Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Island Park
7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Have stayed at Buffalo Run every summer for 12+ years and we absolutely love the place! Can't say enough about the hosts, the facilities, the pizza..."
Phil Arnold
"My family and I have stayed at their cabins twice now. Very nice cabins and park! The owners are amazing people! Their pizza is to die for as..."
Amy McCormick
"We had so much fun! Cute and convenient little cabins and the best hosts..."
Debbie Earl
"This was our first time staying here, it was absolutely amazing!! The owners are amazing people!! The cabins are wonderful! And it is absolutely..."
Tena Gardiner
"This place is awesome! The owners are the nicest and best camp hosts I have ever met. The Park is clean and well maintained. The pizza and coffee..."
Nadine Rendon
"This is a truly amazing place and the owners/operators are exceptional. You must try there pizza..."
Adam Fretwell
"Very Friendly Owners & Even The Campers... It Was A Great Experience!
My Dad & Step Mom Loves It There & Says They Will Definitely Be..."
GeorgeAnn Marie Bock
"Loved the cabin!! Had everything we needed. We were a large party, took all cabins and quite a few camp spots as a group party, we were in cabin 3...."
Sherrie Jordan
"From the first time I met Jeff, I fell in love with this place. Love the cabins, love the RV sites and love the coffee and..."
"Had the chicken parm and veal parm dinners last night and they were outstanding. Every single time we eat there we get awesome food from great..."
Jay B Price
"Try the spicy chicken and broccoli rabe hero special. It is not on the menu, but is an everyday special. It is off the hook! Grilled chicken,..."
Anne Matthaei
"Absolutely the best restaurant....warm, friendly...the penne ala vodka...... outstanding, as with all the food. Recommend highly to..."
Marge Cooney
"A very big shoutout to Josephine and the entire staff at Jacks! They catered my daughters graduation party and everything was absolutely delicious! ..."
Jeanne DeBraccio Gidwill
"I'm not a soup person but being home with bronchitis I decided to order some minestrone tonight. Absolutely the best minestrone I've ever had!..."
Jaclyn Calderone Koller
"Always delicious and on point!! Highly recommend them...."
Jean Bailo Leo
"A must try. Not only pizza great burgers, salads and much more. With Josephine in the Kitchen you can't go wrong. It's our go to place never a bad..."
Vickie Wilson
"Josephine and staff do excellent catering ....!!! Love Love Love the..."
Irene DeSimone-ford
"Great little pizza joint in my home town of Island Park. Spent countless hours in here as a kid. Even though there are new owners, the pizza, and..."
Jamie Schaefer
"The service and the food are exceptional. I think I died and went to Rice ball special..."
Michael LaRocco
"Always friendly. Food is great. Highly..."
Maya Del Príncipe
"A home away from home. The best. It is like you are with family when you go there. All the food is a must try. Don't be..."
Daniel Fasulo
"Amazing food, very friendly staff. They make you feel like old friends or part of their family when you're there. Best pizza and heros on Long..."
John Tinghitella
"Best place for pizza and Italian dishes . Wings are the best..."
Surferlos Zap
"Amazing food, staff is great, and home cooked style..."
Jason Cooney
"This is such a ‘go to’ italian it’s not even funny. Less pricey, friendlier and tastier than their ginos and davinci counterparts, Jack’s..."
Lovetoeat
"Best house special pizza and spumoni italian ice to die..."
Kimberline Avril Sukhra
"Extremely late ⏰ lunch 🥪 this is more like #dinner.. Sometimes lunch breaks are tight when you’re on the road..
But whenever I am working in..."
William Jacobs
"The food is always good. I have family in the area and Jack's is a go to whenever we are looking for an easy dinner. Pizza is excellent. Heroes..."
Brian Testerman
"My wife ate here a few months ago and loved it so much me made me drive all the way from Utah testing pizza all over the country all the way back...."
Matthew Jenson
"Pizza is out of this world. Just moved to IP and already had Jacks 3x in our first 2 weeks of living here. 🤷♀️ Try a pie with pepperoni,..."
Denise Zutel
"They are the best, I am telling you! Salad fresh. Dressing homemade. Shrimps always fresh and cooked as it supposed to. Everything is just..."
Irina Shevchenko
"Wow, this pizza is so good! I don't live around here, so I've missed pizza like this. I wish I was around longer so I could try the wings. I heard..."
Ricky Wood
"Excellent food service owners appreciate you !!!!! Agian BEST CORNBEEF N CABBAGE ON ST PATTY'S..."
Patricia Conte
"As a True New Yorker you can tell your about to have a good slice of pizza just from the smell. JACK'S PIZZA is one of those places, before friend..."
Kenny Mack
"Excellent local shop with an outstanding buffalo chicken slice. Chicken roll also good; always people inside but never a parking problem or too long..."
Alexander Cecil
"Excellent local place with great prices, fresh food, and a warm, family vibe. Amazing for eating in or takeout!
My family has also catered several..."
"Food= 10/10
Dessert= 10/10
Employees= 10/10
Freddy was of great service to us was a very sweet and kind guy. Overall this was one of the best..."
Kaelan Shaw
"We love The Parkor at Mack’s Inn! Not only do they have the best pizza and ice cream in town, their staff are the friendliest and most helpful..."
Alex Barrus
"Might possibly be the best pizzas I've ever had!! Crust was perfect and the baked potato pizza was so delicious!! Can't beat the views either! Highly..."
Mandy S
"We stopped here twice for pizza and salad while we were visiting Island Park. They have pizza, salad, ice cream and chocolate! I actually really..."
Erica Roberts
"Gem! Finally a new great place instead of the old mediocre places around. Great location next to the new SpringHill Suites. Delicious Bluebird bars..."
L B
"We were staying at the hotel next door and came here for late night pizza. The pizza was delicious and very fast for a brick oven pizza. The salad..."
"Love this place everything is clean and the stuff make you feel welcome. What a great place to come for pizza, wings, salads, sangria, cocktails etc..."
Magaly Yessenia Medina
"The best. Jerry Cozzi and the staff are awesome. Food is fantastic. Can't recommend this awesome place enough. Worth the..."
Dan Segarra
"Loved this personal pizza made to order place(in Wantagh). Pizza was excellent ! Crust was perfect which is the hardest part of a pizza. Prices were..."
Barb Johnson
"Great pizza and you get to pick your own toppings with so many choices. Fresh ingredients and the pizza doesn't sit around forever. Great service,..."
Christopher Stiansen
"Great food great people defiantly recommend this place for a good friendly..."
George Buzzetta
"Thanks for a delicious dinner! We were first timers and Tory could not have been more helpful in helping us pick out the best wings on the menu- he..."
Nicole Brennan
"First visit and I will definitely return! I was sold by the variety of food and the healthy choices. That came around with free ice cream and they..."
Josephine Centore
"Just went with my wife and daughter. The buffalo chicken meatballs were great. We all had different types of pizza and they were all delicious. The..."
Brian Smith
"This place has amazing options and food. The best..."
Lulya Morkovka
"What a great place! Food was delicious...loved it. The only complaint is that the place could use more sweeping and clean tables. Besides that we..."
Irene Nunes-Diehl
"Great pizza, great people and a great atmosphere!! This place really gets me going......."
Frank Faulkner
"Love the pizza and the wings. Pleasant staff. We come here all the time and are never..."
Deborah Friedman Salinsky
"Make your own delicious pizza with lots of selections to choose from. Also great selection of..."
Andrew T. Berman
"Friendly service. Went on labor day and they were still open. The pizza was great, but I knocked a star off for their chicken noodle soup. The soup..."
Vita
"Great diy pizza place . Recommend the buffalo chicken pizza and the..."
Tstarr Crafts
"This place has amazing options and food. We always get a Gluten Free pizza and the fact that they have a separate oven for cooking them is amazing...."
Myron Allis
"Went there recently to try the food under the new management. It was great. I found out they also have a space upstairs for small parties. I booked..."
nina kavesteen
"It is an interesting setup they have here - the concept is great! Design your own pizza, with their big selection of toppings, and their choice of..."
Jeffrey Katz
"I like this place for a number of reasons. top of the list is the pesto sauce I make my borata cheese and pesto pizza with. I appreciate the layout,..."
Joseph Naham
"Came here for a birthday party - it was really great inside for the event. The staff was super nice and helpful to all of us. Really attentive to all..."
Jason Lazarus
"One of the best places to go to for safe, gluten free pizza! I always get the Go Figure and Pepper Pig without fail. I'm OBSESSED with the..."
Nicole S.
"Very delicious pizza. You can order any toppings you want. Build your favorite pizza. Excellent service! Bar with wide selection of drinks both..."
Andrei B
"It was amazing. I would definitely go back again. The pizza was very fresh and they cook it right when you order it so it is really fresh. You can..."
Kit #1
"Excellent Pizza and amazing service. My wife and I went here for the first time wand was blown away by the service and amazing food. The ingredients..."
V Ramsaran
"I have always loved popping into PieCraft. The food is great, I love to support local-and it just so happens that friends own the place so...I like..."
Jen Murphy
"Great service. Great selection. Yummy pizza. And a complete Gluten free prep section and separate oven. Very understanding of dietary..."
David Neubert
"Pizza wasn’t bad! Got delivery but it was pretty cold when the driver dropped it off. Has a nice atmosphere if you sit down and dine..."
"I came with my family for the bday the food was amazing pene alla vodka was delicious and the chicken scarpariello was great highly recommend. Pizza..."
Ellior Badash
"always great service and food and check out the bartender for great cocktails on sundays!
A hidden treasure on the south shore for..."
Surferlos Zap
"Our first time there , the place looks beautiful with a lot of personal space between the tables, the service was excellent the food was amazing and..."
Yossi Oren
"Great food and waiter. Nice atmosphere a must to try. Love the chicken..."
Susan Doby Rivero
"First time there.....unfortunately they were down two waiters so our waiter was overwhelmed to say the least but they made good on everything and..."
Rene Costello
"The staff is friendly && they have the best Penne Ala Vodka, hands..."
Krystal Marie
"I went there last night with my wife. Fantastic.. great pork chop and really good seafood salad. Service was incredible and so was the vodka..."
Thomas Pisaneschi
"went to Devincis today and had amazing service and amazing food. We are not from the area but we had a funeral today and they accommodated us at the..."
Lori Spellman Pisaneschi
"The ambience is lovely, the service is lively and caring. I have never had a meal that didn't live up to expectations. Think ahead, and make..."
Fred Zubrin
"Food was amazing and bartender was so friendly! I’ll definitely be..."
Ali Mahones
"I came in with a large group from the funeral home down the block. We were welcomed right away. Our group got a little bigger and they changed the..."
Tom Uzi
"Spent a day at the beach with a friend who lives in the area. We were ravenous by the time we got back to her place and so ordering in had to happen...."
Christina Vetrano
"DaVinci’s always lives up to my high expectations for service, ambiance and delicious and interesting dinners! Ginna, our favorite waitress is the..."
Suzanne
"Nice place to stop and enjoy a fresh, hot Italian dinner if you are in the Jones Beach area. We stopped by on our way back from the Magic of the..."
Kundan Sen
"Came with a party of 7 for a birthday dinner. Prompt and polite service. Quiet atmosphere. Large portion of fried calamari appetizer. The DaVinci..."
Seth Blau
"Loving this neighborhood restaurant with outdoor seatings. Price is definitely good for the amount of food they serve!! And they taste great too.
A..."
Roy Samadi
"We were in the area spending a day at the beach and wanted to wrap up the day with dinner, so decided on a whim to check out this place and it turned..."
Alona K
"My perfectly cooked salmon was burried under these yummy cannelini beans, sun-dried tomatoes and broccoli rabe drowning in a delicious garlic and..."
Chef Via Melissa
"Just moved to Long Beach from Suffolk and we started our journey to find some good Italian restaurants. Luckily, DaVinci’s was highly recommended...."
Peter Marcus
"Loved it.
My wife and I stopped in for a quick bite, and we were very glad we did. The pizza and rice ball were served on real plates not paper, and..."
Joseph Scuccimarri
"Delicious food, attentive service, and great ambience. The place is super cozy with warm lighting, and replete with an old-school charm.
The food..."
abdullah noor
"Our favorite pizza spot in Nassau County. My wife and I used to live around the corner years ago. We stop in once every few years. The Grandma and..."
Jason Smith
"Bartender here is very friendly, great with service and always treating the customers great !, She's always good to conversation with. Food was..."
max gomez
"Amazing food the service was amazing and friendly. Food was filled with flavor beat my expectations. 10/10..."
abraheem qureshi
"One of the best Italian restaurants I have ever been too! If you want fine dining, I highly recommend this place! Delicious food and great..."
"Love this place everything is clean and the stuff make you feel welcome. What a great place to come for pizza, wings, salads, sangria, cocktails etc..."
Magaly Yessenia Medina
"The best. Jerry Cozzi and the staff are awesome. Food is fantastic. Can't recommend this awesome place enough. Worth the..."
Dan Segarra
"Loved this personal pizza made to order place(in Wantagh). Pizza was excellent ! Crust was perfect which is the hardest part of a pizza. Prices were..."
Barb Johnson
"Great pizza and you get to pick your own toppings with so many choices. Fresh ingredients and the pizza doesn't sit around forever. Great service,..."
Christopher Stiansen
"Great food great people defiantly recommend this place for a good friendly..."
George Buzzetta
"Thanks for a delicious dinner! We were first timers and Tory could not have been more helpful in helping us pick out the best wings on the menu- he..."
Nicole Brennan
"First visit and I will definitely return! I was sold by the variety of food and the healthy choices. That came around with free ice cream and they..."
Josephine Centore
"Just went with my wife and daughter. The buffalo chicken meatballs were great. We all had different types of pizza and they were all delicious. The..."
Brian Smith
"This place has amazing options and food. The best..."
Lulya Morkovka
"What a great place! Food was delicious...loved it. The only complaint is that the place could use more sweeping and clean tables. Besides that we..."
Irene Nunes-Diehl
"Great pizza, great people and a great atmosphere!! This place really gets me going......."
Frank Faulkner
"Love the pizza and the wings. Pleasant staff. We come here all the time and are never..."
Deborah Friedman Salinsky
"Make your own delicious pizza with lots of selections to choose from. Also great selection of..."
Andrew T. Berman
"Friendly service. Went on labor day and they were still open. The pizza was great, but I knocked a star off for their chicken noodle soup. The soup..."
Vita
"Great diy pizza place . Recommend the buffalo chicken pizza and the..."
Tstarr Crafts
"This place has amazing options and food. We always get a Gluten Free pizza and the fact that they have a separate oven for cooking them is amazing...."
Myron Allis
"Went there recently to try the food under the new management. It was great. I found out they also have a space upstairs for small parties. I booked..."
nina kavesteen
"It is an interesting setup they have here - the concept is great! Design your own pizza, with their big selection of toppings, and their choice of..."
Jeffrey Katz
"I like this place for a number of reasons. top of the list is the pesto sauce I make my borata cheese and pesto pizza with. I appreciate the layout,..."
Joseph Naham
"Came here for a birthday party - it was really great inside for the event. The staff was super nice and helpful to all of us. Really attentive to all..."
Jason Lazarus
"One of the best places to go to for safe, gluten free pizza! I always get the Go Figure and Pepper Pig without fail. I'm OBSESSED with the..."
Nicole S.
"Very delicious pizza. You can order any toppings you want. Build your favorite pizza. Excellent service! Bar with wide selection of drinks both..."
Andrei B
"It was amazing. I would definitely go back again. The pizza was very fresh and they cook it right when you order it so it is really fresh. You can..."
Kit #1
"Excellent Pizza and amazing service. My wife and I went here for the first time wand was blown away by the service and amazing food. The ingredients..."
V Ramsaran
"I have always loved popping into PieCraft. The food is great, I love to support local-and it just so happens that friends own the place so...I like..."
Jen Murphy
"Great service. Great selection. Yummy pizza. And a complete Gluten free prep section and separate oven. Very understanding of dietary..."
David Neubert
"Pizza wasn’t bad! Got delivery but it was pretty cold when the driver dropped it off. Has a nice atmosphere if you sit down and dine..."
"The most excellent cuisine and the friendliest people with the best service around! Great big TV's all around for viewing from all areas so you can..."
Ed Eldredge
"Ate at Ponds Lodge tonight - the poutine - sheesh. To die for. In heaven. Burgers also soooo good. And Colleen was so awesome!! The whole experience..."
Becky Quinn
"Great food and service in the restaurant !! Didn’t care for the guy working the cash register when I asked him to start the gas pump made the..."
Rick Brakken
"Thank you so much to Carl, Jon, Nikki, and the rest of the staff at Ponds Lodge for their extreme generosity in hosting a Children’s Miracle..."
PJ Yacuk
"Don't get up Island Park much but when I do I don't worry about where I'm going to eat, Pond's always has great food and great service. Labor Day..."
Bryan Vohs
"We stopped for a beer and a snack. The loaded nachos were more like a meal! Friendly staff and nice..."
Brenda Rouzer
"Been here 3 times in the last month, after a day of fly fishing this place hits the spot. Delicious food, the owner..."
Josh Patterson
"We've eaten here two nights in a row and it is by far the best food in the area! Great service as well! Love, love, love the mules and..."
Jessica Young Zeable
"Nothin but love❤ This place is amazing! I unpatiently wait every year to come back for this pizza and breadsticks! And yes, I eat here the entire..."
Stacie McIlwain Nelson
"The Prime Rib, Salad, Sides, and Desert for the Fremont County Search & Rescue Appreciation Dinner was excellent. The staff was super friendly and..."
Eric E Thomas
"Fantastic pizza and cheesy bread! Great service. It was well worth the drive up to Island..."
Julie Chilberg Kippen
"The accommodations, food and staff are amazing. I have stayed at Ponds for several years during snowmobile trips with friends and family. They are..."
Brian Hersch
"One of the best places to eat and hang out at. The best part is it's the same drive time from Rexburg as Idaho Falls and its way..."
Austin Smith
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes