Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Hilliard
20 restaurant menus in Hilliard, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Grateful for Liz and her friendly severe....................................... zzzzzzz................... Great food ....................."
Tod_Skylark
"Absolute YUM!. As soon as you walk in, the owner makes you feel at home! Liz is a wonderful person to know, she runs the place by herself. Service..."
Jenny
"We just got a pizza there because of a post on NextDoor and it did NOT disappoint! The pizza we got was chicken/jalapeño/tomato on one side,..."
Erika Lena Boothman
"This place is One of a Kind. Looks like a small house converted into a small bar/pizza joint on a back residential street in Hillard.
Very relaxed,..."
J W
"Such a fun place, here they are closing. Sad. Great food. One of those off the beaten path places, with a long history. Sad to see it..."
Beth Cotterill
"Fist time here and the food is amazing! All Homemade and Liz is the most sweetest woman I have met in a long time! Definitely recommend if you want a..."
Chase Carter
"The pizza crust is unlike any other Mexican pizza is..."
Anette Koester
"Got pizza here and it was freaking delicious. Not to mention the owner was friendly and hilarious. Highly..."
Michael McGovern
"Very cozy environment with a small town feel. Liz made us feel very welcome and the food was..."
Kaylea Frye
"This gem in downtown Hilliard is tough to find but worth stopping by. It's run by the nicest lady I've ever met. She'll make you feel right at home...."
"a huge shout out to Flyers Pizza (Top Flight Catering) for the hot, delicious, fresh food they delivered tonight for our AMMO car club meet & greet!..."
Rayna Morgan
"I love having Flyers delivered to me at work! The food is sooo good and my pizza is always hot - quicker than ANY other place in town! Flyers is THE..."
Mel Gee
"My husband and I got "The Bomber" and it was AMAZING! You should definitely check this place out if you love good pizza with fresh and delicious..."
Jennifer Murrah
"We LOVE Flyers Pizza! Great food, fast service - and they will draw fun things inside the lid if you ask! We got Link and Snagglepuss!..."
Brian Huhman
"I've only ever got the pizza, but this place never disappoints. One of my kids favorites since moving to Hilliard. Their sauce and crust is simply..."
Jimmy-banger
"Great Pizza, but.... We ordered a pizza and chicken tenders for delivery at the hotel we were staying at after waiting an hour we called back an..."
Br80
"Ggggrrrreeeaaatttt. I've been a customer of Flyers since they opened in West Jefferson when it was called Tonni's and there is no better pizza in the..."
Bev Loughridge
"Best pizza place hands down for the past 25 years. Stopped eating gluten about 4 months ago. Being able to have Flyers pizza still is amazing and..."
Greg Sheriff
"Dang it!!!! I'm upset, that we don't have a pizza place this good in Texas! This company should definitely come out to dallas or Houston. They would..."
I H
"The food was very good. The pizza was cooked to perfection and the subs were too large to eat in one sitting. The person who took our order was nice..."
Ricky Watts
"Great local chain, I mostly get their subs and strombolis, but everything on the menu has been pretty..."
Miles Heather
"Always fresh an hot! Tastes great! The kids love the mystery..."
David Brown
"Flyers is one of my favorite pizza places, and I eat a fair amount of pizza. They are generous with the cheese and have a thick, delicious crust. ..."
"We had the sampler tonight. Three beautiful 7" pizzas. Gourmet, Buffalo Chicken and Tater Tot. All were excellent! The Gourmet had fresh Ohio..."
Tina Tomblin
"I love this place!! There pizza is the best!! I my favorite is the gourmet pizza. The staff was very nice and welcoming. Our waitress was great,her..."
Elde'a Harris
"Great service! Delicious pizza! Would highly recommend Grandad’s in..."
Jane Marine Miller
"Picked up a pizza tonight and it was excellent. Got to the locations a few minutes early and bartender offered beer and a conversation. Pizza came..."
Shane Philabaum
"We love their garlic Parmesan wings and also had a tator tot pizza and bacon cheeseburger pizza (it really tasted like a bacon cheeseburger). Will..."
Tracy Petrosky Marotta
"We eat there at least once a week.
Best pizza ever! Great subs, Greek salad and a waite staff that is well beyond wonderful.
If you don't go, you'll..."
Jeff Collins
"Outstanding Pizza! Service was good!! I'd HIGHLY recommend the Scottish Eggs as an appetizer. Sorry, but the 4 star (instead of 5) was because the..."
Cefcef Cefcef
"First time we came here is was great! The second time it was even better. This time we ordered two just so we could have lunch the next day! If..."
Matt Langford
"I'm super impressed at how good this place is. Their regular pizza has thin crust, which is great! And their pepperoni is crips and spicy. The side..."
Stephanie Antonazzo
"I've ordered pizza and subs from here in the past years. Can't remember ever being mad at my order.. And based on the pizza I just got, accurate..."
Joshua Thomas
"Understated yet delicious. :) The chesse bread was light and flavorful, perhaps my favorite version of! The loaded tots were crispy and not so..."
Nick Albright
"Scotch eggs were awesome and the thin crust pizza, which is their standard, was excellent. It's very family friendly even though there's a bar..."
"Their pizza is one of a kind. The crust is homemade and the cheese is always fresh. But the best part of the pizza is the cold cheese on top. It..."
Laura Segraves
"Grown up eating this pizza from Steubenville area for 40+ years and so geeked to see it in Central Ohio. This is pizza at its finest! Great crust..."
David Gross
"Dicarlos pizza is a wonderful experience. The crust is amazing, sauce is superb, and the cold smoked provolone topped on that hot steaming crust is..."
Josh Sperling
"I've been going to this location for years. Always great service, lady is so friendly. Sometimes a little busy but i dont mind worth the wait. Pizza..."
Colleen Smith
"No frills pizza, crunchy but not thin, with cold mozzarella cheese sold in bags to add on top. A very unique and delicious experience. Definitely..."
Ryan Finke
"Interesting pizza. Not my favorite but it's still pretty tasty. I have nothing to compare it to because its got something special all of its own...."
Jessica A
"Nestled right next to a Sunoco off of Main St. in Hilliard, this is a unique style of pizza for the area. Apparently it's Ohio Valley/Steubenville..."
Colin Flack
"Amazing pizza for takeout. Very cheesy but not overpowering. Relatively thin crust. Could easily crush an entire pizza or two..."
"When I come back to Hilliard from California, without fail I get a Luigi’s pizza.
Double Pepperoni/Double Cheese it’s always fantastic.
You..."
Scott Ackerson
"The new ownership has taken Luigi's back to what made it great! The sauce is definitely boss..."
Brian Penzone
"One of the best tasting pizza I've had locally in..."
Ashley Wright
"This was our first time to Luigi Pizza and I must say it was very good. We ordered an XL Deluxe pizza and 6 bread sticks. I'm not sure if the bread..."
Wildcards Rex
"The Antipasta salad is amazing and the double Italian sub is ginormous!
My go to..."
"Tasty pizza and it was done very fast! Nice staff and cute location. They have a great variety of pizza toppings, and good..."
Joleene Naylor
"I get my lunch here at least weekly and thoroughly enjoy it every time. I've tried several of their pizzas and have to say my favorite is the basil..."
daija yarber
"Stopped by whilst in the area and purchased a taco pizza and a custom pizza. The service was quick, courteous, and friendly with the prices being..."
David Mays
"Had a good experience pizza was delicious I loved all the options for toppings... could use another worker over the lunch..."
Rodney Miller
"Super tasty. I'm a fan of the crispy crust. I don't drink soda, but they have a Pepsi Spire here which is..."
"Just like it should be!. Our family eats here at least twice a month since it's opening, and have been peased each visit. The staff have always been..."
Mick Sherry
"Amazing! Just like home!. Don't let some reviews fool you...the cheese is SUPPOSED to be added after the pizza is cooked. It is the "Ohio Valley"..."
Tricia Chesney
"I'm from the Ohio valley where square pizza shops outnumber churches and gas stations. Needless to say, this place rocks, love the pizza and the..."
Dustin Reynolds
"Their pizza is one of a kind. The crust is homemade and the cheese is always fresh. But the best part of the pizza is the cold cheese on top. It..."
Laura Segraves
"Grown up eating this pizza from Steubenville area for 40+ years and so geeked to see it in Central Ohio. This is pizza at its finest! Great crust..."
David Gross
"Dicarlos pizza is a wonderful experience. The crust is amazing, sauce is superb, and the cold smoked provolone topped on that hot steaming crust is..."
Josh Sperling
"I've been going to this location for years. Always great service, lady is so friendly. Sometimes a little busy but i dont mind worth the wait. Pizza..."
Colleen Smith
"No frills pizza, crunchy but not thin, with cold mozzarella cheese sold in bags to add on top. A very unique and delicious experience. Definitely..."
Ryan Finke
"Interesting pizza. Not my favorite but it's still pretty tasty. I have nothing to compare it to because its got something special all of its own...."
Jessica A
"Nestled right next to a Sunoco off of Main St. in Hilliard, this is a unique style of pizza for the area. Apparently it's Ohio Valley/Steubenville..."
Colin Flack
"Amazing pizza for takeout. Very cheesy but not overpowering. Relatively thin crust. Could easily crush an entire pizza or two..."
"Food is super good and the store.personnel are super friendly. Great..."
Don Boerner
"Pretty decent chain pizza. Love the kickin sauce. Designed for wings, but great to dip pizza. Calzones are very flavorful. This place has a special..."
Jeppy Li
"Favorite place to eat with amazing service. The owners son joe is very helpful and did a great job on my large pepperoni pizza. The family that owns..."
Lauren Pfeiffer
"Ordered for the first time tonight. Awesome pizza. The sauce on the Pizza is fantastic. Great taste. We've lived in the area now for over a year and..."
Michael Ritchie
"We LOVE their pizza! The service is great too. Tonight there was a mistake with my order that was perhaps my fault but they corrected it and brought..."
Brooke Finlay
"Just took a bite of my first Cottage Inn pizza. Delivery was on time, driver was friendly, priced right and taste great!..."
Andrew Weber
"It's really nice pizzeria at nice location. They have very good variety for pizzas, subs and salads. They have seperate vegetarian menu which is..."
Gaurav Shah
"The service is amazing here! We order from this location a couple times a month and everyone there is always very friendly. The food is consistently..."
"Delicious Detroit style pizza. Highly recommend extra sauce for the whole experience. They even have their take on NY Style which is pretty good...."
Rick Hensley
"Detroit pizza is the absolute best, and Jet's makes it great. However, sometimes, they sell you rewarmed slices, which have been totally dried out,..."
Dara Tarolli
"Stopped by to eat my feelings today after a tough day at work. Did not disappoint. 10/10..."
Melissa Terry
"Excellent thick crust pizza. Bakery style or whatever it's called. Also has really good cheesy bread. Staff always super..."
Kody Robertson
"One of the best pizza places in hilliard . Friendly staff and good food..."
"Just tried the stuffed crust pizza - awesome! Salad was fresh and garlic bread was..."
Ginger Kittinger Byers
"Food so good it stained my favorite shirt! Romeo’s Pizza hands down have the best pizza and calzones. Paired with their famous Capone sauce, eating..."
"First time there and it was really good. My husband had the lasagna and I the original beer barrel pizza. Our waiter was ex excellent. We’ll be..."
Robin Reid-Towler Bennett
"We eat here about once every few weeks and love it. Never had a bad meal or bad service. Pizza is excellent (cauliflower crust is awesome) as well..."
Becky Heineman
"Man, had a great server....loved the design and atmosphere of the building..but it was low 40s wish they would of had that neato fire place on..."
Amber Kleoudis
"Aside from my mother's the best lasagna I've ever had. We love everything we've had here and amazing..."
Paula Basham Pereira
"Awesome food, friendly staff and our waitress was a great. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re up that..."
Tonia Schuttinger
"Amazing band The Beer Barrel Boys, server was amazing and the food was..."
Adriann Patterson Brown
"Was showed to a booth and I've been here for 30 minutes without even so much a word on what I'd like to drink. Would just walk out but I've already..."
Joshua Adams
"We had a great time here! The service was great as was the food. We loved having the tabletop s’mores for the kiddos (as well as the adults...."
Aubrey Wade
"Came here for the first time tonight and it was great! We were initially told our wait time was going to be 30 minutes, which was fine, but then they..."
David Lashock Jr.
"First time visiting and loved the atmosphere. Drinks are off the chain, appetizers too. We had pretzels and spinach artichoke dip. The French onion..."
April Burcham
"Had a great dinner here! Service was outstanding and drinks were reasonably priced and delicious. I had the Bloody Mary and would say it is one of..."
Jessica
"I want one of these near me! The food was delicious, the service was great, and the atmosphere was fantastic! Great find by my son for a place to..."
Rich A
"Great place to eat. Sydnie was our waitress and she was awesome! Never had to ask for drink refills, she had them before we could ask. That's..."
"So good. I swore off of Donatos for almost 10 years because so many of the franchises cannot seem to follow the guidelines of what makes this Pizza..."
Brandon Carothers
"Awesome in every..."
Jim Tillery
"Pretty decent pizza, but the famously thin isn't all so thin..., in my opinion. The cheese is super GOOEY and yummy. I also loved the robust taste of..."
Jenny Wright
"I've never had one of their pizzas but I have had their subs and they are..."
Carolyn Narramore
"Thin crust pizza that's always very good. I usually go with the founders favorite. Pep, Sausage, Ham and Banana Peppers. Always good customer..."
Kody Robertson
"First: The young lady at the window provided excellent service! Kudos to her ( she was working the window on 8/19, maybe around 5pm),I hope she gets..."
"For a special treat tonight we stopped off at the Hilliard Pizza Hut on cemetery road and it was awesome as always.
No I see that some of the star..."
J Carder (Mr Manager)
"I must say it's been awhile. I kind of fell off of the PizzaHut chain for years ago and decided to re visit and it was amazing I don't know if..."
Michael Daniels
"I have ordered from this store for several years. As much as I would like to say everything has always been perfect, but I can't. What I can say..."
"Deliciousness!! I wish Wichita KS had one!
Ordered the Big Don and hubby pepperoni..."
Michelle Neufeldt Oliphant
"Love..."
Guy Ruwe
"I havent ordered fron donatos in a long time. I did today for lunch .i have to say im glad i did. My food was fresh and delicious. My order was also..."
Becky Leonard
"OMG 😃👍🏽👍🏽 Two Thumbs Up. Fantastic 😋💕👋🏽👋🏽💯💯 I was craving and was oh!, so satisfied. Love you Donatos 🍕. ..."
Lady V
"My order was ahead of time and delicious. I feel for anyone that works short handed. My experience here my last few pick ups have been great. ..."
"The order was perfect, delivered quickly and still nice & hot. And my pizza was made exactly how I special ordered it, which never happens for me...."
kELLY tOMPKINS
"Always arrives super fast and hot and delicious! A favorite, even with the many options in the city I always come back to this dominos..."
Whitney Schroeder
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes