Best Key Lime Pie in Madison

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Il Goccino
Il Goccino
89/100 (589 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Panna Cotta
Squash
caesar salad
Pear Salad
Ravioli
Cheesecake
Penne alla Vodka
Tiramisú
Grilled chicken
Swordfish
Veal
Key Lime Pie
Pasta
Rice Pudding
Simple Spaghetti
Salad
Cioppino
Tortellini En Brodo
Salmon
Champagne Sauce
Salmon Stuffed with Crabmeat
Pesto
Pork
Prosciutto di parma
Italian
BYOB
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Had an amazing Mother's Day dinner this afternoon. Our waiter Tony, along with the entire staff, offered outstanding service and the chef offered..."
Gregg Nardozza
"Great family fun business. Food and service top notch. Al the owners son a real gentleman. Service total team effort. Specials were great value for..."
Pat Perrella
"We’ve been coming here since they opened and every time the food is amazing, the service impeccable and quality beyond five stars. Al and staff..."
Kristen Esposito
"Food and service always excellent. Al and the staff are very accommodating and friendly. We have recommended this restaurant to our friends and..."
Rosemary Gatta LaPenna
"Great food and even better customer service! Would definitely recommend it to anyone in the..."
Mark Kalladeen
"The perfect Italian restaurant! Amazing food and amazing staff. Ask for Julio and you'll never be lacking for..."
Nancy Rector
"I rate this restaurant 10 star... staff extraordinary... cook outstanding... food absolutely and positively deeeeelicious!! Not even knowing anything..."
Gerry Carlone
"Must be the creamiest Buffalo Mozzarella outside of Battipaglia, Italy. Also, the Polo or Veal Milanese.... Thin as they get, crispy on the outside..."
Cesar Jacques Chekijian
"We found ourselves here on the day after the opening. Food was fabulous and atmosphere warm and welcoming. BYOB. Save room for dessert. We will..."
Kim Holtzman Rowe
"Just stumbled upon this restaurant the other night. So glad we did. We all enjoyed our meal. Excellent!! Can’t wait to go..."
Kimberly Kepler Higgins
"The best Italian Restaurant I ever been too. My kids love it as well. Will definitely go back when I'm in town..."
Drew Weedon
"Delicious meal and excellent service - a great addition to..."
Christine Drobot
"Food, service and ambiance were perfect. The staff is superb. Thank you John for the excellent srrvice. I shall be a frequent..."
Jose Rivera-Benitez
"This is undeniably a hidden gem of a restaurant, offering a truly exceptional and unparalleled Italian fine dining experience. Il Goccino's stands..."
Moe Shaltout
"Enjoyed dinner tonight, Wednesday night. Food was good, service was impeccable, environment was elegant. Everyone was so nice and very welcoming...."
G Liu
"A group of us from NYC went out to Madison for a performance and art show at Drew University. We happened upon Il Goccino and were lucky enough to..."
Meenakshi C
"We had our son's wedding rehearsal there about a week ago & we cannot say enough glowing things about the restaurant, food, Alban, Arber & excellent..."
Claire Saunders
"We recently had our sons baptism party at Il Goccino and we can’t say enough great things about them. Everyone raved about the food, and the..."
Becky Yan
"The food was okay, the service looked so tired and done for the day. Other than that it was good. The portions were on the small side. The calamari..."
Melissa Renee
"This is our favorite restaurant in Madison. The food is excellent and we have especially enjoy the linguine with white clam sauce and the delicious..."
Susan Kovacs
"Excellent refined gem of an Italian restaurant. The caprese was delicious. The pasta alla Norma and chicken parm were excellent. The menu has many..."
Michael Rieger
"Excellent food and service. There were 4 of us eating there and we all liked..."
Rose
"We hosted a private event for 75 people. Food and service were excellent. Highly..."
Mary
"This is a DESTINATION Italian restaurant I am a Brooklynite and first generation Italian American who comes from a family of restaurateurs — in..."
Joseph Riggio
"My first time ever here. Was there for a birthday. The food and service are..."
Cheryl W
"Fantastic family-owned and family run restaurant. You must try the toasted almond..."
Joe Colon
"I had the special of the day Cacio e Pepe. It was the best I ever had and I had it in Rome where it was..."
Dorthy Iantosca
"This is an amazing family owned restaurant. The chef and his family own and operate it. You are treated like family here! The food has been spot on..."
Louis Schornstein
"I had an AMAZING experience here, we had the calamari, Pollo Marsala, Pollo Francese, and Tiramisu. The service was top knotch everything you could..."
Sadiya Johnson
"The minute you walk in this restaurant you feel the ambiance of calm, caring owners and staff. Once seated we were treated like royalty. I have never..."
Charlotte/Ernie Todd
"This is one of my favorite restaurants in the area! It’s a family-owned business with a wonderful atmosphere and really tasty food. Definitely try..."
Bess Rowen
Baldwin Street Grille
Baldwin Street Grille
84/100 (932 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
American
Dinner
Lunch
Monster Burger and Fries
Eggs Benedict
Fish and Chips
Key Lime Pie
French Dip
Meat Raffle
Burger
House Cheese Curds
Make Your Own Bloody Mary Bar with Chaser
Bloody and a Chaser Wisco Style
Chaser and a Bloody a La Melvin Gordon
Iced tea
Veggie Burger with Tots
Beer
Lemon Pepper
Cecina
Hand Battered Cod
Cider
Chicken Tenders and Fries
Michelada
Breakfast of Champions
Sit down
Pub
American
Bar
Reservations
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The food is great but the staff are amazing!! Definitely recommend!!! (Mac and cheese bites are amazing best in..."
Monique Lovin'Life Richardson
"This place has SUCH friendly service (yay, Mel!), and the food is always great. It's a neighborhood haunt absolutely worth checking..."
Tonia Bahr Baumgartner
"Well I was pretty sure I would not be staying when my husband opens the door for me to go inside. I was so pleasantly surprised though. The lighting..."
Kathleen Mailman
"From the outside it looks like a rustic old liquor store. Inside it's nice and clean pool table great beer selection and best of all the burgers! I..."
terry moore
"Baldwin Street Grille has all the makings of a classic neighborhood bar with the added bonus of friendly staff, and great food. I stopped by for..."
Eric Wild
"Classic Wisconsin tavern! Solid brunch and fish fry. It’s clean and cozy. People are cool about masks (meaning, they wear them when not..."
Karleen Eberle
"Madison's best dive bar by far! Stop in Sundays for a true Wisconsin experience. Bartender blows fire when packers score! Hang after the game and..."
Jarod Richter
"Great dive bar. Shake of the day is..."
Greenmarch1234