Reviews Sugar Mill Sweets

Enjoyed lunch with my mother on Friday & we each ordered their chicken salad in half an avocado plus there was a salad & fresh fruit!! 😋 Oh was it good!! Staff is very friendly & accommodating. Wonderful atmosphere & amazing attitudes everywhere! Was definitely worth the trip to FWB. We even split a piece of their amazing coconut cake❣️We'll be back, but YOU MUST give them a try!! 💜

Oh how I miss this man place. Friendly kind staff the best food ever. Those pies and cakes OMG!!! I wish I could have them ship me every thing on the menu. If you’re visiting a must go but get there early. Miss you guys 🤗

I always appreciate a privately owned restaurant over a chain. This little place is a gem. The menu is varied and original. My advice - eat a healthy salad for lunch so you can follow with a homemade dessert guilt free! Their cakes are awesome!

I took my hubby to Sugar Mill Sweets today because our initial choice had closed their kitchen and he was about to get hangry. A close friend of ours had taken me here last year for my birthday so I figured he would enjoy it. He was skeptical at first but I was confident that his doubts would be put at ease and I was right. Our lovely server was so attentive, warm and jovial. Never missing a beat, she got us sorted with some ice cold water, gave us a few minutes and when we were ready to order, she made sure to ask if it was our first time here. Since it was my hubs first time, she told him that he gets a free brownie. That perked him right up. He decided on the Soup, Salad & Quiche combo while I just HAD to have their Chicken Divan. When he couldn't decide on a soup, she brought him little sample cups to try, which I felt was a very thoughtful gesture. For their salad dressings, they have about 5 or 6 but 2 are homemade, their vinaigrette and their ranch. I love vinaigrette so that's what I got but hubby surprised me by getting the same because he usually adores ranch. After sampling the soups he went with the chicken noodle one (I didn't even get a chance to taste any of them - that's how hungry he was) and then we dug into our salads. Oh boy! They were fresh, chilled, crisp and the vinaigrette just brought it to the next level. Shortly after, our mains arrived and from the first bite, I was immediately transported to a time when my late father used to make chicken a la king and beef stroganoff and he made it with lots of love. That's what Sugar Mill Sweets does. Good food with lots of love! Their Chicken Divan made me feel so comforted, it was like going home for a home cooked meal and that's a feeling I have not had since moving to the US almost 2 years ago. The rich creamy sauce that blanketed the fluffy rice, tender chicken and broccoli was full of flavor and although it came with a slice of garlic bread, I passed it on to the hubs because I knew I would not be able to finish it. After we finished our meal, he chose his brownie and all I'm going to tell you is that I'm probably going to go again next week so I can get pictures and add it to this review. That's if Ian doesn't blow our way.

This place is absolutely delicious. Their quiches and ham bean soup is my favorite. But their cakes…oh my goodness. I dream about the strawberry cake and my husband loves the carrot cake. They also made us apple and pumpkin pies for thanksgiving which I know are going to be amazing. Jason and the whole staff are so kind and work hard to make everything so delicious and wonderful. It feels like home inside. By far one the best bakeries I’ve ever ordered from and one of my favorite places for lunch in FWB.