Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Hilton Head
21 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"We had the veal and fettuccine Alfredo, my husband loves veal, has had it from many different places, and says this was the best he's ever had! The..."
Katie Easler
"For over a decade this restaurant has been a family favorite. The owners remember us every year and always make a point to spend some time. This is..."
joseph gregory
"Great Italian food. Owners are very friendly and work hard in their restaurant. Native animals come out after dark to dine with you on the other..."
Jay M
"Our second visit, this time better than last year's! We called ahead for three of us, and got a spot in the side room with the windows. Glad we did,..."
Amy Little
"Got take out this time. Rigatoni Bolognese was a 10 out of 10!
Have eaten there in the past. Food is delicious. It's a welcoming place and at night..."
Phil Catania
"The aroma entering this restaurant had me at the door! Came for the early bird. Mussels marinara..that marinara sauce…yummy. Very simple green..."
Todd Nolan
"Service was great. My husband had the mussels for appetizer and I had the fried artichoke hearts. They were both delicious. The salads were great, so..."
Terrie Perdue
"The veal I had was delicious. Best thing I had at Hilton Head. I give food a 5. My wife's Alfredo was just average though. So I averaged it to a..."
Ricky Payne
"We ordered a catering take out last week for a birthday party we had while on the island. I ordered for 30 people, we ended up having close to 40..."
Cathy Chendraj
"Quaint little Italian restaurant in Hilton Head. Get a table in the patio by the window to see the deer and raccoons munch on their evening meal —..."
Hector Guerrero
"The gnocchi in tomato cream sauce was fantastic! Our server, Mark, was friendly and efficient. My husband’s red snapper special in lemon Sherry..."
Angel Fisher
"Probably the best meal I had while visiting. And it was their early bird, which is an incredible value. Appetizer, salad, entrée, and a glass of..."
Ryan F
"I thought my meal was pretty decent (veal saltimboca), although the others I was with did not enjoy their meal. My desert was the cannoli which was..."
Doug Kahn
"Absoulte FAVORITE restaurant in Hilton Head! Mark, our waiter, that we luckily get every year is PHENOMENAL!! Food is amazing, service is amazing,..."
Jenna DiMestico
"I would be exceedingly surprised if there is a better early bird dinner anywhere. There are plenty of options, and the food and service are top..."
Barbara Brown
"OUTSTANDING IN EVERY WAY! ATMOSPHERE WAS GREAT ALONG WITH SERVICE & THE ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS, PLENTIFUL FOOD! Highly recommend for a quiet evening..."
Christine Williams
"Our first experience at Stellini’s was delicious! The service and food was excellent. We didn’t make reservations and they was able to seat us..."
Hunter Morrell
"Finished out our week on the island with some excellent Italian food! We each got a pasta dish (which come with side salads) and some garlic bread to..."
"Two for two! Prime rib last week was one of the best I’ve ever had. Tonight I had the hanger steak and she had a chicken penne pasta both were..."
Paul C. Godbout
"We found a real gemstone, today, when we dined at Frankie Bones Restaurant on HHI. The menu was so fabulous, it was hard to make a decision. I had..."
Sharon Buzon
"First-time patrons. Got fabulous reviews from friends at work, thought we'd try it out. Started with Sunday brunch. Great food and experience. Will..."
Grant Stange
"Amazing early bird until 530 with many $15-16 menu selections which also includes drink! $2.75 a glass wine selections as well! Amazing food and..."
Mike McClure
"Never disappoints! A shining diamond 💎 in the Serg Restaurant’s group of restaurants. Make it a point to dine here while enjoying beautiful..."
Cinthia Hanna-Kerstein
"Stopped in to have lunch at the bar. Tyler was working and was excellent as always! I had the twice baked spring rolls which are hands down one of my..."
Lindsay Schumpert
"This restaurant is first class! Service is great and the food is unbelievable. I would highly recommend the mussels and the butterfinger..."
Michelle Sacco-Ridgway
"We had the calamari, potato spring rolls, hot spinach and artichoke dip, and chicken Alfredo, everything was delicious, our server was amazing and..."
Abigail Rasmussen
"We love this place we drive to Hilton Head area just for this restaurant 😍😍 Food is amazing I always getting the chicken Alfredo and the..."
Coreyand Michelle Weedman
"It is a really cute restaurant with excellent food and staff. I have been telling everyone about my amazing experience. I definitely will be..."
Courtney Hayes Thompson
"Ordered the salmon with crabmeat & it was delicious! The bread & butter was the best too. Service was..."
Donna Liss Mallinger
"Excellent food & Service! Joanne was a great waitress & surprised us with a delicious dessert- cheesecake!The ambience here was..."
Helen Hill-Fields
"We came for our visit here and we had great service. Made reservations and were seated immediately. The décor is gorgeous. This upscale restaurant..."
Kemoshire
"Everything was fantastic. Our waitress (maybe her name was Macey or Kacey or Dayce) was wonderful. We let her pick everything we ate and she did..."
Kevin Leslie
"Absolutely fantastic meal. Filets perfectly cooked. Lobster tail was amazing. Lobster mac and cheese was awesome. But the jackpot mixed grill is..."
C E
"Such a cool spot this is with the old-school vibes. The food is delicious and is always consistently so. The service is very attentive; they are..."
AXRvibes
"Thanks to awesome reviews, we had Frankie Bones on our list and it didn’t disappoint. Calamari was on point. On the daily specials I had Seared..."
E Blckwl
"Vegas vibe restaurant! We came in late and we’re seated right away. They have a big food and drink menu so there’s something for everyone. We..."
Andrew Kaylor
"Frankie Bones is one of my favorite restaurants in Hilton Head, and that’s really saying something because HHI has a lot of really good food...."
Zane Maguet
"Great atmosphere, definitely make a reservation because it gets busy quickly. Jackpot mixed grill is a must. Butterfinger crunch cake was the best..."
Daniel Wei
"We had a nice dinner at Frankie Bones. We sat outside in the covered area and the temperature was quite nice. The servers were quick, efficient, and..."
Patrick Davis
"Everything was outstanding. The food was delicious. The staff was excellent. The atmosphere was great! The booths were very comfortable and provided..."
Terri Coomer
"Kids wanted meatballs. Wife googled searched for spaghetti and meatballs near us. Wow. Some of the best prime rib we’ve had in a long time. The..."
Jake Gordon
"BEST steak you will find in Hilton Head SC! Rib eye coffee marinated! GO now!, you will not regret it!. Caesar salad was fresh, you can clearly tell..."
Patricia Tilus
"Well, well....I came to this restaurant with high expectations (we drove almost 1 hour to get here) and I have the pleasure to tell you....that you..."
Barbara Bordogna Andreassi
"We went here with a group of 6 people and had a fantastic meal. I had the spaghetti and sausage and it was fantastic. The sausage had a nice even..."
Mark Boehmer
"Fun casual restaurant with an extensive menu! The martinis were fantastic but unfortunately the veal ravioli special I had tasted like a dressed up..."
Josh Jones
"The atmosphere is very unique, and the restaurant itself is very beautiful. The food was excellent as well. The service, though was very poor. The..."
Ruth Nyce
"We had Thanksgiving dinner at Frankie’s and it was amazing. The food was absolutely delicious from my turkey to my husbands pork chop to the..."
Emma Jarvis
"As I’ve read prior reviews I’ve noticed people complaining about the staff. When I entered the restaurant I was greeted with Warm smiles and was..."
debby timko
"Very good dining experience. Only minor negative was the server smelled like he was smoking between visits to our table. The guy reeked of cigarette..."
"This was such a treat to end our stay in Hilton Head. From the minute I made my reservation till we left we were showered with smiles, and that great..."
Rolando Otero
"Came for an early dinner and asked the server for recommendations. Without hesitation, he indicated the Chicken Parmigiano. The warm bread was very..."
Terry Guers
"On my recent trip to Hilton Head Island, I discovered Gusto Ristorante and it was amazing. The dishes were so authentic, it felt like a culinary..."
Cindy Orley
"May B is possibly the best server I’ve had in my dining life. The perfect balance of professional and personal, checks in regularly but not too..."
Chris Sweeney
"Came in tonight for dinner, the three entrees ordered were delicious and pretty good portion, personally my girlfriend lucked out by ordering the..."
Leon Skipsky
"First time visiting Hilton Head . We where greeted so nicely. We didn’t have reservations but they fit us in . The Server Jasmine was awesome..."
John C
"Wow! Amazing authentic Italian cuisine- complete with ambiance and our fantastic Sicilian waiter. The Shrimp pasta dish (wish I could remember its..."
Beth Daghfal
"Food was delicious! Jasmine was a great server and took great care of us. Really recommend the caprese, it was so..."
Ashlan Yeros
"Gusto is a 5 star experience every time we go. The atmosphere is great, the food is delicious and you can’t beat the service. We like to sit with..."
Rachel (Freedenberg) Meers
"We had a very nice meal with good service. The place was not very busy when we arrived for our reservation, but it did become packed by the time we..."
Debbie S
"Needed a place for 16 people - called and they were very accommodating. The service, food and reception was amazing. Never been there before so I was..."
Diane Toto
"I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant! We went here with a group of 6 on a Bachelorette trip because the bride's favorite food is..."
Ashlynn Stephenson
"Great food and drink! Great service too!! Try the Spaghetti Carbonara. You won’t regret..."
Michael Dragone
"Our experience was absolutely fantastic. Ashley was a wonderful waitress. So pleasant and took great care of us. I had the caprese salad and the veal..."
Seth Nelson
"Hands down, the best Italian food on Hilton Head Island. Our family had dinner at Gusto on the last night of our week long vacation and it was the..."
Lou Colella
"My wife and I visited Gusto Ristorante for dinner. We had read the reviews and decided this would be a great Italian venue for our date. Upon our..."
joseph cascio
"Ossobuco was creatively cooked, delicious. The Chef deserves two thumbs up. Includes vegetables (carrots and zucchini) and mashed potatoes.
Chocolate..."
Robert T
"Quite possibly the best dining experience on the island! The food was insanely tasty and the service was incredible. We were warmly greeted by Mario..."
"Good pizza, good service and cold beer. Need I say more...ok I will. Great casual place to grab some NY style pizza after a hot day out at the beach...."
Lindsey Anthony
"There are certain things people do before running a half marathon, and one of those things is to carbo load the night before. We were preparing for..."
The Hungry Sprout
"Most incredible pizza, ever! We ordered the pepperoni, garlic, and basil pizza. Had enough to take back to our condo and devoured the rest..."
Stephenie Griffith
"Finally!!! I found a pizza on this island that I actually want to eat. The Py Pie is spot on for flavor and crust quality. Fresh garlic and basil..."
Josh
"I'd have to say that this was what I was looking forward to most on the island. The pizza is some of the best anywhere, and the subs are loaded with..."
Jiries Dawaher
"Had a margharita pizza and a sausage pizza tonight. Really good. Thin crust, not too crispy. Right amount of sauce. Great taste. Wicked..."
Mark
"Good Pizza. Tried several pizza's while in the area and this was our favorite. Super nice staff and great..."
Matt Lucas
"We got the pms pizza and garlic cheesy bread and enjoyed it! The sausage is huge slices which was delicious. Pizza was really greesy but that's to be..."
Sarah Thoma
"The spinach and shroom slice was great. A couple beers and good company from Dave, the maker if my..."
Rachael
"A real surprise!. This was a great pizza. We ordered the PMS pizza and it was awesome! Will definitely come here..."
Steve Edrington
"A consistently good pie with high-quality fresh..."
Leo Shock
"Great calzones! Wish we loved in town, we would eat here all the time. Dave is great..."
MST0308
"Awesome pizza! Reminds me of the pizza place I love at the beach in Maryland! Perfect for lunch at the beach! Greek salad and dressing was..."
Rebecca Ramia
"Yummy!. One of the best pizzas on the island and beyond. Caesar salad is great too! The dining room is a little toasty, that would be my only..."
Hhipets
"Great pizza and subs. Zero atmosphere! Friendly staff! A hidden pizza..."
Tobermori
"FABULOUS!!!. Can't get enough of the Caesar salad, lasagna, pizza, and soooo much more!!! LOVE this place! An islander's favorite!! Don't miss..."
Anne
"Besides their delicious pizza, we can never dine there without also having their delicious greek salad and mouth-watering toasted Fat Babies..."
ChampagneToast
"This place was good but not great. We really enjoyed the pizza. The garlic cheese bread was over cooked and average tasting. My younger so ordered..."
Michelle
"Best Pizza/subs in HHI. Fat Babies has quickly become a favorite spot to meet up with friends and share a pizza. The crust is so excellent in fact..."
Andy
"Great subs. Very good bbq chicken calzone. The cheesecake cupcake desert is to die for. Will eat there..."
Muadib395
"Loved, loved, loved the pizza. Extra cheese was actually extra cheese. Definitely will visit when I'm in the area again. The service was great and..."
Kathy Parker
"We didn’t eat in so can’t really rate the atmosphere but the pizza and mozzarella “balls” we really good. The mozzarella tasted homemade and..."
Wesley White
"We came here because one of our friends referred us. We are from Kansas City and when we walked in around 2 PM nobody was in the place except for 2..."
Steven Foster
"We had a short wait for a table, but our server, Amanda was very good. She was quick to greet us, bring our drinks, and put in our order. She was..."
Kristina Villella
"We struggled with finding a place for dinner as we have had lackluster meals on vacation. We finally settled here because pizza sounded good and the..."
Lindsay Bernardi
"Their brushettas are phenomenal! We also tried the subs, chicken strips and pastas - all were..."
Brandi McSheffrey
"Great spot for the whole family. In Hilton Head for the weekend and came for dinner with our two littles and my parents. My husband said his burger..."
Emily MacFarlane
"Winter visitors to the island and we always like to try a new pizza place. Had the Fat Baby dining in and it was delicious. Very flavourful and super..."
Ron Hebert
"Tried the "Fat Baby" sub and a 14" pie with sausage and mushrooms. The food was great with the minor exception that the crust was a little bit..."
Matthew Williams
"The best pizza and salads on Hilton Head! The meatballs are amazing too! Service was top notch! We always go here on our trips to Hilton..."
"The team here made what started as a terrible experience at another restaurant into a phenomenal night out celebrating my sons Marine Graduation. I..."
John Joyner
"This is our favorite restaurant that we go to every year on vacation We go as often as possible, 2 or 3 times every year in the week to 2 weeks we..."
Sheila E
"Quality ingredients, good service, and good prices. This place is a quality Italian restaurant in the Hilton Head Island area. I didn't try their..."
Daniel Boyce
"Terrific place to eat! I ordered the chicken parmigiana, and it was one of the best I’ve ever had. Daniel the waiter was also one of the nicest..."
Frenite
"This is tucked away resturant and is one of the few places open late. Our party got Pasta Anthony, vegetable Lasagna and Raviolli from kids menu. The..."
Padmashree Anand
"Coming into town for the first time and looking for a pizza spot. Luckily ran across Bella with amazing service from Calvin. Simple pizza meal was..."
Kelly Lind -DHS- Charles County
"Fantastic Italian food and pizza. I am a Northern Italian and picky about Italian food in the South. This place nails it! So much flavor in their..."
Matthew Adorni
"Really fun atmosphere with friendly staff. Our food took a while to come out but it was well worth the wait! Football was on the TV so that was a..."
Thomas Brackett III
"Great food and great atmosphere. Would definitely recommend as a got to try it if you are vacationing out in the area. There are some items that are..."
D W
"This was our first trip to Hilton Head. We happened upon this fabulous restaurant while sight-seeing today. Our server was such a gem-I believe his..."
Jada Hanning
"Had the tour of Italy, chicken parmigiana, and pizza. Everything was very good. Simple food with lots of flavor. Waiter and staff were friendly and..."
J H
"wonderful food and service. Ryan was pleasant and attentive. The pizza, drink and dessert were fantastic. We will be back and will recommend to..."
Raymond Cabana
"Servers were very attentive. Salads were good sized. Fried mozzarella sticks were the largest I have ever seen and eaten. The pasta was fresh and..."
Brian Katz
"First time in Hilton Head and this restaurant was fabulous..The wedding soup was delicious n the pizza was definitely up there with New York..We r..."
"BEST food we ever had... We will come here every time we are on the island. I had the wild mushroom filet, out of this world - melt in your mouth -..."
Darcie Onkony
"Been coming back year after year. Always some of the best food on the island. Derik, our server, this time was great! Thanks for the great..."
Greg Shell
"We enjoyed our first meal on the island. The food was delicious and our server Derrick was..."
Lisa Yund Haigh
"Upon walking into this establishment you knew you were in for a treat for very good dining experience! The wait staff (Derek) was very friendly and..."
Cam Evangelisti
"Ate here for the first time. I don't know why we never came before, but we definitely eat here again. I had the pork cordon blue. Fantastic!
Our..."
Jacqueline Sykes Campbell
"Catch 22 is our favorite place to eat when on HHI. Great, friendly staff, great food at good..."
Cookie Carpenter
"The atomsphere is cool, the staff and service was excellent. The food was amazing. The Seafood plates was delicious. The crab cakes were the best..."
Tony TTime Gadson
"Derek was fantastic and very informative about the menu. We had the scallops and grouper, and both were fresh and fantastic. Great service and..."
Melissa Lesieur Monaco
"We make this our traditional final dinner on our last day of vacation. It never fails to surpass our expectations! Great food, drinks and staff...."
Dawn Rodriguez
"Best place ever! Be sure to try the catch of the day - truly is what the local fishermen bring in. My fav is the pork..."
Pam Bautista
"The food was tasty. The owners incredibly warming and friendly. Fun times! Like a little family. For sure to..."
Anissa Stark
"What an amazing dinner! We had the hush puppies and that key lime tartar sauce was SOOOO good. The grilled trio was great, with the duck stealing..."
Jennifer Ly
"I enjoyed Catch 22 for the most part. I ordered the pork shank with scalloped potatoes and asparagus. All tasted great. Our waiter was busy but very..."
Mr Mike
"Had an amazing dinner with my family. Making reservations was very smooth and the location of the restaurant was easy to find. Great food selection..."
Tameika Soumah
"This is one of our favorite restaurants! I normally order the rib-eye but this trip I went in a different direction! I had only tried duck once ever..."
Jonathan Coker
"All of the dishes we tried were excellent! Diver scallops for appetizer, main course was the Beef Tips Au Poivre , the catch of the day over rice and..."
Nina Nikolaev
"Everything you’d want for a great HH dinner! Drinks and food were fabulous and our server Alena was the best. Mussels appetizer is a must, also..."
Gregg Kunes
"A lovely meal in a very nice setting. Chad, the waiter, was off the charts charming. And my Cracked Pepper Tuna was cooked perfectly and delicious...."
Mark Gardner
"Lovely service and the best food we’ve had on the island! We will definitely be coming back next time we’re here.
Save room and get the..."
Laura Sy
"Catch 22 checks a lot of the right boxes. The crab filled hush puppies are a great way to start a meal! Early bird specials were a good value. Our..."
Ron Melcher
"One word "Wow" explains this exquisite fine dining restaurant in Hilton Head Island, SC.
The restaurant may not be very big as far as seating but..."
Jonathan Durichek
"We ate dinner at the bar and Derek did a phenomenal job serving us! He was super friendly and we appreciated his ability to care for all of his..."
Kristina Krutzig
"We had such an amazing time here! Everything was absolutely amazing and the food was so delicious!! Thank you so much to our waiter Derek who made..."
Tatiana Fernandez
"We had the most amazing dinner tonight. Everything was so delicious, and our server was the best. We had the Shrimp & Lobster Stuffed..."
Kathleen Smart
"We enjoyed our time in this more intimate setting where we could actually hear ourselves talking. We ordered the scallops with Shitaki mushroom..."
Becky Ansley
"We went here for our 34th wedding anniversary while on vacation in Hilton Head. Everything was fabulous including our waiter Derrick. I had the best..."
Sharie Moskaluk
"My wife and I came for restaurant week. Our meals were both delicious. My wife had the salmon filet served over a five grain salad topped with an..."
Anthony Klausing
"My wife and I had the most amazing anniversary dinner here. The hostess (who's name I didn't catch) was so nice and accommodating went out of her way..."
Heather Kapfer
"We had a pretty good meal. Far from spectacular, but above average. The hushpuppies are unique and really good. I also had a beefsteak tomato..."
David Jones
"Fantastic dinner food and great service. Got the peel and eat shrimp - it was the best shrimp ever. Mixed grill was fabulous and seared tuna was..."
"We went here during our vacation at Hilton Head, SC. I was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere of this restaurant was suitable for intimate and..."
David Watts
"Great bottle of wine (Chianti), amazing appetizers, wonderful dinner (ordered 3 specials) and delicious dessert (carrot..."
Nicole Smith
"First thing we were asked was did we have a reservation. When we said no and asked if we needed one the woman at the front door said it would be nice..."
Linda Wiggs
"Absolutely exquisite! The best Italian cuisine I have had in a very long time. I would very highly recommend flora's Italian Cafè to all who visit..."
Bill Tiemann
"HIGHLY recommend Flora's. As soon as I walked in the door I felt like family. The entire restaurant has an amazing smell that makes you want to just..."
Jenna Martin
"Flora’s has the best Italian food I’ve ever eaten! The lobster ravioli was divine and the cheesecake was exquisite. I’d recommend this..."
Emma Behrens
"Great food. Great people. Wonderful experience. Starting with the Fried calamari which was delicious and unlike anyway I’ve ever had it. Next was a..."
Stu Snyder
"My wife and I were in town due to my work possibly transferring me to our Savnnah office. After I got back from work, I said let’s get some food...."
Splxty
"This mid island restaurant is fun because it is a personal experience with the owners. The food is wonderful, and they come by the table to be sure..."
Julia Lowe
"Okay, so I have been around A LOT of italian restaurants. And to Italy and have never in America had or been to as authentic as this restaurant my..."
"Absolutely delicious! Halibut and veal specials of the evening were flawless!! We thoroughly enjoyed our meals. Our server was very busy but 'spot..."
Cindy Hayes Glass Kohorst
"We just recently dined at Ombra with friends. We had the best experience starting with our waiter, Ned. He has been there for many years, and he was..."
Denise Finelli Weitz
"We always love to dine at Ombra!. It is, by far, our favorite restaurant. We spend several weeks in Hilton Head every year and it is always a must!..."
Sandi Renzella Battista
"Simply the best all around restaurant on the island. The salmon top with lump crab is delicious, The pickled beet salad is so delightful and fresh. ..."
Joy Morgan Gabriel
"Oh my goodness! What a wonderful meal! Customer service excellent, service excellent, atmosphere Beautiful, meal delicious ,My husband and I..."
Jackie Miles Brown
"This is our favorite restaurant on HILTON HEAD ISLAND. We make this our destination eating spot. We can't miss it! I highly recommend making..."
Anastasia Giannios-Poulos
"We love Ombra because the quality of food and the service has always been the best! Chef Michael understands the importance of food in Italian..."
Natalie Diroma
"Wonderful evening. Top notch service. We were seated immediately for our reservation. Server outstanding. We both selected specials, salmon and..."
Ken Nelson
"One of our favorite places to go on Hilton Head Island. The food is always delicious, the service is top notch (ask for Ned, great waiter!) wonderful..."
Barbara Matousek
"Excellent food and service. Highly recommend the scallops for appetizer. All food was absolutely..."
Melissa N Scott
"Hands down, the best meal and best service during our stay on HHI. Will definitely be back during our next..."
Melissa Hurn Adamson
"The absolute total experience of an Italian meal and the feel of being in Tuscany Italy. Great attentive staff especially the manager..."
Stefanie Szittai Burns
"This was our first visit to Ombra and it won't be our last. We had the early bird dinner and the selection was excellent. Our waiter was Anthony and..."
Joyce Farrell
"Outstanding ambiance. Service was exceptional. The wine list and food quality was top notch. Best meal we had on..."
Tammy Johnson
"OMG! The food is soooo good and the service is top notch. Our server was very attentive and personal. She even brought us complementary limoncello..."
Heather Santos
"This was a lovely intimate and charming Italian Bistro. It would make for a romantic night out or a special celebration. The food is excellent and..."
Wanderers Compass Travel Blog
"My husband and I started with their delicious caprese salad, thick slices of form sweet tomatoes topped with fresh mozzarella, the plate was..."
Leslie Morin
"Ordered from early dining menu and had a fabulous dinner. The servings were ample and well presented. Absolutely delicious. Our server Matt was..."
Lea Higgins
"Excellent! The food, the atmosphere and especially the service. Worthy of a 5-star review, for sure.
Our family went with a large group of 7 so we..."
Lauren Accurso
"I have had Italian meals all over this country including being raised at the table of an Italian mother and grandmother. This meal tonight was a top..."
Joseph Fazalare
"After a few nights of southern food in Hilton Head, Ombra Cucina Italiana was a welcomed delight. Our kids split a plain spaghetti and we all shared..."
Brooks Perry
"Husband, sister and I had dinner and drinks. Food was excellent, drinks perfection, and service was superb. Highly recommend. Brian was our..."
Jean Mango
"Outstanding! Had dinner here with a large group and we all can't stop raving about the food and service! Whether it was the branzino, the pasta, or..."
Michael Patterson
"The Bronzini special was incredibly delicious. My duck breast, unfortunately, was undercooked and the red current reduction bland. We love Ombra and..."
Dennis Smith
"This is the absolute best Italian food around. Fresh pasta is light and delicate. We got the scallops which were the bomb! The mussels - delicious...."
Denice Kaus
"Ombra Italiana is an incredible restaurant from start to finish. The hostess was kind and engaging; befriending our young daughter and making her..."
W David Stevenson
"Love, love, love!!! The food is exceptional and the service is amazing! From the time we are greeted, seated, order’s taken, food delivered and..."
Tammy Yousif
"From appetizers to desserts, Ombra Cucins Italiana never disappoints! Yesterday, Branden provided the best service, and of o course, our meal was..."
Winnie Scalora
"Excellent food for a special meal while on vacation. The halibut was excellent. The sauce had great flavor (buttery, light on lemon) but the real..."
"Attended the cooking demo class today..2nd one I have attended and it's nothing short if fabulous. Chef Trey and his staff do an outstanding job of..."
Sherri Lynn
"Our first visit to Michael Anthony’s Cucina Italiano was superb. We had a reservation for the bar and the head bartender was a terrific host. We..."
Kevin N
"It was a wonderful experience at Michael Anthony's! We celebrated a birthday and they did a great job recognizing us when we checked in and there was..."
Michael Haughney
"We had the pleasure of dining here this past Friday evening. From 5PM to 5:45 they offer a “Sipes & Bites” (Reservation Suggested) offering. You..."
Mark Toto
"It's a bit pricey, but the food and the service is exquisite! We were seated in the 2nd floor dining area, which is almost like private dining. Our..."
Pat Turocy
"The food was amazing and the staff were professional and fast. The best Italian food I have ever..."
Colton Jarrett
"Our server Ellie was so lovely! She made us feel so welcome and at ease with her excellent service and warm approach. We thoroughly enjoyed our..."
Brianna Morel
"One of the best meals I've had in a very long time. We had a special Chef's Pairing dinner, and it superceded ALL expectations. From the first step..."
Joann “Neyra” Ren
"Amazing!! Great food and outstanding service. This restaurant could be one of the best in Hilton Head, easily. Their staff is so friendly and so..."
Alejandro Fernandez
"Amazing experience. Our server was attentive and gave great suggestions. Ordered the calamari to start and it was delicious. I ordered the scallops..."
"Excellent food, service, and atmosphere.
The pizza was phenomenal - excellent crispy, flaky, and flavorful crust, and perfectly cooked.
Our server,..."
Jeb Stewart
"I have been coming to Hilton Head Island with my family for over 20 years. On our arrival day, we always grab something quick. I wanted to try a new..."
Christy M
"This place was hopping on a Sunday night but everything was well executed. Cheerful staff that seated us quickly, brought us drinks, brought the..."
Mamatha A.
"We ordered a Mediterranean salad and a Little Bear pizza, they didn't disappoint they both were outstanding! The place was not very busy at 7pm on a..."
Rhesus72
"Had a great meal. Super family-friendly -- dough balls for the kids were a nice touch -- and delicious pizzas and apps. Nice craft beer selection,..."
Josh DeVine
"Excellent little pizza shop here on HHI. Get the knots and whatever pizza you like. Good beer available also so try something new.
Great wait staff..."
Philip Sandell
"One of my favorite pizza places ever! It's just really, really good pizza! The crust is thin and perfectly..."
JD Hernandez
"Their woodfire pizza was delicious but the menu topping options are limited, we wanted Pineapple and Shrimp, which they don't carry. The order came..."
K.R. Johnson
"1st time and we took it to go. This pizza was very good awesome..."
jose alban
"Staff was superb from the host who hustled to get a table cleaned so we could be seated quickly and our server, Raegan, who was extremely attentive..."
Susan Elias-White
"Was expecting better based on all the following reviews, the pizza was mediocre and very expensive. The center of the pizza was soggy and you had to..."
Claus Dieners
"Ordered take-out from here in 2022 and it was so good we dedicated a night out to it in 2023, and then take-out again later in the week. The deck..."
Breezy
"• Excellent customer service 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
• They bring out actual dough for the kids to play with which was so cool to me (along with..."
Mommie & E
"Best pizza on HHI. Wood fired with care and they have the top selections of craft..."
Baird Worley
"Efficient, friendly service (thank you Luka et al). Pizza and Caesar salad were fantastic. Chewy, perfect crust with excellent sausage (1/2) and..."
Linda H
"Their pizzas are really nice and well done. Also have a great selection of beers. The staff is also friendly. Taste best when dined..."
srikant lakshminarayan
"This place was wonderful with great food and friendly staff! Great aesthetic with lots of reclaimed wood used to make lighting, tables, etc. The..."
"The food here is pretty good I had the lasagna and the brownie for dessert. Our server was so patient while we decided on what to order...."
D LUCAS
"No doubt the foods here are very very good and definitely worth the money! The size is also quite decent.
But make sure that you will need to..."
Lisa Greensboro
"This place absolutely knocked it out of the park for us! It dominated every place we tried this weekend in HH! This is authentic Italian food..."
Jen Walker
"Amazing Italian restaurant in the heart of Hilton Head. Delicious food and great service, we are definitely coming back next time! Make sure you..."
Peter N
"Absolutely 5 stars. Our Last night on the Island after eating fish & seafood all week. Great Italian. Started with Olive Di Casa, Calamari & House..."
Karen C.
"Unbelievably delicious!!! The service was amazing! Staff was very friendly! The restaurant is very quaint and we loved the vibe there! Food was some..."
Kaileigh DeForest
"Good food, good service, but you are sitting on top of each other. The hostess needs a lesson in being..."
Matthew Busanic
"Cute Italian restaurant tucked in at the end of a shopping center. They offer indoor or outdoor seating. They did a great job of using the space to..."
Dacia Zimmer
"Pomodori Italian eatery is truly a hidden gem on Hilton Head Island and one of my favorite restaurants. Located on the south end on New Orleans road...."
Todd Oomens
"1st time there.
Birthday dinner w my wife.
The food is exceptional.
I had the short rib ragout w homemade noodles...."
Brian O'Neill
"Pomodori was our first choice to celebrate my wife’s 63rd birthday while vacationing in Hilton Head. We called to secure a reservation on November..."
joseph cascio
"The food was simply delicious. We sat in the bar area in the back and received wonderful..."
Bridget B.
"We stopped in for an early dinner. We did not make a reservation, but was seated inside. The bread and oil was great, would be amazing with some..."
jenny buchanan
"Definitely make a reservation for this place! It is so worth it, we were sat on the patio and received excellent service from Lauren. The food came..."
Christian Emery
"We were here last October; came back for July 2021. Hanan served us; we had last minute reservation and was outside at table near entrance but..."
wes wilkins
"Our Italian go to when in Hilton Head. Great food and..."
Mike Warner
"Fantastic food!! I have never had Italian food like this before! The service was excellent, the atmosphere was great, definitely a great spot for a..."
Kristen Jones
"Love , love this place. The food here is so authentic. Coming from the Philly area, the land of awesome Italian food, this place could stand up..."
Tim Beaver
"The service was great. We dined without a reservation, and sat outside. The marinara was amazing. The salad was a little over priced, considering..."
"Great pizza, quick delivery and reasonable prices. The half baked chocolate cookies were so darn good. We are lucky to have so many great pizza..."
Suzanne Milbourn
"First visit to Hilton Head and had a great dining experience at Stoners. Had the Deluxe Jumbo pizza and it was outstanding. Great fresh crust and..."
Charles Holdenried
"Stoners Pizza is excellent! The cheesy bread is delicious!!! I had a traditional "Hawaiian" pizza with ham and pineapple...just the right amount of..."
Jennifer Ashley Hammitt
"Just wanted to give the place a shot and I was totally amazed. The sauce is spot on and the thin crust held up to the breakfast test the next..."
David Roberts
"Great pizza and cheesy bread!! You guys need to open up a store in Ridgeland... wish it wasn't such a long drive for me, but well worth..."
Daniel Connelly
"Just tried for the first time tonight. Excellent crust, taste and service! Will definitely have..."
Maria Katherine
"Just had Stoner's for the first time today and I will definitely be back! The crust was perfect and the cheese/sauce/pepperoni ratio was spot on. I'm..."
Lara Eberly Garniewicz
"We have tried the pizzas, sandwiches, wings, calzones and salads....we have loved..."
Brooke DeAnne
"Great pizza! Fabulous service! We will definitely be..."
Chris Numberger Atlee
"Great pizza! I'll save you some time, right next door to Kenny..."
Barbara Banks Woodbury
"Incredible place. It’s a small pizza joint with big flavor. Lots of specialty pizza options. We also enjoyed the cheese cake Stromboli. Happy faces..."
Alexis Findley
"Ordered pizza on the phone while heading back to our condo after an evening on the beach. Easy to order and pick up was quick! Prices are good. We..."
bethany sweatt
"The best pizza for ever. Good service and great pizza..."
James Cabral
"Good pizza is hard to find but not here. This pizza is amazing. I couldn’t stop eating it once I got it and the brownie and cookie was so good I..."
thecoolistguy330
"We grabbed some pizza the night we arrived in HHI and it was delicious. Honestly when we opened the box we thought it was going to be just ok but it..."
Emma Jarvis
"Pizzas, wings are fantastic. Price is reasonable. Staff friendly, welcoming and food is hot when you pick up. We go every time we visit due to it..."
Tina
"Pros:
1) wait time not too long. Ordered on July 3rd Sunday at 630pm and took about 30 minutes.
2) People there are nice.
3) 2 benches to seat..."
Joon Kim
"The pizza is always amazing. Order extra for left overs the next day! This year we did some chicken wings and they were..."
Andrew Chapman
"Hands down the best pizza we’ve ever had on HHI! The chicken parm pizza is INCREDIBLE. Driver was fast and friendly, as well. We WILL be ordering..."
Rebecca Volpe
"One of the best pizzas I've ever had! Completely different from the norm and soooo good. Cheesecake pizza is the..."
M_A Gavin
"Great pizza and amazing cookies! Our family called around multiple places for pizza and stumbled on Super Baked. Pizza was ready right on time. The..."
Cman
"Fantastic place. Went Christmas Eve when everything on the island was closed. The people who work there, who I suspect is a family, are really nice...."
Will H
"Great place to get quality pizza, wings and salad for a family. Something for everyone. Not too salty pizza toppings. Customer service is 5 stars,..."
Liana Spiegel
"I absolutely love this place hands down the best wings I have ever had! Family has been coming down for the last 4 years now and each year I stop and..."
John Glasby
"We ordered online and went in to pick up. Very happy with the order, nice fresh ingredients and a very tasty crust. Affordable prices..."
Daniel Harris
"Great food and amazing people. I got a free super baked shirt, and a ice cream. By far best pizza in Hilton..."
Sean Jones
"Awesome pizza! We stopped at Super Baked a couple times while on vacation for Memorial Day and were very happy with the service, prices, and quality..."
Stephanie Lauterbach-Diaz
"We ordered a large pepperoni and 10 wings. Both were done in 15 for pickup and were very good. My preference would have been slightly more sauce, but..."
"We had my daughters first birthday here and it was perfect. From coordinating with the manager, to the food and service- everything was great. Our..."
Lindsey Feagins
"While on a spring break trip, and on our way back from visiting Hilton Head, we decided to stop and have dinner at here
The food was great, and..."
Ethan Poole
"My wife and I went early in the morning, and the Pizza was perfect. Excellent cheese to sauce ratio. Everything tasted fresh and our server was..."
Dustin Langlois
"I’m from Oklahoma. We have this local pizza place called The Hideaway. I believe they have been around about 50 years and have maybe 10 locations...."
Simon Alexander
"We were celebrating our Anniversary in Hilton Head being this is where we went for our first year anniversary. The atmosphere was great the service..."
Elvette55 Spaulding
"Walked in here and what a pleasant surprise. It's a pizza place with other options. We had the White chicken chili and wow was that good. Like give..."
Stephen Tuohy
"Great pizza place in the Harris Tetter shopping center. Outdoor seating, indoor seating, full bar too. Lots of mushroom art everywhere - and the..."
David Danner
"We were there at Happy Hour. A lot of locals. Which gives you a good feeling. Food was excellent. I had pepperoni. Husband had Funky BBQ Chicken..."
D Sewell
"Best pizza I've had in years! The gentleman (bartender) who served us was very nice and helpful. Great experience!..."
Karen Leitzel
"Sydney was our waitress. She was so pleasant and friendly. The pizza was delicious and we had a small greek salad. The salad was good but a bit..."
"Over all good!
Was honestly more impressed but just a plain pepperoni and cheese than by the specialty pizzas! They were certainly good, but if I..."
Andrew Glover
"Service was great!! Attentive, fast and friendly. Food was pretty good as well. Did a large half & half pizza and there were lots of toppings on it...."
Austin Yochus
"Great pizza and meatballs i highly recommend this place very good pizza!! Meatballs are amazing and so is the home made cheese..."
Dirt Every Weekend
"First time eating here, won’t be the last!
We had a Greek salad, excellent blend of ingredientes that makes each bit full of flavor.
We ordered a..."
Jorge Quiroz
"We got pizza for the first night at the beach from Dough Boys. We ordered a large pie with light cheese and Kim’s veggie with a chopped house..."
Daniel Todd
"We were in town last week and visited Dough Boys 3 times to include pizza and wings to bring back to GA. I've been visiting Hilton Head for over 15..."
Mary Sings Sings
"Stopped for lunch. Ordered 3 pizzas, hand-tossed. All 3 were cooked perfectly(the cheese a lottle brown) All very good. Also had chopped salads.
No..."
John Myers
"We ordered the Greek salad, a hand toss pep and extra cheese and a hand toss all the way. Everything was FABULOUS. Kenzie waited on us and was very..."
Kay Harris
"Took a little longer than most places, but I suspect that it was because the garlic knots had to be prepared and cooked. The pizza was pretty great...."
Aaron Bridges
"I'm going to give this place a five star. We ordered a LG cheese and a steak sub and it was delicious. I did order one of their specialty pizzas but..."
Jenny Cleland
"Crazy good pizza! Excellent crust, sauce and mozzarella! The garlic knots for very tender and delicious! Only a handful of tables but we saw tons of..."
Richard Hayden
"Very good NY style pizza. We had the coco Hawaiian, Doug’s Big Elvis, & a mushroom/pepperoni pizza. They were all very good. Somewhat expensive..."
jerome mazurkiewicz
"We ate outdoors and had a great meal.
Ordered a large Ceasar salad and a Large White pie with Broccoli well done.
Both items came out simultaneously,..."
Joseph Bernabe
"Small place but the pizza was delicious. So far best we've had on the..."
Linda Tucci
"One of the best places to get pizza on the island. As a local, I understand that Fourth of July week is super busy. It’s obvious that the..."
Michael Foster
"Some of the best pizza on the island. We loved this place and have been patrons for years, but the tone and customer service representation we have..."
Judge Fredd
"Nice little pizza place in Hilton Head with great service! Food was pretty good for how busy it was & id give it an 8 out of 10 stars & would..."
"It seems like the wait here is always long and for good reason. It’s a fun, family friendly place to get pizza and subs (hoagies).
My favorite..."
X “hungrytommy” X
"Went for early dinner takeout. Placed an order at the restaurant- 1 hour wait for the food. Pizza, salad and wedgie was good, wings were decent..."
Bill Sullivan
"all three courses were so good! we got calamari, a caesar salad and the ultimate white pizza with banana peppers added! their crust is one of my..."
amber lynn
"We visited the Hilton Head location of this local favorite on a Sunday afternoon (around 3pm) in mid December. I expected the place to be really..."
Ricky Reviews
"Excellent Italian food in a cool, fun environment - one part bar with a lot of TVs, another part outdoor eating area, and final part typical indoor..."
Robert Barr
"Absolutely amazing food. The service was impeccable and the atmosphere was so warming and inviting...."
Non Sibi Sed Ipsi
"The atmosphere is awesome especially if you are a Pittsburgh Steelers fan. Twyla our waitress was very accommodating and customer friendly. She was..."
Marianne Brown
"Absolutely loved the food here. We got here pretty late because we had missed most of our day dealing with an illness. They seated us promptly and..."
Pang Hartman
"Sat at the bar, walked in and sat right away on a Friday in late summer... Great service by the bartender, he was busy but right when we sat he said..."
James heath
"My second time having pizza and it was delicious. Ordered the Giuseppi’s Special both times. Nice Pittsburgh themed establishment. We had linner..."
Ron Hebert
"This was our second visit while vacationing here on Hilton Head. As someone who works in a Pizza place at home I was pleased to find a great place..."
Larry Brown III
"I like this restaurant here good good pizza they have place outside. Unfortunately we had to wait one..."
Taras Legar
"Tourists new to the area, we stopped in for a bite at lunch time. Chicken parm/salad lunch special and a cold beer hit the spot. Very good and..."
Miriam T
"My family has been coming here for years, since I was little, and to see them grow over the years has been awesome! Try their house salad with..."
Ashleigh Kormelink
"Good food at fair prices (especially for Hilton Head) and generous portion sizes. My boyfriend ordered the turkey weggie, which he said was great...."
Kristin Keesee
"This is hands down the best pizza I have ever had. The quality is great and the taste is unbelievable. We came down 3 weeks ago on a Saturday night...."
"Rosie was awesome! Pizza was awesome and THEY HAVE PIBB XTRA. can't find it any where lol they are Steelers fans in there but I looked passed it bc..."
AMBER WAYLAND
"The pepperoni was our favorite. Kids loved the chicken tenders and cheese sticks. After eating so much seafood this week we welcomed a good bite of..."
Maria Orszula
"The food was very good but there was a problem. We ordered via an online system. The problem is they do not make you aware that they have two..."
Gene Blair
"The restaurant smells wonderful when you walk in & the food did not disappoint. My husband ordered a calzone and I ordered the MOJO pie which is a..."
Holly Beauregard
"We ordered carry out twice during our week long stay in Sea Pines and were very impressed with the pizza. The service was fantastic as well...."
Joel Rink
"Ate here twice in a week! Pizza was delicious! The dough and sauce- yum! The salad was fresh and the wings were good too. Service is friendly and..."
Michelle Ryman
"Not a fan of Pittsburgh sports (coming from Cleveland) 😂 but I am a fan of their food!! After riding bikes around on the island, stopped in order..."
Mark Griffin
"Great staff. Friendly service. Carry out order was done right on time, and the pizza was..."
Sean DeBoth
"Always friendly excellent service and the food is awesome. I'm sorry to say my wife and I always enjoyed and raved about Giuseppi's in Sea Pines but..."
Donald Izone
"I’ve been craving wood fired pizza lately. My wife and I were returning to Hilton Head from a couple of hours spent in Savanna Georgia and it..."
Ralph Freeman
"I'm a born and raised Chicagoan. The art of pizza is a required class in both middle and high school. Someone stole a page from the book. Other..."
KathyH
"Really good pizza & calzones in a convenient location. Our group enjoyed a variety of dishes & excellent..."
Steve Jones
"Best southern pizza I have eaten. The Giuseppi Special pizza and Skinny Styx were..."
joe mallozzi
"Take out pizza. Pizza was good. Moz sticks and marinara were great. All take out beside some outdoor..."
"I would definitely return to Il Carpaccio again! The food was delicious. I had the Gnocchi Al Pomodoro E Gorgonzola and my partner had a pepperoni..."
Bee Bunny
"The food here is very good, and the service is always so friendly. The vibe is laid-back and super casual. Prices are hard to beat. This isn't "fine..."
Liz
"Wow, what a great Italian restaurant. Just discovered this gem near Main Street. Started with egg drop spinach soup, arugula saiad with oranges and a..."
Tim Beaver
"We haven't been here in many years. Not sure why. The food was very good and the portions were generous. The wait staff was efficient and concerned..."
Henry Noble
"Fantastic Spaghetti al Ragu...one of the best sauces I've ever had.
Update: food is still fantastic 2 years..."
Roger Cassell
"First time here for us. Food was so delicious. Yes, it was cooked fresh! Service was great as well. So glad they ate open for lunch. Definitely..."
Kate Hendricks
"Great atmosphere and the quality of food along eotj portion size is right on target with the price. A fabulous wine selection..."
John Coon
"Always a winner. Delicious food. Professional, attentive and dare I say attractive staff. Loved the..."
Bill Leahy
"If you have been looking for authentic italian, this is it. Best in the region. Everything we had was fantastic. There is definitely a wait, but it..."
Amy Gutting
"Went there with family for a early holiday dinner. The calamari fritti was great. Everyone else has different pasta or the salmon which was nice..."
David Levy
"It's a nice break from all the overpriced seafood on the island. The pizzas are incredible! The crust was so thin and the mozzarella was cooked to..."
Jordan Lassiter
"Pleasant atmosphere, waiter was top notch , very polite and attentive, for starters calamari with delicious sauce, salmon especial delicious along..."
Jennifer Gass
"This unassuming, Italian restaurant, in Hilton Head is really outstanding. It’s not upscale, and you won’t find fine wines and dining but all the..."
Rich Hajdu
"Really good Italian food for low prices. No frills....if you want fancy go..."
Erik Crown
"The Salmon was absolutely scrumptious! Best Salmon I’ve ever had! My husband had the Shrimp Scampi and he absolutely loved the shrimp flavor and he..."
"Loved, loved, loved the pizza. Extra cheese was actually extra cheese. Definitely will visit when I'm in the area again. The service was great and..."
Kathy Parker
"We didn’t eat in so can’t really rate the atmosphere but the pizza and mozzarella “balls” we really good. The mozzarella tasted homemade and..."
Wesley White
"We came here because one of our friends referred us. We are from Kansas City and when we walked in around 2 PM nobody was in the place except for 2..."
Steven Foster
"We had a short wait for a table, but our server, Amanda was very good. She was quick to greet us, bring our drinks, and put in our order. She was..."
Kristina Villella
"We struggled with finding a place for dinner as we have had lackluster meals on vacation. We finally settled here because pizza sounded good and the..."
Lindsay Bernardi
"Their brushettas are phenomenal! We also tried the subs, chicken strips and pastas - all were..."
Brandi McSheffrey
"Great spot for the whole family. In Hilton Head for the weekend and came for dinner with our two littles and my parents. My husband said his burger..."
Emily MacFarlane
"Winter visitors to the island and we always like to try a new pizza place. Had the Fat Baby dining in and it was delicious. Very flavourful and super..."
Ron Hebert
"Tried the "Fat Baby" sub and a 14" pie with sausage and mushrooms. The food was great with the minor exception that the crust was a little bit..."
Matthew Williams
"The best pizza and salads on Hilton Head! The meatballs are amazing too! Service was top notch! We always go here on our trips to Hilton..."
"We have tried a variety of pizza restaurants on the island and have found that New York City Pizza is the best around and the most consistent. Having..."
Tory M
"Not sure about the recent reviews, but don’t listen to them! Dominick provided wonderful service and great conversation while we dined in. We had..."
Annette White
"Food is great. Atmosphere is okay but I ordered online 30 minutes prior to arrival and waited another 45 minutes after I arrived for two pizzas. ..."
Allan Wilayto
"Pizza was very good and actually New York style. Skip the " Smash Burger", not very good. Meatball sandwich was outstanding. Very good, friendly..."
Mike Colie
"New York City Pizza never disappoints. Whether we are ordering pizza, wings, subs or one of its fabulous dinner entrees, we know we will be having a..."
Leslie Gromis Baker
"I had been craving Pizza for the prior 2 days, and had already purchased food when I noticed this restaurant on the way back to the truck.
Yes, I..."
Laura Lockhart
"This place is amazing!! The waiter was a sweetheart and chatted with us about different types of pasta and how they go with different wines! Did not..."
Samuel Ouellet
"YO THIS PLACE WAS BOMB. We're on vacation in Hilton Head from Florida and I have to say this is the best pizza I have had in many many a year. Great..."
Jessica Atanasova (Hitokiri NekoHime)
"This pizza did not disappoint! It smells delicious and tastes even better! The staff here were great too. I couldn’t recommend NYCP highly enough -..."
William Austin
"My kids love going there on weekends, they have nice staff members and amazing pizza! We were able to relax, and spend some quality time enjoying..."
"The food pizza and some Italian dishes the best - but more importantly you will feel like Norm on “Cheers” the entire staff so friendly fun..."
Mike Hayes
"We celebrated my daughter’s birthday here tonight with the family. I delivered a tres leches birthday cake there this morning and they provided the..."
Jill Schrott
"It’s the only place around here that I’ll order Eggplant Parmesan . (My family included)So delicious!! Never had a dinner or pizza that wasn’t..."
Nancy Coppa Bare
"This was our first visit. This place is awesome! Great Pizza and service! We had Doreene as our waitress! She was super friendly!
We will be..."
Moti Cohen
"Doreene is the best. She was so nice and sweet!
The service was good and also the pizza �
I will be back just because off Doreene she was amazing..."
Shir Goldhammer
"Waitress was AWESOME....
Pizza was GREAT and dough homemade!
Probably best pizza on the island. Thank you..."
Andrea Andie Dick
"Great place to eat with very friendly Staff & Pizza was..."
Jeannean Chesser Heber
"My fiance and I have been there 5 times. All 5 times we had great food and great service! We are going to be..."
Michael Smith
"We walked in as a table of 5 about 40 minutes from closing. We asked if they could seat us and did without hestitaion. The staff was very friendly..."
Brittany Geraty
"My wife and I have tried MANY pizzas over many years and we both feel that NYC Pizza is among the best. We eat this pizza every year on our annual..."
Larry Vannozzi
"I thought the food was pretty good despite the reviews. Not amazing, but..."
Bre Ianniello
"It's good and a really nice drink selection. Ask for extra crispy, the NYC style was a little soggy in the middle. I would definitely come back. Our..."
Stephen Tuohy
"Came to HH for vacation. My wife was determined to have NYC-style pizza. Went with this place. Pizza was really good in the end, but a premium was..."
Joshua Talley
"The pizza is delicious! The more toppings you get, the harder to eat as they are left in big chunks is my only complaint but others might enjoy that...."
Rachel Jasper
"We visit HH every year and New York City Pizza is our first, but not only, stop. Love the pizza, soups and salads. You won’t be..."
Pat Miller
"We have been coming to this location since our honeymoon in Hilton Head in 2006! The food is always spot on. Very dependable and very consistent! ..."
Steven Baumrind
"Pizza was amazing. Heart burn was worth it. Feeling bad about myself (for eating an entire Supreme pizza ((alone in my hotel room))) was..."
Chad
"New York City Pizza
Hilton Head Island
Good variety of options.
Bar on site
Good amount of space for dine in.
Close to Coligny Beach.
Located right..."
N S Prasad
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes