The best Restaurants in Mayfield ranking of February 2025
74 restaurant menus in Mayfield, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Amazing service, great attitudes which is a major plus. Listened to exactly how I wanted it made and cave out great, if not better then great. The..."
Ronnie G
"This location is always a pleasant experience. They're friendly and happy to..."
Peggy Funke
"Not a lot to say it your rub of the mill subway seemed nice and clean not a long..."
"I've truly discovered that there's never a shortage of new places to try whenever I visit Cleveland. Austin's Smokin' steakhouse is right off Wilson..."
GoodNomJoni
"I went here for the first time and enjoyed it my waiter was really nice and..."
Rose
"I had the opportunity to visit Austins last night and I had a very pleasant time. The service was very nice. Just happened to be $5 off steak night...."
Raishaun
"Former employee. One of the best steak houses around the area. great atmosphere and..."
Jeff Peters
"Smokin!. My boyfriend and I had a great lunch at Austin's. Phil's Favorite Salad was fresh and refreshing, and BF's steak salad filled him up. The..."
Lucy
"Listen! This place is great! Food is fresh we have visited twice and its quickly becoming our favorite place to grab some dinner! I love the steaks..."
Satasha Sawyer
"Despite having lived in this area my entire life, I have never been to this restaurant, until tonight, and I sure am glad that I did! My party and I..."
Amy Hewis
"Great food great service the waite staff is great they don't rush you in and out and they all know the menu will and can help you make a good choice...."
"Great service, great food, awesome sweet tea, friendly staff! They brought our food to our table and checked on us mid meal. The cook came out asked..."
Raymond Hayes
"Guys, this is a wonderful place to eat if you are fish hungry. It was crisp, delicious. Sides were fresh and delicious also. Staff smiling and..."
Priscilla Dick
"Sorry, it's a long one, read on to find out why:
We stopped here on our way home from Paducah on 12/20/21, just 10 days after the devastating..."
Patti Ingram
"Awesome food. Awesome..."
Fae Deliveries
"Good food here served pretty quick. You can eat inside, plenty of room tables clean, bathroom clean. Very friendly folks work..."
Brad Wilson
"I like this place because when you order from the drive through they. Did the order right. The food is hot and..."
Meatloaf Chicken and Dumplings Broccoli and Cheese Casserole
Country Fried Steak Fried Apples
Mini Confetti Pancakes with Bacon or Sausage
Hashbrown Casserole Fried Chicken Dinner with Baked Apples
Grits
English Muffin
Southern Fried Chicken
Pancake
Gummy Candy
hot chocolate
French Toast
Chicken Fingers
Juice
Sirloin Steak
Chicken Fried Steak
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Mid-range
"Breakfast was delicious. Really neat shop full of all types of gifts/souvenirs. Service with a smile. Loved it. We also had a party of 12! So this..."
Roni Green
"I have to get a kids meal since they serve great portions!!! No matter what size, it is always..."
ky grnii
"Had great service today. Server had an awesome personality and was very attentive to the needs of the customer's. Food was also well prepared...."
Jason Riegler Sr.
"Terrific breakfast menu. I had country fried steak along with their hashbrown casserole with cheese and bacon added. It was awesome. The service was..."
Marty Smith
"We had a great time & experience. Our server Erika was great. Very attentive and friendly. My husband's order was missing an egg & Erika got it..."
"I love DQ! LOVE their food LOVE their ice cream! It's a little slow but that's because they make the food fresh and it's good and hot when ya, get..."
Kimberly Westerman
"Peanut butter shake was good and thick. Service was..."
Rebecca w
"Since the new owners took over you get hot food and it doesn't take an hour lunch to get your..."
"Best Maxican food in Mayfield. Very clean, good quality food per money. Fast service and staffs are very polite. I will go there again and..."
Blaise Costa
"Food was fantastic!! Our orders was a little wrong, but the fixed it right away with smiles! Amazing, authentic, tasty food. I love some good Mexican..."
Stephany Sherman
"Absolutely delicious food and great prices my husband and I went out for a date and it was under $30. We can't wait to go back..."
Holly Landry
"Best Mexican food in town (my opinion). Friendly staff and got our order changes..."
Rich Gough
"Excellent. I had the Mexican salad and it was fantastic! Waitress was super nice and polite and very..."
CINDY REICHOLD
"The food was delicious and the service was super quick. Our waiter was also very..."
Haridas Attur
"I cannot eat much due to stomach things bit thier chille rellena even in small amounts is good..."
Christina Bryan
"Great food good service not the best but it's..."
"Super nice employees! Humans make mistakes and that's what happened. Our order came to the car with only the cheeseburger being correct. I let a car..."
Mitch Lilly
"Is really good place to take kids. Although they never seem to get my kids happy meals right! Every time I have went it’s either the drink wrong or..."
Ashley Stokes
"It was really busy due to being Halloween but we went for the 50 cent corn dogs and it was delivered pretty fast. A couple screens weren't working..."
"Have been to a number of local Aladdins and like the consistent menu. Visited Mayfield location and loved it. Same owner seems to have been here..."
DJ
"Best hummus. The best hummus in cleveland. Get a fattoush salad and spoon the hummus into it. Great flavor. Their pita could be thicker, but the..."
Susie
"Easily one of my favorite restaurants. I have been eating at Aladdin's for years and I never get tired of it. It is my go-to restaurant when I'm in..."
Shaft Douglas
"This place is not something I though I would like but once I tried it I became addicted. Their kababs are just great and the real surprise here is..."
William Toto
"Love the spicy..."
Daniel DeSantis
"I’ve been dining at Alladin’s for ever. I’ve frequented the one in Cleveland Heights and live close to the one in Independence, but I ventured..."
Bonnie Hampton
"Always fantastic food and a great change of pace for flavors around town. Never a bad idea when we choose to eat from Aladdins. We often order online..."
Kevin Dudgeon
"The management and service staff are friendly and dedicated to great service. We have been eating here for years. The last time we ordered, the..."
Anthony Jenkins
"Eaten here twice and both times the service was good. Ordered the shush kabob the second time, pictured, and it was really..."
Bryan Stewart
"In the 20 yrs we have come here it has always been great! Forget being a good healthy restaurant, it's a great restaurant,..."
Laurel DiFranco
"I Order from here on doordash all the time. My food is always right! Love the Chicken Shawarma, Beef Kaftas. Great..."
Jeff Pierce
"Best food! So fresh, always delicious! This place is a must try! Great desserts too! Friendly..."
"It was nice. The girl at the counter was friendly and polite. She was new. Said that she had only been there 4 days. She was very helpful. The only..."
Randy Adams
"I have had friends to explain to me the experience there was really bad the price gouging hurting the hurricane or tornado covet and people are in a..."
Debra Lee
"I am 8 & 1/2 months pregnant, and I went through the drive thru at Arby's the other day, ordered a 2 for $6 (one for me, one for the baby) - and the..."
Backhoe Mama
"The food was good but it was made even better by the service. I don't know who those girls are working the window but they were precious and did an..."
"Service displayed from the staff on "Thanksgiving Morning" was on point. Even though they were the only place opened, thanks for providing breakfast..."
MadStyleChica 15
"The service was great the food was hot and the staff was super nice and friendly I give it 4.5 stars and recommend this place to..."
Jason Jackson
"I appreciate them for making a special sandwich not even really a part of the menu and it was..."
"Love this place, one of my favorites in NEPA. Varied choices on menu, food tastes good, friendly staff, nice atmosphere, always pleased when we go..."
Paul Williams
"Great atmosphere. Excellent food. Pleasant staff. Alternating table seating to accommodate pandemic. Met a friend for lunch. First time at..."
Michael Macedonia
"We went for seafood and I have to say it was some of the best we had! I had mako shark piccata and my wife had broiled haddock. Prices were..."
George Palickar
"Just had the best steak I have ever tasted
I ordered the prime rib OMG LOVED IT AWSOME JOB TO THE PREP AMD LINE COOKS ONE HAPPY CUSTOMER WILL..."
willy odowd
"Good food at reasonable prices. Soup was great and the fish is..."
Keith Redding
"Nice place. Reminiscent of an older diner with a little sprucing up. The food was pretty good and it was not pricey at all. I had a shrimp and penne..."
Lola Consuela
"Great waitstaff. Varied menu. Pleasant atmosphere. Delicious. Moderate..."
Mary Lou Searing
"Great food. I just went for the first time and it was delicious. I highly recommend dinner there if you have a couple bucks to spend. I will..."
Connor Griggs
"It was refreshing to have such a friendly person take my phone order. The service at the counter when I picked up my order was just as friendly. ..."
"I went with my family tonight for my dads birthday , complete with 3 little kids! And jennifer was amazing! She was extremely patient efficient and..."
Pamela Hecey
"Delicious 🤤😋 - our server was Austin, he was super helpful with our food questions, as well as making me a fresh jalapeno margarita. The wings..."
Melody Dufrene
"Terrific food at reasonable prices. Very cozy atmosphere with friendly attentive staff. Definitely returning when we can sit outside in front of the..."
Patricia Jones
"So so good. This is THE place for ribs. We’ve never been disappointed..."
Cheryl Keys
"Casual dining - outside dining looked very nice, inside was comfortable. The staff were super friendly. They have a good variety of beers,..."
Karein Macaulay
"First of all the bartender was a DELIGHT. The food was so darn good. Impressive beer selection and a great..."
whitney overmyer
"We went to the area in a whim and found this place! Amazing food, great atmosphere, and nice staff. I got the fat heifer...I think that’s the name..."
"This is the best pizza in town (Mayfield, KY). I love their garlic crust. They always make my order above my expectations, and their staff/delivery..."
Karen Hotz
"We order tons of pizza! Always satisfied 😌. Nice drivers, they deserve their tips! Great job cooking staff..."
redskullztv
"I have never really cared for The taste of their pizza. But the person who made my two pizza’s tonight! Excellent Job! Ready in a short time,..."
Tamra Yekinni
"Order is always correct, and done up quickly. Great deals to make feeding a large crowd not break the..."
Stephany Sherman
"My pineapple and chicken Pizza was perfectly made, textbook density, saucing, cheesing, and topping. They killed their corporate inspection and..."
Thomas McLean
"It was some of the best pizza I've had in a long time . Domino's never..."
GAVIN Bayram
"Amazing Pizza and amazing staff! We love their..."
"Their salads are the best salads in the area ALWAYS Fresh and crisp!!! And Ranch lovers their ranch is DELICIOUS very clean restaurant and great..."
Lauren B
"Get the Reuben. Best sandwich on the menu.
Hand-tossed pizzas are a regional favorite. Ask about PJ's Pizza, an all-meat treat with a perfect blend..."
Joey Reed
"Food was great. Server was very friendly and she wasn't late on anything.
This was my first time trying this restaurant and for sure will come back..."
Raed Ashi
"The appetizer was delicious! The pizza was amazing though! Can’t go wrong with the house..."
Liz Matheny
"The food is always good. So is the service. A very nice place. They have a room available for gatherings and meetings as..."
"Good food, decent atmosphere and service has always been pretty good. I've had a better food experience ordering things that aren't wings but their..."
Jacob Perry
"Food was good. I had never been there before and i had to guess at the sauces. I feel like the atmosphere could have been more inviting. The manager..."
Catherine Scott
"Very good experience, good variety of food, not just wings. Did have wings and very good. Excellent staff. Plan on going back to try different..."
Jeff Gorham
"Best place to eat in Mayfield by far. Good food. Good service. Ugly waitresses, try not to look at their..."
"Found Carr's Steakhouse while traveling through Mayfield a few years ago. We were impressed then and have made it our go-to place to stop for dinner..."
Mark Wehrstein
"First off, the inside of the building is really cool if you're into old architecture. Definitely has that old steakhouse/bar feel to it.
Sat at the..."
Steve Furst
"We are in from out of town and decided to try them out!...we loved our food and we had an awesome server named Caleb!...the building has beautiful..."
MePreshus
"It was amazing! All of our food was delicious, hot and fresh! A very professional & friendly young man was our server it was refreshing to see that..."
Annie Starnes
"We arrived before dinner and it was empty. Everything was hot and fresh and everyone was friendly. Loved the food and atmosphere. We had the ribeye..."
DarkAlly1
"BBQ nachos were spot on. It seems as if Thursday may not be the best day to visit, the "truck' runs on Friday. No whipped cream for my pie, and at 6..."
Amy Adams
"Good food, great service. Nice environment and what looks like all new furniture on their fairly large patio. I would suggest stepping up the..."
"Ordered food to go in the restaurant, food was ready super fast! Food was fantastic! Got everything correct, even the things we asked to be left off!..."
Stephany Sherman
"The service and food were good. We came in at the end of their lunch rush. Our food came out just a few minutes after ordering. They are..."
Shanon Seals
"Always fast and friendly service. Food tastes great! All meals are well prepared and well portioned. Always have a great experience whenever we come..."
Jason Riegler Sr.
"Great food and friendly people. Everything was very fresh and..."
Velva Guthrie
"I love the food here. Good flavor. The service is really..."
Teri Bush
"The Food was great, everything I ate was. The scenery may not have been Paris, France but its definitely a place to revisit time and time..."
GamurSnek
"This is the only good Mexican restaurant in Mayfield. My family and I love it. Food is always good and it never takes too long to get..."
"I got the Chalupa box. It was a really nice combo!!! Tasted great too! The drive through employee was very friendly and I received my food quickly!..."
Rene Roy
"Food was good. Somebody forgot to put the soap dispenser bottle into the soap disoe see. It was lying in the sink for some..."
Haridas Attur
"Good service most of the time but I did get 2 boxes and they took over 35min to get it to me in lobby. Said manager went..."
Noah Hill
"They made the effort to fix our order without being asked. Was kind of slow going through the drive through that..."
Aaron Read
"Great experience tonight in the drive Thru.....good service, fast, and order was..."
"What A Great Surprise!. I had ice cold tomato juice, a ham and cheese omelet, home fries, freshly cooked thick patty sausages along with biscuit and..."
Frank Carvell
"Great food. Great service.
Great place for a Meat and Three. I had the roast beef, potato salad, cole slaw, and mashed potatoes.
I'm counting..."
Joey Reed
"Good ole southern cooking that's absolutely amazing.Fresh and hot.Gravy is so wonderful, sausage is amazing, eggs where perfect and omg the biscuits..."
Kandy Palmerville
"Best breakfast in Mayfield still. Would love to see them do a different gravy recipe though. The current is just plain low seasoning and seems almost..."
Ginger Courtney
"Passing through town and a local said this was the best breakfast in town. They weren't lying! Everything was great and fresh and homemade, just like..."
grizzly adams
"I ordered take out and the woman on the phone was super helpful. I would've done it later if I had known that this little place would be packed! I..."
Anna Allen
"They were short staffed this morning but the waitresses kept everyone served and did it with a smile. The food was great and the prices were..."
Julie Wilson
"Great country homemade food. Great atmosphere and wonderful emplyees.. this is a great choice for breakfast and..."
Kelley Coles
"Just passing thru & was impressed with the staff & how they handled a large crowd. Food was magnificent country eating & more than enough portions...."
"Buffet was really good. Met up with a long time good friend. We enjoyed our visit. Good selection of different pizzas and the salad bar was topped..."
Bluegrass Meadows
"I used Google reviews to pick this place. I love "local flavor" restaurants. I LOVE pizza so this was a no brainier after seeing it had a 4+ star..."
Sherie Loverkamp
"Best salad. Best pizza.
We didn't come all last summer during the pandemic.
We spend winters at our Florida house and we have been so hungry for..."
Elaine Crider
"Best pizza in town! They had a free community lunch on 2/21/22 and didn't charge anyone a penny, just left the tip jar out for the staff..."
Robert Kaler
"My mom, Zida, has worked here since 1981 when it was Devanti’s and it was owned by John Lazaritus. This place is a Mayfield icon. Food here has..."
U.S. Militia
"Best pizza around, can't beat the price. End of story, hands down..."
Daniel Elsey
"Love this place. Super nice staff, great value, amazing pizza and the pecan rolls are just.......ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS..."
"This BK is actually really good and any time I eat there my order is always fresh, hot and correct. I absolutely recommend this BK over others. I..."
Brandy Bennett
"I definitely recommended to all my friends & family the service was great but what touch me was this older man came in & was asking about price & the..."
Susie Connell
"Best Burgers on the planet, nice staff and clean place. 4/14/2022 They mixed up my order, but fixed it no problem at all! Thanks you all are..."
"The food was really delicious I feel as though it's one of those places people have to visit and eat at. The staffs are wonderful and polite. Really..."
Tolu K
"Delicious Korean food, highly recommended. Charging 12,5% service charge on top of the bill is a bit too much though, other than that all..."
Eva
"Soooo yummy! I love the Ban Ban Chicken! The Kimchi and Vegetable Pancake doesn’t have a strong kimchi taste so that was a real..."
Gnip Weis
"My go to place for Korean food. I've been here several times and the food is always top notch and the staff are both friendly and funny. On this..."
R.M Delgado
"Dining in this traditional Korean restaurant few years ago with my Miss. We ordered a Kimchi soup, a hot stone bowl rice (bibimbab) and a fried pork..."
"I saw you on new day Cleveland for favorite veggie pizza,it looked so good that we decided to try the California dreamin in...it was fabulous.. You..."
Michelle
"Hats off to pizza Roma I finally found a place that knows how to make..."
Bill
"Pleasant experience. Walked into Pizza roma today - what a Great experience. Great Food and Friendly owner . I will definately be..."
Lester
"Tried it today. Great pizza. I loved Sicilian Pizza, but my family loved Hawaiian. Either pizza - we will be back for..."
EatingWellisAnArtForm
"Best Pizza ... WOW!!. This is the best pizza I have ever tasted! We ordered a pepperoni pizza last night and my 4 year old son wants to go back there..."
Jeff B
"Best Pizza around. I have gone to pizza roma for about 3 years now and i have yet to come up with a complaint. the service is outstanding and..."
Jenna
"Charlies famous pizza and sausage is the..."
Joe
"I love pizza roma! the food is awesome and the service is always great, it has a nice, happy atmosphere. everything tastes great from the pizza and..."
Erin
"Very tasty calzone and good..."
Jeff
"Pizza Roma. Some of the best pizza in the area. The salads are so fresh and generous. Taste of Italy salad is amazing.You have to try them..."
Jtrouw
"Excellent, go for the pepperoni or sausage. Pizza made from scratch inluding..."
Shane Mears
"Awesome local pizza. Try the California Dreaming..."
Matt Ruts
"I wish I could give this place more stars. This is my favorite place to go for authentic Italian food. I just ordered a pizza for pickup. I was..."
Amanda D'Arcy
"We got artichoke heart and mushroom and I think it was likely the best pizza I have ever had. I am from California but my wife is Italian and she..."
Derek Frew
"We tried the pizza last night... it was amazing!!! The staff was kind and friendly! Would definitely..."
Virginia Mcclain
"Excellent pizza. Great sauce. Outstanding..."
Steve Bohman
"California Dreaming is the best pizza I've ever..."
Bridgette Bright
"We are from out of town. Fiance wanted to go to Yours Truly next door but thankfully they were packed. I was in the mood for pizza so we stopped in..."
Frank Lucas
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes