Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Long Valley
3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Surprising that in an area with so many pizzarieas, pezzo just came in and bested them all. Easily the place to eat and take out for Italian in Long..."
Christian Schmidt
"Food was delicious, service was excellent and priced for excellent value. They serve one of the best garlic breads I have ever..."
Kenneth J. Gross
"Delicious food, huge portions, and reasonable prices. It's a great..."
Danae Heywood
"Went with my daughter and granddaughters, a very good sausage..."
Dennis Scheifele
"Great food! Best pizza ever!!!
Good prices for good..."
Barbara Quirk
"Best pizza I have had in a long time. Definitely will be going back..."
Brenda Embrey-brown
"This place is GREAT! Friends told us about it, and the menu selection is superb, and the pizza is phenomenal. Finally, a "real" Italian restaurant in..."
Paul Tupaczewski
"If I am looking for specialty pizza, I go here. They have regular pizza, but how can you not choose from one of the MANY specialist pies that the..."
Kurt Gibbons
"I've only had their slices (chicken parm, buffalo chicken, chicken milanese, pepperoni, mushrooms, an arugula one with fresh mozzarella and plain). ..."
Steve Angeli
"Grandma pie perfection! Mussels in red sauce, calzones, shrimp scampi, shrimp fra diavolo, buffalo chicken wraps, pasta fagioli...ALL of it, just..."
Peggy Dispenza
"Wow! I just stopped by here in passing. It was already after 1:00, but there was only one empty table and a line for takeout. I only had two plain..."
Thomas Murzenski
"The owner and everyone working there was incredibly nice and the pizza is top notch. Would highly..."
Andrew P
"I was out with family shopping for christmas trees in the area, stopped in at pezzo.. Picked up a chicken arugala pie and a meat lovers ..mom..."
Tatiana Gonzalez
"The best pizza I’ve ever had! I know, I know, that sounds like a cliche. Let me expound. I’m 50 years old, a lifelong NJ resident and I’ve been..."
Daniel Sienkiewicz
"Had a wonderful Dinner here, the girl behind the counter recommended a Chicken Arugula Pie... WOW... Great advice .. thanks..."
Angel Gonzalez
"Best pizza in Long Valley. They don’t deliver. But amazing..."
Stephen Galgocy
"We originally were gonna go across the street after we went pumpkin picking at ort farms however, they could not seat my whole family at that time..."
Catherine Compitello
"Best pizza in Long Valley and around Morris County. Even the personal pizza is 12 inch, so it's good for 2 people. Thin crust is crispy and the..."
Lucy K
"Not a complicated review. It's good pizza, but is a touch..."
Matthew Marino
"Solid pizzaria. Fresh quality, high volume, good food. Always fully staffed and efficient. I wish this place was near my..."
Dan McArdle
"Most reliable Italian restaurant in the area. Great food. Eat in, take out service. It's been around for about 10 years now, so has a solid..."
Gregory Adams
"Regular pizza nights or super bowl blow outs. They handle it all with no dip in quality. REALLY REALLY GOOD..."
"Got a chef salad and a meatball slice. They were very good! I'll go back and get pictures next time I go. It says "Phil's pizza" out front right now..."
bob m
"Food is good, but the last two times they got the order wrong. I order online through the Slice App so it’s in writing and I don’t have to deal..."
Garrett Szibdat
"Pizza is good, hit or miss on the wings, sometimes great, sometimes just..."
Andrew P
"Management ensures that their customers are completely satisfied, excellent pizza for an even better price. Must check..."
Jacob Lazar
"Delivery took forever but the za was really good so I'm not even..."
"Landed here by chance but it was our lucky day we did. The service and the food was phenomenal. Marianna was a sweetheart, and she attended to our..."
Jas Saw
"This place was not even on the Pizza Hunters App list for the day, but we are glad that we had the chance to stop. Ronaldo was an amazing host, even..."
Chuck Mound
"This place is the hidden gem in Long Valley. It's small, but the pizza is the best in town. What people don't realize is how fantastic the food is..."
Adam Wormann
"Authentic Italian food, very good food, good service, it feels like family owned, because they are very accommodating and friendly, loved this place..."
Thomas Naturale
"I had the Buffalo Chicken Tenders and Chicken Parmesan over Capellini. First time there and I'd definitely go..."
Andrew Lowe
"Our family had a delicious meal here this afternoon after pumpkin picking. Our crew of six had yummy potato balls as an appetizer, then salmon,..."
Patricia Monk
"After looking for a new pizza place due to increasing prices, I found Cornerstone Pizzeria which was recommended by a friend. And I gotta say,..."
Tim Stolarz
"Your mom and pop place. Pizza is great, not sure about other more elaborate dishes such as lasagna though. Can't beat the price. You can take out or..."
Alex F. Lazo
"My wife and I decided to go out for some pasta, decided to try out this place after seeing some reviews.
We had gnocchi and fettuccines we both left..."
ED alle
"The food is delicious! The owners are very friendly! I would recommend Cornerstone to hungry people who long for delicious, reasonably priced..."
Karen Parkin-Demmons
"We had a lovely experience for dinner here this evening. Sitting outside was so serene and relaxing compared to the hustle of NYC. We ordered the..."
Myra Melcer
"This place is amazing. The owners are originally from Sicily, and they serve up Jersey Italian food just like Mama would make it. Sometimes they even..."
Edana Kleinhans
"Their pizza is great and is our go-to. Prices are reasonable. Took our family here for a sit-down dinner, and it was absolutely fantastic. ..."
Adam Wormann
"I've ordered so far from cornerstone pizzeria and both times I've gotten the Penne carbonarra and both times it was delicious like out of this world..."
Trishina Trimmer
"Solid pizza. Restaurant smelled great, but we only had a pie. Bottled beer only, but a good selection of it. Great staff. Owner's a true gem. ..."
Michael Testinsky
"I've only ever ordered food for pickup and it's always been fantastic. Authentic Italian food made by authentic Italian..."
Marco Sanna
"The owner (or one of them) was nice enough to make a fresh pie for the two little kids I was babysitting even though they were set to close within 10..."
Miranda Maniscalco
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes