Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Melville
10 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"The BEST Italian food around! We order food from here every week and it never disappoints. Very accommodating too! The owner, manager and Bridget are..."
Gabrielle Brittman
"Drove in from Florida yesterday, first stop was our hotel, second stop was La Focaccia cause I needed authentic NY pizza after a combined 26 hour..."
Big Mike
"By far my favorite pizza place I've been to. I'm fairly picky with pizza, but I always go here when I'm working in the area. I got a slice of Buffalo..."
Zach C
"Best pepperoni pizza I have had in a while. The pepperoni garlic knots are great too. A must-go-place, if you are in town. The staff are very..."
Ray Moncada
"Delicious! Best pizza we’ve ever had! We liked watching the guy make the sauce and dough right there. Will be back next..."
L T
"I work next to this place. I walk by it every day. It is the greatest pizza place. Are used to make pizza around 1984 through 1990 I know what I’m..."
Bryan Salamone
"The BEST Pizza in all of Long Island! Everything is so good, and you will not be..."
Stacey Genève Travis
"Great food! Never had a bad order and you have to try their Garlic Knots best..."
Nick LaSorsa
"Food was delicious and service was exceptional!! The lunch special is a large portion. Best Chicken Bruschetta I’ve ever..."
Katherin Tehelen
"Price 2 stars, Pizza 4 stars. Garlic knots 4.5 stars.
Almost $16 for a buffalo, regular, 4 knots, bottle of soda...."
Jason O
"We’re visiting from out of town, and found this hidden gem on our way back from a day of shopping. The pizza was delicious, so cheesy and not..."
Courtney Cox
"Got a couple of regular slices and garlic knots stuffed with pepperoni! Outstanding! The garlic knots were to die for!!!! Will definitely be..."
Murray K
"Great pizza, call ones, sandwiches and even salads. Very fast, friendly and clean. Prices were also very reasonable. Highly..."
Greg DeCristofaro
"Best pizza on Long Island. I’ve lived here 25 years and have never had a better slice anywhere else. I had to take a bite before I took the..."
Barbara Gallo
"Went there for lunch first time last week. I work in the area. Service was quick, place is a little small but clean and they have a few tables..."
Giuseppe Sparacino
"I stop by here with my wife because had to hang around town while my daughter visits a friend from school. Anyway, we were in mood for pizza so ask..."
Eli
"Garlic knots !!! From Long Island - to NYC the BEST knots I’ve ever had , yet..."
Joshua Rechner
"Great pizza and amazing staff! Been coming here for years and will continue to as the quality stays consistent! Definitely give them a try! The..."
"We have been going to Cirellas for years and always have had an excellent meal or just enjoyed the home town restaurant bar scene for lunch or..."
Acava
"Small, cozy Italian restaurant with a surprise -- a sushi chef and a full sushi menu. We didn't order any sushi, but there was an amazing sushi..."
Songbird1329
"A Favorite Casual Spot. When in town we eat here quite frequently.A group of us meet at the bar and have dinner on a Tuesday or..."
Roger T
"My favorite place in Western Nassau. Been going there since 1996 and I have to say I never had a meal or a glass of wine I didn't love here. The..."
Peanutsmom
"A Local Favourite. Beautiful fresh and lively menu with exceptionally good Sushi offerings as well as a great selection of Italian dishes.The..."
Marie
"This intimate bar & restaurant is small, cozy, always crowded and a local favorite. The staff are friendly and courteous from the valet parking to..."
Thomas Spencer
"Really excellent place. My team and I stopped in randomly and early for dinner. We all agreed, best Italian we have had in a long time. We will..."
Stephen Johnson
"I always loved Cirella's but haven't been here in years and it was better than I remembered! For an Italian restaurant, they had plenty of healthy..."
Loretta Laz
"Cirellas is outstanding! From the arrival with the hostess to the server, everything is impeccable. We moved from the city a few years ago, and the..."
Christina Stumer
"Delighted on Monday night with my party of nine for dinner. Nolan was attentive, food was delicious, and even the request for roundtable was honored...."
ann mollenhauer
"Absolutely one of my favorites!
Shoutout to the chef. Portions are perfect.
The staff is..."
Eliana
"Can't go wrong with this Italian restaurant. Cirellas offers Italian food and sushi which I have never seen before. I always order the short rib..."
Bryan
"First time there. Excellent service. Never felt rushed and the food was delicious. Highly..."
Diane Gaertner
"Bartender Nick is outgoing, accommodating, and friendly. Food is Phenomenal. Italian Food And Sushi. Bon Apetit! I figured it would either be..."
Ian Lepkowsky
"Ok, we had a 30 minute wait, the place was packed, but I’m glad we stayed.
Seafood and lasagna dishes tasted amazing, expertly attended to by..."
Paul Blackett
"Great staff. Absolutely delicious Italian food and sushi! Been a long time customer and have never been disappointed. Hard to recommend a better..."
John Panicola
"I was surprised this place is kinda affordable.
The food is really good. The best part about this restaurant is the service. The staff here is super..."
Nx Nu
"My friend and I went for lunch yesterday. She enjoyed her branzino and I enjoyed my salad with shrimp. Nolan, our waiter, was terrific! He went above..."
Joanne Del Collo
"A+ dining experience. The veal parm was so tasty. Huge portions! Staff were all attentive. Definitely recommend this restaurant and will be..."
Adam Lobel
"I had not been back here for 5 years and the restaurant is brighter and much less crowded than I remember. I also don't remember the sushi but all..."
Michael Wasowicz
"Tasty food, very friendly service. Very tight/small parking lot with aggressive neighbors who will tow you..."
Halley Knigge (Griffin)
"Great food. 3 of us had Chicken Parmesean. So good!! Didn't think to take a..."
"One of my go-to restaurants because the food and service are consistently very good! I met a friend for dinner here Friday night (7/7). Our..."
Kirsten Ostrofsky
"We had a dinner party for my daughter’s wedding in the Garden Room. It was fabulous! The food was beyond our expectations and the service was..."
Anne Rosenblum
"Went on a Saturday night at 5:30. Two of us, no reservation. Hostess, (older woman, angry school teacher type), was rude and curt. Gave us 30 minute..."
L Br NY
"Best Italian in the area! Lighting was great, ambiance, nice. Great bar area. Nice sized booth seating. Great service and clean environment and of..."
TheRJWilliams
"Walked in and thought it was a pizza only place and my wife was wanting a chicken meal. A customer assured us that not only do they have meals but..."
Daniel Rafuse
"Good service, and the food was tasty. I went for a business lunch but I've also been here with family. It's great for all occasions. Consistent and a..."
Haley Kammerling
"I was disappointed with the food. The salad had way too much dressing, so the salad was soggy before I was done eating it.
The cheese on my burger..."
Meredith Naim
"One of our favorite places to eat and we love the atmosphere.
The bartender, Ivan is excellent -always friendly, personable and places his efforts..."
Traci
"Excellent food. Attentive service. My veal chop parmigiana was amazing Chicken Marsala terrific as was the fried..."
Dennis Herman
"Placed a catering order for a client lunch.
The food was a little pricey but very good.
They shorted me on utensils and plates which was..."
Merik Dolber
"Quick service with excellent food. We had the mussels followed by Diavola Pizzette, both of which were..."
Blaise Vitale
"I just had my 30th birthday party here. So accommodating and very helpful. The food is absolutely delicious! The sangria was amazing too! Definitely..."
Tracy Melideo
"We enjoyed the outstanding appetizer eggplant rolatine and the main dish of chicken madeira. Our server Jose was extremely attentive .
The..."
Roy Pick
"There for a 75th birthday. We were greeted immediately with a smile. The server introduced himself and made sure we had water and asked if we needed..."
Bill Multer
"Great food ! Lobster parparele linguine clam sauce Valentine’s Day espresso martini . Can be loud at times. No carpeting. Industrial high ceilings...."
"The atmosphere,the service & food was amazing. They have a lot of selections of food. This place is very clean & friendly. I wish they were in..."
Lamar
"Legit! If you can't find your kind of slice here it's probably not made. The Sicilian was great, the from Sicilian was fantastic. Give it a try you..."
NotAdelard
"Whenever we visit the Huntington area to visit family we go here at least once. My sister is a regular here. It's just a location that we always..."
Gaylene Kihs
"Although this is a self-service restaurant, the staff is very helpful, and the food might surprise anyone who has not been there before. It is..."
Kevin Sullivan
"Victors is amazing ! pizza is amazing, and the meatball heros are delicious. The Chicken & Tomato slices are also my favorite. The thai chili slices..."
Edward Park
"Pizza and Chicken Wings Were Absolutely Delicious. Very Tasty and portion was awesome. Definitely making a trip back from our home town of Bay..."
George Palomino Jr (El Maniatiko)
"Victor's hit home in a very special way with there food. After joining the Air Force on active duty I was taken away from the east coast, and their..."
Andre Walker
"Nationwide pizza review:
Kind service. Great seating. Great parking.
Freshness A-1. !!!!!! Selection is..."
Shawn P.
"Great food, good prices, very large selection.
10 out of 10 recommend. Never met a slice of pizza there I didn't like...
Until today that is... I..."
Nick Mainella
"Very nice atmosphere
Went here a year ago with daughter's wedding girls.
Great for vegetarians and vegans.
Took my mother and she now found her new..."
Jill Forland-Oderwald
"I had the half meatball parm hero and small salad. It is the perfect amount for lunch. Fresh and..."
James Vicino
"Amazing portions of food, glad we’re business neighbors .. our employees enjoyed the pies.. thank..."
BP Melville
"Best pizza in all the towns. Quality! My go to pizza place. They give fresh slices..."
Kim
"I've been going here for nearly 20 years and never been disappointed. They have great lunch specials and the garlic knots are ridiculously..."
Frank DiBella
"Good flow and good people. A simple chicken roll but it was really good. Soft bread and good pull on the cheese. I regret not trying one of their..."
Toney Tilhoo
"Food was delicious, people were friendly, and we had a great server!!! We will be..."
Monique LaBrecque
"I'm not going to lie, when we went here during the week and lunch time their system was down and the place was a mad house. But the pizza is worth..."
Maria Martinez
"Victor's has been awesome for the last quarter century. Despite leaving Melville for the service 20+ years ago, every time my family comes back to NY..."
"I love Marios they have excellent dishes and pizza! It's my goto place in a..."
Cathy Gierbolini
"LOVE IT!!!! Great pizza and really friendly..."
Joanna Yannotti
"Pizza and Salad was great! Service was also on point! Will definitely be back..."
Marie Philemond
"This place has the most delicious seafood pasta!! Mario's seafood special was incredibly delicious!! Definitely 5 stars!!!
They make homemade..."
Jane Im
"First time at Mario’s of Huntington, I have been to many of the other locations. I ordered a regular slice and grandma it was good but I expected..."
George Panagopoulos at Douglas Elliman Realestate
"Did a pick up order & the food was hot & ready at the time promised. Very nice staff. I had gotten the penne alla vodka which didn’t have much..."
Christy Benko
"The best pizza place! Junior is a god amongst pizza gods! You will not be disappointed..."
Robert DePaolo
"The pizza was good. But the chicken parm was not fresh tasted microwaved from a refrigerated pre cooked choped up cutlet. I had a chicken parm hero...."
John Avanti
"The pizza is very delicious. Friendly customer service. The place is clean. Public bathrooms are clean..."
Danitza Samouhi
"Been here a few times and I’d definitely give this place a 10/10. My best friend and I love coming here for a quick meal! The staff is very..."
Gabriella Valencia
"Great food. A gluten free menu as well.
Terrific..."
Linda Dickman
"I am addicted to their food! Everything I have had so far is delicious! Online service is great too. Will be back again...and again...and again!..."
Katherine Gibbons
"I’ve had take out here many times and they have great service and wide variety of pizza to order. My favorite is the penne pasta pizza!! I will be..."
"One of my go-to restaurants because the food and service are consistently very good! I met a friend for dinner here Friday night (7/7). Our..."
Kirsten Ostrofsky
"We had a dinner party for my daughter’s wedding in the Garden Room. It was fabulous! The food was beyond our expectations and the service was..."
Anne Rosenblum
"Went on a Saturday night at 5:30. Two of us, no reservation. Hostess, (older woman, angry school teacher type), was rude and curt. Gave us 30 minute..."
L Br NY
"Best Italian in the area! Lighting was great, ambiance, nice. Great bar area. Nice sized booth seating. Great service and clean environment and of..."
TheRJWilliams
"Walked in and thought it was a pizza only place and my wife was wanting a chicken meal. A customer assured us that not only do they have meals but..."
Daniel Rafuse
"Good service, and the food was tasty. I went for a business lunch but I've also been here with family. It's great for all occasions. Consistent and a..."
Haley Kammerling
"I was disappointed with the food. The salad had way too much dressing, so the salad was soggy before I was done eating it.
The cheese on my burger..."
Meredith Naim
"One of our favorite places to eat and we love the atmosphere.
The bartender, Ivan is excellent -always friendly, personable and places his efforts..."
Traci
"Excellent food. Attentive service. My veal chop parmigiana was amazing Chicken Marsala terrific as was the fried..."
Dennis Herman
"Placed a catering order for a client lunch.
The food was a little pricey but very good.
They shorted me on utensils and plates which was..."
Merik Dolber
"Quick service with excellent food. We had the mussels followed by Diavola Pizzette, both of which were..."
Blaise Vitale
"I just had my 30th birthday party here. So accommodating and very helpful. The food is absolutely delicious! The sangria was amazing too! Definitely..."
Tracy Melideo
"We enjoyed the outstanding appetizer eggplant rolatine and the main dish of chicken madeira. Our server Jose was extremely attentive .
The..."
Roy Pick
"There for a 75th birthday. We were greeted immediately with a smile. The server introduced himself and made sure we had water and asked if we needed..."
Bill Multer
"Great food ! Lobster parparele linguine clam sauce Valentine’s Day espresso martini . Can be loud at times. No carpeting. Industrial high ceilings...."
"The menu choices were excellent! The food fresh and flavorful. Don't skip the fresh hot bread to dip in the olive oil with seasonings. Our server..."
Kenn Gaither
"The restaurant (the physical structure) is actually very attractive inside. Nice decore. Nice lighting. Several televisions.
I like the tile floor...."
Glen Fergo
"5 stars. I satisfied. Good services and pretty good foods. I recommend to everyone. With my family I enjoyed so..."
Chonghun Daniel Song (송정훈)
"An excellent dining experience! Our waiter Jack was friendly and attentive, all of the food was really delicious and there were no issues changing..."
E J
"Great restaurant Big location plenty of space wheelchair accessibility. Staff is incredibly pleasant service with a smile. Lunch menu big variety..."
IrisGiovanni B
"Food has improved - 3 stars & service warranted the 4th star. Had pizza - a little light on the toppings but still flavorful and baked well - crispy..."
Hilda K
"This was a nice surprise when we looked up restaurants in the area. Elegant enough for adults but still kid friendly with a great priced menu and a..."
Deirdre Goss
"Fantastic food and service! Classic Italian cuisine at a great price. A family friendly atmosphere and very attentive wait staff. Our server, Tina,..."
John St. Jeanos
"My husband and I went for dinner Saturday night and had a great experience! The restaurant was very clean and the food was delicious! Our waiter..."
Kerry Mooney
"Enjoyed dinner at Bertucci’s with our family of four. Everyone enjoyed the food - rigatoni, ravioli, eggplant and shrimp scampi. But the..."
Frank Evangelist
"I've only been here twice, but both times the service was prompt and accommodating. I haven't had any of the problems others seemingly have, so maybe..."
John Doe
"Delicious warm, fresh rolls at the start of every meal with a dish of olive oil to dip them in. Excellent entrees for not too high of a price. Nice..."
Amanda Bayne
"My friends and I had another wonderful lunch yesterday. Brian, our incredible waiter, always goes above and beyond. He remembers all our favorite..."
M Block
"We had a Birthday dinner for my son here after visiting near by White Post farms. We had a very large table full of little kids and the staff handled..."
Igor Kolker
"This is a great casual family place. Kids love the raw dough they give to play with. The rosemary chicken sandwich here is great. The rolls are..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes