Best Sandwiches in Hill City

6 restaurant menus in Hill City, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Desperados Cowboy Restaurant
Desperados Cowboy Restaurant
87/100 (2398 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Chili
Salmon
Ribs
Sandwiches
Burrito
Burger
Chicken Sandwich
Hamburgers
Meatballs
Bread Pudding
Chicken fried steak
Pesto
Beef
Fish
Pork
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Sit down
American
Bar
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Mastercard
Wine and Beer
Accepts Visa
Parking Available
Accepts American Express
Highchairs Available
Street Parking
Free Wifi
Accepts Discover
Accepts Credit Cards
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"The service and the food were amazing - had to wait for a little bit to get seated but after that everything was quick and the food was amazing -..."
Deanna Davis Peterson
"Excellent waiter and service. We had children with us and the waiter even acknowledged them. Our party had salad, bison/elk burger and a party melt..."
Jessica Brahmer Khatri
"Had the Desperado Buffalo/Elk burger. One of the best burgers I’ve had. Staff was wonderful. You have to try this..."
James P. Welch
"The food and service was outstanding, great choice for lunch while in town. Got to have the “Desperado” burger, watched my son wolf down that..."
Eric Miller
"This was by far the best food we ate while on vacation in the Black Hills! Fresh grilled veggies were awesome, the meat prepared perfectly and the..."
Luana Vetter
"Two of the best burgers we’ve ever eaten! Desperado and Outlaw burgers. Great service and very ice..."
Pam Cappetto
"Excellent food...Always something new or different to try in season. Don't miss the Buffalo tips, chicken fried steak or the house made chips with..."
Kim Barbieri
"Was really Good. I had the desperado Burger. Was a little peace of heaven. If you love Elk, Buffalo, Beacon and Cheese then you will enjoy. Service..."
David Haack
"The Food was Superb and the service was too!! The Walnut Pie was Excellent!! The atmosphere and cleanliness was top notch! Recommend this place..."
Lee Ann-Bob Piggott
"Cute atmosphere... excellent homemade food and our waitress was the best ! We had 8 people in our group and she tended to everyone's..."
Rita Sekmakas Bezdicek
"The walleye was delicious..just fair warning there are bones. The green beans and sweet tater fries were amazing, too! Our waitress was brand new and..."
Kristina Frisk
"We waited about 35 minutes to be seated. They were,like so many other businesses, so short staffed. They did a wonderful job and the steak I had was..."
Sheila Ove
"Had dinner here the country fried steak was good. My husband enjoyed his sirloin steak it was cooked perfectly medium rare. Great service she came..."
Lynda Sigwanz
"This is the spot in Hill City! Just walking past here you smell the burgers and meats cooking. Hard to walk past here not stopping for something..."
Elma Imamovic
"Great western themed restaurant. Good food, decent portion sizes, really good atmosphere and staff. Didn't want dessert but our waitress brought out..."
Roo Boo
"Great atmosphere, very clean and cozy. Good food and great service - we would certainly..."
S O
"Loved the Buffalo burger!! Service and atmosphere was great. Glad we made pigs of ourselves and had the apple pie ala mode. It was Delicious!!!..."
Chris Towner
Subway
Subway
81/100 (241 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Fast Food
Fast food
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Sit down
American
Fast food
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"I stopped here on my road trip after visiting the Devil's Tower, Mount Rushmore, and Crazy Horse - I was hungry! It was not too crowded when I went...."
Laurel Clark
"I love the fact that they offer you choices that are very healthy and reasonably low in calories. I just wish the bread was a little bit tastier. I..."
John Calomeni
"We were on vacation and this Subway was near our hotel. We went for dinner and it was the best Subway we have EVER been to! The food was so fresh......"
J K
Bumpin Buffalo Bar & Grill
Bumpin Buffalo Bar & Grill
80/100 (2544 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
American
Pub
American
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Buffalo Steak
Salad
Rocky Mountain Oysters
Wings
Buffalo Waffle Fries
Oyster
Bumping Buffalo Burger
Salmon
Fish & chips
Grande Nacho Supreme
Fish & Chips
fish n chips
Sandwiches
Nachos & French Fries
Ribs
Bloody Mary
Burger
Chicken Sandwich with Mac and Cheese
Nachos
Pinacolada
Hamburgers
Chicken Sandwich
BLT
Root Beer
Fish
Potato Cakes
chicken strips
Bison Burger
Chocolate cake
Hamburger
Fish-And-Chips
Beef
Jumbo Chicken Wings
Prime Rib French Dip Sandwich
Brisket Sandwich with Fries
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Reservations
Sports bars
Seating
Table Service
Family style
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Outdoor Seating
Free off-street parking
Takeout
Highchairs Available
Television
Accepts Credit Cards
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Mid-range
"I worked this summer behind the bar, and it was one of the best experiences I've had job wise in my life. Fun, exciting and very good place to work..."
Räzo Josuha
"Always a favorite stop when in Hill city, great food, fun atmosphere with some hidden history in there as well. Upstairs is a great spot to watch the..."
Amanda Matlock
"Best chicken sandwich (Homesteader) ever! My husband had the hot beef sandwich which he said was also excellent. This restaurant was extremely busy..."
Kim Johnson Dahl
"Great local place to grab a bite and relax! Loved the beer cheese soup, it was to die..."
Joanne Straney
"We were going to eat at The Mangy Moose...but they were short staffed and were having a limited menu...decided to pop across the street to The Bumpin..."
Andrea Anderson Venneman
"We stopped in last Thursday and were greeted right away with the waitress getting our drink orders to us quickly! The food was great and we..."
Lisa Petersen Bruns
"The food was amazing and the service was superb. Highly recommend stopping..."
Tracy Hargens
"We had a great time last night. Food was amazing! I had the Buffalo burger. My son had the regular kids burger. And my husband had the "Fat" one. And..."
Melinda Shaffer
"While visiting the Black Hills we were thirsty for some icy refreshing cocktails, and found the Bumpin Buffalo. The friendly & fun bartender made us..."
Vanessa Redding Lewis
Alpine Inn
Alpine Inn
92/100 (2021 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
German
Steakhouse
German
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheesecake
Filet Mignon
Toasts
Roast Beef
Sandwiches
Tiramisu
Burger
Schnitzel
Cheesecakes
Bread Pudding
Beef
Pesto
Pork
Dumplings
Pasta
Salad
Sit down
German
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Live Music
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"My husband and I were in vacation in the Black Hills this week and met up with some friends in Hill City who recommended the Alpine Inn. I have..."
Margo Orris Leisinger
"We drove from Sheridan Wyoming to eat at the alpine inn. Truly worth the drive! The smell of German food when you walk in is amazing! The food was to..."
Deb Leo Pfau
"What a nice place in Hill City. The hotel/restaurant is decorated and lit up so beautifully. They have just two items on the menu for dinner but..."
Marlin Jeffers
"The food is amazing don’t ruin the filet with steak sauce it’s that good! And the bread pudding is to die for. Our server Melissa knows her stuff..."
Edwena Turner
"Excellent food and service. Don’t skip dessert! Highly recommend for anyone in..."
Shawna Bowker Lindsay
"Awesome place great vibes and great staff highly recommend we eat here at least once a year..."
Aaron Jones
"What a fabulous place to eat! Really a fun and quaint little place. Go early as it fills up fast. Enjoyed the food..."
Dana Rouskey-Gurske
"This restaurant was recommended by my nephew who used to live in the area. I had no idea what to expect, and boy was it great surprise. The only..."
Cyndi Preku
"I have been there three times and it’s always amazing. I live in MN but when we come to visit friends in the Hills the dinner at the Alpine is a..."
Cody Anthony
"Whenever we come to Rapid City, we have go to Alpine Inn. We’ve never had a bad meal or service. My sister and I got smart and started ordering one..."
Connie Adams
"Great food and desert to die for. Been there many times and always have to stop..."
Cathie Rouse
"The walleye was delicious..just fair warning there are bones. The green beans and sweet tater fries were amazing, too! Our waitress was brand new and..."
Kristina Frisk
"We waited about 35 minutes to be seated. They were,like so many other businesses, so short staffed. They did a wonderful job and the steak I had was..."
Sheila Ove
"Had dinner here the country fried steak was good. My husband enjoyed his sirloin steak it was cooked perfectly medium rare. Great service she came..."
Lynda Sigwanz
"This is the spot in Hill City! Just walking past here you smell the burgers and meats cooking. Hard to walk past here not stopping for something..."
Elma Imamovic
"Great western themed restaurant. Good food, decent portion sizes, really good atmosphere and staff. Didn't want dessert but our waitress brought out..."
Roo Boo
"Great atmosphere, very clean and cozy. Good food and great service - we would certainly..."
S O
"Loved the Buffalo burger!! Service and atmosphere was great. Glad we made pigs of ourselves and had the apple pie ala mode. It was Delicious!!!..."
Chris Towner
Hill City Cafe
Hill City Cafe
72/100 (2493 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Cafe
Diner
Diner
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Cafe
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Cakes
Fish
Salad
Wings
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger
Ribs
Burger
French Fries
French Toast
Hamburgers
Toasts
Roast Beef
Shrimp
Beef
Omelette
Chicken fried steak
Frog Legs
Pancakes
Sit down
Café
American
Diner
Buffet
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Seating
Accepts Credit Cards
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Cute little cafe in town. Waitress was pleasant and food came out quickly. I got the breakfast burrito and my husband got eggs. My burrito and the..."
Mary Jane Swift
"The staff was friendly, the food was AMAZING! The Buffalo burger was cooked to PERFECTION, it wasn't dry like most places. The strawberry rhubarb pie..."
Anastasia Marie
"We found the Hill City Cafe after riding the 1880 train. Delicious French Dip sandwich, onion rings , and vegetable soup.brought shortly after..."
Jamie Wagner
"Saturday morning buffet at 0600. Pleasant ebullient staff. One spontaneously will play guitar and sing in between being pleasantly attentive to..."
Tom Maley
"The hot beef was wonderful. Fast service, the server was extremely attentive and helpful. The price was right. Was definitely satisfied. Another Hill..."
Dyana Miller
"Our server, Crystal took excellent care of us. Hill City had the Wine, Brew, & BBQ festival going on and all the restaurants were very busy and..."
Heidi Nelson
Slate Creek Grille
Slate Creek Grille
70/100 (1041 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Dinner
Breakfast
Lunch
Late Night
Wings
Chili
Fish & Chips
Ribs
French Fries
Sandwiches
Toasts
Burger
Omelette
Chicken Sandwich
Hamburgers
Meatballs
Osso Buco
Chicken fried steak
Tilapia
Shrimp
Beef
Pancakes
Salad
"This is an OK restaurant working to up it's game it feels. We'd eaten here a few years ago. It's consistently moderate in quality and pricing. I do..."
Mary Gail Hammock
"Service just a little slow but good was very good. Worth the..."
Pat Fengler
"Services was great, friendly!! Food was great!! Laredo burger was..."
Bc4austin
"Excellent buffalo burgers, served with homemade soup, marinated vegetables, or grilled potatoes & onions. Very friendly staff. Definitely will be..."
Diana Sullivan
"As typical as it..."
Peter Zurawski
"SCG was a really nice place for a sit down meal! They have a variety of good food options and also some deals/specials everyday! Service was very..."
Glen Morris
"Hill city is so wonderful all year round. This is a cozy place with great prices and awesome quality food. I suggest you try one of those cinnamon..."
Charles Kent
"The buffalo elk burger was really good and generous portion of fries at a reasonable price. Lodge..."
TimH
"Great food, good service - home-cooked taste with a comfort food feel! We ate here twice this last week, once for breakfast and the other for dinner...."
Christy Beving
"The food was amazing. We had the fried dill pickle spears. Just the right amount of well seasoned breading. I had the chicken fried steak. Fork..."
Peggy Medema
"The onions rings here are incredible! I got the bison burger, which was delicious as well. Service was great, the building was very clean. I ate here..."
Maggie Awe