Best Sandwiches in Greencastle

6 restaurant menus in Greencastle, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Myers' Market
90/100 (336 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Soups
American
Soups
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Sit down
American
Soups
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Digital Payments
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Love Myers Market. Great place to grab a fresh sandwich for lunch or love Thursdays for the grilled sandwiches. Always happy with the meat, last..."
Darcy Marley Hendershot
"Just ate the best corned beef ever! Thanks for carrying quality meats! I may have to come back on Monday to see if there’s is any..."
Carol Wenrich Cox
"They have the best bacon in Indiana. Picked up 90lbs yesterd as..."
Sandy Lacy-Robinson
"Excellent deli selection and loved that they had Ale 8 and XXX Root Beer available. I will be back next time I’m in..."
Elaine Gilbert
"This place has the..."
Tyler Watson
"My son Thomas and I were traveling from Wisconsin on our way to Bloomington for the USATF National Track meet. We stopped at Myer's Market hoping to..."
Kim Basala
"I live in Terre Haute and drive there to get..."
Brandon Ringwald
"Great product, great service, great everything. Love the fresh meat and chocolate treats. Would recommend to anyone who's looking for a good lunch..."
Rachael Graham
"We had 2 inch thick New York Strip steaks grilled for our anniversary dinner. The best steaks we have ever had!! Tender and juicy! Great meat ! The..."
Rhonda Collette
"A very creative business with a little something for everyone. MUST..."
Jason Vance Smith
"I had the fried chicken salad yesterday for the first time and it was AMAZING!..."
Michelle Boller
"Love Myers' Market! Always have a great variety and the friendliest staff!! This is just what Greencastle needed!! Thank you..."
CJ Burgeson
"Great lunch and went back for meat to take home for..."
Tonya Veatch-Hanna
"First time I chose to eat here. Highly recommend to anyone who wants a good deli sandwich. Can't wait to try more options. Can't wait to try the..."
Kyle Boehner
"Go during lunch for a deli sandwich or just shop a lot of local products. And just about anything from the meat counter will taste great as well. If..."
Josh Frye
"It was good They Have got lots of neat things in there Store they had many different kinds of bacon It smells so good in..."
Debbie Dodson
"Good vibes here and really nice looking selection of meats. I will be back to buy some steaks! However, I was a tad disappointed with my chicken..."
Nicole
"They were quick service. The deli sandwich was good. They also have a fresh meat..."
David Wilson
"Love this place! Had lunch with family here yesterday and had fried turkey on marble rye with broad ripple chips. Best deli turkey sandwich I’ve..."
Kathleen Kyle
"I love this place. Best meat around and prices aren't "break the bank" prices! Everyone is always kind n helpful. I usually send in an order using..."
Elaine Richard
"High-quality! I love the unique items, like candy and snacks. The sandwiches and soups are always flavorful. The prices are hard to beat for such..."
Jessie Hoskins
Lizzy's
Lizzy's
90/100 (766 ratings)
Dessert
Fast food
American
American
Fast Food
Dinner
Lunch
Mushroom Bacon Swiss Burger
Reuben Fries
Sandwiches
Lizzy's Roast Beef Supreme
Burger
Crab Claw Burger
Pittsburgher and Fresh Cut Fries
Cheese Cake sundae
Carmel Apple Sundae
Cowboy Burger
Ice Cream
Signature Sundae for Breast Cancer Awareness
Candy
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Steak House Burger
BLT Sandwich
Steak & Cheese
Club Sándwich
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Cheesesteak
Turtle Sundae
Crabby Fries
Café
Fast food
American
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
Mikie's Ice Cream & Green Cow
Mikie's Ice Cream & Green Cow
90/100 (1032 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Lunch
Dinner
Sandwiches
Burger
Salad
Ice Cream
Sit down
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Lunch
Cheap Eats
The Cafe At Antrim Way
The Cafe At Antrim Way
88/100 (113 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Cafe
Cafe
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Salad
Crab
Sit down
American
Café
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This is my favorite breakfast and lunch spot. You get great food with friendly service. I love to stop by and get a salad on my way to dance...."
Morgan Hill
"I have been coming in for breakfast for the last two weeks and the breakfast is great and low cost! Staff is very friendly and the coffee is free!..."
Jared Haines
"Love eating at the cafe , very friendly staff, good..."
Diane Krug
"Best coffee and loewst price breakfast in area..."
Carol Maroukian
"Great food. You can't beat the 2.99 breakfast also a great selection of sandwiches for..."
Jamie Burcker
"Awesome, great food and great service, great..."
Cheryl Gross
"The food is excellent !! It is really worth the visit. I never ate breakfast, but their lunches are awesome. Love the crab soup n crab..."
Mandy L Medeiros
"Outstanding as..."
Jim Papa
"Love this place. Breakfast is always excellent. Everything is always exactly as you..."
Robin Keihl
"The food here is yummy! I have only ever had lunch and never have been..."
Carol Hall Jones
"Awesome..."
Eric Socks
"Very good..."
Jay Sensenig
"The breakfast was fantastic. I am very selective where I eat. Have travelled out of area often and getting fresh, high quality made to order food is..."
Judith Markel
"Great food everything made to order may take a few minutes well worth the wait , I can't remember the last time I went some were ordered eggs benict..."
Timothy adLarsen
"Pretty good food but, ran out lettuce so no B L..."
Mark Powell
"The breakfast special is great. $2.99 and tax for free coffee or water, 2 eggs, 2 bacon, & 2..."
David Black
"Inside of car dealership. Small eating area and limited menu but the prices are really low and the food is..."
Tom Woodward
Almost Home Restaurant
Almost Home Restaurant
85/100 (744 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Drinks
Breakfast
Pork
Sandwiches
Burger
Shrimp
Salad
Fish
Sit down
American
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Reservations
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Accepts American Express
Parking Available
Street Parking
Free off-street parking
Accepts Discover
Highchairs Available
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The September Dinner at The Farm provided a perfect blend of excellent food, beautiful surroundings, and interesting conversation. Jack Gibson's..."
Susan Stewart
"Very nice place to eat. Right in the middle of town across from CH. It is much bigger on the inside than it looks on the out side. The food was very..."
Rick Kelly
"We have a family dinner at Almost Home once a week. They are very nice to children. The food is great and the desserts are amazing. Kasey is our..."
Cynthia Mustaine
"I love the atmosphere the most of Almost Home Wonderful place to work as well Amazing homemade pies and soups and Amazing Culinary Food, a well put..."
Carolyn Strange
"Came in to town for a horse show. This place is a hidden jem! Food was fantastic! Service was exceptional! Definitely a place I will visit..."
Patrick Gierut
"Great place!!! Enjoyed the food! Mothers day buffet really..."
Joe Moody
"I have eaten there many times. Always good food and great service. Amazing the town of Greencastle could have such a fine restaurant. I suppose..."
David Houston
"I came to Greencastle from Richmond, IN, 2 hours away for a church function. I decided to peruse around town and try a local restaurant. Almost Home..."
Ben Hill
"Beautiful location and atmosphere. Wonderful locally sourced food and best desserts around. Price is very reasonable for a nice..."
Jennifer Kirby
"We had a great, casual dinner. Good beer selection. Loved the Cubs..."
Mike Hogan
"Such a fun environment and great food! The service was even better!! Thanks for treating us like family..."
Lauren Rae Wiatt
"We recently hosted my daughter’s bridal shower at Almost Home. The atmosphere, the wait staff and the food was amazing. From the fresh flowers as..."
Brad Clapp
"I was highly impressed with this place. It's very nice and clean inside. The food is amazing. Especially the "strawberry pizza". The bar has a great..."
Warren Smith
"Fantastic! We truly enjoyed the food, atmosphere and service. Brittany did a great job with our service - friendly and quick - this is so rare these..."
Shelly Rigsby Stuthers
"Delicious!!!! My mother and I went. I had the chicken salad and it was so delicious. We also had an order of cheese curds and let me tell you, the..."
Emily Scharf
"We stopped for a nice lunch on our journey along US231. I had the signature salad which was fresh and excellent, and my wife had the chicken salad..."
Michael Brown
"The most amazing Strawberries I've ever tasted! The strawberry pie is a MUST! Soups are so flavorful and delicious too. I got the broccoli cheddar..."
Bo Turner
"My friends enjoyed dinner here. I just had chips and a couple drinks because the vegan options are essentially nil. They have a hummus platter, but..."
Kim S
"This place is truly one of a kind! The staff was welcoming and kind, and more than happy to accommodate for anything we needed. They have a full bar..."
Brandon Ball
Brother's Pizza
Brother's Pizza
82/100 (775 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Sandwiches
Salad
Lasagne
Sit down
Italian
American
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Television
BYOB
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Food’s delicious. Staff is very nice and they got everything correct. The dining area space is small and clean. Brought the food out within just a..."
Rola Sam
"We love brothers pizza. We order usually every Friday night. Everything is always the way we ask for It. Food is here quick and tastes..."
Brittany Iden
"Having lived in Clear Spring, MD I was already familiar with the food and service. Being by myself, I ordered a Stromboli. The medium is huge!..."
Jean Syverson
"Everything was delicious. Food was ready quickly and perfect. My only complaint is the people sitting behind us had a small child that was..."
carla werdebaugh
"Good Pizza. Seems like a local favorite. Place was packed. We tried veggie and plain and they were decent. Good service. The men's bathroom was..."
Muhammad Faizan