Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Marco Island
12 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Spaghetti Marinara Fresh Tomatoes Garlic and Parmesan Cheese with Meatballs
Escargot
Eggplant
Little Vino
Meatballs
Pasta
Most Seafood-Plentiful Pasta Del Mar Ever
Bolognese
Salad
arrabiata
Lasagne
Crab
Martini
Carbonara
Scallops
Beef Carpaccio
Key lime pie
Clams
Calamari
House Salad
Cakes
Mussels
Chicken Marsala
Bruschette
Sit down
Italian
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Private Dining
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Late Night
Mid-range
"Excellent atmosphere, service, menu, and execution. They are able to do many dishes, gluten-free, which mattered to me. We went with a group of 15,..."
Matthew Wilson
"We had a wonderful experience at this restaurant last night. The staff was friendly and helpful. Our waiter, Yogi, provided excellent service! I had..."
Yvonne Knestrick
"My friends and I went tonight to ciao Bella and it was absolutely delicious. Everyone loved what they ordered. The atmosphere is really upscale and..."
Patsy Keigney
"Nicely decorated for the holday season. 3 people really liked their meals. My veal was tough and pretty tasteless. Ater he took our order our waiter..."
rick angstadt
"This was our first time eating at Ciao Bella. We were not disappointed. The food, the drinks, and the service were excellent. I had the spaghetti..."
Anthony Bonanni
"We always have an enjoyable experience! It's a very welcoming, comfortable, clean environment; note the salt lamp! The acoustics are excellent. ..."
Anne Arbelaez
"Absolutely cannot say too many good things about this restaurant, the food is excellent, and the service was wonderful. It happened to be my..."
Maryann Infelise
"We ask for the table in the corner to the left of the entrance that is often serviced by the bartender. They usually "save" it for 5, but will give..."
Ernie *
"My wife and I and a friend dined here this past week. We come to Marco twice yearly for years, but somehow had never dined here before. We had a..."
Michael Corriveau
"Very romantic place. Service and food were awesome. Second we walked in everyone stopped what they were doing to great us. We will be back for..."
Josh Lamb
"Delicious! Food and wine were outstanding. Great service. Very nice..."
Donna Wittmeyer
"If you get the pork chop(small roast) either go very hungry or plan on a second meal with it. Very good and..."
Raymond J Fern III
"We made reservations for 4, but had another person join us. The staff was very gracious and found another table to accommodate us. Our waitress was..."
Dawn Wideberg
"Jazmine was extremely attentive and helpful. Great cocktails and food. A must..."
Jason Landry
"Absolutely the best food in Marco Island!!! Staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming. Drinks are reasonable and delish. We have a great time every..."
"Spectacular rack of lamb and salad that I had. Good service! Environment is ok. Feels a bit more like a basement but I don’t care as long as..."
Marco Island Real Estate BROS
"Very nice place to grab a bite to eat. Fast and friendly service. The stuffed mushrooms were fantastic as was the Shrimp Alfredo. I had the Veal..."
Rick Roseberry
"Very laid back place, the food was incredible. I had the chicken sorrento and it was divine. Everyone at the table enjoyed their meal, the server was..."
edward visconti
"The band, Torched, is rocking out, and the dance floor is jumping. I’m loving the air conditioning and the clean bathroom. This is definitely a..."
Starasia Starr
"A must-do restaurant located in Old Marco. From the parking attendant, to the host, to the helpful and knowledgeable wait staff, everyone works..."
Charles Brand
"Hands down our favorite dinner spot of our whole trip. The service was super slow when we went but there are good reasons for it and all of which are..."
Jeremy Proto
"I had cheese ravioli with meatballs in the pink vodka sauce, I really enjoyed it. Large portions! We also go the grouper francese dish. Would..."
Tom McPherson
"Very good food and service
Good music..."
Lore L
"Baked Stuffed Grouper with delicious crab meat topped with an amazing lobster sauce. I’ve yet to try anything different when we come here. This is..."
Dena Turner
"Italian food is not my favorite. I had the veil Parmigiano it was the best Italian food I've ever had. The service was fantastic. I hope to eat here..."
Great Italian Wine from Puglia That Matched Up Well with a Mix of Entrees
Lasagne
Our Specialty Pizza
Cannoli
Shrimp
Linguine with Mussels Fra Diavolo
Homemade Special Pizza
Bruschette
Homemade Pappardelle w Shrimp in a Scampi Sauce
Pesto
Homemade Pappardelle w Shrimp Crab Meat and Sea Sgallops in a Creamy Pesto Sauce
Burrata Caprese
Fish
Eggplant
Meat Pizza
Antipasti
Salad
Lasagna Bolognese
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Clams
Mushroom Risotto
Chicken cordon blue
Calamari
Chicken Marsala
Parmigiana
Calamares
Braciola
Shrimp Scampi
Café
Southern-Italian
Sicilian
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Television
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"My favorite Italian restaurant on Marco Island! The staff is so friendly, loving, and inviting like you are family. The food is homemade and..."
Mark Kukla
"It’s soo good to have a local real Italian restaurant. With real Italian food. Pizza dough is made with Italian flour ( for me as a glutarded..."
mila bridger
"What a wonderful experience we had here! We tried this restaurant on Marco Island for the 1st time to treat a family member for their 81st birthday...."
Kayoko Griessmeyer
"This place is superb! I am always looking for Italian that is as good if not better than mine. This place is very good. I had the lasagna bolegnese,..."
Mark Shoplak
"We ate outside on the sidewalk and enjoyed great service and live music while we dined. Entres pictured left to right: the special that night was..."
Brent Wentzel
"Sorry my camera is acting up and pix aren't great but the food is AMAZING! From the house dressing to the FABULOUS Italian Wedding soup. It all lit..."
denise davenport
"We have enjoyed wonderful dinners at Davide's for over 10 years, but this year at Christmas time it was " magical ." Davide makes every guest feel..."
Rich Peluso
"Best Italian food. Good portions and good prices. The veal or chicken parm is..."
gabby maljak
"really good authentic italian food, by far the best pizza on marco island. this place is a must try, and you will be happy you..."
D. A.
"Davide! You never disappoint. We live in NJ, I travel there 4 times a year and always stop in for the best Italian food outside of Italy.
When you go..."
Rocco Franco
"Italian restaurant
Grouper pizaiola , excellent dinner
And the server Nada, very nice and attentiveness
Our favorite italian red in the Marco..."
Fernando DaCosta
"I was visiting from Michigan and decided to try this place based on customer reviews. I chose a table outside and was offered water and bread while I..."
Caitlin Campbell
"The food was amazing! And the service was awesome. I took 1 star away though because they could use a little more organization.
Last night we ordered..."
Jessica Funk
"Excellent place to have our last dinner on vacation. The owner was awesome and made us feel at home and our server was perfect. Highly recommended..."
Pete Dezzi
"A little restaurant in a strip mall that makes extraordinary Italian food. Their veal milanese is the best I've ever had, bar none. I am just amazed..."
Joe Imperato
"We love Davide’s pizza. We LOVE his pastas and wine selections. Tonight we enjoyed a 2016 Brunelo Montalcina from “La Togata” paired with Home..."
"I was staying on the island for the first time and went to Sami's for dinner. I was not disappointed. I had the spaghetti and their sauce was great...."
CC
"Literally the best pizza I have ever had the PRIVILEGE of tasting!!! If you’re ever in town, highly recommend going! Great food, great service,..."
Ethan Misson
"Consistently delicious. They have a great patio out front and often have live music that we find ourselves singing along to. The food is incredible -..."
Sara Tarr
"In Marco for a couple of days and dropped by Sami’s. Wasn’t sure what to expect but turned out to be a really nice experience. Sat outside and..."
Henri JA
"My family and I visited Marco island first time and decided to try Sami’s! We were very happy with our meal - we got a cheese pizza and pepperoni..."
T Slocum
"Sami’s is an absolute culinary gem. Exceptional food, attentive service, and a delightful ambiance make it a must-visit. I just traveled from DC to..."
Sadman Rahman
"This was our 2nd visit. The owner of this lovely establishment is a fantastic human and loves what he does! He greeted us upon our arrival and..."
Amanda Alafi
"UNBELIEVABLE food!! We could not get over how delicious our meals were. Fresh, yummy pasta and ingredients. Sasha was the sweetest server. Sami..."
Rachel Copeland
"The food was excellent. Everyone working was so kind. The owner went above and beyond to ensure we had a good experience. The live music was a..."
Jessica Jarrell
"absolutely would recommend sami’s!!! everything was incredible from the food to the atmosphere to the amazing service. i got the lobster ravioli..."
Olivia Faz
"Nice place to grab some deep dish pizza and a stromboli. Food was excellent hot and fresh. Our server was super nice and attentive. The only..."
Richard Roseberry
"This place is a TEN!! It was so good we came back a 2nd time to try something else on the menu! The pizza was amazing along with the cheese raviolis..."
Brenda Franklin
"What a pleasure to dine here! The owner Sami deserves special mention. He is constantly walking around making sure everyone is enjoying themselves..."
Michael Nick
"Was in the area for a couple nights and decided to give Sami’s a try. I arrived for an early dinner and enjoyed outside dining. The tables were set..."
Caitlin Campbell
"November 21. We had a really good meal at Sami’s and we would just like to say how well we were looked after by Tameka our server and a warm..."
Carol Shatter
"The food was excellent! Service was great! Our waiter deserved extra for the service. Kenieco was attentive and so helpful! Kudos to him. The wings..."
Lila Baker
"Great food and service in a clean and modern environment. Wonderful place to eat. We’ll be back many times. Great..."
"Amazing and authentic. 2 words we use to describe the Italian Deli and Market. Our party of 3 decided to stop in based on the reviews and the..."
Elizabeth Peatee
"Life changing pizza!! And I promise I’m not saying that lightly.
The food was absolutely amazing, we ordered a bit of everything because the menu..."
M A
"Truly a gem for super fresh made to order meal. We had a couple appetizers and a pizza, check out the pictures, $65 with a generous tip. Plenty of..."
Alan Ames
"The steak bits sandwiche was sweeted by caramelized onions and so delicious! The clam pasta was light and fresh. While the Italian sandwich was..."
Nicole
"We are here 2x in our week vaca; amazing and will definitely go back!!! The first time we did take out deli sandwiches. You can’t get any fresher!..."
Natalie Reimann
"I tried the sink pizza (sorry I had to change the onions for jalapeños). I loved it! Staff was very polite and the restaurant looked nice and clean...."
Gerardo Solorzano
""Edit this sandwich is not from this restaurant "I had an Italian sandwich. Fresh perfect bread! Excellent fresh ingredients. Maybe the best Italian..."
e.7.2521
"Got margarita pizza and a pepperoni pizza and pasta. This pizza was truly NY style and was absolutely delicious. If you come to the area and are..."
Sean Jonsson
"Walked in and ended up ordering from the bar and eating outside due to the fact they do not offer table service. The Caesar salad was fantastic-the..."
Rianna
"We love to stop in after a day at the beach and get some prosciutto and ciabatta bread. The last two times it was packaged perfectly ( single layers..."
Jane Johnson
"I’m town from Ohio. Found this place and I wish we had one back home! Will definitely come back. Great food and..."
Mike Wall
"Such an amazing place!
Delicious pizza, eggplant sandwiches and Italian wedding soup. Love their burrata salad as well.
Service is hit or miss but..."
Ivy T.
"Delish! Glad we found this place while..."
Elizabeth Brown
"Best mushroom soup ever!! Great burgers too. We love taking Monday lunch there over looking the beautiful driving range. So beautiful and so relaxing..."
Debbie Boggs
"Had the diavola pizza and the steak and cheese. The pizza was cooked perfectly. Great crust. Delicious flavors. But disappointed it wasn't spicy. ..."
"Went to Marco Island for a weekend gateway with my wife and kids and we decided to go out of the hotel for dinner. We went to DaVinci’s to try..."
Alain Jares
"Best food we had on the island! The service was great and they were able to seat us quickly even on a busy night. A little pricey, but totally worth..."
Andy Rustand
"Great Italian food & great service. The lady that sat us recommended an amazing pasta. Kyler was our server he did a great job at being knowledgeable..."
Jonathan N
"Overall great experience & will go back. Minimal wait with 6:30 pm reservation on busy weekend. Service friendly and fast. Food all tasted..."
Natalie Reimann
"My husband and I came down to Marco Island for the weekend and decided on DaVinci’s for dinner. We were surprised to find this to be the best..."
Liz Carissimo
"Awesome food and a great selection. Everything from traditional to lamb chops.
Appetizer was wonderful we got a tomato caprice. Of course, the lamb..."
Rodney Klein
"Wonderful! Our daughter was craving Carbonara, not onthe menu....but not a problem! It was delicious! Thank you..."
sara nelson
"The service is outstanding…The staff is pleasant, friendly and hard working. The food is fresh, hot and eye pleasing. The grouper was delicious. ..."
Sam Hemoud
"We had an amazing dinner. Very happy with the gluten free options, they are celiac friendly. Our server Ersen was attentive and pleasant. We will..."
hunter prendes
"Wonderful dinner. I had the shrimp appetizer as my meal, Stacciatella E Gamberi, it was superb and filling! My husband asked for a veal picatta over..."
"This pub is in a plaza but when you walk in the door the beach vibe pops out… cute little laid back good time. I like to swing by here and play..."
nathan goodfellow
"The burgers are always delicious and you can't beat the prices for the domestics on tap. Always enjoy coming here and have never had a bad..."
Brian Garcia
"When they say “bar” remember it is in the oyster sense. Adult beverages limited to beer and wine ONLY. All self-service but prices reflect this...."
JJP Mustang
"This lovely place is tucked away and we almost missed it. The Shrimp and Coconut Shrimp baskets were wonderful! There is no waitstaff, you order and..."
Judy Scott
"I was in town for a 2 day tournament. Randomly walked in the first day and got the burger with blue cheese and bacon on garlic bread. It was the best..."
matthew ogden
"Once a week there is a gentleman by the name of Joe who it seems has been recently singing here. Had a blast wonderful music choices and great..."
Daisy Dukes Perez
"The food wasn't bad, just not great. Not a huge local selection on beer. Lots that you can get..."
Darrick Smith
"Tickled pink by the food, service & fun I had at the Crazy Flamingo 🦩 on Marco Island, FL.
I ordered a medium rare Burger with Blue Cheese &..."
Veronica Fox
"What a great place! No waiters or waitresses, but that makes for faster service because they have it all handled from the bar in great time!! The..."
Adam Vernier
"The best customer service we have ever come across. Great little spot on Marco good vibes good food AMAZING service! Made our trip. Fills the wine..."
Alyssa Nguyen
"I stopped in here with my family for a quick bite to eat and was so happy with the food! You order at the bar so it is a no frills type of place...."
Sammi
"Good food a fair price…. The shrimps are delicious.
My son didn’t like the Thai..."
thekristianblack
"Great food , quantity, and good prices. They do not have table servers but the folks behind the bar are friendly and fast. We will go back..."
"My wife and I had a great experience! The service here was outstanding and it's what all fine dining experiences should feel like! The service was..."
M R
"This is always my 'go to' restaurant when I have new folks in town and always for family. Service is always impeccable but not overbearing...."
Doug Harker
"Beautiful views from the outdoor terrace. Amazing food that is beautifully presented and tastes divine. The staff is wonderful, very knowledgeable..."
Mark Kukla
"Hands down the best fine dining in the NAPLES /MARCO area. The food is amazing , the views are incredible but the service is hands down better than..."
Patricia Rainier
"What a remarkable experience. We settled in for drinks and an appetizer at the bar, surrounded by a beautiful old-world marble ambiance with a..."
Stratis Christakis
"Had a perfect engagement dinner here after proposing on the beach! We parked at the restaurant with the free valet then walked through the restaurant..."
Wade Bessell
"Despite the rain we still had a good time! Amazing view with delicious food plus wonderful service. We had the Romaine with Cesar salad dressing as..."
Nancy Han
"Looking for great Italian food when on Marco Island, then this is your destination. Reservations needed if you hope to get in. What a great..."
mike ciriello
"Great foodie spot on Marco Island, located at the Marco Beach Ocean Resort. The sunset view atop the outdoor dining patio makes this a really great..."
Garren Rimondi
"Thank you to all of the staff at this restaurant for making our visit a memorable one. The ambiance, view, food, and employees are all exceptional...."
JM3
"Amazing dining experience. The people are extremely welcoming and professional. The views are amazing. The food in itself was a great experience..."
imran chowdry
"Delicious food and lovely view. We sat outside to view the sunset and even though we came in the summer, it was still nice due to the fans in the..."
Mia Larsen
"Superb dining experience. Jose was very attentive and helpful when deciding on selections. Each course of our dining experience was..."
Debbie Farantzos
"We went for my wife’s Birthday as the restaurant was recommended by the concierge at the Hilton Marco Island Resort. We arrived early to watch the..."
Daniel Dieck (rockydogz)
"I highly recommend Sale e Pepe. We had reservations for the terrace and the view did not disappoint. Jose our server was amazing! From start to..."
jennifer jordan
"Excellent cuisine, we had an excellent server Alessio, and a beautiful place! Staying at the JW Marriott for a few nights and we’re less than..."
Rebecca Stover
"This place is absolutely awesome in all aspects. My husband and I made a reservation for dinner during our Honeymoon, and everything from beginning..."
Noel Reese
"The experience, the food and the view was outstanding.The service was excellent and our waiter was able to accommodate to the celiac in our group.I..."
Morgana Stroich
"Sale e Pepe restaurant in Marco Island, Florida, has been my best culinary experience to date.The opulence, the ambiance, and the gulf views of this..."
"We love trivia night on Wednesday and/or Thursday! Food is great bar food. So far we’ve had the pulled pork sandwich, Cesar salad with chicken or..."
Christina Boxma
"If you are a 21-27 year old this is not your bar, the owner told these two older women that their tan was paid, he flirted with them the whole time,..."
Cor2ran
"This place is a 10/10 and all the employees were truly the best! I stayed in Marco Island for 5 days and I came here all 5 days. The drinks & food..."
Sara Hemmer
"Nice bar, laid back pool spot. Awesome bartenders. Good..."
Matthew Postman Parr
"Went to the bar for trivia night. It was good food and drink. Atmosphere is..."
Tyrone Counts
"Phenomenal food at Mario’s! Great bartenders..."
Country boy Luciano's fishing and cooking
"Marios is a great hangout. The food is excellent. They offer five pool tables in the bar area. They have huge bay windows giving the place a nice..."
Natasha Drummond (SUNSHINEBELLA)
"Friendly atmosphere and Luciano’s great service definitely worth..."
J P
"Would have earned 5 stars had the staff not taken 15 minutes to begin..."
John McClorey
"excellent place, I really enjoyed the food, the music and the friendliness of the people. good drinks the bartender prepares for me... I will..."
Alejandra Britos
"Great band tonight, Marco Midnight, had fun and will be..."
Bill Leonard
"The bartender cool as ****. Good recommendations and good food, much better than many bar foods in the area, and just great tasting overall. Nice..."
Sergio Pena
"The pizza really is excellent, and nice venue for low-key live music. Wait times can be a bit long for food, but wait staff is friendly and helpful...."
Ryan Velting
"Great service! Better than your normal bar food and better than your neighborhood bar! Will definitely recommend ! Will be..."
Christina De La Barrera
"Perfect little dive bar. 9pm is 'Marco Midnight' apparently but this place stays open as long as you're enjoying yourself and behaving. Great drink...."
Misty Heavilin
"We had so much fun in Marco for our first trip! Heading back this week. Devon served us and he was the best!! Met so many great people and had many..."
Amanda Whitman
"Looking for some entertainment and a couple slices of pizza. The pizza was delicious. Several pool tables were open and other arcade machines. We..."
Patricia Humphries
"Delton and Todd were awesome! Our food was delicious. Drinks were ice cold 🧊! Great place to stop with your friends for darts or..."
"Great food, great service! The pizza dough had a really nice flavor. We got the thin crust and it was cooked perfectly. Awesome garlic knots and..."
Ron B
"THIS PIZZA was amazing! Fresh hand tossed crust, fresh veggies, perfect amount our sauce and cheese. The service was excellent, all staff friendly..."
Meagan Benz
"One of the best waitress services we’ve ever had, Rosie took care of us well, very prompt and kind. Food was wonderful and they were really big..."
Jacob Lamping
"First time at Joeys, and will not be our last! Came in the evening, just wanting some pizza and it was very tasty. They had a drink special of a..."
Jennifer Bixler
"First time here and it was good. The service was awesome and the pizza even better. I’m not one to complain but if I could critique it in anyway I..."
Jonathan Colon
"Ate here tonight with my family for my first time and my parents second time. Did not disappoint!! We are in visiting from Chicago so it’s safe to..."
Kaytlyn
"Some of the best pizza I’ve had. I had the thin, Joey’s Way, as recommended by the bartender and it was amazing! Highly..."
Kevin Rand
"If you love Italian, you must visit Joey's! Authentic Italian food that tastes amazing and presentation is impressive. Will definitely go back next..."
Kaybe Slaven
"Great food and service! Their pizzas run big! They also deliver to..."
Jack G
"What a pleasant surprise! I was truly impressed by the pizza I had here. Very close to being like a pie from NY. My only "disappointment" came from..."
Michael Nick
"We just ate there and wow so impressed. The service was perfect and the food was delicious! We ordered the antipasto salad and it was different and..."
Anna McDowell
"Man is my 50s from Chicago. I've had lots of good pizza. Joey's was amazing! Fantastic crust and fresh delicious toppings. Easily ranked in the top 5..."
James Davis
"First time eating at Joey’s and he didn’t disappoint! Maybe one of the best pizzas we have ever had. Choice of about 20+ signature pizzas and it..."
Fran ackley
"In all honesty, I sometimes hate to tell everyone how fantastic a place is, since I want to keep it to myself, but I’m happy to share Joey’s. The..."
Mary Ahmann
"Our first dinner on vacation to Marco Island was at Joey’s Pizza. Nice open ambiance with very friendly servers. For a starter, Escarole soup was..."
joseph cascio
"Joeys is a family favorite. It is a wonderful place to gather, or sit at the bar for a fun time with Mike and Mikey. Service and food is always..."
"The food is OK, I wish the spaghetti with meatballs would be a bit more flavored but their fettuccine (with chicken) and their pizza are excellent...."
Lucian Narita
"Nice place to have some pizza with a beautiful beach scenery. Have indoor and outdoor..."
NeGoshen Family
"Decent prices, good service, and really good pizza! A nice meal all around, especially if you need a little break from soaking up the sun. We ordered..."
fenrael23
"The food and atmosphere was wonderful. I had the rigatoni with vegetables, omg it was so good. I hope they have it on their menu next summer when we..."
Kathleen Prince
"Nice little place. Pizza is incredible - kids can't get enough. Salad is great too, for the adults. This place is much better now with the new..."
Vadim Kuhay
"Generous food portion and taste great too. Staff were very friendly & attentive. I loved the generous shredded parmesan served on the food. It was..."
Vee Square
"Wonderful evening meal with pizza, salad &..."
Steve Harrison
"Really nice dinner. The mussels were great. The margherita pizza was good, but a little soggy in the middle. The atmosphere is nice and..."
Nat Mills
"I totally 💯 recommend this place! Food is delicious and the ppl who work there is Amazon and full of patience ! Thank you so much..."
Mariana Vazquez de Molinari
"Quick, tasty and very..."
Vica V. K.
"The food and service at this place is amazing! Emmanuel took especially good care of us and provided top notch service. The white pizza and farro..."
Tim B.
"Great GF options for you and your kids! Pizza and Pastas are delicious and cooked to order. Pricey...but you are paying for the view of a restaurant..."
Shawn McLane
"Great value and yummy..."
Sharon D
"Great food, lovely view and atmosphere. Try the chicken marsala. If you don't see it on the menu ask for it. Excellent.
Friendly service from Deb,Gia..."
bob weatherwax
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes