Best Patty Melt in Mackinac Island

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sea Biscuit Cafe
100/100 (3 ratings)
Restaurants
Bars & Pubs
American
Cafe
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Drinks
Breakfast
Cheese Crock
Eggs Benedict
Arancini
Chicken Wings
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Breakfast Burrito
French Dip
Carnitas Nachos
Smoked Whitefish Dip
Whitefish and Chips
Perch Taco
Irish coffee
Blake's Rotating Cider
Avocado toast
Spiced Bloody Mary
Whitefish Reuben Sandwich and Sweet Potato Fries
Patty Melt
World Famous Derby Burger
Nashville Hot Chicken
American
Café
Seating
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Television
Sports bars
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Late Night
Breakfast
Seabiscuit Cafe
Seabiscuit Cafe
83/100 (2876 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
American
Bar
Pub
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Breakfast
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Beef
Breakfast Burrito
Avocado toast
Tacos
French Dip
Carnitas Nachos
Lobster
Smoked Whitefish Dip
Nachos
Whitefish and Chips
French Toast
Perch Taco
Toasts
Pasta
Blake's Rotating Cider
Falafel
Salad
Spiced Bloody Mary
Fish & chips
BLT
Wings
Sandwiches
Patty Melt
Jambalaya
Mac and cheese
Burger
Nashville Hot Chicken
French Dip
Whitefish Reuben Sandwich and Sweet Potato Fries
Hamburgers
Eggs Benedict
Gyros
World Famous Derby Burger
Arancini
Fish
Chowder
Cheese Crock
Chicken Wings
Fish & Chips
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Pork
Tapas
Shrimp
Cheeseburger
Irish coffee
Fish Taco
Sit down
Bar
Pub
American
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"This intimate place has the best of everything. The staff are amazing and friendly and the food is off the charts! Justified Lettuce Wraps, Painted..."
Lisalee Chism Hogue
"Came to the island for our honeymoon..this is by far the best service and food we've had yet! Lisa is amazing, along with the bacon and other..."
Stephanie Hakim
"Great dinner and then another great meal at breakfast this morning. The true “go to” restaurant on the Island. Reasonable and tasty craft..."
Sarah Olson-Rosenbaum
"We always enjoy stopping here while we're on the Island. The food is ALWAYS delicious and the staff has always been great with each visit. We usually..."
MagikGal
"Whitefish & chips were very good. My mom got the pulled pork grilled cheese. Both amazing! The grilled cheese was the perfect blend if cheese and..."
Samantha Garland
"Amazing food! The staff were very friendly. Great place to eat if you have a gluten sensitivity or celiac... lot of..."
The Refner Family
"We decided to stop at the Seabiscuit Cafe for a late lunch. We ordered the Painted Pony Macaroni appetizer and it was delicious. My husband ordered..."
Ruth Ann Sommers
"So far to me best food at least on the main drag. Bbq wings, the French dip, fried Mac & cheese. Everything I've seen looks excellent. Nice pub feel...."
Adventure Rhoades
"Delicious whitefish Reuben sandwich !! Complete it with sweet potato fries. Whitefish dip appetizer with naan bread and salted crisps was fabulous...."
adamltw
"We stopped in to have a light lunch. We ordered the cup of whitefish chowder with the whitefish dip. The chowder was amazing. The dip was also..."
Donna Smith
"We stopped at Seabiscuit for lunch after we arrived on the island. Great service, the drinks were delicious and the food was amazing. The smoked..."
Elizabeth Jeane
"Great seafood! Expensive, but worth it. The fish was out of this world! Fish dip was awesome as well. Friendly staff, cool..."
E F
"The Seabiscuit Cafe offers a simple and delicious menu with a full bar. Their service is very friendly and are great with making recommendations or..."
Cody Weikel
"The place so nice we ate here twice. The wife and I were on our 10yr anniversary and stopped for supper. My burger was awesome and the wife had fish..."
Ninji522
"Love the ambiance of this place - really great decor and friendly staff. Food was really good too... the burgers had a really nice flavor to them and..."
Brian Thompson
"Stopped in for dinner last night and it was a great choice. The pulled pork sandwich was fantastic, and my kid loved their classic American..."
Mandy Gooding
"We were fortunate to visit Mackinac Island twice during 2023. Both visits included a meal at Seabiscuit Cafe as you can always count on a good food..."
David Tchozewski
"Our dinner was satisfactory. I had fried whitefish with coleslaw and fries, my dinner partner had a cup of whitefish chowder and strawberry salad. My..."
Nicky Yu
"I haven’t had good dining experiences at Mackinaw Island, however, sea biscuit Cafe was excellent. Autumn, our server was Excellent. She got a..."
Roger Cortez
"Enjoyed a wonderful lunch at Seabiscuit Cafe. Tomato Basil soup and Grilled Cheese Sandwich. The weather was chilly, so a hot coffee & Baileys hit..."
Brian Sawa
"We arrived to a Mackinac Island in the evening and were hangry. A pleasant surprise was Seabiscuit. We were greeted by Hannah, the hostess who talked..."
Robert Bozeman
Mustang Lounge
Mustang Lounge
81/100 (2210 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
American
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Beef
Jumbo Shrimp Fajitas
Patty Melt
Pork
Impossible Burger
caesar salad
Quesadilla
Boneless Wings
Prime rib
BBQ Brisket Burger
Pasta
Pretzel Bites
Salad
Tater Tots
Wings
blt Dip
Chili
Coney Dogs
Mac and cheese
Burger
Jumbo Shrimp Basket
Crispy Shrimp Basket
Ribs
Grilled cheese
Porky Mac and Cheese
Fish Sandwich
Tater tots
Ruben and a Beer
Nachos
Hamburgers
Mustang Punch
Chicken Sandwich
Pretzel Bite Nachos
Fish & chips
BLT
Whitefish Dip
Reuben sandwich
Mussels Diablo
Fish
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Seating
Accepts Discover
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"It was our first time at Mustang Lounge, heard about it from a recommendation on Reddit. Service was good and very fast, we got the Brisket Burger..."
Nate Weber
"Server was great. Food was delicious. Shrimp was prepared perfectly. Creative for branding the Mustang into the bun of the burgers. Prices were..."
Jason Tucker
"Great food, the patty melt was awesome. I added mushrooms and they were tasty. The ranch was really good. Service was fast and..."
Ryan Zimmerman
"Ambience is great and food is delicious. We ordered crispy chicken sandwich and crispy shrimp basket. Crispy shrimp is amazing!! Staff is friendly..."
Geethika Garikapati
"Amazing late night menu! Changes every night, and food comes out hot and fresh. Staff were super friendly, drinks are cold, food is delicious...."
Zachary Nagourney
"Food was good and the service was excellent. It was kind of down a side street and less busy than some of the other restaurants. There was some..."
Misty W
"This is a really fun joint to eat! Yeah, it's more expensive than McDonalds, and it takes longer too. Put your big boy pants on and enjoy the show...."
Infantry Shooter
"If I had to choose one restaurant to visit while on the island for food and drinks, it will be the Mustang Lounge. The staff are always friendly and..."
Jon Saelee
"Recently visited the island this past weekend and restaurant/bar hopped at night. When we went to Mustang's I had the Mustang Cider and my god it was..."
Laila Jamaleddin
"I loved the delicious food and the staff was very welcoming and very..."
Jimmy King
"Stopped for a cocktail/beer on our walk around the island. Really liked the atmosphere... Oldest bar in..."
Cindy Woolery Anderson
"Food was very good & so we're the drinks. The prices were high, but to be expected on the island. Service was..."
Nikki Bixby
"The wait at this restaurant was pretty short, but the restaurant was pretty busy which was great. The service was great and the food even better. I..."
George Shara
"Food was great, service was exceptional. Our server was helpful, kind and funny! Nice place for dinner on Mackinaw if you're looking for a less..."
Dana Lentz
"After a long day of the exploring the island this place was perfect to refuel. The staff was friendly and fast! The patty melt (add mushrooms) was so..."
Lauren Wolf
"Summer drink menu was excellent! We also had a bloody and it was very good! Loved the inside decor and a plus is the outside is dog friendly! We had..."
Alan
"Nice, laid back atmosphere! Pizza was delicious! One of the more affordable places to eat on the island during spring..."
Elizabeth Dawes