13 restaurant menus in Hackettstown, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Just an absolutely amazing experience from start to finish. We just loved the extremely warm and friendly atmosphere that was perfect for any..."
Steve Copertino
"Great little Italian restaurant with a cosy ambience, it really speaks for the wonderful family-run atmosphere. Tight seating space for..."
Ranjani Ranganathan
"Service is exceptional- they were super attentive even tho the place was nearly packed.
Not a fan of the seating arrangement as it is a small space..."
Momana Jahan
"My wife and I took my mother to dinner for her birthday. We eat out a lot and while we often find places that are pretty good, we almost never find..."
Bruce Kerr
"I felt as though I was leaving my own family's house when I left Toscana. This is fine dining in Hackettstown. The food was cooked perfectly. The..."
John DeMaio
"We just went to Toscana for the first time, and we can't wait to go back. All of the food was amazing! We highly recommend the meatball appetizer-..."
Katie P
"After many visits, it is my pleasure to give this restaurant my highest recommendation. The food is excellent; perfectly executed simple Italian..."
Caleb MacGray
"This place has some of the best Italian food I’ve ever had. It was all home made, and you could definitely tell. If you come you have to get the..."
"Wow. We moved here to Hackettstown in October and have slowly been eating our way through town. Last night was our 2nd visit to Mama’s in the past..."
Patrick Mack
"This past Sunday (Feb. 18) we introduced two more of our friends to the Italian delights of Mama's! As always, the staff are warm, welcoming and..."
Wayne Applegate
"One of the owners met us and explained their history. My wife, now eating Gluten Free as she can was very interested and impressed with the menu.
We..."
Mark DeVoe
"I have been coming to mamas for over 8 years now, I have moved from New York to Pennsylvania to New Jersey, and always find my way to back to mamas..."
Celina Desiree Katsch
"Such a great meal and friendly service. Try the pear and gorgonzola purses - fabulous! Other notables were the calamari appetizer and the gnocci in..."
Tammy OBrien Roselle
"Took my niece with celiacs there for first time. Can't rave enough about the full menu offered gluten free. Especially recommend the GF mozzarella ..."
Paula Maloney
"I catered a meal recently and everyone loved the food. I ordered Chicken Parm. and Eggplant Rollatini and they threw in bread, extra sauce and a..."
Lois Commander-Fredericks
"Had a late lunch here yesterday with my family. The Vegan dishes were outstanding. I also have to say the service was just as good, if not better! ..."
Matthew Struck
"Great food and even better service. A terrific place to take someone special or even the whole family. Lot's of wonderful options on the menu for..."
Albert Meyer-Pflug
"Tom is the ultimate host. The staff was so professional and on the ball. The gluten free meals, vegan meals, and traditional pasta meals were..."
Little Ronald Pellegrino
"I'd been really scared to eat out since my celiac disease diagnosis. Many places offer gluten free options, but cross contamination is the bigger..."
Aileen Mary
"Great place,never disappointed. Owner is super nice so is his staff.It's on my twins visit list whenever they are home from college. A Myrtle Beach..."
Melinda Benedek Robertson
"Their vegan menu is large and everything we had was beyond delicious! Sheri was so helpful and kind, we absolutely adore her. The rest of the staff..."
Allyssa Rea
"This was my wife and I's first time here, and it was a wonderful dining experience from start to finish. The staff was extremely friendly and the..."
Mike Angowski
"Wonderful place, delicious food, great staff. I also had my baby shower there about 4 years ago and it was a great time. The staff was happy,..."
Erika O'Dell
"Tonight was our first time to Mama’s cafe. We were treated like family from the moment we walked in. The owner took the time to explain the menu to..."
Sandy Deaquino
"Amazing mom n pop experience. Food was delicious and the service was excellent. Kiara was the most amazing and patient waitress. We were a big party..."
Titi
"My fiancé and I had a great meal at Mamas Cafe Baci. We were camping in the area and wanted to go out to eat, something that can be very difficult..."
Kyle V
"The service was amazing and the food was just delicious! Although expensive, the entrees were very filling and it was difficult to even finish a..."
Adrika Venkatanarayanan
"Absolutely amazing vegan options. My husband and I were in heaven. Had no idea this gem was near us. THANK YOU for catering to people with special..."
Crimson Cuppernell
"Dad came into town and wanted a good Italian meal. Food was excellent. I had the chicken toscana $29 and dad had linguine white clam sauce $31....."
John S
"I've been here several times. The food is always amazing. They have a lot of gluten free selections that, according to my girlfriend, taste great...."
"It was good. I thought every meat tasted exactly the same. There was a garlicy meat at the end. Anyhow, it's an experience. Next time I may try a..."
bob m
"Wait staff was excellent, the quality and taste of meat were superb! We've been here so many times and they never disappoint. Everything is made..."
Iris K
"Service was nice. Food was good as well. Interior lacked a bit of ambience but generally nice and clean. Bathroom was also clean. Servers are..."
Gerry Harman
"This place was great. I've been looking for real Brazilian steakhouse since moving out here and this place. Does the job. Not just do. They have a..."
Daniel Castellanos
"We went for a nice evening out. The ambiance was amazing service was exquisite, staff were inviting. It felt like luxury. Our meals were cooked to..."
Gabrielle Vignolini
"Awesome place with great food! I’ve been going here for many years and have never had a bad meal. You will love the atmosphere and the service as..."
"Ordered a whole brisket and two BBQ chickens for a weekend party, I received a tutorial on slicing the brisket from Piggy's. It was the hit of the..."
Matthew Capano
"Attended a party over the weekend that was catered by piggys. Food and selection of food was on point� some of the best corn bread iv ever had as..."
Jas Sabin
"I go to piggy’s deli all the time. There breakfast sandwich is off the charts good. I go back simply because the food is amazing and the people are..."
Tyler Carpenter
"Ordered a buffet for a Memorial Service in Hackettstown, when I got there the service was already set up. The amount of food was eminence, The..."
Roberta Simon Housel
"Love the food and the staff even enjoy seeing fox news on the TV beats watching the fake news networks that some other establishments watch all..."
Daniel Alex
"Always have a great meal. Overall the food is great, place is clean, and staff is friendly so that's all you can really ask for..."
Christina Ralston
"This place is hands down the best BBQ around! As a group we pretty much had a little of everything and it was all delicious! We all highly recommend..."
Wayne Higgins
"Fantastic place with super wonderful staff!! I can't say enough good about Piggy's Deli - it's a place you can go where they treat you like family..."
Carol Michaels Thomas
"Honestly the Best deli around IMO; quality products, clean, cannot get better chicken salad anywhere else and all the BBQ meats and sides are..."
Alicia Anne Hamilton
"My entire family LOVES Piggy's! Best sausage egg & cheese sandwiches ever; delicious deli sandwiches and amazing chicken salad made daily by Diane...."
Kelly Bloodworth Stiles
"This is the best Deli - food is great - especially the BBQ. Staff is always friendly. Place is super..."
Mark Hamilton
"Best deli and BBQ EVER! Salads are fresh and their salad bar is amazing! There is literally something for everyone on the..."
Melissa Sanders Nichols
"We had piggy’s cater my sons graduation. What a terrific job they did! We just brought the food home and served it...."
Julianna Rheuport Tirro
"I just want to thank everyone at Piggy's Deli for the amazing job they did catering the memorial service we had for my husband. At the worst time in..."
Vickie Kenny
"Came in yesterday for lunch and went with the BBQ! I had the combo plate of brisket and pulled pork. They were delicious. There wasn’t a ton of..."
Jeff Z
"Deli in a strip mall. Big inside, but only a few tables inside. A few more tables outside, but they are right on the parking lot. Kind of expensive..."
Thomas Murzenski
"The best brisket..juicy tender. Smoked chicken was tender...but it would have been perfect w sauce on side. The slaw had too much mayo. The baked..."
Bea Lynn
"Thank you soooo much Piggy's Deli for the fantastic catering you provided for our party! I had heard great things about you but had never had the..."
Susan Milner
"AMAZING BBQ!!! Have eaten here several times on the run and with my family. Also have used them NUMEROUS times for catering business lunches and..."
"Hands down the best restaurant in the Hackettstown area. Actually, the best restaurant I've been to. Outstanding staff, impeccable service and..."
Allison Blaine
"From casual brunches to special occasion dinners, Chef Bill's menu and specials highlight fresh seafood, seasonal choices, and local farms. The..."
Valerie Kuzminski Arch
"This has become our favorite place to eat. It's pricy but have yet to have anything to eat there that is not outstanding. The chef has awesome..."
Kenneth J. Gross
"My son and I stopped in for brunch before he returned to college. We sat at the counter, which gave us full view of prep and finished dishes. We..."
Karen Toole
"From Gabby our server, to the host, to Chef Bill, our experience was amazing. The atmosphere was beautiful, the food absolutely delicious. You must..."
Jennifer Smiley
"I’m a local and go here all of the time. The food is excellent, so is the friendly service. It’s so good and consistent I bring all of my..."
Ali Cooper Knight
"This is my second time in and again they did not disappoint. Had the Elk and it was amazing..Will always come back when I am in town..Thank you Chef..."
Nick Volpe
"Fabulous!! Can’t wait to come back and I live an hour away.. Fresh food, beautiful presention and a lovely..."
Jeannie Conforti-Salvatore
"Everything was amazing from the corn chowder with crab meat to the NY strip steak to the desserts - smoked sea salt brown and cannoli..."
Jenifer Rozakis-Coombs
"So delicious! I had trouble deciding just how many amazing dishes to try! Great Brunch :) came back last night to try dinner and was SO impressed...."
Lelica Palecco
"It’s always such a treat to eat here! The food is insanely delicious, of the highest quality and perfectly plated! I’ve run into the Chef/owner..."
Kimarie Santiago
"James On Main, what can I say about James On Main. Best food I've had. That being said this is my first venture into a more fine dining atmosphere..."
David Baldwin
"We had an excellent experience at James on Main. We did the 7 course tasting menu. The portions were the perfect size and the flavors were layered..."
Kristin Pamperin
"Excellent meal in an intimate setting. Very creative..."
Raymond Trevisan
"Under Covid restrictions they have limited capacity into the restaurant and now have a $95 Prix Fix menu for a 6 course meal, 2 provided by chef and..."
Melissa Legemaat
"Had a really good dinner. Everything was really great and the service was great. Kinda wish there were a few more options on the menu. I will..."
"Stopped in with my husband for breakfast. If heard good things and was thrilled to find them true!
The wait staff was excellent, friendly and..."
Rosemarie Mazzei
"There's very little that motivates or draws me into the unamerican authoritarian state of New Jersey, where the government deprives the people of..."
Yeshua's Talmid
"Food was absolutely delicious. Staff was very pleasant. Seating was a bit busy, but sat fairly quickly. I would highly recommend this place if you..."
"You might not think Hackettstown would be home to a great sushi and steak house, but you'd be wrong. The menu is amazing, you can literally pick from..."
Alexander Kontoleon
"Beautiful decor, decent ramp but the doors are heavy, there's lots of space for maneuverability once you get inside but it's a little awkward to get..."
Mattie *
"We tried the hibachi restaurant downstairs.. While the service, atmosphere, and menu offerings were all good, the food was slightly bland,..."
Brooks
"Easily the best service in this area. I never hold places to unreasonable standards, probably because I'm in the industry and I'm a little more..."
Sean Williams
"I frequent Fujiyama, but I usually go upstairs for the sushi restaurant. A friend had mentioned hibachi and I said "hey, I know a spot! I haven't..."
"Was in Hackettstown to drop my daughter off to watch her HS basketball team at Centenary Univ. My son tagged along with this master plan in place to..."
Camp Clarke
"Good grill food. I ordered cheese curds and chicken wings. The wing sauce menu can be overwhelming so I just try and stick to the Star Ledger picks..."
Sean Murphy
"Sat outside and had wings and salad. The wings were good! And so was the salad. Solid beer menu as well. I will definitely go back. Service was good..."
bob m
"Friends and co-workers have mentioned Marley's and their wings quite often. So recently on my way home from Pennsylvania I decided to take Route 46..."
Q Brown
"Marley's has an INCREDIBLE number of wing flavors to choose from, 250 at the time of this review!
Mondays they have a special for buy one get one..."
James O'Brien
"One of the few pet friendly restaurants in the area.
Good menu selection with wings, burger, pizza, salad to mention a few. Wing sauce options are..."
Edgy B.
"Food was very good and the wings were huge. For 6 Honey Barbque and 6 Honey mustard, 12 Teriyaki, gravy fries with cheese and 2 sodas was $48.00 +..."
Herbert Haak
"Attention all wing lovers, this is the place to be if you want a variety of flavors. Marleys has over 250 flavors, and man are they delicious!..."
"Every time I eat here I find a new delicious meal! The menu is filled with unique mouth-watering dishes, sandwiches, soups, salads, main dishes,..."
Pete Smith
"I've always had great food and service here. My orders are always prepared correctly and they taste great. It can get packed on prime hours so call..."
Spike R
"Great local pub . Good food fun unique selection. Neighborhood hangout for..."
Deborah “Gourmet Mermaid Shopper”
"Sat outside, weather was perfect. 2 piece ensemble provided music. Food and drinks were good. Prices are reasonable. Nice atmosphere. Definitely will..."
Gordon
"Delicious food as usual !!!!!
UPDATED REVIEW 4/11/22
Still love this place . The food was fantastic as usual the service is great in the atmosphere..."
Tammy L
"Cool little Pub, often with live music and outdoor seating. Food is good for the most part but sitting in a small strip mall setting isn't..."
John Ardia
"There's something on the menu to please most everyone. Flatbreads, salads, sandwiches, pasta, seafood, soups, etc. All with some creative touches..."
"On June 10, my family held my mother's 75th surprise party at the Tap House and everything -- from the planning process to the dessert, was..."
Melissa Sanders Nichols
"I asked our waitress, Kristen, if I should try one of the burgers (which sounded awesome) or the Cuban sandwich (Cuban's are my fave but can really..."
Corrie Sayers
"Always a great experience, I highly recommend visiting for the atmosphere, staff, food & great craft beer! (Not necessarily in that order, tho)...."
Gene Lynch
"Was there for the first time today, Mother's Day! Kudos to the Chef and staff for putting on an absolutely wonderful brunch buffet! The food and..."
Karen Erb Walker
"Food was delicious (we had the meat lovers pizza), atmosphere was nice, beer was tasty! We were in and out in under an hour on a Saturday night! ..."
Angie Watson
"Excellent food served by an outstanding waiter! Our party of five all had something different and each dish was..."
Elizabeth Bannerman Busciglio
"Amazing place and amazing staff my regular Friday night..."
Justin Weiss
"The food was great but the services was to die for Lisa was super friendly n such awesome..."
Jestina Marie Francisco
"Absolutely Amazing..... I had the tomato &Mozz app that has a balsamic glaze that is out of this world...... a burger off of the verbal specials..."
Kris Lynn
"We had lunch this afternoon and the food was fantastic. Our server, Amanda was fabulous. Very, very pleased with the..."
Ana Masurekar Lynch
"My new favorite place! Can't usually find a wide selection of porters and stouts, but this place had 5!!!!food was yummy, ..."
Janet Weeks
"Food excellent, service great, casual atmosphere. We will definitely go..."
Marilyn Compel Ryan
"Delicious meal- served quickly. Friendly, competent waiter too. We will be..."
Teresa Bennett Gibbons
"We really enjoyed the atmosphere, service and food here. The wings were great, so was the hummus and pizza. Lots of beers on tap especially if u like..."
bob m
"If you want your money's worth and alcohol this is the place to go. It might just be the person working tonight but the drinks you get here are a lot..."
Christopher Green
"First time here and we wasn't disappointed. Was able to get a ribeye which wasn't on the menu. Cooked perfectly! It was served with spinach and..."
Patricia Ferguson
"If you have never tried this restauranr...Go! The food is always terrific. Try the cocktails..."
Debra Sansone
"Great food, friendly staff and fast service. Lots of beer on tap and a laid back..."
"So many wonderful choices, reasonably priced dishes, friendly welcoming staff, and of course the food is..."
Melissa Sharp
"Nice! Friendly server, 1/2 price apps on several. $1 less drinks. Happy Hour special. Always a favorite..."
Carolyn Gergits
"Great place with excellent pizza, generous pasta servings and a very family friendly atmosphere.
My favorite dishes are the Enzo's steak sandwich..."
Christopher Cannavo
"Italian wine tasting dinner. Wine and food both very good. Love going to these wine and beer..."
Anthony Gaito
"Had the yummiest crab cake with shrimp and rice in a cream sauce. Nothing short of..."
Janice Kustera
"It will always be "my favorite place" I have been coming here for years and each and every time it is fantastic !!! Yesterday myself and a very good..."
Denise Lavista Salamoni
"We have been customers of Dinos' for years. He and his dad Vinnie always make you feel right at home. The food is amazing, never a disappointment...."
Sheri Fuzia Welsh
"I go to the pasta grill at least 10 times a month...the food is awsome..never had a bad meal..and the owners are great.. friendly staff too..I..."
Dennis Welsh
"We love it. We eat there at least once a week. Good food, good friends, it's like home, without the dirty..."
Peggy Rickard Graf
"The food was excellent, served hot and the waters were polite and willing to help you if you needed anything, I totally enjoyed my dinning ..."
Harriet Sipos
"Dino and his staff are great people! The food is truly authentic..."
Curtis Mack
"Excellent. As always, excellent food, staff.... Everything! Well see ya again real..."
Gene Lynch
"The food is excellent! I also catered from there and everything was delicious and everyone enjoyed it. The quality is great for a local place. I will..."
Cristina Sousa
"Traditional Italian food is very good. Frutti di mare ravioli was excellent and so was Penne Laura. Our server Nick was on point and very attentive...."
Victor Desousa
"We had the Veal Parmesan and when I tell you it was second to none it truly was!!! It was a meal that even after i was full i had to keep eating..."
Patrick Burns
"My family and I have been eating at Past Grill for many years and usually multiple times a week. Food is always top notch and prices reasonable. ..."
Kevin O'Shea
"A favorite place of mine. The food is excellent. Nice environment, very comfortable, and relaxing. I recommend the Shrimp Mango appetizer. A..."
Rick Kessell
"Very cute spot and the staff was amazing! So friendly and helpful when asked for suggestions. You could tell it is a neighborhood favorite. ..."
Amber Dico
"Pasta Grill is one of my favorite places that I feel like I never get to enough. It's always delicious and we're always treated like regulars even..."
Krista Simonet
"Just wow! After craving great pasta for weeks, Pasta Grill exceeded my expectations ten fold! The Asiago and Russa dishes were stellar and priced..."
"Great food and atmosphere. Good place to watch sports. 40 beers on tap. Lots of ipa and stouts, many from the local breweries. Also lager and red..."
bob m
"Great food, but even better staff. We had our wedding rehearsal dinner planned here (through an outside catering manager than managers this..."
Sam Fry
"Excellent food, good beer selection and Guinness poured right! Went here for lunch, I had the meatloaf and it was fantastic. It is meatloaf, with..."
Don Windrem
"The food was great. I had the lamb stew and my wife had the Murphy chicken, and both was very well prepared and flavorful. Not a huge menu, but what..."
Roland Simeon
"Love this place...dined there several times while visiting our granddaughter at Centenary University...requested the lower dining room with padded..."
"I had one of the most delightful and relaxing lunches I have ever had today. Nicole was my server and she was delightful and took excellent care of..."
Chris Scrivens
"Love this local diner, great service and food. Sit in the back and watch the river flow..."
Bob Amarant
"We visit quite frequently ☺️ I love this place! The atmosphere is great and the food is even better ! Had my daughters birthday party here and..."
Alexis M Thompson
"Wide variety of consistently good food. Friendly fast..."
Denis Keily
"Great food and service.the portions were very good and a huge menu to choose..."
John Janus
"Love this place! We go here all the time for breakfast, lunch and dinner. My favorite is the California..."
Sharon Fielding
"Good food, clean place, great location, polite staff.
Has..."
Charles Odin
"Can't wait to come to NJ and visit my favorite place to eat again...
Great food &..."
Marie Elizabeth
"Great service and the food was delicious. Family..."
Linda Elba Paredes
"This is a very nice diner with delicious food! I used to eat here very often back in 2017 with a special person to me, and I have fond memories..."
Jer Brack
"We had a great breakfast! Will definitely be back. Great service and food. I really enjoyed the..."
bob m
"Very friendly staff. Food is consistently good across the board from breakfast to dinner. Excellent prices. Beautiful view of the river and..."
Melanie Pancoast
"Just started Weight Watchers and I didn't know who to trust preparing my food. River Star was WONDERFUL!!! The waiter Harry had excellent suggestions..."
Robert Interlante
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes