Have stopped here 4-5 times in the past year or so and the food and service has always been excellent BUT today I had their Banh Mi sandwich for the 1st time and was amazed, truly exceptional insides & the Utica Bread is the best! Soup is always great as well. Nice to have a place nearby that can always be depended upon for excellent food & service!
The best all around. I love this place. We Eat there so much we should buy stock in it. Great crew and Clay is the best. Can't say enough about the Eatery.
Absolutely love this place! This is my go-to eatery when I'm looking for a healthy salad (their Asian Chicken salad is amazing! ), or a great grilled sandwich! Not to mention, they have the BEST macaroni & cheese I have ever tasted!
Had the Hippiecrite, it gets 10 stars! Staff was super friendly, service was very efficient, prices fair for the quality of the finished product. I found my new favorite spot to grab some grub!!
*side note my daughter had a plain old ham sub but it was anything but 'plain', it was packed full of thin sliced ham, fresh veggies. It got my 6 year olds 2 thumbs rating and my GF had the patty melt with cheddar not swiss, burger cooked perfect and again.. smiles all around.
Best Reuben I've had in my life hands down!
Chicken Philly with Buffalo Cheddar and BBQ Sauce. Great beer selection.
If your in or around Hamilton NY there is no reason nor to eat here. Recent addition of an outside dining room provides a clean place to enjoy their delicious and fresh food. You'll find a variety of sandwiches and salads with creative toppings. As well as delicious soups. I believe these change daily. If you like spicy goods be sure to get their pepper relish!
Super friendly, huge selection on the menu, and an equally large selection of beer. Saw a lot in the coolers I can't seem to find anywhere else. Treated my young daughter very well while we were there, and was a super enjoyable place to be. Would HIGHLY recommend it to anyone looking for a good sandwich!
Good hot or cold sandwiches, and the chicken pot pie was worth noting
Try the Mac and cheese with ham sandwich. It is awesome.
I’ve only been here a few times but make sure I stop in whenever I’m in Hamilton. They have awesome home cooked food, a nice beer selection and friendly staff. Highly recommended!
Great place. Great sandwich. Fast and efficient. A good find.
The food is always fresh, the staff are very friendly and efficient.the have hot and cold foods. They have specialty soups, homemade pot pies, an excellent delhi. It is my got to place.
![4]( "Recensione")
WoW!! I think 🤔, no wait, I KNOW I had one of the BEST sandwiches 🥪 ever in my life & it came from the Hamilton Eatery 🤗. My daughter & I decided to grab something quick for lunch & we were both new to the Eatery. She enjoyed a beautiful turkey club 🥓 ($8.95) while I customized a turkey American, mayo & lettuce sandwich ($7.95, a tad bit steep IMO). The amount of protein vs bread (OMG the best & freshest sourdough 🍞 I’ve ever had!) was right on the mark. Every bite had a lil bit of everything. Next time, for me, the one thing I would do differently is ask for them to go light on the lettuce🥬. When I order a sandwich I'm not looking for a salad 🥗 between bread but it was easy enough to take off so no harm.
With the exception of a somewhat snarky order taker/cashier, I found everyone I talked with to be helpful & polite. Oh & I would strongly suggest & encourage having hard copies of the menu so one could either take it home or stand to the side so not to hold up the line. With a large family (👩🏼👨🏻👨🏼🦰👱🏼♀️👱🏼👦🏻👶🏼) it would help tremendously & cut down on unnecessary foot traffic during this pandemic.
I can’t wait to return & try something new. A great experience & I strongly encourage everyone, if you are in the area, to give them a try.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes