This is the best ice cream in Suffolk County! The staff is super knowledgeable and friendly, and can whip up any flavor you want if it’s not on the menu. They do birthday cakes as well! Doggy treats? They got them! If you’re in the mood for ice cream. This is the only place to visit.
Not only amazing creamy ice cream but they made it so easy for us to navigate my son’s nut and egg allergies. What a great find!!
Magic Fountain is the place to go for your Ice Cream fix. The choices of flavors are exhausting. It makes for a tough decision. Especially when your only passing through once in a while. Do not let the long line deter you from getting your ice cream. It is well worth the wait. The servers are competent and quick. So do not pass this establishment up when opportunity knocks. 👍🗽👍🗽
I passed Magic Fountain on my way to dinner, and my friend remarked, "They have the best ice cream!" So after dinner away we go. And by now it was after 8 pm the line to get in was around the building. I peeked in the windows and could see chalkboards listing a variety of homemade ice creams, ice cream sundaes, milkshakes, soda and more. They also have soft serve, sugar-free, and frozen yogurt to temp your discerning palate. Kudos to the staff here. The line moved swiftly, reducing the wait for a sweet indulgence. And it was well worth any minute. The soft serve is creamy, had a delicious chocolate flavor. My friends enjoyed Butter Pecan and Black Raspberry. So the North Fork has more than wineries attracting a crowd. Next trip stop in for ice cream at Magic Mountain!
Absolutely amazing experience, with amazing staff! I’m was so happy to see an allergy chart and ingredient list with all the food allergies, and was amazed at how natural and healthy the ice cream was! Portion size was very well done, and will go again soon!
Great ice cream. Reminds me of hilderbrandts.
Delicious and prices can't be beat! The summer sunset was amazing!!! Lots of flavors and they are great at listing what's in each for dietary concerns and even have vegan options. Would love to come back next time I'm on the North Fork. Staff is also friendly and wonderful girls!
Delicious ice cream. Highly recommend their sampler pack. Try something new while you are here. It will be worth it. There can be some wait. It is part of the experience. If you want to skip the wait, you can also order ahead via their website.
Drove by the area to get to the sunflower maze. Made a note of the crowd as we were passing by. On our way back, stopped here for some delicious homemade ice cream - available in unique flavors, created and served with care. Growing up in India, Rooh Afza was a summer staple - was pleasantly surprised to see it featured as a flavor (and on their banner)!
Always super friendly, will let you taste any flavors you want...which you won't be able to resist, because there are just too many delicious options to choose from! Definitely go for the large "banana boat" style--no actual banana included, but you get three huge scoops in a plastic container...perfect for sharing on-the-go!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes