Best Ice Cream in Homer

6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Carmen's Gelato
Carmen's Gelato
96/100 (278 ratings)
Dessert
Espresso and Salted Caramel
Ice Cream
Raspberry Cheesecake Chocolate Noir and Maple Nut Butter Pecan Gelato
Gelato
Cherry Chocolate
mango
Affogato
Latte
Pistachio Gelato
Artisan Gelato
Café
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Mid-range
Brain Freeze Madness
Brain Freeze Madness
94/100 (121 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
"Soft and hard ice cream are both exceptional!! This is hands down the best ice cream..."
Courtney Adele Farkas
"Awesome as usual can't pass the place without stopping in for a scoop or two. Butter Brickel and campfire smores are my..."
Kathy Hall-Merritt
"Best shake I've ever had. And huge definitely worth a..."
Dan Brown
"Absolutely the best ice cream in the county! Generous servings. Momma's Mud Pie is the best. Is it spring..."
Barbara Miller
"Very high quality Ice Cream. The service is excellent and there are lots of nice places to sit and..."
Toni Raye Blair
"Gnome, Gnome,..."
Sheila Sunderland
"My favorite ice cream place of them all in the area. Have one in walking distance, and 2 more closer than Brain Freeze, but I pass them all up to get..."
Melissa Metzger
"We stopped in today and see how good it was and it was a weird had the banana split never had strawberry soft serve ice cream it was..."
Scott Brazo
"Our favorite place to get ice..."
Gregory Nelson
"Best hard ice cream flavors, by far! Blows ColdStone and B&J's out of the water. Their sundaes are full of toppings and so delicious. I'm sad they're..."
Jess Stratton
"Awesome Jr banana split definitely worth taking the time to..."
Jeremiah McMillen
"Jerry like to stop by and have a hotdog , fries . Then mosey on over for our favorite ice cream..."
Carrie Chiasson Abbott
"maine wild blueberry and toasted coconut. enough said. FANTASTIC! and large servings! Love you..."
Paula Banner Gustafson
"LOVE! Best ice-cream in the area and they all are so..."
Jessica Clark
"Awesome entertainment and great ice..."
Alysha Wehnke
"Maybe I will come get some ice cream tonight and see my lovely work of..."
Brittney Brown Thompson
"AWESOME! Stopped to see what they offered...I LOVE the Andes Mint..."
Debbie Willis-Brazo
"Best ice cream shop in the area. They have the biggest selection of ice cream flavors I've ever seen. The prices were very nice and the large cone..."
Aric Montgomery
"My partner and I drive out of our way to come to Brain Freeze Madness! We love coming here for their Dope Whip, and the staff is super friendly and..."
Carmen Greco
"Some off the best and most interesting flavors of ice cream and sundaes. Prices are not bad for the quality of the hard ice cream. We used to go..."
A Kernaghan
"A great place to stop! Our server was very informative and had a good sense of humor. Great ice cream, decent portions, for a reasonable..."
Bud Smith
"Excellent Gifford's ice cream! Very friendly & efficient staff!! Love it, so glad they're now open for the 2017 season! It's been a long..."
Debra Finn
"Friendly staff, a large and varied menu, and huge portions! It's exactly what a local ice cream stand should be. Tastes like..."
David Syracuse
"Best ice cream anywhere. I love the Dole Whips. Prices are very reasonable. Love Theresa and the entire..."
Julie sweet
"Friendly, helpful staff. Prompt assistance. Magnificent ice cream, many delicious choices. Good..."
Virginia Brown
"Our favorite ice cream joint in Cortland County. Family owned and operated...they're great..."
Steven H. Fisher
"One of our favorite ice cream places. The flavor options and extras are..."
Steven Barton
"Great amount of ice cream, excellent flavors, wonderful..."
Kim Eggers
"The best ice cream around! Staff are always pleasant and jovial! Brain Freeze great to work with for community events as well...."
Renee Compton
"We love this ice cream. Fast friendly service, always with a smile. Many many..."
Stacey Goldyn-Moller
"The best coffee ice cream I ever had! Love this place. Best ice cream in..."
Patricia Ward
"Excellent ice cream good prices enjoyed..."
William Wartman
"Great ice cream, attentive, friendly, fast..."
Dan Sargent
Main Street Belly Deli
Main Street Belly Deli
93/100 (71 ratings)
Restaurants
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Sandwiches
Ice Cream
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Flagship Creamery
Flagship Creamery
89/100 (293 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Restaurants
American
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sandwich
Crepes
Gelato
Banana Nutella Crepe
Cookie
The Ultimate Crêpe Bomb
Banana split
Oreo
Strawberry
Sit down
American
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Brunch
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Very friendly staff and great tasting ice cream. They make their waffle cones right there. On a sunny day great beachfront sitting area. They had..."
Best Friends RVing-Sailing
"This place is awesome! Really friendly family runs the place and the ice cream is great! Freshly cooked waffle cones and huge scoops. We stop here..."
Eric
"Got an ice cream sandwich with cookie dough ice cream. The ice cream was delicious but the cookies were very hard and difficult to bite into. I wish..."
Anne Cerveny
"Delicious ice cream and friendly staff! They also have cute small kid cones for..."
Ashlee Allen Beutler
"I got the blueberry cheesecake crepe. Itbwould have been purfect if it had just avlittle less filling with whip..."
blessedveteran
"Great place! They serve Tillamook and Blue Bunny! My two favorite brands of ice cream!! Also they have amazing waffle cones and toppings. Best ice..."
Kristi
"The girls that work their are so nice and so is the owner. They have the best ice cream, but their Green Chili Crepe is amazing! It's everything I..."
Lisa Ravenscroft
"Crepe bomb was awesome and they had the best salted caramel sauce I’ve ever..."
Alexis Barnett
Boss Hogz Restaurant
Boss Hogz Restaurant
84/100 (516 ratings)
Dessert
Diner
Diner
American
American
Lunch
Dinner
Sandwiches
Burger
Tater tots
Hamburgers
Ice Cream
Pork
Sit down
American
Diner
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Super Cream Dairy Bar
Super Cream Dairy Bar
82/100 (730 ratings)
Dessert
American
Lunch
Salad
Ice Cream
Hot Fudge Sundae
Orange Vanilla Ice Cream
Hard Ice Cream in Cup
Vanilla Soft Serve with Rainbow Sprinkles in a Waffle Cone
Peanut Butter Binge Sundae
Chicken Tenders 5
Mint Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Marshmallow
Super Cream Banana Split
"We are new to the area and this is the first time we tried Super Dairy. The ice cream is the best we've had in many years and the staff are courteous..."
J Becker
"A great little stop on a very Sunny hot day. The ice cream was very splendid With an amazing amount of different flavors and different Combinations..."
gerard grohol
"Great ice cream at a good price. Nice outdoor seating area and lots of..."
Brandy Bednarski
"Just about the best ice cream joint I’ve ever eaten at. Decor inside is really cool. Really good prices too. Definitely worth stopping at if..."
David Davis
"There was a bit of a line, but it moved pretty fast. Person who took our order was very helpful. Lots of interesting homemade flavors, sundae..."
Jen Morrissey
"My 2 sons just got a chocolate cone and a cookie dough ice cream in a cup we just got ho.e and they already want more I also had a large chocolate..."
Michael
"Wow great coffee ice cream . Cool place not too expensive at all for 4..."
Al C
"I dropped in for a root beer float on my drive home, the service was fast and friendly and the float was delicious! I'll definitely be returning if..."
Sean Conley
"Best milkshakes and banana splits in the area! Deep-fried cheese curds are the best. I have not had a bad experience at this establishment yet, and..."
R********** ******I*
"They have a huge variety of treats to choose from. The prices are reasonable and there's plenty of seating outdoors and..."
Mary Fellows
"Here’s the weight of an hour and six minutes online for the walk up was worth the wait. The drive-thur definitely shorter wait. Quality of the..."
Luis “Lou” Alvarez
"The best Ice cream stand in the area. Lots of options , as well as some food options like fries etc . They have a nice big seating area both inside..."
punk rock Michelle
"Super cream is super yummy. Whenever we are back in town, we must visit this iconic place! Chocolate and vanilla twist..."
Tamara Demeree
"Outstanding and inexpensive home made ice cream! Definitely a surprise as located in small town of Homer. I had black raspberry, rum raisin and..."
Frank Ferko
"I enjoy the ice cream there. I forgot about their hot food. I recently started stopping there for a quick lunch. I enjoy the food there. Nice place..."
robert burleigh
"Cute place, still serving ice cream. Lots of..."
Sarah
"Really nice employees. This place has inside seating as well as plentiful outdoor seating as well. They provide cups and water outside; guess I am..."
Cate T.