It was the best prime rib I have ever had. The restaurant is stunning with a fireplace in the dining area. The staff is very friendly and attentive. My waitress's name was Barbara. She is a lovely woman and a pure joy. We will definitely be returning when we are in the area again.
Expertly done traditional fare!
Everything was fantastic, from the expertly toasted rolls to the perfectly cooked prime rib. The bruschetta appetizer was the best I've had and the chicken wing soup was superbly appetizing! I would return simply for it. The attentive staff was cordial and incredibly helpful. I'd give a 6th star for the service if I could!
Melinda Allein Ventola
+5
We don't go too often but we've had their Baked Chicken Sunday Special a couple times already & it is Delicious & the price can't be beat for all that's included(soup & salad & dessert). Great wine list & the view is beautiful of Lake Chautauqua
This was our first time following an adventure through Panams Rocks.
Had the veal with hollandais sauce it was fabulous!
Jim was a very attentive courteous server.
Can't wait to go back.
We also stayed at their historic hotel.
This was my first visit and I loved it. Food and dessert were top notch. Oh and the view of the lake was added plus.
It was great- the food, the hosts, everything. We have had great meals there for our banquets and Ben really works with us on what we would like
Beautiful restaurant, delicious food and great service! Enjoyed shopping in the gift shop earlier in the day also. Would definitely go back!
We stopped in for lunch. The food was very good, and the server was friendly. It is a beautiful place.
Husband and I have enjoyed many meals here - dinner in main dining room, up on the deck with great view of the lake , or in the bar - very cozy for a late night snack
Love the chilled, refreshing dinner salad with house ranch dressing - of course ! Filet - Chicken Chautauqua , and Coconut shrimp - are my personal favorites
Wait staff, bartenders - always friendly, quality of food has been always good for us.
We hadn't been there in a while, so with nice weather predicted we decided to plan our Valentines dinner at Webb's. It was wonderful. The service was excellent, the atmosphere as warm and inviting as always, and the food was delicious! A couple of keyboard players took turns playing lovely background music. Our appetizer, dinners and dessert were all superb. The horseradish crusted salmon was especially wonderful, as was the potato crusted salmon. We will make a point to get there more often!
Spent a leisurely Saturday late afternoon enjoying a great meal in front of the fireplace as the sun was setting. From the bruschetta to the main course to at wonderful bourbon pecan cheesecake - everything was excellent.
Most reliable and best meal in town. Customer service is fabulous! Well worth the money! Service doesn't change weather it's the summer season or winter.
We love visiting Mayville and always choose Webb’s for our lunch or dinner destination. Excellent food with a nice variety to choose from. Pleasant with a warm and cozy atmosphere. Love!
Had a great dinner on the deck. Had a great filet and lamb chops. Great atmosphere!
We had a wonderful dinner New Year's Eve. Delicious food from appetizer, salad, entree and dessert! We weren't rushed. Had awesome service. Carriage ride offered after dinner. We will definitely be going back! Wonderful Easter and Mother's Day brunch in the past.
Have been coming here for as long as I can remember... my family used to have a cottage close by... now I have to drive up from south Carolina... which I do at least 2 or 3 times a year.... love the food, service is ALWAYS fa tastic
Nice large restaurant. We sat upstairs outside so we could have a view of Lake Chautauqua. Arrived at 4 pm when they opened on a Friday evening, so there wasn't a wait. We started by ordering drinks. A Margarita ($12.00) and a Blueberry Remedy ($10.50), both of which were good but very small. Barely 8 oz of liquid by time the ice was added to the glass. The variety of rolls came out warm and were delicious. My husband and I both ordered the Chicken Mediterranean, which was presented very well and was delicious. Lastly, their dinners do not include salads, so we ordered house salads in addition to our dinner for a $13.90 up charge for 2. Our waitress was friendly and good at her job. If we are back in the area, we will probably eat there again for the location.
Our waitress Julie was the best from start to finish. Food was good. Love the seasonal decor and oil lamps on the table.
Brynn made our entire experience at Captains table restaurant one to remember. As a young mutant filled with radioactive oooze, Brynn dabbed some of my Chernobyl goodness off the table when needed. Her demeanor was extremely kind. At one point, I watched the delightful Brynn roundhouse kick to a Tarantula that was trying to steal my baked potato. If it wasn’t for Brynn and her quick to act on high stress-level situations, I may not have gotten to enjoy my baked potato.
We stumbled about this restaurant when we realized another local spot was seasonally closed. We didn’t realize it but it was a little more formal than anticipated so we sat in the bar area which worked out just fine. The food was tasty and service friendly. It is a little pricey but we felt the food quality was worth it. I would recommend!
Me and my family dined in tonight and our experience was enjoyable on a very high bar. The food was prepared perfectly and presented extremely well. The look of the place, the atmosphere, and service were all exceptional and quite appreciated. Personally my first time here and it's a favorite already.
Wonderful meal to celebrate our 52nd anniversary after a cruise on the Chautauqua Belle. We dined outside on the upper deck and had a great view of the lake. Our waitress was friendly and very professional. Our meals were Chicken Mediterranean and Scallops. Both were outstanding and we hope to go back again soon!
Delicious food, great service, and a wonderful atmosphere. The Chicken Chautauqua is worth trying. The rolls they serve are spectacular. They have great drinks on tap and it is worth dining at Webb's.
I had the Filet Oscar and our guests had the Chicken Parmesan . The presentation on both entrees was fabulous. And the food was extremely delicious! We only visit the area once a year, but we will most assuredly return next year. It is a hidden jewel!
Came here for lunch on a road trip after everything in one of the towns we drove through was closed. Was hesitant about some previous reviews I saw but decided to make my own opinion. Great ambiance and friendly service. Food was tasty and seemed like a lot was homemade. Great coffee flight btw. Dinner menu was looking good but dinner starts at 4:00pm. Overall no complaints. We will have to come back for dinner.
My dinner was called th Oscar, I think. It's totally delicious. I will order this again. I love how they pair the wine with the dinner. Wait staff so friendly. Great experience for all.
Went for Lunch with my wife and mother, sat on the balcony and it was a great view and awesome food and service. Joe provided superior service. I will be returning again.
This is my favorite restaurant. We love the food, atmosphere, and especially the captain's table. We went here for my son's birthday, as well as my own.
The food was a little pricey but well worth it. There was more than enough food in the portions we received. Nice view of the lake if you are fortunate enough to get a seat in the front. My one complaint, the wait staff is a little slow. I was there on a Sunday afternoon around 3, during a Bill's game. There were maybe 6 occupied tables and most of them were finishing up from a late lunch. We still waited some time for our waitress, who did apologize for the delay. We weren't in any hurry, so no big deal. Good food, nice atmosphere. If you aren't in a hurry, it's a nice place to eat.
Food was great. Service was a good. Atmosphere was great. They were very busy today because of the chocolate walk. 🍫
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes