This pizza place is excellent... If you aren't a fan of New York style pizza, this place probably isn't for you, but if you like New York style give em your business. You won't regret it.
Hands Down the best pizza available anywhere near this area! Best New York style pizza I've ever had! That crust is amazing and every aspect is delicious. This isn't just food, it is culinary artwork. Not to mention, the people are wonderful! If you haven't had it yet, I'd certainly make a stop there - you won't be disappointed
Had this pizza tonight. Had it opening week, and thought we would try it again. So sorry that I missed 8 years of eating this great pizza! It was amazing!! Thanks for making such great pizza
Brenda Millhouse-Huebner
+5
Amazing food! Amazing staff! Amazing owners! We loved it and would definitely recommend!
Best pizza ever! Highly recommend the Margarita pizza. Truly New York style. Delish!
My family and I ate here for the first time last night. The place was cozy and clean. We ordered a pizza and spinach calzone and salad and all ingredients were fresh. Everything was fantastic, even the service. So happy to have found this gem so close to home. Will be back again and again for sure!
It’s hard to find NY Style pizza here in Columbus. This small pizzeria satisfied our Italian Pizza craving !
One word. DELICIOUS. Hands down the best pizza I have ever had! Keep up the great work!!!!
Haven't found a better pizza than Joe and Mimi's. Can't beat excellent food and excellent service.
Great pizza! It's hard to find a good pizza in Ohio. If you want real east coast pizza this is place!
Deborah Rodriguez Garcia
+5
Love this place, great food, New York & North Beach/San Francisco style!
Great New York Style pizza and excellent service also!
Closest thing to east coast pizzeria I've seen yet!
Delicious food, excellent service and friendly staff!
Great pizza, even better spinach calzone! First time eating there, we will be back. Also need to mention how friendly the staff was, GREAT PLACE!
Fantastic New York style pizza. Be sure to get a garlic knot as well.
Maggie Humphreys Barno
+5
LOVE the pizza and pastas! Yum! The sauce is scrumptious! Wish they were open Monday and Tuesday too!
Best pizza in Licking County!
This Jersey girl LOVES, LOVES, LOVES Joe & Mimi's pizza!!
Best pizza around. This is the best pizza I've had in Ohio, and I'm from New Jersey. Delish!
Much Needed Pizza Place. This place recently opened and it is a much needed addition to the Granville area. Granville had some okay pizza places but was in need of someplace with truly good pizza. Granville is such a wonderful little village and needed a pizza place that fit it's personality. And with a wonderful crust, delcious pizza and natural ingredients, this is the pizza joint that Granville needed. The owner is wonderful and loves to interact with the customers. They offer a New York style crust and a Neapolitan crust among other items. They are only open in the evenings currently and get pretty busy. So call ahead. You won't be disappointed.
Best pizza in all of Licking County. Huge plus is that they're family owned and local. 100% recommend.
Definitely one of the better pizzas in Granville. I wouldn't call it New York styles cause it's thicker but still delicious. We got the gambler and cheese sticks. Pricey for takeout pizza but well worth it. Would totally come back again.
PSA: This is amazing pizza. Though I have some family members that did not care for it, I question their tastes versus the quality of food. Not very much room to dine in so plan on takeout. I would recommend as a must for local Granville Pizza!
Closest to Northeast style pizza I’ve found in OH. Slight confusion on the order and they resolved it wonderfully. Beef pepperoni which was delicious. Highly recommend!
Best Pizza I have had in the area so far. Ricotta tasty Pepperonis large and spicey. Antipasta quite filling. Garlic Butter seems like it was home made and absolutely delicious. Highly recommended.
Joe and Mimi’s has the best New York style pizza in central Ohio! We get pizza here about once a month or so, and they are very consistent(which is rare for pizza joints) ,staff has always been friendly, pizza is delicious and one of my favorites!
Delicious spinach calzone, and the gamblers pizza is amazing. We got both to go, and they held up well to the delay before eating them. The dough is the perfect combination of chewy and crispy, and the topping was generous, and not as oily as what you get at some places.
Great on the reheat, too!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes