Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Martha's Vineyard

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
La Soffitta
La Soffitta
89/100 (238 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Drinks
Taleggio & Prosciutto Bruschetta
Marinated Mozzarella
Cod
Truffle Potato Fritters
Tagliatelle
Duck Confit Carbonara
Shrimp
Espresso Martini
Pesto
Shrimp Scampi
Wine
Truffle Steak
Lobster
Falafel
Tiramisu Cheesecake
Pasta
Salad
Bolognese Alla Grey Barn
Creamsicle
Shrimp & Tomato Fennel Ragu
Scallops
Prawn & Pasta Nera
Calamari
Bass & Gnocchi
Risotto
La Soffitta Salad
Calamares
Misto Di Mar
Sea Scallops Gnocchi
Italian
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Drinks
Dinner
Mid-range
"So... This place blew some socks right off. Just amazing choices from beginning to the end. Who'd have thought the balsamic in the olive oil with the..."
Christopher Rutledge
"Nice ambiance and service. Prices are of course on the higher side but worth it. Food tasted good. The drinks were nice too. I ordered a prosecco..."
Megha Mukim
"La Soffitta always amazes me with their pasta dishes like a classic spaghetti and meatball, as well as their desserts and oh my, you must taste their..."
Marnely Murray
"Food and service was amazing. We sat on the heated patio due to COVID which turned out just as lovely. I highly recommend the grilled shrimp..."
Lisa McCrey
"Absolutely phenomenal Italian food! Best on the..."
The Dipper
"La Soffitta hands down the best restaurant in Vineyard Haven! As far as MV goes it could very well be #1. The food is AMAZING. One must understand as..."
jack straw
"Lovely restaurant on Main Street in Vineyard Haven. Cool place and excellent service. The bread is phenomenal. I know - who talks about bread. It is..."
Kimberli Hull
"Food/Travel Influencer - Instagram: @michaela_romanosmith Review: Went for dinner and had an amazing experience!! Some of the best Italian food I've..."
Michaela Romano-Smith
"Lots of gluten free (GF) options including the best fried calamari we've ever had (incl wheat battered) and fresh baked GF rolls which was a..."
Donna Kehler
"La Soffitta offers superb Italian food within a warm atmosphere - I really enjoyed my seafood pasta with lemon cream sauce, and the bread was..."
Tiffany Cheng
"Had the Pollo Al Marsala and it was delicious. Great meal and atmosphere. I'll admit, I eat here often and I'm hooked on that chicken..."
Adam Darack
"What a great experience! My wife and I were looking for some good Italian food on the island and we lucked out. Our server Mike was also great, as..."
Johnny C
"Very good. Beautiful interior and very friendly and competent waitstaff. The menu had so many delicious sounding dishes that it was hard to choose..."
John Davis