Best Pepperoni Pizza Slice in Key West

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pizza Joe's
Pizza Joe's
82/100 (639 ratings)
Quick Bites
Pizza
Italian
Fast Food
Fast food
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
It's Pizza What You Think It Is
cheese pizza
Sit down
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Cheap Eats
"Me being a Firefighter, this is a welcoming sight to see. Pizza Joe's is a pizza shop that gives back to 1st responders from any department in the..."
Mr. Mark Watts
"Okay if you are walking Duval Street in Key West and just need a quick bite to eat STOP HERE! We snagged 2 slices of pizza and 2 bottles of water for..."
Bikes Brews and BBQ
"Pizza is a little pricey but so good and worth it!! I always stop here when I am in kw. Their open late and only take cash. Their triple meat pizza..."
Tiana W
"Pizza here was pretty good, especially for being outside New York. I didn't expect much but it was actually a nice spot. The person working was great..."
Michael Fuller
"This place is the bomb for late night eats. Great pies & they take care of first responders. Any place that appreciates those who sacrifice..."
Mark Price
"If you ask me and my wife this is the best pizza place on the entire island! I'd even say better than anything I've gotten in NYC. Now we only had..."
Christopher Noll
"Best pizza in key west. Just like eating pizza in N.Y. OR N.J. I haven't had pizza in fl. This good since I left up north in 20 years. A MUST PLACE..."
John Rawlins
"Food was great, was super surprised that they gave free pizza to first responders (of course we tipped). I think that's amazing and shows what type..."
Nicole Clemons
"Stellar $5 sausage/pepperoni/meatball pizza slices! Crust is awesome. Cashier looked stoned out of his mind but who really cares for..."
Alexis Magness
"Not a bad pizza late at night. $5 each plain slice. Cash..."
Yasser A.
"Yum yum and more yum! U can smell it before u get there. Asked if I could have mushrooms on the pizza already made, no extra charge and gave me a ton..."
melanie rose
"This is a must visit any time I visit Key West. A cute little walk up counter, the pizza is some of the best I have..."
Cassi McCarrick
"So, I was a bit too drunk to remember how Pizza Joe's was lol but took photos and vaguely remember eating some 'za. I'm just thankful that they were..."
Sky Thai
Angelina's Pizzeria
Angelina's Pizzeria
75/100 (1239 ratings)
Quick Bites
Pizza
Italian
Fast Food
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salad
Pepperoni & Mushroom Pizza
Pizza Margherita
Lasagne
Cookie
cheese pizza
Pepperoni Slice Cheese Slice
Loaded Slice
Pepperoni Sausage Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Add Pineapple
Peppers
Half Cheese Half Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Sit down
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Wine and Beer
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Grabbed a slice while walking around Duval Street. Not bad, but not a favorite either. Staff was a lot of fun though (challenging my Galaga..."
Internet Shopper
"Good pizza. Went on a cruise in March 2014. Took the Duval pub crawl and stopped here for a bite. Pizza was very good. Going back to Key West May..."
Guy
"Key West's 2:00 am place for pizza. Funky pizzaria on the western end of Duval Street...aroundthe corner from Capt. Tony's... across the street from..."
Bud
"Decent pizza when you need drunk..."
Tyler
"Good street pizza.... Street pizza is any pizza sold directly over a counter or from a truck and consumed outdoors. This street pizza is among the..."
Mikie Steve
"Good pizza...workers are A$$HOLES...try harder next time ya..."
Richmond_JMC
"Pizza was good. Good prices also, 3.50 a slice, and the slices are big. Cool atmosphere and awesome..."
Jackson Goerges
"Great Little Place. I loved this place, and I am much harder on judging pizza joints than any other place, it was a little pricey for slices but..."
OrlandoFoodGuy
"A Favorite among the Locals. This is one of the favored pizza restaraunts preferred by the locals. It is a step above most other pizza places, they..."
Keith Thompson
"Good Pizza for the Crawl. Not necessarily the best pizza on the rock (I vote Big Johns for that), but it is a good slice to grab while doing the..."
Kempshark
"We have to have some pizza here EVERY time we stay in Key West...espcially after having a few drinks during Fantasy Fest! AWESOME drunk food!..."
Kari1211
"Fabulous Pizza!. And if it weren't so maddening, the PIZZA NAZI behind the counter might actually be..."
CASEY
"Have eaten here several times and 9 outta 10 times it is great, but have had some average slices. Will try again...90 percent is pretty good I..."
Sue E Sydel
"Best pizza on the "Rock". Always..."
Richie Rich
"Different, but GREAT. Some of the best Pizza I've ever had!Angelina's is in an odd location, but it will be one of the best slices of pie you..."
Todd Lytle
"This pizza was exactly what we needed as we ended our night on Duval Street. Slices are huge and delicious. Service was fast and the employees were..."
Rylee J
"Easily the best pizza I’ve ever had, don’t know why this place isn’t closer to 5 stars, but whatever. If you’re in key west and want some..."
theCoolguy113
"Growing up in NY/NJ and eating pizza weekly this pizza hit the spot! Traditional NY style with a crispy under-carriage and a nice flop. Mr.Portny..."
Spacely Smith
"Great pizza, unique joint! Prices for toppings are expensive. Came out pretty fast considering how busy they were. Served hot! Very tasty. Gave us..."
a f
"Good customizable pizza slice! Great..."
Heather Michael
"The best pizza I’ve ever eaten! Went here on my trip at about 1 AM and this place was jammed packed. Great service and big portion..."
Russell Lavender
"Visit my YouTube Channel/THUMPER RUSTY, for all of the vids I've done from around the country! **** BESTEST PIZZA **** "IN ALL THE WEST"... Get a..."
Glyndon Disharoon
"Great pizza and the prices are perfect! Nice quick bite to eat when you want to keep seeing the..."
Desiree Rose
"Great pizza no matter what time of day or night u pick it up! Fresh hot by the slice or whole.. made to order any way u like! Staff is great 😊..."
Just my thought & opinion
"The pizza is great, but the subs are a underrated treasure. Get ‘em warmed, cheesy- great stuff. Price is great too! For Key West, you wont find..."
Carlos Cespedes
"Ordered delivery. Arrived very fast. Driver was super nice. Calzone was..."
JR
"Some of the BEST pizza I’ve had after a night of drinking! My only regret is that I only got one slice..."
Ashley B
"Angelina's is a wonderful pizzeria with delicious slices served day and night. The staff is always very friendly and accommodating, even in the..."
David July
"Very crispy and hot sausage slices. Fair price and nice guys behind the..."
Indy CessnaPilot
"The pizza was awesome. The atmosphere is more for adults. A lot of drunk⁹ The only thing I didn't like is that you have pay a quarter to get a..."
Jackie Montanez