Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Greenport
7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Wow! You are greeted by friendly staff, and the brick oven pizza is absolutely delicious! The crust is not too thick, not too thin, it is cooked to..."
Pathways For Wellness - Debbie
"Staff is friendly and the food is yum! Crispy thin crust - is greasy but still so good! There is cute patio seating and a few tables inside. There..."
B Noble
"Very nice atmosphere with kind staff. Sat outside and split a pizza with my boyfriend for lunch, it was the perfect size for sharing. Pizza was a..."
Emily
"Literally no pizza on eastern Long Island compares to 1943. I’ve even moved 45 mins away and refuse to get my pizza anywhere else. The staff is..."
janelle butkevich
"My son lives on shelter island and recommended your pizza. I thought mashed potatoes on a pizza sounded strange.( he said trust me) 🤪We ended up..."
ash pa
"After a long day exploring Long Island, pizza at this restaurant hit the sweet spot. Service was fast, friendly & efficient. We had the Red Pie with..."
Sonia
"Yes. Just yes. It’s giving some of the chilliest vibes and best service you’ll..."
Nate Church
"I don't know how to describe this pizza besides telling you it's very sturdy. The flavors are on point, but because of the thinness, the pizza got..."
meera dave
"Glad we got to stop here on our trip to Greenport.
It’s a small cozy spot. Very good pies. I come from
NYC where there is some great pizza, and..."
Peter Montalvo
"Best pizza in the area. Had takeout this time, and looking forward to dining..."
A Booth
"Coal fired pizza was AMAZING best I’ve had. Staff was super chill and lovely and food came out so quickly. Ambiance was great, except for a couple..."
Christina Mazza
"Excellent pizza, we ate dinner twice in this place during our visit to Greenport. We had the classic Margarita, the Margarita with sausage, the..."
%%%%%
"Delicious pizza! Their original pies are..."
Ana Valle
"Great wood fired pizza. Been here 3 or 4 times now. This time we got a red with mozzarella and a white pie and added caramelized onions. Both were..."
Daniel Maffei
"It's easily the best pizza I have had in NY. Only downside is Greenport is a 2 .5 hr drive from where we live, but we make the trek a few times..."
Paul Leonard
"Love this little place in the Square where the American Beach Hotel is. Great Brick Oven pizzas varieties of flavors. They have a nice wine by the..."
Roni Jenkins
"Great slice, thin crust and full of flavor. Perfect balance of cheese and..."
"Best pizza on the North Fork!. Great pizza. Recently redone dining room. A nice place to stop for a slice while walking around beautiful..."
KC
"It’s been a very rainy week and Wednesday was no exception. We decided to grab a few slices and have a simple dinner. We walked in and ordered 2..."
Allison F
"Great place good food and prices huge portions.Will go back next time in..."
MARCO LOBIANCO
"The pizza was delicious and the crust was nice and crispy. I got a BBQ slice and a Sicilian slice and was not disappointed at all. Price was decent..."
William
"BBQ Chicken pizza and the regular cheese pizzas were both delicious. The store is small, but clean and well organized. Employees are friendly and..."
Karim Poonawala
"I just had a family get together catered by this restaurant and the manager, Elio (I apologize if I spelled his name wrong) and his staff helped us..."
TKA
"Clean, welcoming and delicious.
Clearly the best pizza on the North..."
Michael Feinberg
"Absolutely great , can’t be disappointed, the pizza is fresh from the brick oven . The staff is amazing and..."
Tei Aji
"Great food with huge portions. Excellent value, we will be back next trip to..."
John Smiley
"I ordered the grandma’s pizza which was very good. I also ordered a calamari, but I didn’t appreciate that only half of the take-out plate had..."
George G
"American-style pizza with an amazing selection of slices. Super friendly & helpful staff. Their garlic knots are to die for! Highly..."
"We had lunch there as we heard that it was a great place to eat. I was not disappointed at all! We all had sandwiches et it was really good. The..."
Dimitri Sterlin
"The perfect little market/restaurant. The view from back patio area on the docks is gorgeous. The staff was fun and inviting, and the food was..."
Daniel Swerdlow
"Great food, very nice view when eating outside in the back. A lot of options including vegan. Everyone is wearing masks, but social distancing is..."
Douwe Horsthuis
"Amazing bakery and cafe with outdoor seating - we love the pastis de nata, croque madam, and enjoyed the market with fresh..."
Hannah Schwartz Fields
"Great European atmosphere and Marie’s charm makes this cafe a very special..."
Max Gerbut
"Love this place! Must have a sweet croissant,
cheese or chocolate....worth every calorie. Outdoor seating that's dog friendly..."
Adam Skovron
"Went here for breakfast... AMAZING! If you're looking for French pastry, you've found..."
ali H
"Quaint locale. The food was delicious and meticulously prepared. All of the ingredients were top notch and extremely fresh. They have a small market..."
E Mena
"Incredibly nice staff, and a delicious apricot..."
Nikki Cappelli
"visited summer 2022
A great little market for essentials, and premium items. They have most of the typical grocery items you'll need, plus tons..."
Keith Jackson
"What a wonderful experience. I called Marie a month in advance for a family party of 10. I allowed her to create the menu and she crushed it. And..."
Jay Reilly
"Amazing ice chai latte w oat milk and great pastries! Fast service..."
"I've come here at least 2 times a month since 2012. From 2012 and on, the food has only gotten better. The atmosphere changed for the better since..."
Dylan Tsivouras
"This is a wonderful low key place that makes an awesome pizza. We ordered an 18” plain pie. It was wonderful using nice fresh tomato and a..."
Angela Kunz
"We are the traveling Motor Coach Gourmets. We frequent restaurants in many different cities and review them. Our ratings are as fair as we can make..."
Traveling Motor Coach Gourmets
"Nice lovely outdoor patio with picnic tables for big groups pizza was delicious and the garlic knots was off the..."
Alex Demiane
"Wonderful place and great pizza! We love Greenport and passed Emilio´s many times before finally going in last summer and we were missing out! Great..."
Mike Buttitta
"We just had a great meal at Emilio's! The four of us ordered wine and a large pizza. The place is clean and the food is excellent. The pizza crust..."
Ralph Navarro
"We come here with our muscle cars plenty of parking. The town is very welcoming of Muscle cars and exotics. Emilio’s owners are huge mustang..."
Peter Pryer
"Average pizzeria, decent tasting pizza with pasta dishes and heros. Very clean, separate dining room apart from common self seating pizza area. One..."
varanone
"Love the beautiful renovation!!!! Outrageous Italian food and great original pizza- the crust is to die for! It's one of those restaurants that you..."
Donna T.
"Service was excellent on the mid week visit in springtime. The lunch was very good and the cannoli freshly filled with a filling similar to what you..."
Antoinette Merenda Carbone
"We loved this place! Super cute outdoor seating area. Inside was very nice as well but we didn't sit there. We had the mozz sticks for appetizer and..."
L Savi
"Really good food. A little pricey but definitely best pizza in town. Outdoor seating and they serve beer and..."
"For an incredible experience come to Porto Bello. I was visiting the North Fork and my friends brought me to this seasonal local favorite. The first..."
Rob Williams
"We had another amazing meal at Porto Bello Greenport. Food, Service and ambience is just perfect.
Try the new version of their arugula salad with..."
Steve Kerge
"Porto Bello gets a resounding recommendation from me with all round 5 stars for its billing (not the financial meaning ).
From the hostess who..."
Syed Doha
"This is the first time that we tried this restaurant, and it was one of the best decisions we made. The food was exceptional as well as the..."
Vasily Theodorou
"The place is very nicely appointed, nicely decorated. The food is delicious
Service was very slow but they seemed to be short staffed. Our waitress..."
Kathy Kelly
"This is our first visit to the area. We arrived off the ferry and we were looking for a place for lunch. We had the muscles for our appetizer. Sorry..."
Deborah Shepherd
"This spot is my family's go-to on the North Fork every summer! It is especially lovely to experience the outdoor seating, but the indoor dining..."
Ashley Yu
"A wonderful little gem in Greenport Long Island. Thoroughly enjoyed our time there. Both inside and outside eating options are great. We're coming..."
John J. Beglan
"My favorite Italian restaurant during the pandemic especially during gorgeous summer weather. Dining at the outdoor patio and watching beautiful..."
Richard Yu
"Beautiful views and delicious oysters..best I’ve ever had! Our server, Miss Hayes, was so sweet and accommodating. The local Sauvignon Blanc was..."
"The ambience is as romantic as you can get, especially when seated outside on the dock. The food (especially the skate. THE SKATE!!!) is superb, but..."
Cesar Berrios
"Great food and friendly service. Highly recommend Peel and Shrimp on the menu. They have excellent drinks too. Here is some picture of Lobster..."
Emily Adams
"We ate at the bar on a busy Friday night, and couldn't have had a better experience. We started with absolutely fresh out of the water that morning..."
mm fleisher
"We're so glad we took a chance on this spot, despite some mixed reviews. Service was attentive and accommodating. The cured tuna and scungilli..."
Corinne Rossi
"Absolutely excellent. I walked into here based on a creative looking menu and was surprised with a delicious meal that would’ve fit right in..."
DogDog Wol
"Barba Bianca's second weekend open was smashing. A delightfully simple atmosphere and even more delightful staff. With consideration of nerves, we..."
Erica Zollo
"I have been dining in Greenport for 35 years. this is the first restaurant that has raised the bar on great food & service. it's been a long time..."
Peter Bransfield
"Great food and excellent service. Everything we had was delicious especially the crudo of the day and the lamb meatballs. One of the best restaurants..."
Thomas Davis
"Good friend zucchini blossoms and very good crab salad with polenta. Tasty skate, ok lobster risotto and interesting fregotta with..."
William Mintz
"The Food, Amazing!! The staff, attentive , most efficient and friendly👍 The atmosphere, perfect!!!
You MUST try this restaurant!!, again and..."
Annemarie Gambardella
"great place. Menu is a little small. lobster risotto was..."
Kristopher Pilles
"Great food, beautiful setting, fantastic service. Great summer..."
Hugh McBride
"It's Fortino's Tavern now. Great food and even greater..."
Thomas Hilton
"Just excellent!!! Everything as perfect. Cannot wait til opens again this summer...."
Philip DiPippo
"Great food on the NoFo Italian without the heavy red..."
Charles Dinerstein
"Great, clean..."
Scott Lagattuta
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes