"The best pizza I have ever had in over 35 years of my life! I have tried everything at this pizzeria, the chicken parm is out of this world the sauce..."
Zay T Studio
"Friendly staff, compensated me fairly when they got the order slightly off. Garlic knots are a bit too doughy to my liking but the sesame pizza..."
Kenji Horiuchi
"If you are in the Hicksville area this is a must stop for a great old school slice with a flair. Located in a unassuming shopping strip mall, this..."
Tomas Gonzalez
"Ordered 10 pies for a party yesterday. The Pizza was amazing! Love the sesame crust! Everyone was asking where it was from!!! Delivery was great and..."
J H
"DiMaggio's has been a long time staple in Hicksville. Even though it's under new management, they kept the quality of the food the same. Staff is..."
Hellmuffin 67
"Excellent New York style pizza with a great selection and some of the best crust I've ever had. Tastes like home. Very friendly staff and quick..."
Irfan Punekar
"Got the thin crust cheese pizza š.. They added sesame seeds to the crust.. Soooo good. Thanks..."
Niurka Rosa
"Our family's favorite pizza place!
All the dishes are great..."
ireneb71
"I drove 1350 miles from Florida just to have the best NY pizza. They did not disappoint. Crust crisp but chewy. Toppings not skimpy. Hot and fast...."
Christopher Zinno
"Yes, the sesame seed crust makes the pizza different from most, but the sauce is the key. That's why the pizza, the baked ziti, the meatball heroes..."
tdubble dog
"They Have been there with some of the same staff for over 20 years Frank and the boys do a great job amazing pizza great food great consistency and..."
Jeff O'Neil
"Been ordering from here for years , always great tasting and reasonable prices. Love the sesame..."
Irene G
"What an awesome place! My company was playing a charity soccer event for the Michael Magro Foundation at Kevin Kolm Field. Our players were hungry so..."
Maria Ponzio
"I went today to get a Buffalo slice and it was great. Spicy , a bunch of chicken and the crust was just crisp enough with some sesame seeds..."
Jar
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes