American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Keyport
17 restaurant menus in Keyport, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Their pork chops were out of this world. Juicy and tender and the service was great. We were seated immediately with our reservation and they were..."
Terik Ahmed
"My husband and I ate dinner there for the first time tonight. Phenomenal! It felt like the best comfort food I've ever had. Simple ingredients cooked..."
Darlene O'Keefe
"Staff is nice and helpful, ambience is beautiful, little too dark for me. The closer plate is the pork chop and the other one was veal. I specially..."
Beanne Vega
"The food is good, especially salad
Prices are high
No juice
No kids menu
No guest WiFi in combination with bad cellphone reception
Limited parking..."
Vitaly Ivanov
"My family and friends have been going to Drew's Bayshore bistro for years! Always a delicious meal with great service. Definitely need reservations...."
Walter Vashey
"I never leave reviews and after last nights dinner I am compelled to. Truly the best meal we’ve ever had, and we LOVE to eat out and try new..."
Megan Ford
"BYOB!
The food is a must try. My hat goes off to the Chefs. Keep up the good work. The service is a team effort, pleasant, and attentive. Everything..."
Jesse Fig
"After a few failed attempts at getting food to go I finally did this past Friday and all I can say is that they didn't disappoint. The food was..."
"Lenora's is a Mexican Coffee Shop with all American flavor. The Vegetable Omelette comes with pieces of Spinach, Red Peppers and Onions. The home..."
Maravillosa
"If I had the ability and the authority I would definitely give this restaurant a Michelin Star. The restaurant is very clean and well maintained. The..."
Justin Hoffer
"In the quaint adorable town of Keyport on W. Front street this place is a hidden gem. The atmosphere is uniquely decorated and very homely..."
Brian Pachman
"A local gem. Lenora's Cafè has amazing American and Mexican dishes. Had their French Toast, which was super fluffy amd flavorful. My husband had..."
Michelle Watkinson
"Pancakes had good flavor but they did pick up the taste of something else on the griddle. I hear the sandwiches are great so I’ll try one of those..."
Cheryl Bacigalupi
"Love stopping in for breakfast. Nice quit atmosphere. Food is great. Lots of omlet options. Great prices. Also nice area to just walk around in..."
"Nick another lovely visit!!! Another delish meal & excellent service!! We even got to see you - no matter how briefly!! Haha! The place was rocking..."
Trish Connors-Angeli
"Love this place - believe the hype. Great wait staff, and the food was probably the best diner food i have ever had. well..."
Brian Teevan
"I highly recommend this diner. From the soup to dessert it was delicious. All three of us had awesome food which was not normal for any diner. I..."
Anne Marie Brabant-Mousseau
"I am a real estate agent and I am always looking for great local spots to eat at. The wait wasn't too bad. The fact that there was a wait is always..."
Ryan Brown
"Was at the Broad Street Diner in Keyport yesterday with friends for the first time! Had a delicious salmon with Cajun shrimp dinner, also served..."
Maryjo McGrath Erdek
"I love this place the food is so good and you get so much for a great price. But most important is the staff here is so friendly and very hard..."
Susan Kane
"Outstanding. We loved the food. My smoked brisket hash with eggs was excellent. Portions are large, but not unmanageable. Attentive service - our..."
Steve Scott
"We stumbled upon this diner hidden in Keyport. We will definitely visit again, great atmosphere, food was very good, and the service was..."
Jeanine Ciprello
"This place is an awesome Jersey diner find! The staff are friendly, definitely get your money's worth on food portions. It's fast and hot the food. I..."
Blondie 205
"This is a small classic diner. Their food is quite good, especially their breakfast.
The place could be a bit cleaner, and sometimes we encountered..."
Ron M
"Very Cool Retro Diner. What Sets Broad Street Diner Apart From Many Others Is Their Extensive Menu. In Addition To The Standard Diner Favorites Are A..."
Marc Stephens
"The coffee is amazing.
I stopped in for just a black coffee and it is fantastic. I went back inside for a second larger size to go. The staff is..."
Damian B
"Definitely earned its spot as NJ's best diner. I recommend you try the biscuits and gravy when you go here as they are the best tasting biscuits and..."
Vovik
"Food was amazing can't wait to go back food was amazing nice cute little spot perfect for breakfast or lunch. I had the best..."
chastity vega
"The food is always delicious! I always get the Belly Buster; a lot of food for just 10 dollars! This diner is very popular, so be prepared to wait a..."
Viviana Beckford
"We are definitely going back! What an amazing experience small very homely with delicious..."
"The best subs in Jersey!! We drive there from South River. Worth the ride!! My go to meal is Italian sub with a Stewart root beer... Yummo!!! Love..."
Eileen Ann
"The best subs you could ever eat, with the best staff! No sub will ever compare to a 'Mike's..."
Christie Pedersen
"By far one of the best subs I have ever had! The entire team here makes you feel like family! Great place to..."
Dean Bennett
"Haven't been here in years after moving out of New Jersey, but got a chance to bring my wife for her first visit. She absolutely loved it, and it was..."
Marc Koellhoffer
"The best subs in Jersey. I've been eating their subs for 50 years and they are just as good today as the first one I..."
Bill Larkin
"Stopped tonight for the first time in a while. Best sub around, no..."
Betsy Alverson
"Best subs in America!!! I have been eating here Going on 30 years I love the family I love the food I miss the old Boardwalk but the water is the..."
Topher Sakofsky
"I've been coming here since I moved to Keyport back in 1995. The best subs around and the owners are..."
Nichole Schumann
"Basically the same as it ever was growing up as a Keyport kid in the 60s, 70s and 80s. They are the absolute best sub sandwiches...."
Joseph Neff
"All their subs are always fantastic. Bread is always fresh and soft, the way it's suppose to be and they make the BEST roast beef with provolone I..."
Tricia S. Starnes
"Best sub sandwiches around! Can't beat the..."
Jill Kennedy
"love these guys...been going here for years..always awesome....after Sandy rebuild they kept their prices down. The picture was taken on their grand..."
Barb DurchakCrosby
"Been going there since I was very very young ! Still the great subs I remember !!!! Great to visit with them today !!!!!..."
Kathy Thomas
"We make the 1/2 hour trip just for MIKES SUBS ! A family favorite! Always the..."
Nicole Oakley
"My father brought me to Mikes for the first time today, has an amazing family atmosphere that immediately makes you feel like home as soon as you..."
Jason Hennelly
"Excellent Italian Sub - not too much oil or Italian taste, but the bread and meat were very fresh. The staff were courteous, the meat provided was..."
Albert K
"Great price for a great sub. The staff was crazy kind and courteous. Fast and efficient, you'll get your sub in like a minute. My only gripe is it's..."
Billy
"I have eaten here several times and it's been an excellent sandwich each..."
Akavar Dylutra
"Best subs in New Jersey, hands down . Same location, same family, same great food...."
John Bulatowicz (Bluto)
"This place has the best subs hands down. We take all our out of town guests here. Now every time they come over it’s “we are going to mikes for..."
Suzana McRae
"Such an amazing family business. They are all incredibly dedicated to the art of sandwich making and it shows. They were able to put together a last..."
Devin Patel
"Half sub is the same size as everyone else's full sub. Really friendly staff and food was..."
"Ray is one of the sweetest business owners in Keyport. Thanks for all the scoops!..."
Justin Tarahomi
"This is a great ice cream joint in beautiful Keyport. Where it stands out is in their ices and their staff. They always provide exceptional device...."
James S. Borg
"Really different Italian ice, not overly sweet and with a nice texture. Perfect selection for anyone's preferences, if you want to try something..."
Glam Lady
"They have so many choices. Be prepared to taste a few before making your final decision. Had the Chocolate Jelly Roll Italian Ice this evening and it..."
Joseph Casper
"Been goin to this place for years and it will never disappoint me. They're always super friendly and the choices are always awesome! Thanks for..."
Devin Bailey
"Delicious ice cream and Italian ice at a fair price. Many flavor choices. Great location on West Front Street. You can eat in or walk right across..."
Ann McIlmurray
"I had the chocolate peanut butter cup and chocolate chip mint both were delicious. The peanut butter cup actually tasted like Reese's Peanut Butter..."
"The cleanest place and best fast cooked fish. I drive 20 miles to get there and it's well worth..."
Linda Ann
"Food is sssoooo good. Either get a platter or seafood sandwich with fries. Even buy fish by the pound off the..."
Becky Thorne Manganelli
"Been going to Keyport Fishery for 60 years. Have never had a bad meal. Had flounder sandwich. Delicious � scallops were the best. Can never go..."
Karen Nebus
"Awesome fishery been around a long time serving a fresh selection of seafood everyday and it’s always crowded and busy. It’s a must go to..."
Colleen Michele Balog
"The best of the best! I bought flounder and shrimp sandwiches that were just as delicious as the first time I had one back in the 60’s..."
Karen Sutphin
"Great food.. Love their New England clam chowder...Everything is always super fresh...Only small complaint is there's to much onion flavor in the..."
Becky Jones
"I love this place. The seafood is great, freshly cooked and one can sit at the water & enjoy their meal surrounded in..."
Patricia King Brown
"The absolute most amazing seafood I have had. I recommend the soft shell..."
Nick Chit
"They will have a set down place soon but I love buying my dinner and set by the water and eating that's the..."
Steven Lynch
"Excellent, as always. Our family has been going to Keyport Fishery since I was a kid. They have the freshest, best fish anywhere in the..."
Linda Shaner
"Food is great, reasonable and worth the wait. Don't let the lines fool you, they move..."
Karen McGivney Marcotullio
"Wow, this place is a blast from the past. Not a 5 star diner but the food was good and a great value at 10 bucks a plate. Got our sandwiches and..."
Mike ajax
"If you are in the mood for Seafood, then Keyport Fisheries is a spot that you can check out. With a variety of seafoods ranging from shell fish to..."
Angel Luis
"The BEST fish and chips I have ever had. Ordered fish and shrimp platter. It was very good. Hot, fresh and tasty. I ordered the New England clam..."
Shirley S
"After reading the reviews, I had to bring my family to this venerable seafood spot. About two weeks ago, I drove about 45 minutes with my family to..."
Will A
"This place is iconic. Been coming here for years. They serve the freshest fish. Get it fried or take home fresh fish. The waterviews are great and..."
Chad Simons
"My friends and I stopped by Keyport Fishery to get some takeout to bring to the beach. Every player ordered was delicious. The fishery only does..."
"I had a surprise 75th party for my dad. All together in my party was 16, 12 adults and 4 kids. We picked the $30/person option.. I want to say what..."
Lauren Ann
"I go there quite often with my family and highly recommend this restaurant the food is great especially my favorite the calamari and the American..."
Sharon McCarthy Keegan
"Great place. Church converted to a restaurant. Very different & trendy. Staff and Manager Joe were great. Came around several times to check on..."
Dave DiPasquale
"Had an awesome time. Rented the upstairs for a party, the staff, food and drinks were excellent. I highly recommend this..."
David Finnerty
"I have been there a bunch of times. I love the buffalo chicken pizza and the calamari is my favorite!!!! Highly recommend..."
Jaclyn Marie
"Great food and great service. The outside bar eating area is perfect for watching the game and enjoying the beautiful weather. Tiffany was our..."
Jennifer Ann
"Tried this place for the first time for Restaurant Week. Warm and cozy atmosphere, both inside and out. Great menu (both regular and Restaurant..."
Rick Keller
"This was our first time eating at Old Glory . The hostess was pleasant and efficient seating people immediately. Our waitress Capri was friendly..."
David Basile
"We recently had a small wedding where we had a small private party in their Lounge the food was excellent staff was wonderful I would suggest this to..."
Robert Dombroski
"One of the most coolest restaurants I’ve been to since moving from Florida!! Ambiance, food and service = 5stars!!! We will be back again and..."
Brigitte Rivera Hofmann
"Old Glory does comfort food very well and has something for everyone. Anything from burgers to a delicious pumpkin ravioli. Recently had the seafood..."
Isaac Kremer
"Everything here is always delicious! We had appetizers coconut shrimp and a phenomenal jalepeno dip! I had the Angus hanger which was fantastic and..."
Teresa Paris
"Hit or miss but the tomato bisque and the meatballs are excellent! The shrimp skewers, not so much. They need to grill them as they come out boiled..."
Nicole Beckler
"Food was really tasty the chicken wings were a little and not all the way but a bit burnt that’s what held back the 5th star I Diddnt complain..."
Matthew “Matty ice”
"Parking on the premises but also street parking available. This was my third visit. Place has a good vibe. Indoor and outdoor dining. Noise level a..."
Snooki D
"We had chili wings, hot wings, crab cakes, chicken-bacon-ranch pizza and more and it was all absolutely Delicious!! Rum buckets were Great! Great..."
Lynn Wegner
"The food was delicious. The appetizers were the best part this go around. But it was our first time going with family who really likes it there. I..."
Lynsey Camacho
"Stopped in this awesome place for the NFC Championship Game on Sunday night. Jade was nothing short of amazing!! She was the hostess, the bartender..."
"My husband and I recently had a party here following our sons Baptism. Kenny and his staff were very attentive and accommodating. From planning and..."
Mackenzie Chalk
"McDonagh's Pub
2 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735
Irish Pub
Vincenza Buffalino
We went. Tonight, Sunday night, for lobster night. $12.95 for 1 pound..."
Angel Buffalino
"Meeting w/ the Boys to watch the Giants game
We ordered up grilled foot long hot dogs, Pretzel Sticks, and my Pals have some great beer bucket..."
Richard Molinari
"Amazing time. Food was yummy. Our server Victoria is the best. She is attentive kind and knowledgeable. She handled our table if 20..."
Carol Chmielewski
"Tonight at dinner I was reminded of how fantastic the staff and service is at mcdonaghs.
We had my daughters baptism luncheon here a few weeks ago..."
Kristen Harnischfeger
"We were there Monday night August 6th for my son’s birthday. The food was very good our waiter he was very attentive to us. We played bingo 2..."
Joanne Bozzone Santasieri
"Really enjoyed this place! Clean, fun & true pub feeling! Our waiter Carlton went above and beyond to make our experience wonderful! Food was in true..."
Doreen Doe
"Great food friendly environment good music and our server David was awesome we will be..."
Jill Manno Ward
"Went Sunday had a great early dinner, food was great, waiter was awesome!!! I’m just upset that I got disqualified from the rubber ducky race..."
Phyllis Phyl Smith
"Went there to watch the fight had the time of my life. The beer was on point. The Shepard pie and Irish stew were amazing I can't wait to go again..."
Adrian Karl Davalos
"Every visit has been a pleasure.
Good food , staff and brew and atmosphere.
This place don’t suck,..."
Joe Norris
"Keyport is a nice little area with some good eats and this is one of them. Last night was our second time there and the food was delicious. We had..."
Tony Cavallaro
"Been to McDonagh’s pub a few times. Love the outside as they now serve pizza out there. I do like their burgers, plenty of taps and staff is..."
GoodoleEats Good
"Family and I went there for valentines this year
By far best it’s ever been everything was perfect from the views of downtown Keyport to the..."
Matthew “Matty ice”
"Went to this bar on Sunday over Memorial Day weekend. Our server Steph was amazing, so friendly and nice and very helpful!! Band was also very good!!..."
Bridget Samaritano
"We went a few weeks ago and weren't big fans of the food or service but decided to give it another chance today and had a way better experience. We..."
Christine Hartman
"Walked the town's local area of shops and took in the waterfront in the afternoon. McDonagh's colorful outdoor appearance drew us in. We grabbed some..."
Roberta F
"Wow since Covid this place in the heart of Downtown has gone through some nice renovations and improvements!! The staff, servers and bartenders were..."
"normally go to a nearby chain place for breakfast and there was a long wait so we decided to try this place. Couldn't be happier, food was great,..."
Lisa Lauer Lynch
"I was upstairs at a group event. The room there is very nice and perfect for a group of 75. A flat screen TV is available and bathrooms on the..."
Jonathan Toborowsky
"can't have keyport hangs without the yellow rose. staff has always been super nice and if you don't try the country fried steak, you're a..."
Joel Monet
"My husband and I have been going to breakfast here every Sunday for a few years. Often we bring the kids and grandkids too. Annmarie and the staff..."
Irene Renie Reilly
"Janine, is attentive, friendly and one of the best waitresses we have ever had the pleasure of being served from. The menu is vast and the prices are..."
James Bowman
"Best pancakes ever
Service good all the diner greats
I had the Philly cheesesteak..."
Miquel Torrente
"Always a childhood staple. Still the best place for family and friends to feel welcomed and enjoy great food and friendly..."
Rhiannon Tooker
"Impeccable service and food good
Definitely recommend..."
Kathy Hornreich
"Good waitress service, large portions, excellent food, and a Senior menu for ages FIFTY FIVE (55) and up. Ample parking and easy to get to from..."
Ron Berreman
"We have ordered numerous different items from the menu and have always been pleased with what we ordered. The soups , entrees , and desserts have..."
Pat Jorgensen Perhacs Szollosi
"I liked it there. Had steak n eggs for breakfast with my wife. Food was VERY..."
Dave Martin
"Excellent bacon Swiss cheese burger & fries. ☆☆☆☆☆ Thanks, Great service too, Emma..."
Steve Daly
"Good Food, Great Coffee.
Fast service and a polite..."
Robert Ocasio
"Great food and wonderful staff! I highly recommend..."
Lori Reynolds Sujew
"Great atmosphere, Great food and Great price! My favorite pit..."
Frank Rapisardi
"Food is great the people who work there are the best always very friendly and warm feels like..."
Joyce Zweidinger
"Great breakfast! Terrific service! Wonderful people! So homey! Stayed an extra half hour just drinking coffee and enjoying the atmosphere. Loved..."
Terri Donato
"This was my st time ever here. I had heard stories about it being great from my Wife and her Family. (Ohio Native) They we're not wrong. The service,..."
Herby Deal
"The cowboy burger was super great. Came here with someone during elderly hour. It is not bad at all with the elderly. It was really cute, the staff..."
Victor Cano
"My first time coming here. I'm here on vacation flew, in from PR on our way to Hazlet from Newark airport we deicide to go there cause my..."
"The dinner was excellent and got your money's worth from soup to desserts 😃😁
When I got here it wasn't busy to when I left it started to get..."
DevthegamingartistYT
"Me and a friend decided to have dinner here for the first time this weekend. After being seated we were promptly attended to greeted by our waitress..."
Joanne Occhipinti
"I have been coming regularly to the Town and Country diner since September…. Twice a month for our ski club meeting, and frequent other visits for..."
Gillian Dewis
"Our group of friends were there last night to see Strictly 60s they were fantastic. Our waitress was Michelle who was also the bar maid she did one..."
PAT Hudak
"Great menu selection of large portions. Friendly staff, especially Lindsay! So attentive and energetic! Nice to have a place to sit, relax and enjoy..."
Nina Angulo
"Our ski club has our bi-weekly meetings at the Town and Country. We also had our kickoff party there back in Nov 2021. The overwhelming consensus..."
davebones1
"On Thursday February 17, 2022 my family had dinner at Town & Country Diner. We called ahead because we needed a place to eat in between viewings of..."
"This was our second time at Burlew's. It is your new favorite place. Outside dining, casual, staff is friendly and on point! I have loved everything..."
Stacy Linn Stockton
"We had stopped in for a quick lunch and instead enjoyed a beautiful afternoon with great food, ( I highly recommend the scallops ), a beautiful view..."
"So glad we went off our route to have lunch here! It was lunchtime on a Wednesday, so they weren't very busy. Service was exceptional, understandably..."
Jason Brockert
"Both mine and my husbunds meals was perfect. Took half home. I had salad he had the soup and our entrees was perfect. Me 8 fried jumbo scallops with..."
Dawn Gargano
"Our food has always been AWSOME + so much food we have to take some home for later. We eat there at least 1 to 3or 4 times a week. For breakfast,..."
Grace Dunn
"To me this is a hidden gem. Love their chicken scampi or marsala. Sundays are the best because of the cream of Turkey soup! The staff are so nice..."
Hoppy Hour Chicken Tenders and Buttermilk Pancakes
French Toast Strawberry Sundae
Steak and Eggs
Tilapia Spinach Red Potatoes Garlic Bread
Coffee Regular
Pancakes
Stale Dry Pancakes
Crepes with Strawberry
Spinach Mushroom and Swiss Omlette
Pumpkin Pancakes
Colorado Omelette
T-Bone Steak & Eggs
Bananas Foster French Toast
Strawberry Banana Pancakes
Cupcake Pancakes
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Funny Face Pancake Combo
Chicken Fried Steak Breakfast
Breakfast Sampler Platter
Burger with Fried Egg
Sit down
American
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I love this place. It doesn't get as busy as it used to but it still offers the same favorites I love. The food here is delicious, the wait staff are..."
Nikki Aouaki
"Here's the scoop: the servers/staff were all very personable. There was a table in front of us who didn't thank they're server and as they walked by..."
"Amazing food !! Amazing view !!
Friendly staff with a pool table near marinas shopping in downtown Keyport
Very very worth the stop
The calamari was..."
Matthew “Matty ice”
"We love this place. Debbie greeted us and she was warm, genuine and gregarious.
Our server was professional, knowledgeable and attentive.
Food was..."
John Stains
"Wally Danielle and staff was awesome great food and I mean amazing clam chowder. L absolutely loved the decor reminded me of an old cabin
Really..."
Raymond Tozer
"Excellent bar food. Great and friendly staff. Cold Beers. Great outdoor seating and..."
Michael William Majorczak
"Love this cool joint! Great pub grub and fantastic bartenders! We will be back..."
Karolyn Wray
"Bill threw an amazing party for my husband's 50th birthday, definitely recommend for party or night out. We love this place ❤ Best pizza, seafood..."
Elizabeth Kay
"Delicious food and really great specials. Ordered King Crab w/fries for $34.99 and a snow crab special for $17.99. Food and service were great. The..."
Jeannie Caccioppoli
"Great friendly local bar with awesome juke box selection and great sound system. I love their food, just wish their menu had more salads on it. Love..."
"I ordered wings a few months ago didn’t enjoy them I reached out to them they corrected it and my food was delicious but also they are so friendly..."
kristina alvarez
"I wanted to thank the crew at Domino's in Cliffwood New Jersey for paying it forward to me. Due to my Direct Express debit card declining even though..."
Sheila Beltagy
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes