen take & re-bake pizzas to go. I've never had a bad meal here (or..."
Megan Garner
"Amazing! The grouper and the coconut shrimp were to die for. The red chili pepper cherry dipping will change your prospective on life. Looking..."
Wayne McClanahan (Wayne)
"The shrimp salad was so fresh and delicious. I highly recommend that dish. I'd go back just for that. The sweet tea was the real southern treat too...."
Jordan Person
"Wonderful place for a nice and pleasant dinner. We chose the restaurant for a family dinner. And despite the rainy weather we had a beautiful..."
Daniel Czemmel
"Great food, friendly staff, delicious cocktails and a gorgeous view. We will definitely be going back. Watched the storm roll in while we were..."
Alysia Train