Reviews Carmela's Pizza

5
Kevin Tyrrell
+5
Awesome Veal Chop. NYC Steakhouse quality. Impeccable service, you don’t need to travel far for the best. Staff is like family
5
James Rogers
+5
Excellent food, great service, highly recommend.
5
Samantha Kronenbitter
+5
What a wonderful staff! Great pizza, love the garlic dogs..... This is a genuine mom and pop shop that provides the best. They close on Sunday for family night and you don't see that anymore but open on Monday when I somehow have a craving for 🍕😜😍enjoy
5
Ryan Suh
+5
4.75/5 In the neighborhood, kids wanted pizza / pasta. Ordered calamari friti, eggplant rollatini, and the grandpa pie where any other pizzeria would call it a grandma pie. Grandpa Pie - 10/10. Any other pizzeria, this is a grandma pie. Their grandma has onions and breadcrumbs, which is a grandpa by other pizzerias. Straight to the point, this pizza is amazing. Great flavor. Seasoned perfectly, right amount of sauce, mozzarella, great crust. We devoured this pie. This is a must order. We would come back for the pizza alone. Calamari friti 7/10 - the large pieces are fried and battered perfectly. Soft and tender. 10/10. The smaller pieces, they shouldn’t serve it, it was tough and hard 3/10. Gave the kids the good large pieces while the adults ate the thin very tough leftovers and the tentacles. A lots of tentacles, never seen so many in a calamari dish. The tentacles were decent, 7/10. No choice, we were too hungry and nothing else served yet, we finished it. If wasn’t too hungry, wouldn’t eat the thin ones at all, that bad. Eggplant rollatini 6/10. Wouldn’t order this again. The ricotta filling is bland, no flavor. Everything else is great 9.5/10 but the ricotta ruined the dish. 2nd visit: Ordered the same Grandpa pie. Consistently great 10/10. Buffalo wings with sauce on side. 10/10. Nice big portions of chicken, not tiny. Haven’t had great Buffalo wings like this on LI. The Buffalo sauce was made perfectly, mild spicy with hint of sweetness. It doesn’t have a chemical taste.
5
Rosa's Resources
+5
They get a 5 star. Omg the food is so good. I started out with the chicken salad . The staff us friendly make you feel at home. Thus is no lil Cesar this is the bomb.com when I'm in Long Island the are my favorite Italian restaurant. Yummy for my tummy. I ate there over n over again the staff is amazing and the food is good. They always cheer and call me by my name when I visit. The price is right as well. I keep coming here over n over again when I say delicious that what I mean.
5
Alexandra Gleason
+5
Love this pizzeria and restaurant. Daniella is SO nice, kind and welcoming into her establishment. Their food is amazing- ordered two pizzas last night and my 4 year old triplets ate almost 2 slices each. We’ve gone in and dined as well- best chicken parm I’ve had in a long time and Daniella makes homemade pasta which is so delicious! Family owned and they really care about their customers. You will always be greeted no matter how busy the restaurant is. Thank you!!!
5
Chari Bayanker
+5
Top-class slices. Very warm and friendly staff. New Pepperoni Vodka slice is a killer. Get there soon.
5
Michael Tanner
+5
Nice selection of freshly prepared dishes. Arugula salad and veal travolta were outstanding.
5
Michael Correa
+5
All I can say is I wish this Restaurant / Pizzeria was closer to my house rather then my work. I can honestly say I have never tried something that I didn't like. Not only great food but great people, they make you feel at home...
5
Dani J. Muccio
+5
Rigatoni Carmela - Sauteed shrimp with escarole, sliced black olives, sundried tomatoes, and artichoke hearts. Such a great mix of textures.
Clicca per espandere