I recommend you go! We will definitely be returning. The service and food were on point;) The Buffalo Crab Cakes were awesome! The Chicken Milanese delicious and the Italian Sausage Rigatoni was phenomenal (per husband). Thank you for a wonderful evening.
Amazing! Completely worth having dinner there. Perfect Martinis’, excellent Lobster’s Rolls coming with legendary French fries. We ended with delicious dessert, mine was a dreamy cheese cake. Service is great, hyper pro and cost-wise absolutly acceptable for such great quality. ($96.68 for two - generous tip included). So thrilled that we came twice during our 4-day stay. Would come even more but they were closed one day! This was convenient for us since Osprey is in the wall of Shelter Island House where we stayed.
Lovely porch seating, cool even on a very hot day. The salmon with red cabbage and carrot in peanut dressing was well executed. The menu is small because the kitchen is small, but better to have fewer selections prepared well than a large menu with some misses. Prices reasonable for what you are getting.
Food was amazing! The chef didn't disappoint. The pulled pork nachos, chicken Parmesan sliders, and the prime rib were very satisfying!!! This man makes the best food!! ❤️
The best eggs benedict! We weren't rushed and will be sorry to see them close on Shelter Island.
Amazing wine ... food and service. Recommended the pasta .... amazing desserts..
High end, yet affordable. Super friendly staff. Amazing food.
excellent food, gracious service & charming setting
Fun place. Good food and service.
So Much Fun!! Tim is The Best!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes