American cuisine: the best places to taste it in Mahopac
20 restaurant menus in Mahopac, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Tried the new place in town and I am impressed! The family came to celebrate my husband's Birthday and did not leave disappointed! From the friendly,..."
Audrey Hiney
"My family and I came to Prime for dinner. Everything from my peach spritzer to crab cakes appetizers to my cajun mahi mahi dinner was amazing! If i..."
VJ Gjonbalaj
"Was a regular at the previous place and also the other steakhouse in town and have to admit it’s a Huge step up from both. The place looks great!..."
Joseph Michaels
"I just left this place with my husband and 2 year old son. From the food to the service, this place is amazing! My husband had the Oscar filet and I..."
Rachel Miraglia
"We had a great experience. The specialty drinks were very good. The steaks were cooked properly and lightly seasoned. Waitstaff was very friendly..."
S Churyk
"Last night was our first time dining at Prime 957...and it definitely won't be our last! We ordered the special, which was the dry aged 40 oz. Rib..."
Diana Henley
"One of my top 5 restaurants I have been to! What a pleasant surprise, although it did come highly recommended from friends and it did not..."
Darnel Guerrier
"Had a nice dinner with family the other night. We started off our dinner with both styles of wings as well as trying the fried alligator, which was..."
"Service was great! Food amazing! Worth the 45 minute wait. The pancakes taste like a delicious piece of cake! They are bigger then the plate, so..."
Denise Mauri
"Had a WONDERFUL experience at countryside kitchen! The food is amazing, the service is outstanding and the open grill behind the counter really gives..."
Nicole Tremarzo
"amazing food every time, and so many gluten free options! comfortable environment with good music, and i love that the owners work alongside their..."
Francesca Ricci
"We arrived at 9:30 and was seated right away. Service was outstanding; no one ever asked me if my eggs were soft enough! We were asked 2 more times..."
Noreen Parrell
"First timer and pleasantly enjoyed! The New Yorker was amazing and we couldn't even finish the Countryside "Big" Breakfast. Coffee was strong and..."
Arlene Rivera
"Incredible Breakfast! Came with another person and ordered the blazin waffles and the holy cannoli. Did not disappoint, great food and portions and..."
Tomas Yafar
"Been here many times. Finally decided not to get pancakes and try an omelette instead. Had the chili omelette, and it was amazing. My Dad had the..."
"My wedding on 5/21/22 was an absolute dream! Having a bridal assistant follow me the whole night and check in on me was something I didn't know I..."
Julie Abato
"Villa Barone Hilltop Manor is the absolute most amazing place to have your wedding! You must go check out this place as a venue! I remember the day..."
Kathryn Iapaluccio
"I did my daughter sweet sixteen on March 12, 2022. I can’t even describe how beautiful it came out. They help me with everything and their service..."
Arlene Soto
"I don’t even know where to start. My (now) husband and I are in complete awe with Villa Barone Hilltop Manor. If I could give this rating TEN..."
Susan Hernandez
"We had an absolutely amazing time! The food was delicious from the cocktail hour to the cake! Villa Barone did an amazing job. The place is just..."
Gerri
"Villa barone is one of the best weddings I have tended in a long time top notch staff cater to every need they made you feel like royalty thank you..."
Frank Spignardo
"Our wedding was absolutely amazing. We could not have pictured a more perfect day. Louis and Briana were amazing and attended to us all night long...."
Melissa Vessecchia
"This venue made all my dreams come true and then some! The food was delicious! As the bride, they treated me like a queen! Thank you for making my..."
"I absolutely LOVE this place and the owner, Donna is one of the nicest women I've ever met.
The food, the atmostphere, and the employees make this..."
Veronica Frascati Cossetto
"The best kept secret, a hidden gem! We went to lunch, which was delicious & wonderful mimosas🥂
Ivana was great! She was so nice & an awesome..."
Karen Hale Rushneck
"Fantastic place. The food is out of this world with some of the best coffee that will ever grace your lips. Aside from that it is an art gallery,..."
Amanda Gordon
"A neighborhood gem. Wonderful cafe for lunch with friends, brunch with family, breakfast with the kids, or drinks and entertainment on the weekend..."
Gina Chiarella Schum
"Unique place , peacefull, old times, good healthy snacks, I always get my custom mix! Friendly,
Time slows down here. Highly..."
Zdenek Ulman
"Glad we finally made it to this place! Better than I even expected and I hear great things. I went with the curried chicken salad wrap and I am glad..."
Lora Tuttle
"I always love coming here on Saturday evenings with my husband. Such a great atmosphere with the live music and amaaaazing food. The new burgers on..."
Laura Marie Mendell
"Love this place! Warm friendly atmosphere..like sitting in your own dining room with all your friends & family ....oh yeah & the food is awesome..."
Evelyn Cheek
"The absolute best place to go!!! Amazing food,amazing drinks and even better..."
Ivana Fable
"I have been going to the Freight House shortly after it opened. I love the place!
The food is excellent
The owner, Donna is a wonderful person and..."
Susan Bonnie Good
"WOW. The vibe. The atmosphere. So welcoming and comfortable. I was greeted warmly. Enjoyed listening to, and playing some acoustic music. I ordered..."
Ethan James
"Just had the best lunch at this amazing comfy cafe.....Donna puts her heart and soul into everything she creates and you can taste it in every bite!..."
Wendy Stephanie Wulkan Jacopino
"My favorite place to go when I'm in town. Breakfast wraps are delicious!!! Fresh ingredients, warm smiles, and rad people! Love this cozy, eclectic,..."
Brooke Long
"The Freighthouse is one of the best cafes in Putnam County everything is perfect from the fabulous coffee down to the superb ambiance, not to mention..."
Andrea Marie Parente-Milioti
"Great food, friendly staff, yummy chai latte (sorry not a coffee drinker but I hear they have the best), amazing atmosphere...what more could you ask..."
Debbie Ciano
"I love the decor at the Freight House. They have outdoor seating but we came on a Sunday on a soggy weather so we were not able to enjoy our meals..."
Sh R
"Stopped off here during my long bike ride on the trail way. Loved how the ice was actually coffee in my iced coffee. Sandwich was good too! The girl..."
Rachel Grady
"This place is a little slice of heaven! The food, coffee, atmosphere, and most importantly the wonderful people who work there are all amazing. Full..."
Caitlin Franze
"Absolutely love this place! The coffee is really good and the drinks are very well made! Cute vibes and overall, definitely a great local business to..."
Sofia Haikin
"Great atmosphere. Classic music, kind staff, tasty cafe/ brunch food with creative twists. Food is fairly priced and overall a really nice place..."
Lucas Palmer
"My wife and recently moved to Putnam County from the city, and we were in search of someplace where we could chill, relax, and have fresh squeeze..."
Nathaniel Query
"Nice vibe, great coffee, yummy food, friendly staff, live music, free wifi, and pleanty of comfortable indoor and outdoor seating. Using the bike..."
Jared Fiacco
"Excellent menu. Fresh squeezed juice, yummy pancakes, local art for sale, and an adorable old time ambiance. Can't wait to go back for cocktails!..."
"Update! Whatever you do - get the fried wantons! The food is delicious! The Chinese food restaurant that we have gone to for years has really lost..."
Amanda McDonald
"Love their food but my only complaint would be that they don't wear hair nets or..."
Mrs. Atkins
"I go to this special place from time to time because I enjoy the good mood that is unique to this restaurant. The team is highly helpful and..."
"I'm from canada,I have come to visit a family tried the icecream never had anything like this one before.the owner Mr.vijay was very friendly and..."
RATNAKAR RAYAVARAPU
"My daughter has been an employee there and I’m shocked and saddened by the people who say the owner is rude or mean to his employees. He teaches..."
Polly Anna
"One of the Best Ice cream shops in the Area.The owner & Staff are always nothing short of a pleasure to deal with . I've tried many of their Flavors..."
Norman Marques
"We are lucky to have this place in our town. It's easily some of the best ice cream I've ever had. The hard ice cream flavors are creative and simply..."
John M.
"As being a recent resident of Mahopac, this ice cream spot is really good. The owner is a bit kooky, but good hearted in nature. I love the selection..."
Kay Cee
"Friendly service, ice cream was absolutely delicious and it is spotless! Best tasting ice cream I’ve ever..."
"This is one place that you can go over and over to eat we love this place very friendly staff and the food is on..."
Sonnia Gaine
"The food is absolutely amazing, I highly recommend the 32oz Porterhouse, it was simply cooked to perfection. This place will compete with any other..."
Frank Holzhay
"Amazing that what I would say, my waitress was so caring and really listened to me. The service was great. But the steak I had was the best steak I..."
Karen Kohn
"It was one of the best meals we’ve ever had! The Asian calamari was worth the trip alone! Good drinks also! Yummy lamb and steak. Absolutely..."
Paula Dinu
"Our children gave us a 50th Anniversary party last night. I can't say enough about Char Steakhouse, the food is fantastic and the service is..."
Mary Fleischman
"Had a great meal and the atmosphere was great! Our waitress was the..."
Linda Cali
"I love this place. I have never had a bad meal. The steaks are out of this..."
Terese De Natale-Lifton
"I love this place. Great food and good atmosphere. I have yet to have a bad..."
Adam Hamblin
"First time visiting Char this past Sunday. Everything was great. Our waiter, Ryan, was awesome. So friendly and accommodating. Will definitely be..."
Jaime Michelle
"Went last night for a Valentine's Day dinner and everything was excellent. Our server, Jessica, was very professional, personable and courteous. The..."
Derek Lennon
"Absolutely love them. Never had a bad meal and service is always..."
Cata LH
"Had a get together last night with a group of 11. Rick and his crew were fantastic. Nikki our waitress .... amazing! Food was top notch. I suggest..."
Jason Sampogna
"I was here last night for the first time. I had a classic steak with French fries and creamed spinach. It was cooked exactly the way I wanted it...."
George G
"I had the Tomahawk 🥩 and it was cooked to perfection it was so delicious and our service was great as well ❤️🩹 I loved the whole..."
Gregory Samuels
"Excellent place for a nice dinner. I've been there for my third time now. And have not yet been disappointed the food is great and the prices are..."
Danimalous Bearmaximus
"We've enjoyed Char Steakhouse as a favorite dinner and brunch spot for years... but hosting an event there last night took our great experience to a..."
Sandra Wimbert
"My husband and I went last night to celebrate my birthday and the entire experience was fabulous. The service was incredible (thank you Jennifer! )..."
Eliza Rose Stephens
"Awesome dinner! Our server Jessica was delightful. We really enjoyed our dinner. Will definitely come back and highly..."
Caroline Balducci
"brunch was fantastic. large servings. great price. decor can be updated. friendly staff with great..."
"I heard a lot of good things about this place so I decided to see what everybody was talking about. I had the fried chicken breast sandwich with..."
Phil Doucet
"It's so hard to find a good wing place around here that delivers. So we tried The Blue Hen, ordered 50 boneless wings, 8 different flavors and they..."
Andrew Wyka
"Wow!!!! Really, just wow!! What a menu! I can't wait to come back and have the mac-n-cheese..."
Elizabeth G. Fonda
"Great service and the food was absolutely delectable will definitely go back. Wings and brisket to die..."
Phil Vanguard Byrd
"We had lunch at the Blue Hen and everything was amazing... fried chicken, burger, salad, chicken fingers... everyone was happy and left full! We..."
Lisa Janniello OConnor
"Great food! The wings are absolutely awesome! Plenty of sauces and dry rubs to choose from. I shall return on a weekly..."
Louis Cardea
"The staff is really nice which you will see right from the entrance. The place is cozy and the food is just delicious.....Going back..."
Michael Randazzo
"These wings give me life. We were skeptical about ordering here because of how much we loved Planet Wings and absolutely hated Mahopac Wings, but we..."
Danee Wyka
"Absolutely love the boneless wings and the many choices in sauce !! The cilantro lime rice is always a favourite as well as biscuits (please bring..."
Arielle Athena
"We ordered some fried chicken party and everyone raved over how great it was! Meaty, moist, and not greasy. Definitely ordering from them..."
Sherri Feldman
"So good I could live here. Everything is..."
Ryan Foley
"Perfect. The food and the atmosphere is top notch! Love Love..."
Jess Anne
"Great food great service. Portions are generous huge boneless..."
Thomas Jay
"Food is so fresh and delicious.
I’m disappointed that I didn’t find them sooner.
Visited Twice in 10 days
I won’t go to KFC ever again.
The..."
gerard quattrucci
"Let me start with the staff. The front ladies are very friendly. Prices are reasonable. Since I found this place 3 days ago I ordered twice. I had..."
Fabiana “Faby” Cruz
"Great local place with great food at a fair price. I have taken out from here many, many times and have never been disappointed. Food is always..."
Bob Considine
"The wings are good. The hot is about a mild medium feel. The salads are very good. We've had the walnut pear with arugula salad and the roasted..."
Jill Terhune
"Stopped by the Hen after seeing reviews and having a cravin for fried chicken... Grabbed a box as it was a slappin deal and cane w/boneless wings so..."
Da Terpatraiters
"Great food. Fair prices (the boneless wings should be named boneless CHUNKS. They are not small ! ) Great amount of food for the price... VERY clean..."
James 3
"Was visiting town stopped by to get dinner for the first time. Got large grill chicken salad... was unbelievably good 👌Highly..."
"Absolutely love this place. Nothing fancy, but the food is excellent. If you are looking for a casual restaurant that serves the freshest seafood..."
Frank Schmitt
"Don't judge a book by its cover.. I drove past Rick's twice because it's in the back of a little strip mall. The exterior didn't immediately impress..."
TheTruth
"Absolutely deliciously fresh seafood. I would say the best around. Great selection of seafood to purchase and they also have a sit down area where..."
Natalia Baquero
"My wife is hooked on this place. For good reason. I've never seen a fish market so clean. And the fish so fresh. Definitely top notch fish! Only..."
Jorge Centeno
"This place is fantastic! Food was great! Calamari appetizer was beyond phenomenal! The shrimp scampi and salmon entrees were both delicious and the..."
Lou Maiello
"Super fresh food and very nice and knowledgeable..."
Amber Bayly
"Great seafood, very fresh ,great service highly recommend. Great place to get lunch to go cooked shrimp and cocktail sauce best lunch..."
natasha didonato
"Oh my god! The oysters were amazing!!!! This is my new favorite seafood store!! Thank you, Diane for having such a great store and quality..."
Michael and Nadia Whiting
"This place is my preferable site. Of all restaurants I know I prefere it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to visit this restaurant. when I..."
"Great food. Great people. Decided to have a my birthday there for my 40th after I met with the..."
peter maleszewski
"***edited*** This was a delicious salad. It reminded me from that scene in "Pulp Fiction" I've never had a 10$ milkshake. Dame that's one good..."
Paul Plateroti
"I enjoy each visit to the Carriage House, everyone have have taken here after church has always been very happy with their meal.
Each time they..."
ed cole
"I went to the Carriage House for the first time. The food was great from the French Onion soup.... To the Mushroom Onion Swiss burger.... To the..."
Debby K
"Great food, atmosphere, and staff. Looking forward to eating here again soon. Burger and wings are..."
Mike Messina
"want to mention that their service is amazing too! The restaurant has an incredible..."
Leah Knowles
"Cozy ambience. Tasty food though menu is a bit..."
Rachel Doherty
"Very cozy, real fireplace. Staff, very nice.
Simple menu, great choice of entrees.
My wife had the shrimp and clams, I had the chicken francese.
Both..."
"This place is great, and the food was awesome. I was here for a friend's family gathering after a funeral. The stuff was wonderful and helpful. My..."
Jeffrey Usher
"Excellent food & superb service – a perfect pairing! We were expecting a larger crowd for a family event, but our group was much smaller due to a..."
Val Marie
"Edit: came here for dinner during a snowy day. They were able to sit a party of 5 relatively quick (thank you weather). We ordered multiple..."
Kay Cee
"Our first time dining experience was a good one!
Monday evening, we were quickly seated outdoors. The menu offers a large variety of appetizers to..."
Czarina
"Delicious food, friendly staff but the view is what makes the place..."
Kat R
"Delicious sauce, great parmigiana veal and chicken. The breaded or dipped in flour, battered eggplant left a lot to be desired. I could not taste..."
Bruce Cohen
"Four Brothers has been my family's go to for birthday celebrations for many, many years. Today was no different. My brother, sister-in-law and I came..."
"The food here is decent... The portions are good for the price so you get what you pay for. Everything is prepared well and tastes fairly fresh. The..."
Da Terpatraiters
"I like to go with friends to this place with my highest recommendations. I go to this restaurant often. I get very good feedback from my friends...."
Joseph Woolridge
"The location is amazing! Had the brunch and it was a good deal for what you get. It's a good place to sit and relax while enjoying a drink or two..."
Natalia Baquero
"I just hosted my small 11 person wedding at Blu and it was really special. From the beginning they were extremely accommodating. The food is amazing,..."
Erica Seeger
"Such a relaxing breakfast ! Staff very friendly. Food was hot fresh and really good! The view from our table . Just beautiful.we were there in..."
Terry cal
"Scenery, service food. But all seriousness with covid going on you would think the glassware would be Spotless. 🙄 Disappointed but drank with a..."
"Great wings and ribs. Not disappointed ,worth a trip. The beans with the ribs are delish, cornbread is soft and full of flavor. Wish2 came in the..."
jdorset1 (That Dude)
"My first time here today for lunch was pleasantly surprising. I ordered the combo, which come with 2 meat choices. I chose St Louis, dry rub, and..."
Traveling Cosmos and Tacos
"Amazingly good food! If you are looking for a smoked/ BBQ place, THIS IS IT. The staff is super friendly and it has a cozy feel. We got the combo..."
Jalese Grays
"Delicious BBQ. The pastrami was the star of the show for me. The extremely warm and friendly staff makes it impossible not to come..."
Rick
"The indoor portion of the restaurant is dark and not very nice. The outdoor portion is amazing. Nice tables and fire pit section. Ample parking. Only..."
"I love the Olympic, good food, it's all a matter of opinion, but the burgers are great, and the cheesecake is the best of the..."
Skittles
"Wonderful local Diner! Nick and Veronica owners celebrated 39 years this week!!! ❤ known for fresh seafood steaks Prime Rib Pasta and divine..."
Deborah “Gourmet Mermaid Shopper”
"An amazing menu and great parking. The place has ample seating with two sides of the restaurant and equal bathroom space. The baked food in the front..."
Alcy Leyva
"Sunday breakfast was here, my first time!! Tasty corn beef hash, but I forgot that when you leave New England real maple syrup really is not a thing..."
Cassie Lee Blanchette
"Nice local diner with friendly service. The food was good but some of the dishes and utensils are old and had stains on them which was a turn off...."
Irizarry Fontanez
"I went there for an impromptu late lunch. Seated with alacrity, the service was friendly and welcoming throughout. The ambiance was nice for a diner:..."
D I
"Prime rib with horseradish cream sauce was amazing. Always looking for Primerib and never knew they had it. It was damn good as..."
"I generally don't review fast food chains, because they ate generally the same. This one has a cool little lounge area with furniture that's pretty..."
Andrew Likes To Drive Here & There
"This is my favorite DD 2go2. Always clean, friendly staff, and products you order are consistently delicious. You can sit, read, or join a..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes